U.S. judge considers sanctions against attorneys in prison case for using AI in court filings
A U.S. federal judge said Wednesday that she is considering sanctions against lawyers with a high-priced firm hired to defend Alabama's prison system after ChatGPT was used to write two court filings that included nonexistent case citations.
U.S. District Judge Anna Manasco held a hearing in Birmingham to question attorneys with the Butler Snow firm about the filings. She said there were five false citations in two filings in federal court. Manasco said that nationally, there have been broad warnings from courts about the use of artificial intelligence to generate legal filings because of the potential for inaccuracies.
Manasco said she is considering a range of sanctions, including fines. She gave the firm 10 days to file a brief with the court.
Butler Snow lawyers repeatedly apologized during the hearing.
They said a firm partner, Matt Reeves, used ChatGPT to research supporting case law but did not verify the information before adding it to two filings with the federal court. Those citations turned out to be 'hallucinations' — meaning incorrect citations — by the AI system, they said. Four attorneys signed the filings with the information, including Reeves.
Story continues below advertisement
2:15
First Canadian court case over AI-generated court filings
'Butler Snow is embarrassed by what happened here, which was against good judgment and firm policy. There is no excuse for using ChatGPT to obtain legal authority and failing to verify the sources it provided, even if to support well founded principles of law,' firm lawyers wrote in a response to the judge.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
Reeves told the judge that he alone was responsible for the false citations and that, 'I would hope your honor would not punish my colleagues.'
Alabama has paid millions of dollars to the firm to defend the state prison system and its officials in lawsuits. That includes representing the state as a defendant in a Department of Justice lawsuit alleging that male inmates live in violent and cruel conditions.
The filings in question were made in a lawsuit filed by an inmate who was stabbed on multiple occasions at the William E. Donaldson Correctional Facility in Jefferson County. It alleges that prison officials are failing to keep inmates safe.
Story continues below advertisement
Manasco also questioned Bill Lunsford, head of the Butler Snow division that handles prison litigation, who signed the filings. Alabama's attorney general has appointed Lunsford as a deputy attorney general because he represents the state in court.
Lunsford wrote in a response to the judge that he scanned over the documents before filing them but did not do a detailed review since it had been reviewed by Reeves. He told the judge that the firm has been proactive in warning lawyers about the limitations of artificial intelligence.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
8 hours ago
- Global News
Confusion surrounds Vancouver's Lapu Lapu ‘memorial event'
There appears to be some controversy surrounding the City of Vancouver's plan to hold an event to honour the victims of the Lapu Lapu tragedy. Council has unanimously voted to move ahead with what has been described as a 'memorial event.' The motion, brought by Coun. Sarah Kirby-Yung, outlines an event called 'Come Together; Vancouver Strong' at Rogers Arena in June, but no specific date has been set. R.J. Aquino, chair of Filipino BC, says that while victims and families support a benefit concert, a 'memorial event' felt 'inappropriate and ill-advised.' Vancouver Mayor Ken Sim said that the council met with Filipino BC as recently as Friday and the event was discussed. Sim says his office has reached out to Filipino BC to seek clarification and reaffirm a shared commitment to ensuring the event is done with the community. Story continues below advertisement Vancouver-Kensington MLA Mable Elmore, who was at the festival when the tragedy happened, said this may be a case of misinformation. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'There was an error in terms of that motion,' she told Global News. 'It referenced a memorial event. We agreed on the first meeting it's going to be characterized as a benefit or concert in terms of that's more accurate.' The City of Vancouver has approved $50,000 to cover any cost overruns of the event while Rogers Arena has agreed to host the event. Eleven people were killed and dozens injured when an SUV drove into a crowd at the Lapu Lapu festival on April 26. Kai Ji Adam Lo is charged with eight counts of second-degree murder in connection with the incident. Story continues below advertisement On May 30, Lo appeared by video link from hospital, and his appearance was drastically different than at the time of his arrest. Dressed in black, he sat quietly during the proceedings. Provincial Court Judge Reg Harris confirmed he had received and read a mental health assessment. Lo is due back in court this month. — with files from The Canadian Press
Global News
8 hours ago
- Global News
30-year-old worker drowns in industrial accident at B.C. mill
See more sharing options Send this page to someone via email Share this item on Twitter Share this item via WhatsApp Share this item on Facebook A 30-year-old man died on Wednesday in an industrial accident at a mill in Crofton on Vancouver Island. North Cowichan/Duncan RCMP were called to the Catalyst Pulp and Paper Mill around 12 p.m. A piece of heavy equipment fell into the ocean with its operator trapped inside, police said. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Numerous first responders from police, fire and ambulance initially attended with the support of the Canadian Coast Guard divers to attempt a rescue. Unfortunately, the operator did not survive. 'The BC Coroners Service and WorksafeBC are conducting concurrent investigations into what led to this tragic outcome,' Cpl. Alex Bérubé, spokesperson for the BC RCMP said in a statement. Anyone with information is asked to contact the North Cowichan/Duncan RCMP at 250-748-5522.
Global News
8 hours ago
- Global News
Family of B.C. Mountie who took own life angry officer she was involved with now with SPS
NOTE: This article contains sensitive descriptions regarding suicide. Please read at your discretion. The family of a Richmond RCMP officer who took her own life four years ago is upset the senior officer with whom she was involved in a relationship has now been hired by the Surrey Police Service. Const. Jasmine Thiara died by suicide on Richmond's Moray Bridge on Feb. 21, 2021, shortly after texting a colleague that she was being bullied by a senior Mountie she was involved with. 2:02 Families seek answers over similar deaths of two female police officers 'She had so much life to live, and she was so ambitious; this wasn't a person with suicidal ideation, this was someone planning for the future of herself and her unborn child,' Raven Thiara, Jasmine's sister, told Global News on Wednesday. Story continues below advertisement 'We weren't just robbed of my sister's future and her turning 30, but also of my niece or nephew, who now would be growing into a toddler.' A subsequent probe by the Independent Investigations Office concluded there was no evidence of bullying or criminal harassment that led to her death. The officer faced a separate internal RCMP code of conduct investigation, the results of which the force will not release, citing the Privacy Act. However, the RCMP did confirm he voluntarily resigned earlier this year. Raven said the force hasn't disclosed the results of that probe to the family either. 2:06 Family angry about IIO report on RCMP officer's death 'The issue with that is transparency and accountability are the two things we've been exploring and imploring the RCMP for since the onset of my sister's loss. These issues that have gone on are not isolated, they're systemic, as we also saw with the death of (Vancouver police Const.) Nicole Chan, who also passed after being bullied to death,' she said. Story continues below advertisement 'I wanted to bring closure to the public's chapter, too, on where is he now? What is he doing now, and has anything changed? But we still haven't gotten all those answers to provide that closure.' Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Global News confirmed with the SPS that the officer has since signed on as a constable with the municipal force. SPS spokesperson S/Sgt. Lindsey Houghton said the department was fully aware of his background, but noted that several investigations had failed to substantiate any allegation of misconduct or criminality. 'What I'd say first is I certainly empathize with what the family has been through. I personally have known other police officers who have committed suicide. It's tragic,' Houghton said. 'We never want this to happen. The other thing that I will say is that multiple independent agencies investigated this case, and have come to, from what we are aware (is), the same conclusion. They have not substantiated anything related to bullying, nor have they found any criminal conduct. So I hope that at some point the family can find some closure. It's not an answer Thiara's family is happy to accept. 1:55 Developments in the case of a Richmond Mountie's apparent suicide 'I'm concerned and alarmed, I feel a lack of security there — what is the vetting process, and what is the threshold for when you can become an answer a call to service?' Raven said. Story continues below advertisement She also questioned whether the officer truly 'resigned,' noting that he took a position at a lower rank with the SPS. 'I believe that this is semantics and another way to evade accountability by the police, because if they say he left on his own volition, under goodwill, it's hard for us to pursue further litigation, especially on the civil front for a wrongful death and wrongdoing, because, again, there is no wrongdoing admitted to,' she said. Raven said the family isn't finished pursuing Jasmine's case, and hasn't ruled out private legal action. She said the family has also filed a complaint through the Surrey Police Board. 'We're entitled to feel safe when we call someone to service. We're entitled to know who's coming to our door with a gun and badge, and we're entitled to know if that history includes any investigation into the death of a deceased partner,' she said. 'I'm patient. I believe the road to justice is long, and we're here for that whole road, we will see justice through. And I don't believe by the end of this road that he will be carrying a gun or a badge.'
