
'Unfair' charges in Pitsea leave drivers 'scared of parking'
Motorists who have used a car park in Essex say they have been stung with charges for overstaying, even though they insist they left long before their three hours was up.Visitors to the retail park in Pitsea, Essex, have questioned the reliability of the automatic number plate recognition (ANPR) cameras.Taryn James was billed for £100 for a five-hour stay, but she said she had been in the car park for less than an hour, and the experience had left her "really scared to park in any car park".ParkingEye, the company that manages the site, said its ANPR equipment was fully operational but it had cancelled Ms James's bill "as a gesture of goodwill".
Ms James, 49, said she arrived at the retail park on 1 November 2024 just before 13:45 GMT and left shortly before 14:30 GMT. She later visited Sainsbury's for 10 minutes at about 19:00 GMT.She said she had used her Google location records as evidence to try to overturn the charge."I've had one ticket in my whole life and I paid it because I was in the wrong that time, but I'm not paying for something that I didn't do," she said.
Another driver, Helen Murphy, said her husband received a letter saying he had parked for about eight hours – something they disputed."Our first reaction was fear," she said. "You think, 'I'd better just pay it'."The couple, who are in their 50s, asked ParkingEye to check its camera, insisting there was no way the car had been there all day.The next communication they received from the company was to tell them the bill had been voided.Ms Murphy said the situation had made her angry "because there will be people who just pay it without question out of fear".
A ParkingEye spokesperson said the car park "features prominent and highly-visible signs throughout, providing information on how to use the car park responsibly".They added: "Our operational data shows that on both dates when the respective charges were issued our systems were fully operational with no technical issues. However, following a review we have cancelled both charges as a gesture of goodwill."ParkingEye won a 2015 Supreme Court case after a motorist from Chelmsford claimed that an £85 charge it had imposed was "unfair and disproportionate".However, although the ruling confirmed that such bills were "legally enforceable", the court added that the company could not charge over-stayers "whatever it liked".The judges wrote that a parking company "could not charge a sum which would be out of all proportion to its interest or that of the landowner for whom it is providing the service".
How do I appeal against a charge?
There is nothing in criminal law to support a charge for parking on private land, says BBC Watchdog's Prof Margaret Griffiths. It is more of a contract – when you park on private land, you are entering into an agreement.The parking requirements you are agreeing to – such as the permitted length of stay – and the tariffs "must be clearly displayed on a notice", Prof Griffiths said, and cannot be hidden or obscured from view. "If all of that's in place and you've breached the terms, then you can expect to be charged," she said.But what if you get one of these notices when you know you were not in the wrong?"You could have a very strong case for an appeal," Prof Griffiths said.She suggests:Contacting the company at the earliest opportunity to tell them that you're contesting the charge. Asking it to provide proof of its case against you. It's up to the company to prove that you breached the contract. It's not up to you to prove that you didn't.Supporting your case with photographic evidence. If the meter wasn't working or the signs were not clear, for example, take a photo.If you cannot reach agreement with the parking company, you can take your case to an appeals service. The parking company must give you details about how to do this.
Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Wales Online
4 hours ago
- Wales Online
Boy, 15, taken to hospital as police investigate report of shooting in Cardiff
Boy, 15, taken to hospital as police investigate report of shooting in Cardiff Police have said there will be an increased police presence in the Cardiff suburb as investigations continue Police were called to Clos y Ffynnon, Pontprennau (Image: Google Streetview ) A 15-year-old boy was taken to hospital after police were called to a reports of a shooting incident in a Cardiff suburb over the weekend. Residents reported seeing a heavy police presence with armed officers in the Pontprennau area of the city on the evening of Saturday, June 7. Police confirmed they were called to a house at 8pm to reports of an incident at Clos y Ffynnon, Pontprennau, in the east of the city. No arrests have been made so far, and police are continuing to investigate. There will be increased police presence in the area as investigations continue. A South Wales Police spokesperson said: 'Officers are in attendance at Clos y Ffynnon, Pontprennau, Cardiff following a report of an incident at around 8pm on the evening of Saturday June 7. 'A 15-year-old boy from Pontprennau has been taken to hospital. His injuries are not considered to be life-threatening. Article continues below 'An increased policing presence will be seen in the area of Clos y Ffynnon while officers conduct their investigation.' Detective Superintendent Mark O'Shea, from South Wales Police, said: 'We understand the concern this incident will cause, and I want to reassure the local community that teams of detectives and specialist staff are working at pace to piece together the events of Saturday evening.' Extensive enquiries are ongoing, and there will be a visible police presence in the area while officers continue the investigation. Information and footage can be submitted online here. Article continues below Alternatively anyone with information can also contact South Wales Police quoting 2500180055.


Scottish Sun
10 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Our lives are being made hell by angry shoppers parking in our street… despite 500-space strong car park metres away
Residents say Costco shoppers leave them abused, blocked in, and fed up daily AT ALL COSTS Our lives are being made hell by angry shoppers parking in our street… despite 500-space strong car park metres away Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) FURIOUS locals say their lives are being made a misery by Costco shoppers clogging up their street — even though there's a huge 500-space car park just metres away. Residents of Torrington Avenue in Coventry claim they're being sworn at and even threatened by customers using their road to park instead of the store's own car park. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 Locals claim abuse from Coventry Costco customers over parking issue Credit: Google 3 Locals say the situation gets worse on weekends and during Costco's busiest hours Credit: Google They've now begged the council for a residents-only parking scheme, saying the situation is unbearable — especially for those with kids or mobility issues. In a petition to the council, they said: 'Customers regularly use the street to park which at peak times not only means that residents struggle to find space but have recently also been facing verbal abuse and threats from customers.' They added: 'The current parking situation is especially an issue for those with small children and limited mobility as having to park further away constantly is a challenge. "Costco has over 500 spaces which is more than ample to meet demand, and there is no reason why customers and staff need to use the street at the expense of residents.' Locals say the situation gets worse on weekends and during Costco's busiest hours. Some have even resorted to putting up cones and signs in a desperate attempt to keep spaces outside their homes clear. One resident, who didn't want to be named, said: 'It's chaos some days. "You get people blocking driveways and shouting abuse when you ask them to move. "It's just not right when there's a perfectly good car park sitting almost empty.' Despite the outcry, Coventry City Council looks set to reject the request. Officials say parking levels in the area simply don't meet the threshold needed for action. A similar bid for restrictions was made last year, also covering Torrington Avenue between the A45 and Eastcotes. That too was knocked back after surveys showed enough spaces were still available. A council report explained: 'The parking survey conducted in response to that petition showed that the section of Torrington Avenue highlighted did not meet the parking availability criterion set out in the Council's Residents' Parking Policy (less than 40 per cent of spaces available during the daytime).' A follow-up check on Thursday 3 April 2025 reached the same conclusion — with 54 per cent of spaces free, well above the required threshold. The report concluded: 'As the recent parking survey shows that the number of parking spaces available during the daytime (54 per cent) still exceeds the criterion for consideration for a residents' parking scheme, the Cabinet Member is recommended to decline the request for a residents' parking scheme on Torrington Avenue between Eastcotes and the A45.' The final decision rests with Councillor Patricia Hetherton, the cabinet member for city services, who will make the call at a meeting on Tuesday, June 11. Residents say they fear things will only get worse if action isn't taken soon. Some have even started discussions about installing private barriers or applying for dropped kerbs to stop people using their space. Another local added: 'We understand people want to save a bit of time by parking on the road, but it's not fair on us who live here. "We just want to be able to park near our homes without having to deal with arguments or walk down the street with kids and shopping.' Despite the council's findings, residents say they'll keep fighting. They're urging others in the area to speak out and hope that pressure from the community might still sway the decision. The Sun has reached out to both Costco and Coventry City Council.


Edinburgh Live
10 hours ago
- Edinburgh Live
BBC Antiques Roadshow guest speechless as £1 vase bought at boot sale makes staggering value
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Antiques Roadshow's Eric Knowles was left gobsmacked when a glass vase, purchased for a mere £1 at a car boot sale, was valued at an astonishing amount. A woman from Ayrshire, who wished to remain anonymous, brought the vase to the BBC show for evaluation, not anticipating the staggering valuation she would receive. The vase was identified as a 1929 piece by famed French designer René Lalique, after being scrutinised by experts at Dumfries House near Cumnock, and was valued at a minimum of £25,000. The five-inch-tall glass vase was crafted using an ancient technique known as cire perdue. This complex method involves creating a wax model that is encased in plaster, then melted away and replaced with molten glass, with the plaster mould being broken away once the glass cools to reveal the final creation. The market value for Lalique pieces has seen a significant increase in recent years. Antiques Roadshow expert Eric Knowles shared his excitement with the Irvine Herald: "It's wonderful to find treasures like this beautiful vase during the programme's filming," reports the Express. (Image: BBC) He continued: "It certainly gives us all a buzz and we thoroughly enjoy meeting people everywhere we go. I've been waiting over 25 years for such a piece to come in, and this was the stuff of dreams. They'd dumped it in the attic after the plant in it died and were about to throw it away. We had a lot of clouds in Dumfries, but this was the cloud with a silver lining. It's worth at least £25,000." The vase ultimately fetched a whopping £32,450 at auction, exceeding its previous valuation by £7,000. This follows a rerun of the beloved BBC programme, which aired on Sunday, June 8. Viewers were transported to Brodie Castle in Scotland, where a parade of treasures awaited appraisal. Among them was a man who wowed Richard with a 1960s Rolex GMT-Master, inherited from his uncle. Richard, peering intently at the watch, informed the owner: "All Rolex collectors refer to these things by their reference number," and "You know as well as I do, because it says so on the dial, that it's a GMT-Master." (Image: BBC) Richard explained: "It's the reference 1675, which is the classic GMT-Master. When you said 60s, I think we could fairly safely say 1960 to 1961, so that all fits in." Upon closer inspection, Richard was thrilled to find the watch unaltered, noting that many watches are often modified during servicing, much to collectors' dismay. He said: "They would've changed the bezel and they would've changed the dial with an upgrade," before adding:"You would've had it back thinking, 'Oh, it looks like new'. Collectors hate that, it's absolutely original, spot-on." The expert told the owner: "It's a Rolex product, of course, but it says 'Made in the USA'. So perhaps he specified that he did not want the oyster bracelet; he wanted a jubilee bracelet, and they put this one on for him. "Which sort of detracts from it a little bit, probably detracts from it by a couple of thousand pounds." However, Richard had some good news as well, revealing that the watch is worth "£12,000 to £15,000." You can catch Antiques Roadshow every Sunday at 8pm on BBC1.