logo
'Unfair' charges in Pitsea leave drivers 'scared of parking'

'Unfair' charges in Pitsea leave drivers 'scared of parking'

BBC News18-03-2025

Motorists who have used a car park in Essex say they have been stung with charges for overstaying, even though they insist they left long before their three hours was up.Visitors to the retail park in Pitsea, Essex, have questioned the reliability of the automatic number plate recognition (ANPR) cameras.Taryn James was billed for £100 for a five-hour stay, but she said she had been in the car park for less than an hour, and the experience had left her "really scared to park in any car park".ParkingEye, the company that manages the site, said its ANPR equipment was fully operational but it had cancelled Ms James's bill "as a gesture of goodwill".
Ms James, 49, said she arrived at the retail park on 1 November 2024 just before 13:45 GMT and left shortly before 14:30 GMT. She later visited Sainsbury's for 10 minutes at about 19:00 GMT.She said she had used her Google location records as evidence to try to overturn the charge."I've had one ticket in my whole life and I paid it because I was in the wrong that time, but I'm not paying for something that I didn't do," she said.
Another driver, Helen Murphy, said her husband received a letter saying he had parked for about eight hours – something they disputed."Our first reaction was fear," she said. "You think, 'I'd better just pay it'."The couple, who are in their 50s, asked ParkingEye to check its camera, insisting there was no way the car had been there all day.The next communication they received from the company was to tell them the bill had been voided.Ms Murphy said the situation had made her angry "because there will be people who just pay it without question out of fear".
A ParkingEye spokesperson said the car park "features prominent and highly-visible signs throughout, providing information on how to use the car park responsibly".They added: "Our operational data shows that on both dates when the respective charges were issued our systems were fully operational with no technical issues. However, following a review we have cancelled both charges as a gesture of goodwill."ParkingEye won a 2015 Supreme Court case after a motorist from Chelmsford claimed that an £85 charge it had imposed was "unfair and disproportionate".However, although the ruling confirmed that such bills were "legally enforceable", the court added that the company could not charge over-stayers "whatever it liked".The judges wrote that a parking company "could not charge a sum which would be out of all proportion to its interest or that of the landowner for whom it is providing the service".
How do I appeal against a charge?
There is nothing in criminal law to support a charge for parking on private land, says BBC Watchdog's Prof Margaret Griffiths. It is more of a contract – when you park on private land, you are entering into an agreement.The parking requirements you are agreeing to – such as the permitted length of stay – and the tariffs "must be clearly displayed on a notice", Prof Griffiths said, and cannot be hidden or obscured from view. "If all of that's in place and you've breached the terms, then you can expect to be charged," she said.But what if you get one of these notices when you know you were not in the wrong?"You could have a very strong case for an appeal," Prof Griffiths said.She suggests:Contacting the company at the earliest opportunity to tell them that you're contesting the charge. Asking it to provide proof of its case against you. It's up to the company to prove that you breached the contract. It's not up to you to prove that you didn't.Supporting your case with photographic evidence. If the meter wasn't working or the signs were not clear, for example, take a photo.If you cannot reach agreement with the parking company, you can take your case to an appeals service. The parking company must give you details about how to do this.
Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Austria shooting LIVE: Terrified pupils flee ‘bullied' ex-student, 21, armed with shotgun in massacre that left 10 dead
Austria shooting LIVE: Terrified pupils flee ‘bullied' ex-student, 21, armed with shotgun in massacre that left 10 dead

Scottish Sun

time6 hours ago

  • Scottish Sun

Austria shooting LIVE: Terrified pupils flee ‘bullied' ex-student, 21, armed with shotgun in massacre that left 10 dead

SCHOOL RAMPAGE Austria shooting LIVE: Terrified pupils flee 'bullied' ex-student, 21, armed with shotgun in massacre that left 10 dead AT LEAST 10 young people have been killed after a "bullied" former student opened fire in a school in Austria. Terrifying footage shows pupils fleeing the 21-year-old male shooter as he went on the deadly rampage before turning the gun on himself. 6 Policemen are seen on a street close to the school Credit: AFP 6 Paramedics are seen on the street after multiple people were killed Credit: AFP 6 Ambulances are seen on a street near the school Credit: AFP 6 A cop stands next to an ambulance close to the school Credit: AFP 6 BORG Dreierschützengasse in Graz, where the shooting took place Credit: Google maps 6 The victims include six females and three males, local police officers confirmed. They are all children and teenagers, they added. Another 12 are seriously injured and in hospital receiving treatment with up to 30 said to be wounded in total. Horrifying video shows pupils hiding in a classroom as gunshots ring out nearby. Others clips show students running for their lives as heavily armed cops make their way inside the BORG Dreierschützengasse high school. A massive police operation in Graz was launched shortly after 10am this morning when the first gunshot was heard. Troops from Austrian special forces were seen storming the institution in the country's second biggest city. Three days of mourning has now been declared across Austria. The gunman was an ex-pupil who didn't graduate and is said to have been a victim of bullying during his time at the school, reports say. He is said to have been carrying two legally owned weapons - a Glock pistol and a shotgun at the time. The lone shooter was found dead in a bathroom after turning the gun on himself, the Austrian interior minister confirmed. He was not known to police and a motive is yet to be confirmed. In total, over 300 police officers were deployed to secure the school grounds. Authorities issued a disaster alert to local hospitals, and wounded students are being taken to a nearby concert stadium. Follow our live blog below for all the latest updates...

Man arrested after cross-county police chase to recover stolen cash machine
Man arrested after cross-county police chase to recover stolen cash machine

ITV News

time10 hours ago

  • ITV News

Man arrested after cross-county police chase to recover stolen cash machine

A man has been arrested following the theft of a cash machine from a Co-op store in Hampshire. Hampshire Police, along with officers from Dorset and Wiltshire, engaged in a cross-county pursuit in the early hours of Monday morning, after the ATM was stolen from the shop in Chandlers Ford. Officers from Hampshire's Roads Police Unit, Dog Unit and District Policing teams were deployed to track down the vehicle involved, which was found to be a stolen Audi RS4. It was tracked using ANPR systems and Dorset Police were able to deploy a stinger, to try to stop the vehicle as it entered the county. The driver was eventually stopped on a narrow track, and then attempted to evade police on foot. The dog unit, along with help from a drone, then tracked him to a nearby outbuilding, where he was detained. Police confirmed a 23-year-old man from Wimborne was arrested on suspicion of aggravated burglary, failing to stop, and driving a vehicle dangerously. In a statement, Hampshire Roads Policing said: "After stealing an ATM in a burglary in Hampshire, the occupant thought using fake number plates would throw us off the scent. "RPU, ARV, a Dog Unit and district policing team officers deployed, and the vehicle was sighted heading out of Hampshire. "With help from our colleagues in Wiltshire and Dorset we continued to get sightings of the vehicle, allowing us to be waiting as the car travelled towards Wimborne. "A pursuit ensured and our colleagues from Dorset Police were poised with a stinger to puncture the cars tyres... "Officers were quickly guided in to arrest the driver for multiple offences. The stolen ATM and vehicle were also secured."

Five feared killed in horror school shooting as armed police swarm scene
Five feared killed in horror school shooting as armed police swarm scene

Daily Mirror

time11 hours ago

  • Daily Mirror

Five feared killed in horror school shooting as armed police swarm scene

Elite armed police have raced to a school in Graz, Austria's second largest city, after a gunman opened fire in broad daylight. The BORG Dreierschützengasse school is being evacuated with officers swarming the scene. Austrian special task force Cobra has also been deployed to the horror incident, which unfolded at about 10am local time. There are fears as many as five people may have been killed and multiple people injured, according to local media, and a police spokesperson believes the shooter may be a pupil at the school. Students and teachers are believed to be among the victims. Federal police have been deployed to the scene, according to local reports. Cobra units - armed special forces part of the Federal Ministry of the Interior - have rushed to a community administered hospital nearby the shooting site. At keast five people may have died following the school shooting this morning. Police rushed to the scene at around 10am local time (9am GMT) this morning, in the Dreierschützengasse neighborhood, with a local spokesperson telling national broadcaster ORF early on that one person may have died. Fritz Grundnig said one person "possibly also dead" following the shooting. Police have confirmed in a post on X, formerly Twitter, that Cobra units were deployed to the site of the suspected shooting this morning. +++Aktuell läuft in der Dreierschützengasse in #Graz ein Polizeieinsatz. Bitte an die Anweisungen der Polizeikräfte halten. +++ #graz1006

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store