Joe Hart reveals what REALLY happened when Carlos Tevez refused to come on for Man City against Bayern Munich... and claims treatment of his old team-mate was 'unfair' after infamous clash with Roberto Mancini
Joe Hart has offered a fresh take on one of Manchester City 's most explosive controversies — claiming Carlos Tevez was wrongly portrayed as the villain in his infamous row with Roberto Mancini during a Champions League game in 2011.
The incident unfolded during a group-stage clash with Bayern Munich in September of that year, when then-manager Mancini accused Tevez of refusing to come on as a substitute with City trailing 2-0.
The Argentine forward had already been left on the bench in the previous league game and was clearly unhappy, but the fallout stunned the football world.
Mancini told Sky Sports post-match: 'He refused to come on. One player refused to go on – I can't accept this.' The Italian added that Tevez was 'finished' at the club.
Tevez denied flatly refusing to play, insisting: 'I had warmed up and was ready… I wish to state that I never refused to play.'
Despite that, he was suspended, placed on extended leave and did not appear again for the club until March 2012.
Now, more than a decade later, Hart has reflected on the chaos of that night in Germany — and believes the truth behind the row was more complex than it appeared from the outside.
'The whole drama surrounding Carlos during that Bayern Munich game, I felt was very unfair,' Hart said on BBC podcast Football Daily.
'I think Carlos did make himself available to come on the pitch, but he was asked to warm up, having already warmed up for 20 or 25 minutes, and then he was asked to warm up again to come on. I'm pretty sure he said, "I am warm."
Hart, who was City's No 1 at the time, believes the chaos stemmed from a combustible clash of personalities and poor communication on both sides.
He added: 'Both very, very hostile characters, which was part of why they were both good at what they did, but at that moment it clashed and it didn't work well.
'Mancini was very aggressive, very animated. He had a go at Edin [Dzeko] for some reason. Dzeko didn't really know what was going on, but it was like, "whatever".
'And then he went wild at Carlos. Both in broken English, didn't really understand each other. And I could see Carlos trying to find out what was being said to him. When he realised what had been said to him, he felt really wronged.
'It was a classic case of two alpha males having a different version of the same event and neither being able to say, look, we both need to calm down here and just sort this out — because they were both right to an extent.'
Despite being cast aside, Tevez returned later that season and helped City dramatically secure their first Premier League title in May 2012.
Now 41, Tevez was back in the spotlight at Old Trafford last weekend as he produced a headline-grabbing display at Soccer Aid.
Former City team-mate Joe Hart also took part in last weekend's charity game at Old Trafford
The former United and City striker scored four goals in 15 minutes to help the World XI overturn a two-goal deficit and beat England 5-4 in the charity game.
He was loudly booed before he'd even kicked a ball — a reflection of lingering resentment among Manchester United fans after his acrimonious 2009 switch to rivals City.
Tevez, who won six trophies at United including two Premier League titles and the Champions League, famously featured on a 'Welcome to Manchester' billboard after making the move across town.
At Soccer Aid, he revelled in the pantomime villain role — cupping his ear and showing off the back of his shirt after each goal.
He was also booked for cynically dragging down Aaron Lennon late on — with the referee playfully allowing Lennon to show him the yellow card — and clashed with YouTuber Angry Ginge, who was left with a nasty gash on his leg after a crunching collision.
Ginge later posted a photo of the wound on social media with the caption: 'Cheers, Tevez, t***'.
Hart also featured at Soccer Aid last week, starting for the England XI at Old Trafford.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
34 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Jasprit Bumrah entered the arena like a gladiator and we stood still in the presence of greatness, writes OLIVER HOLT after India bowler dismantles England's top order at Headingley
The floodlights came on at Headingley in the early afternoon of an oppressive June day, the better to illuminate the scene. It bore its moment in the spotlight, too, because it presaged one of the most gladiatorial entrances of any sport: the arrival of the great fast bowler. When Jasprit Bumrah stood at the top of his mark at the Kirkstall Lane End, everything seemed to stop. The hum of the hordes on the Western Terrace quieted. Even the proud brick houses on Cardigan Road, their attic windows open in the heat, gazed down on the contest. Whatever else happens in this summer of sport, the sight of Bumrah bowling at English batsmen will be one of its highlights. Because you need know little about cricket to recognise when you watch him, and when you watch the effect he has on opponents, that you are in the presence of greatness. Only 86 bowlers have taken more than 200 Test wickets and none have done so at a lower average than Bumrah's 19.4. His slingshot action makes him an enigma, too, difficult to read, difficult to play against. It adds to the compelling nature of the spectacle. The contest between Bumrah and Joe Root, England's best batsman of this era, and perhaps of any era, may yet come to define this five-Test series but the first five-over spell of his visit to England was a wonderful glimpse of the dramas and dangers and alarms and unease that his bowling will plunge England into. Part of the theatre is the idiosyncrasy of his technique. He starts his run-up like a nag, halting and reluctant, not looking like he wants to continue, seeming as if he might give it all up and start again. And then he accelerates into it. And by the time he arrives at the crease, he is almost dancing. Now he's not a nag. He's a Lipizzaner, prancing and snorting, elegant and imperious, the best bowler in the world. 'Bumrah's first half a dozen steps to the crease aren't even running,' former England spinner Phil Tufnell said on Test Match Special. 'He bowls 90mph off about four paces.' The ball's trajectory, coming from behind the perpendicular, makes his deliveries even more difficult to face. Zak Crawley had the misfortune to face him first. He looked trapped before the ball had left Bumrah's right hand. He edged the fourth ball of England's innings past the slips for a four to third man. That was as good as it got for Crawley. Bumrah's sixth ball was a Jaffa. It did Crawley all ends up. The England opener tried to get behind it, tried to fend it off, but it turned him inside out and caught the edge of his bat. It flew straight to Karun Nair at first slip and he caught it without alarm. Only when Mohammed Siraj came on did Duckett and new batsman Ollie Pope find any respite. Facing Siraj felt like freedom compared to facing Bumrah. They loosened up and played their shots. They were in charge. When Bumrah returned, Duckett and Pope were in captivity again. Bumrah's seventh ball was an outswinger. Duckett swiped at it outside his off stump. Bumrah had deceived him. The ball fell just in front of gully. It was an escape. Bumrah's 10th ball was a yorker, a brilliant yorker. His yorker is a thing of legend, a delivery perfected by India's equivalent of kicking a football against a garage door again and again and again to hone technique. Bumrah perfected his yorker as a kid by bowling a cricket ball into the skirting board at his home in Ahmedabad. 'Summers in India can be really hot in the afternoon,' Bumrah told The Guardian earlier this year, 'and parents don't let kids out. I was a hyperactive kid, lots of energy, but my mother would sleep in the afternoon. 'Then I found that if I bowled a ball into the skirting board, it didn't make a sound. So I could bowl without disturbing her. I did not imagine at the time it would develop into a yorker, I really didn't know what one was.' This yorker did not hit a skirting board. It hit Duckett's boot. Bumrah was convinced it was out but the umpire disagreed. India reviewed it. The ball had pitched outside leg. Duckett was reprieved. Bumrah's 14th ball found late swing. Pope flailed at it. It flew at catchable height through the gap where a fourth slip would have been. By the end of the over, Bumrah would be bowling to five slips and a backward point. Four balls later, Bumrah found Duckett's edge again. The ball flew past Yashasvi Jaiswal at gully. If you were to be uncharitable, you would have said it was a drop. India's fielders put their hands on their heads in despair. Bumrah smiled. With the last ball of his fourth over, Bumrah got the better of Duckett yet again. The England opener drove at the ball but could not keep it down and it flew to Ravindra Jadeja at backward point. Jadeja is one of India's best fielders. It was a comfortable chance. To general astonishment, he put the ball down. This time, Bumrah did not smile. He beat the air in frustration. England's torture was almost over. Bumrah's fire finally began to dim. With the last ball of his final over of the spell, Duckett drove him through the covers for four. It was the first time any of England's top three batsmen had looked comfortable in Bumrah's entire opening salvo. It had been a treat, frankly, an opportunity to see the best Test bowler in the world at the top of his game, exhibiting his craft. He could have taken five wickets but one was enough to show us what this summer holds. He did eventually bowl Duckett later in the afternoon. The batsman had almost had his nine lives by then. And a minute or two after 5.30pm, Bumrah bowled his first ball of this series to Root. He found an edge. It did not carry.
South Wales Argus
41 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Ben Duckett thrilled as Ollie Pope silences questions about his England place
Pope was at the centre of an outstanding day of ultra-competitive Test cricket against India, finishing with exactly 100 not out as England fought their corner under pressure in this Rothesay Series opener. He walked out to bat on the second afternoon with everything stacked against him – India boasting 471 first-innings runs and the peerless Jasprit Bumrah having just made short work of Zak Crawley with the new ball. That 💯 moment… Take a bow. Oliver John Douglas Pope 🫡 🤝 @IGcom — England Cricket (@englandcricket) June 21, 2025 With grey clouds overhead and floodlights needed to improve visibility in the middle, it was a deeply unappetising situation for a player who came into the game with his place under scrutiny. A few hours later, having guided his side to 209 for three, the mere suggestion that he might be replaced any time soon felt fanciful in the extreme. 'It was goosebumps when he got his hundred, you could see what it meant to him,' said Duckett, who shared a stand of 122 with the vice-captain. 'He probably couldn't walk out in tougher conditions, Jasprit running down the hill with the lights on. 'There's no better feeling than that, scoring 100 against that attack after coming out at four for one. You can see that in the way he celebrated but it didn't just mean a lot to him, it meant a huge amount in the dressing room as well.' Much had been made of a theoretical head-to-head between Pope and rising star Jacob Bethell, a notion captain Ben Stokes swatted away on the eve of the match as he threw his full support behind the incumbent. The selection debate has been too loud to avoid but the Surrey man may well have settled it in the most public way possible, bat in hand in front of a sellout Saturday crowd in Yorkshire. 'We're very good at keeping things in the dressing room but obviously you can hear the noise from outside,' admitted Duckett. 'We're not having discussions in the dressing room about who's going to play. But the way Popey has dealt with that has been superb. It sums up and proves why he's England's number three and is doing what he's doing.' Duckett had a front row seat as Bumrah threw everything he had at England. The unpredictable paceman finished with three for 48 from 13 electric overs but could easily have doubled his haul given the number of edges, chances and near misses he generated. Ben Duckett played his part (Danny Lawson/PA) The last of those saw him have Harry Brook caught for a duck only to be called for a no-ball, a late gut punch, but he will surely be back for more. 'He's the best bowler in the world,' said Duckett, who was eventually bowled for 62. 'He's good in India on the flattest pitches ever and, when he's coming down the hill with the lights on, swinging both ways, it's tough. 'I feel we minimised the damage early on, it could have been a lot worse today so we're pretty happy with the position we're in.'
Daily Mail
41 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Love him or not, Rishabh Pant is the most watchable cricketer on the planet, writes LAWRENCE BOOTH... after India star's electric performance at Headingley
Rishabh Pant brought up his century with a one-handed mow off Shoaib Bashir into the Western Terrace, and celebrated with a somersault. Somehow it felt like a normal few seconds in the life of the world's most watchable cricketer. There was more to come as India threatened mayhem on the second morning of the first Test. Two balls later, he deposited Bashir for a straight six. Not long after that, he slog-swept him for six more. Next ball, on 124, he charged at Bashir, and should have been stumped by Jamie Smith. It was like watching a highlights package, in real time. The only surprise came after a message arrived in the middle from India's 12th man. Pant went into his shell, and was finally leg-before to Josh Tongue for 134 playing a shot few knew existed in his repertoire: the shouldering of arms. Had he been advised to rein it in? If so, England were delighted. Still, a bright morning in Leeds had been further illuminated by Pant's brilliance, thrilling a capacity 18,000 crowd who were cheering mainly for England but couldn't help but be enchanted by India's wicketkeeper. And the tourists' subsequent collapse, with seven falling for 41, only reinforced the value of his knock. Pant arrived in England needing no introduction, his reputation as an innovator and an imp preceding him. And on the first evening here, when others might have defended in the day's last over against the second new ball, he danced at Chris Woakes and smeared him for six. It was the shot of a player at ease with himself — and with the potential consequences of his actions. This is a man who nearly died in a car crash two and a half years ago. What does cricket matter? The Indian debate around Pant can feel like a microcosm of the English debate around Bazball: when he comes off, he's loved; when he doesn't, he's loathed. 'Stupid, stupid, stupid,' roared Sunil Gavaskar after one harebrained dismissal in Australia over the winter. No one felt inclined to disagree. But you'd have to be especially po-faced not to enjoy Pant, who now has more Test hundreds — seven — than any other Indian wicketkeeper, including MS Dhoni. Throw in seven dismissals in the nineties, and there is a strong case for handing Pant the gloves in a World XI. Three of his hundreds have now come in England, two more than any other visiting wicketkeeper. His innings, meanwhile, contained six sixes, a record for any tourist in this country, gloves or not. Pant, still only 27, was made vice-captain for this trip, part of India's reset following the retirements of Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma, yet there was no expectation that the step up in office would be accompanied by greater responsibility. Whether falling over while sweeping Bashir over his shoulder, or advancing at the quicks as if they were medium-pacers, Pant does things his way. Cricket fans on both sides are in for quite a summer.
