With a jury now in place, the heart of Karen Read's retrial is set to begin
After three weeks of jury selection, a panel of nine men and nine women has been seated in the murder retrial of Karen Read.
Read, whose trial in the death of her police officer boyfriend exposed allegations of law enforcement misconduct, returned to court in suburban Boston this month to be retried on charges of second-degree murder and other crimes.
Read's widely publicized first trial ended with a hung jury last summer.
The heart of the trial is set to begin Tuesday with opening statements.
Here are key dates in the case.
Jan. 29, 2022: John O'Keefe is found dead
John O'Keefe, a 16-year veteran of the Boston Police Department, was found unresponsive in the yard of a now-retired Boston police sergeant, Brian Albert. O'Keefe, 46, was pronounced dead shortly after and a medical examiner attributed his cause of death to hypothermia and blunt-force trauma to the head.
The night before, the couple had been drinking with other law enforcement officers in Canton, just south of Boston, before they drove to an afterparty at Albert's home.
What followed was not captured on video and no witnesses have claimed to have seen what led to O'Keefe's death. But lawyers for Read, an equity analyst who'd been together with O'Keefe for two years, later said that she dropped him off at Albert's home and watched him go inside.
Hours later, after discovering that her boyfriend never came home, Read's defense team said that she went out looking for him — and, eventually — discovered his body in the snow outside Albert's home.
In court, Albert denied that O'Keefe ever entered his home. And after Read was arrested on charges of second-degree murder, motor vehicular manslaughter while driving under the influence and leaving the scene of a collision causing death, prosecutors painted a different picture of what investigators believe happened.
April 2024: A widely watched first trial
When Read's trial got underway last April, the Norfolk County District Attorney's Office described a relationship in shambles and a drunken defendant so furious with her partner that she backed into him with her Lexus SUV and left him for dead.
Adam Lally, the assistant district attorney who prosecuted the case, pointed to vehicle data that captured Read reversing her Lexus for 60 feet at 24 mph outside Albert's home and forensic testing that showed O'Keefe's hair found on the vehicle's bumper.
Also found the on vehicle's bumper were the remnants of a drink — O'Keefe was seen leaving a bar earlier that night with a cocktail in hand — and bits of a drinking glass, Lally said.
Read's defense team was allowed to make a third-party culprit defense, permitting them to call witnesses and present evidence supporting an alternative theory of O'Keefe's death.
According to that theory, O'Keefe was fatally beaten and bitten by a dog in Albert's home. Her legal team alleged that Read was framed by Albert and another person who'd been at the party — an agent with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives who'd traded flirtatious texts with Read before the defense said she ghosted him. (Albert testified that O'Keefe never entered his home but he would have been welcomed with "open arms" if he had.)
The defense also accused the lead investigator in the case, former Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Proctor, of manipulating evidence, failing to properly examine the case and leading a biased investigation. Among the evidence introduced were text messages that showed Proctor using derogatory language to describe Read to friends, family and supervisors.
At one point, Proctor said that he hoped Read would take her own life.
Proctor acknowledged making unprofessional comments about Read and sharing details of the investigation with his sister, who was close friends with Albert's sister-in-law, but he said he only provided 'newsworthy stuff' and he denied that his conduct compromised the integrity of the investigation.
July 1: A mistrial is declared
After a nine-week trial and five days of deliberations, Norfolk County Superior Court Judge Beverly Cannone declared a mistrial when jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict.
The Norfolk County District Attorney vowed to retry the case and appointed Hank Brennan, a former prosecutor and longtime criminal defense lawyer who previously represented Boston gangster James 'Whitey' Bulger, to be lead prosecutor.
The defense sought to have the crimes dismissed, alleging 'extraordinary governmental misconduct' and saying that retrying her for two of the charges, including murder, amounted to double jeopardy. The lawyers made the second claim after they said two jurors came forward after the trial and said the panel would have acquitted Read of those crimes.
Judges in superior and federal court denied both claims.
March 19: Lead investigator Michael Proctor is fired
A trial board with the Massachusetts State Police fir ed Proctor after determining he violated agency rules by sending derogatory texts about Read and sharing confidential investigative details with non-law enforcement personnel.
The panel also found that he drank alcohol on duty and drove his cruiser afterward.
Proctor has not publicly commented on his termination, but his family said they were 'truly disappointed' with the board's decision, which they said 'unfairly exploits and scapegoats one of their own, a trooper with a 12-year unblemished record.'
'Despite the Massachusetts State Police's dubious and relentless efforts to find more inculpatory evidence against Michael Proctor on his phones, computers and cruiser data, the messages on his personal phone — referring to the person who killed a fellow beloved Boston Police Officer — are all that they found,' the family said in a statement.
'The messages prove one thing, and that Michael is human — not corrupt, not incompetent in his role as a homicide detective, and certainly not unfit to continue to be a Massachusetts State Trooper,' the statement added.
It isn't clear what role Proctor will play in the retrial and legal experts told NBC News that his presence will likely loom over the proceedings.
April 1: The second trial gets underway
Jury selection began in Read's retrial in a Norfolk County courtroom, with prosecutors and defense lawyers questioning hundreds of potential jurors.
After three weeks of screening jurors, the panel was seated.
The 18 jurors include six alternates.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Leamington Spa shop closed down over illicit vape sale concerns
A convenience store has been forced to shut down after concerns around the sale of "illicit" vapes and tobacco and child exploitation.A full closure order was served on Mars Mini Market, on Clemens Street, Leamington Spa, after the application was granted at Coventry Magistrates' Court on 30 May, Warwick District Council said.A spokesperson added the notice followed "serious concerns" from the community around anti-social behaviour and exploitation of children and young people."Working in close partnership with Warwickshire Police and Warwickshire Trading Standards, we took decisive action to prevent further harm from taking place," they added. The council's community safety team encouraged people to continue reporting concerns so that it could "respond swiftly" and take action against any other businesses operating in a similar way."The community safety team would like to express our sincere thanks to the community for providing vital intelligence that supported us throughout this process," it added."Your information made a significant difference and directly contributed to the success of this case." Follow BBC Coventry & Warwickshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Daily Mail
3 days ago
- Daily Mail
BREAKING NEWS Chris Minns gives Anthony Albanese's government a brutal wake-up call on issue impacting millions
The leader of Australia's most populous state has called for a review of the 'massive' federal excise on tobacco amid concerns of a growing black market. Ahead of the NSW budget on June 24, Premier Chris Minns said a decision had to be made about resources devoted to combating illicit tobacco sales. It could mean reallocating police away from domestic violence, youth crime and gang cases to regulate tobacco sales. 'We may need to do that because I'm concerned as a constituent and as a father to see the number of high street premises being taken over by tobacco firms,' he told reporters on Monday. 'But I wonder whether we need to roll this back a couple of steps and look more closely at the federal government's massive excise on tobacco.' The excise has driven down the number of smokers in NSW to about one in nine adults, the state's most recent population health survey shows. But the 'massive increase' in excise had 'exploded the illicit tobacco marketplace', Mr Minns said. 'It's meant that many people who wouldn't go near an illegal behaviour ordinarily are buying illicit tobacco almost on a daily basis,' he said. He called for the size of the excise and its influence on illicit tobacco sales to be investigated. There are an estimated 19,000 tobacco retailers in NSW, with a paid licensing scheme and steeper fines for selling illegal cigarettes to take effect in July to curb black market trade. Queensland police found a fake wall full of cash and a secret tobacco store on Thursday during a major crackdown on more than 20 illegal traders. In Victoria, illegal tobacco sales have prompted regular violence, with more than 100 firebombings in two years. The federal tobacco excise topped $1.40 per cigarette in March but the expected tax take has nosedived, with almost $7 billion wiped from projections in the federal budget. Economist Chris Richardson called the excise increase without a commensurate enforcement scheme an 'epic policy fail'. Treasurer Jim Chalmers' March budget revealed $6.9 billion had been wiped off tobacco excise projections to 2029, with about one in five smokers shifting to illicit cigarettes or vapes. In response, federal Labor committed $157 million across two years for federal health, crime and tax agencies to strengthen enforcement and target crime gangs. NSW Opposition Leader Mark Speakman said he would not advocate for a reduction in the excise. He said it was up to the Commonwealth to determine the excise and states to enforce the law. 'This is a matter for NSW Health but clearly it has been incapable, and Chris Minns has been incapable, of tackling this scourge,' he said. Mr Speakman said an inquiry was considering enforcement alternatives. Mr Minns said on Monday he wanted health officials running hospitals, not criminal investigations or enforcing bans on nicotine vapes. An estimated one in five adolescents vaped at least occasionally in 2024, up from one in 40 adolescents in 2019. In 2021-22, an estimated 1.9 million Australian adults were current daily smokers. This represents about 10.1 per cent of the adult population, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics.
South Wales Guardian
5 days ago
- South Wales Guardian
Heaven security guard cleared of raping woman in his car near venue
Morenikeji Adewole, 47, of Dartford, Kent, had been charged with raping the woman near to the club in the back seat of his Lexus while she was drunk in the early hours of November 1 last year. The complainant had queued outside the club for around two hours with five friends for a Halloween-themed event but was denied entry for being too intoxicated, a trial at Southwark Crown Court was told. Adewole then walked her away from the club's entrance and picked her up in his car before driving the woman to a small road called Adelphi Terrace. A jury of eight men and four women reached a unanimous verdict on Friday after around six hours and 30 minutes of deliberations, with Adewole found not guilty of both rape and attempted rape. The defendant cried and wiped away tears with tissues in the dock as the verdicts were delivered in court. Giving evidence during the trial, Adewole claimed that there was sexual activity with the complainant but he did not have penetrative intercourse with the woman. He said that the woman had earlier told him she was 25-years-old but in the car she said she was 19 and he 'stopped immediately'. Addressing Adewole after the verdict, Judge Martin Griffith said he should still be 'absolutely ashamed' of himself for taking advantage of the drunken woman. The judge said: 'Your job was to take care of them (the club attendees). Your response to that was to go off in a car with her because your brain was driven by your groin.' The trial heard Adewole had used a false ID to get a job at the club, having been employed at Heaven under the name Olusola Julius Alabi, and was in the UK on a five-year tourist visa that did not allow him to work in the country. He had previously pleaded guilty to two counts of possession of an identification document with improper intention relating to the offences. Judge Griffith passed concurrent six-month custodial sentences for each offence, but said the time had already been served by the defendant during his time on remand. He added a victim surcharge would also be drawn up in due course. The judge told the jury: 'Thank you very much for the obvious care and attention that you took.' Heaven nightclub, which has operated in Charing Cross for more than 40 years, was temporarily closed down by Westminster City Council after the alleged incident on public safety grounds.
