Consumption and treatment sites in Kitchener and Guelph will close this week despite injunction being granted
A judge has ruled the consumption and treatment services (CTS) sites in Kitchener and Guelph can stay open.
But the win in an Ontario Superior Court doesn't mean the local sites will stay open beyond Monday — the day the province has said they must close by.
Sanguen Health Centre, which operates the Kitchener site, said in a social media post on Sunday that they will close. There are two reasons why, the post said. One is because the site's exemption under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act expires on Tuesday. The other is that there is no funding to remain open.
"We find the judge's acknowledgement of the potential harm caused by these closures hopeful," the statement said. "However, the situation is complex. The absence of provincial funding and the expiration of our CDSA exemption present significant barriers to maintaining services."
Melissa Kwiatkowski, CEO of the Guelph Community Health Centre which operates the CTS in Guelph, confirmed they are unable to extend CTS services beyond Monday.
"The government has been clear they will not fund the [CTS] site and will withhold funding from organizations that continue to operate," Kwiatkowski said in an email to CBC News on Sunday.
Last week, advocates from Toronto and Waterloo region took the province to court over the decision to close CTS sites across Ontario. They sought an injunction to stop the closures on March 31, a deadline set by the province. They also argued closing the sites violates both the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Constitution, including the right to life, liberty and security of the person.
On Friday afternoon, Justice John Callaghan of the Superior Court of Justice granted an injunction until he could make a decision on the Charter challenge, which he said will take more time to decide.
A spokesperson for Ontario Health Minister Sylvia Jones said the ruling doesn't change the province's plans to replace the CTS sites with homelessness and addictions recovery treatment (HART) hubs.
"Provincial funding for HART Hubs cannot be used for drug injection services and will be contingent on the organization not seeking to continue those services," Hannah Jensen said in a statement on Friday.
Diana Chan McNally, a Toronto community worker and expert in harm reduction, told CBC Toronto"even though we are not illegal at this moment, it does mean that we will most likely lose services" because of the lack of funding.
Kwiatkowski said the team at the Guelph Community Health Centre "continues with the difficult work of preparing our community for Guelph's CTS service to close on March 31st while we operationalize the government's new HART Hub model."
"Over the last seven months, we have worked diligently with many partners in our community to ensure this program provides urgent help to those who need it. Our HART hub will have some services available as of the 1st of April," Kwiatkowski said.
"While this is not a replacement for [a consumption and treatment site], it does have promise, and we want it to be a success for our community."
CTS closure a 'significant' loss: Sanguen
The site in Kitchener is the only one in Waterloo region. It has operated since 2019 on Duke Street W. near Kitchener's city hall and has offered people a space to use drugs with staff on-site, as well as other support services.
Sanguen has run the site on behalf of the region and reports there has never been a death at the site from an overdose. Staff intervened to prevent an overdose more than 1,000 times since 2019.
In 2024, the site saw more than 15,000 client visits and managed 79 on-site overdoses.
In its post on Sunday, Sanguen said the organization "remains absolutely committed to re-establishing fully funded and legally exempt supervised consumption facilities in our community."
"These services are integral to harm reduction efforts aimed at mitigating overdose risks and are a fundamental component of the health care we believe everyone is entitled to," the statement said.
Sanguen said they would reopen immediately "if we had the necessary exemption, facility and funding."
Advocates who are part of the Waterloo Region Drug Action Team are hoping to convince local politicians to find that funding.
In a letter sent to Waterloo region's MPPs and regional councillors on Sunday, and shared with CBC News, the drug action team urged the politicians to help keep the site in Kitchener open.
"One of the applicants in the court challenge is a resident of Waterloo region. The court has accepted the high risk of death and injury to CTS clients should CTS sites close, including the risk of death to the Waterloo region applicant. We do not want your constituent, or other CTS clients, to die," the letters said.
"The lives of constituents locally and beyond very much hang in the balance. Time is of the essence, obviously, and the community is unclear about how area MPPs are facilitating an emergency response."
HART hubs to open Tuesday
The province announced in August 2024 it would close consumption and treatment sites it deemed were too close to schools or daycares.
The sites in Kitchener and Guelph will be replaced by HART hubs, with HART standing for homelessness and addiction recovery treatment.
The biggest difference will be that drugs will not be allowed inside HART hubs. That means people cannot use or have drugs tested on site.
In Kitchener, the HART Hub will be located at 44 Francis Street S. and will be operated by the organization Community Healthcaring Kitchener-Waterloo. It is still slated to open on Tuesday with provincial funding.
It will offer services including mental health, addictions, transition beds and help with housing, identification and employment.
In Guelph, the HART Hub will remain at the Guelph Community Health Centre, although staff say not all services will be available right away as the provincial funding is worked out.
Kwiatkowski previously told CBC News services like crisis and withdrawal recovery beds and supportive housing units will be placed on hold for now.
"I know how much we asked for, but we don't know how much we're getting," she said in an Interview with CBC News. "We can't spend money we don't have."
In an email to CBC News, Ontario's Ministry of Health said it continues to work with HART Hub partners to collect information for their multi-year budgets.
The Ontario government is investing $529 million to create a total of 27 hubs across the province. Nine of those hubs are expected to be open by Tuesday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
12 hours ago
- CBC
Homelessness and addiction hubs in Sault Ste. Marie and Sudbury face delays opening
Social Sharing Treatment (HART) hubs in northeastern Ontario are still waiting for final approvals from the province to start operating. On the eve of the provincial election, Ontario Health Minister Sylvia Jones announced 19 new HART hubs would be operational by April 1. The hubs would provide access to recovery and treatment systems for people struggling with addictions and mental health issues, but would not provide any safe drug consumption services. Lisa Case is the CEO of the Canadian Mental Health Association (CMHA) Algoma, which was chosen to run the HART hub in Sault Ste. Marie. She said the organization has submitted its budget with the province for the planned hub. Ontario's Ministry of Health and Ontario Health have reviewed that submission, Case said, but now she's waiting for additional feedback. "We have received updated terms and conditions related to that funding that we're reviewing with our partners and responding with some additional questions, but we're still in that holding pattern right now," Case said. She said the province has allocated CMHA Algoma a budget of $6.31 million annually over three years to run its HART hub. Case added the services are especially needed in northern Ontario. "We've been hit harder across the north in spite of the creativity that we've used as community partners and the interventions we're able to provide," she said. "We're seeing just the volumes of individuals seeking help and then often the distance to get help." The City of Greater Sudbury will run a HART Hub in collaboration with the Health Sciences North hospital. The city says it's still finalizing logistical details but should have more concrete information to share by next week. Ema Popovic, a spokesperson for Ontario's health minister, said in an email to CBC News that nine HART hubs in the province that were previously supervised drug consumption sites opened on April 1. That includes the NorWest Community Health Centre in Thunder Bay.
CBC
6 days ago
- CBC
Peer support agency in Thunder Bay, Ont., readies for relocation, new supportive housing
Social Sharing A peer support agency in Thunder Bay, Ont., is relocating its drop-in centre, as it expands its services to include supportive housing on the south side of town. People Advocating for Change Through Empowerment (PACE), located at 510 Victoria Avenue E., is a central location for some of the city's most vulnerable. There, they can get food and free clothing, do their laundry, take a shower and connect with others in a safe environment. The organization has recently become involved in the province's new Homeless and Addiction Recovery Treatment Hub (HART) program, following the closure of the region's only supervised consumption site, Path 525, at the end of March. "We love this space. However, to make it work better with the new initiatives coming up by the government and for the initiatives going on in this business area, like the [Victoriaville] mall coming down, our people need a place to go," said Georgina McKinnon, PACE's executive director. In the coming weeks, PACE will relocate to 409 George St., directly across from Shelter House, remaining in the neighbourhood it's been serving for years. With the new space comes room for a dozen new supportive housing units, which McKinnon hopes become part of a continuum of care for people recovering from addiction, she said. "We're hoping to be one of the last steps, that people come out of recovery, go into more heavily-supported housing, down to lightly-supported housing," McKinnon explained. "We can help them out downstairs in PACE before they get out into the world on their own." The Thunder Bay district continues to have the highest opioid-related death rate in Ontario, at nearly five times the provincial average. NorWest Community Health Centres, which operated Path 525, is the lead partner for Thunder Bay's HART Hub. Unlike supervised consumption sites, HART Hubs do not allow supervised drug consumption, safer supply or needle exchange programs. According to the province, they instead focus on providing primary care, employment support, and mental health, addiction and social services — much of which PACE already offers. "I'm so excited," McKinnon said of the upcoming move. "PACE is expanding in so many ways, it's amazing." 'They help me with all of it' Everyone who works at PACE has lived experience of the challenges their clients are going through, such as homelessness, addictions and mental health issues. David Baumgartner is a long-time client at PACE who started coming there when he was staying at an overnight shelter. "It kind of became like my second home. I'm here often, pretty much every day, for everything from just talking to people to eating to getting clothes, whatever," he said. "They help me with all of it." He said it's important for the city to support places like PACE, which are open to everyone. "Even though I have an apartment, I still come here to eat. I come here to get out of the house; it gets depressing sitting in there all the time," Baumgartner said. "It kind of became like my second home." - David Baumgartner, client at PACE "It's really important to have a space like this, where people can feel safe." McKinnon said PACE is planning a seamless transition to its new space to avoid any disruption in services. A moving company is expected to start bringing things over from the Victoria Avenue East location in mid-July. Renovations have already started at the George Street building, she said. Her hope is that as PACE expands its presence in the region, more people gain a better understanding of the clients it serves. "Once you get to know the people that come to PACE, you get a whole different idea of them. They're wonderful people that really want to give back to the community," McKinnon said. As temperatures begin to rise, she said PACE is most in need of donations of seasonal clothing — especially for men — as well as shoes, kitchen and household items and fans.
CBC
30-05-2025
- CBC
Drug checking machine reopens in Kitchener despite consumption site closures
A local health centre says their drug checking machine is back in action — despite the province passing legislation that banned similar harm reduction policies in certain areas of Ontario. Sanguen Health Centre said on social media that they received an exemption for their machine that tests illicit drugs for cross-contamination. They said a new drop-in location will be open on Mondays, Tuesdays and Fridays at 130 Victoria St. S. in Kitchener and testing started on Friday. The centre previously ran the region's consumption and treatment services (CTS) site on Duke Street W. It served Waterloo region residents, using harm reduction and safe supply techniques, from 2019 to 2024. They were closed in April due to the Progressive Conservative government's shift away from CTS sites that allowed drugs on the premises and were too close to schools or daycares. Leigh Wardlaw is the co-ordinator of the drug checking program and said that the exemption for their machine is outside the scope of provincial legislation. "We have our own exemption," she said, adding the drug checking program exemption was granted by Health Canada through the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act. "It's been a very eye-opening experience in itself as we didn't know what was in the local drug supply," Wardlaw said. "We only used test strips before and now we're finding all these new things ... so we're able to educate the public on what we're seeing." CTS replaced by HART hubs Homelessness and Addictions Recovery Treatment (HART) hubs replaced CTS sites in Kitchener, Guelph, Hamilton, Thunder Bay, Ottawa and Toronto. Drugs or drug consumption are not permitted on site at the HART hubs. Waterloo region's HART Hub is operated by Community Healthcaring Kitchener-Waterloo and operates on Francis Street. In March, advocates took the province to court over the closure of CTS sites, saying closing the sites violates both the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Constitution, including the right to life, liberty and security of the person. Justice John Callaghan of the Superior Court of Justice granted an injunction until he could make a decision on the Charter challenge, which he said will take more time to decide. That meant the CTS sites could remain open; however, most organizations said they lacked the funding to keep operating. Despite lack of funding and strained resources, Sanguen Health Centre appealed for an exemption from Health Canada in order to continue operating their drug checking machine. Bill 223, the provincial legislation passed that made CTS sites illegal if they were within 200 metres of a school or daycare, does specify that any exemption requires the approval of the provincial Ministry of Health. But Wardlaw said she doesn't expect a legal battle to ensue as a result of the exemption and that the province holds much of the power regardless. "They're essentially the ones that hold the rug," she said. Ema Popovic, spokesperson for the Ontario Ministry of Health, told CBC News in an email that the provincial government's main priority is offering people who struggle with mental health and addiction treatment while "not giving them tools to use illicit drugs." "In the fall, we passed legislation that prohibits any local board of health from applying to participate in the federal governments so-called 'safer supply' programs and any request ... must receive approval from Ontario's Minister of Health," she said. "To be very clear, Sanguen has received no such approval." What is drug checking? In the name of safe supply, the Kitchener CTS site previously offered to check residents' drugs for cross-contamination with other substances that were more likely to facilitate an overdose. Sanguen Health Centre told CBC News that the drug checking machine was now able to operate at their new drop-in location and they received a mobile exemption and will try to create an outreach plan to get the machine on the road to other communities. Sanguen's drug checking program uses a Raman Spectroscopy to identify substances in minutes. Since 2023, Sanguen says they've been able to test thousands of substances including fentanyl, methamphetamines, crack/cocaine, MDMA and ketamine. Julie Kalbfleisch, director of Sanguen Health Centre, told CBC News in an email that funding for the drug checking program through Sanguen was part of a pilot project. Funding ran out at the end of last year but they "have enough funding to support the program until the fall." CBC News reached out to Health Canada about whether the drug-checking machine could receive federal funding but did not receive a comment. Kalbfleisch said Sanguen is currently seeking "other funding opportunities" and there are grant applications in the works. She added Sanguen is "grateful for the exemption from the federal government for this life-saving work" and that they "do not anticipate provincial backlash."
