Veteran activist John Minto unlawfully pepper-sprayed and arrested
John Minto was charged with obstructing and resisting police during a protest in Lyttelton on Waitangi Day 2024. Photo: RNZ / Pretoria Gordon
Police unlawfully pepper-sprayed and arrested veteran activist John Minto at a pro-Palestinian protest in Christchurch in February 2024, the Independent Police Conduct Authority has found.
The 70-year-old was charged with obstructing and resisting police during a Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa protest in Lyttelton on Waitangi Day, though charges were later dropped.
A police investigation concluded their actions were lawful, but that the officer had failed in his duty "to provide aftercare" after pepper-spraying Minto.
But the IPCA has found both the pepper-spraying and the arrest itself were unlawful.
In a letter from IPCA chair Judge Kenneth Johnston KC, he stated the authority found "a number of inconsistencies" between the account of the officer and video footage of the incident, which "led us to doubt the genuineness" of the officer's version of why he had used the pepper-spray.
The IPCA did "not accept" the police version that Minto had moved from where he was standing, or that the officer could have perceived Minto presented a real threat.
Johnston said the IPCA considered whether there was sufficient evidence for police to charge the officer with assault, but could not rule out the officer pleading self defence.
Instead, it asked police to "consider an employment process" for the officer involved.
The IPCA report said Minto was arrested for obstructing the arrest of another protester behind the officer who pepper-sprayed him, half an hour after that arrest and by a different officer.
But Johnston said there was "no case for obstruction", and no grounds to suspect Minto had hindered the arrest of the other protester, "or indeed showed any intention of doing so".
"Our view is that you were standing lawfully on the footpath both prior and during the other protester's arrest. The evidence does not show you advancing past where you were originally standing after being pushed by the officer who pepper sprayed you, and that you were not paying any attention to the arrest."
Police were approached for comment, but said they had only just been made aware of the ruling and would need more time to respond.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
2 hours ago
- Scoop
Government Warned Corruption And 'Insider Threats' Increasing In New Zealand
The government has been warned that corruption and "insider threats" are increasing in New Zealand, despite the country's longstanding reputation as a country largely free of it. An advisory group says the country is poorly prepared to tackle the increasing threat and recommends developing a national anti-corruption strategy and modernising the Crimes Act, which the Minister responsible says is key. The Ministerial Advisory Group on transnational and organised crime was set up in February to provide independent advice and recommendations to improve the cross-government response to what Associate Minister of Police Casey Costello described as " an increasing threat." Previous reports have said New Zealand was "losing the fight" against organised crime, and specified a need for police to have greater financial powers to fight it. The third report has stated New Zealand's "lucrative market" and established crime networks have made the country "more susceptible than ever" to corruption and insider threats. It also pointed to the "deteriorating situation in the Pacific" as making the region more vulnerable. It defined corruption as the "abuse of access or authority to advance the objectices of organised crime". "It is a critical enabler of organised crime, particularly at national borders. It grants criminal networks access to protection, sensitive information, and operational impunity. "This is a real and increasing threat," the report said. The group was told by enforcement agencies about "trusted insiders" at ports and airports helping to retrieve concealed shipments of illicit drugs before customs inspections. "That information is consistent with an unpublished global report which estimates that 70 percent of maritime seizures worldwide involved links to trusted insiders." It raised a specific concern in the Pacific where exposure is increased due to expansive maritime borders, strategic trade corridors and growing cross-border flows of goods and people. "When individuals in border security, customs, or immigration are compromised, criminal groups can exploit these weak points to smuggle drugs, weapons, other illicit goods, and people with minimal detection. "Bribery, coercion, and cronyism can transform ports, airports, and checkpoints into open channels." If corruption was left unchecked, the report warned it could erode the integrity of New Zealand's institutions and undermine its collective security. "We are already seeing increasing pressure on Pacific nations which have limited capacity to detect, investigate and prosecute organised crime threats. "The financial incentives offered by organised crime groups can be tempting - especially for those working in jobs with useful access, but low pay, in New Zealand and within the Pacific." The advisory group reports to Costello who told RNZ she was not surprised by the contents of the report, except to learn that New Zealand was the only Five Eyes member who did not have an anti-corruption strategy. She did however believe New Zealanders might be shocked to learn corruption was getting worse, "we've kind of considered ourselves as a little bit of a haven". The report specified New Zealand's "reputation as a country largely free from corruption has long been a source of national pride and international credibility". But also pointed this had led to a "degree of inertia," referencing Julie Haggie, chief executive of Transparency International NZ, who said in the report "New Zealand's response to increasing corruption pressures over several years has been lacklustre and complacent". "New Zealand is poorly prepared to deter and tackle the increasing threat of corruption, but that is not to say nothing is being done," said the report. Costello said the report was not suggesting organisations were corrupt, but the ability for organised crime to target individuals was there. "That's where we see that familial or cultural pressures, that ability to have control over individuals, and that's not just in the drug world." She said New Zealand was not out of control, but the country needed to shift the way it was doing things, strengthen legislation and put clear strategies in place. Costello believed bringing the Crimes Act up to date to deal with corruption was one of the key recommendations. She said work being done at the moment was bringing agencies together to have consistency around sharing information. Another recommendation was to have a centralised agency that would have oversight across all agencies. "Whether that's in the public service commission, or whether it's in police or SFO [Serious Fraud Office] or a new agency, it's having that one oversight so that we work more cooperatively." In regards to the Pacific, she said it was important New Zealand supported its economic growth and viability. "When people are poor, then the amount of money you need to corrupt someone is relatively low. "Leaning in more to support those economies to help them not just gain knowledge, but actually keep these systems in place. "How do they optimise their control of their border so they're collecting excise, that they're optimising the revenue they can get from legitimate business, as well as ensuring that they aren't corrupted." She said the reports were about making New Zealanders more aware about organised crime and an appreciation of the challenges that it presents.
Otago Daily Times
2 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Warning of phone scammers impersonating cops
Photo: RNZ Police are warning New Zealanders to keep an ear out for cold callers impersonating police officers. Waitematā's acting Detective Senior Sergeant Ben Bergin said scammers would pose as officers and try to extract personal details from the victim. "The story changes slightly, but it will usually involve some sort of investigation and this 'officer' will report having located a valuable item of yours, such as a passport," he said in a statement. "He will need your help or ask for your personal information. The caller speaks with an English accent and provides a bogus ID number to the victim." Police arrested a number of people last year for a similar scam, which involved the scammers asking victims to withdraw cash as part of an "investigation." "We strongly advise that you hang up," he said. "From time-to-time, Police officers may contact you as part of their genuine duties. It can be a bit surprising to receive a call unexpectantly, so stop and think if you get a far-fetched story shared down the telephone line."
Otago Daily Times
6 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Man admits murdering baby, trying to kill woman and child
Police and forensics staff at the scene following the incident. Photo: RNZ A 34-year-old man has admitted murdering a baby and trying to kill a woman and another child in a New Year's Day attack this year. The Hamilton infant died at a home on January 1, and an older child and a woman, understood to be their mother, were also attacked. NZME understands the woman was stabbed in the neck. This morning, a man reappeared in the High Court at Hamilton, where he pleaded guilty to murder and two charges of attempted murder. Defence counsel Richard Barnsdale made an application for his client's name to be permanently suppressed. Justice Kiri Tahana scheduled a date for that application to be heard in August and ordered interim suppression to continue. Crown Solicitor Rebecca Mann said she would likely file an application for permanent suppression of the victims' names. After reading reports that the defendant was not mentally impaired, Justice Tahana convicted the man and remanded him in custody for sentencing in September. Witnesses recount the horror While the media was declined a copy of the court's summary of facts today, due to issues around identifying victims, NZME spoke to several witnesses at the time of the incident. As police carried out their scene examination at the victims' home and another house on the street, blood was seen smeared on the walls of the porch and the front door frame of the second house. The residents at the property declined to comment, but others said the offender was stopped by police dogs nearby. He had been jumping fences, moving between properties, trying to escape police, they said. One local resident who said he was one of the first on scene, said: 'I knew the baby was gone ... it was lifeless'. He saw a man dragging a woman, bleeding from the neck, across the street. 'I was trying to look for [the alleged offender] to make sure the kids were okay because we know that they had kids there,' he said. The last time he saw the injured woman, she couldn't breathe properly but was speaking. Another neighbour said she and others helped keep two uninjured children safe, wrapping them in blankets. '[One child] was playing with a doll, and she mimicked what she saw. The trauma that poor child has to live with.' Near where the man was found, large pools of dried blood could be seen on the footpath. The incident brought many neighbours to tears.
