Royall: Booing during an Anzac Day service just ain't the Australian way
Don't miss out on the headlines from Opinion. Followed categories will be added to My News.
There are some special sounds that define Melbourne, that are part of our city's DNA.
The roar of the crowd for the opening bounce at the MCG, the steaming of an espresso coffee at Pellegrini's, the ding-ding of trams.
Another is not a sound at all. It's the hushed solemnity of the Anzac Day Dawn Service.
Every April 25, the ceremony at the Shrine of Remembrance is a beautiful, poignant event that brings a tear to your eye. I lose it every time at the hymn Abide With Me.
But as we now know, this year's service was marred by idiots. Just a few, a small minority among 50,000 Melburnians who had risen early to honour all who have served this great nation.
They first took exception to the welcome to country by Bunurong Elder Mark Brown.
MC Justin Smith acknowledged Indigenous including those who had served in uniform. 'We're here for the Australians,' one man shouted in reply.
Even Governor Margaret Gardner's Anzac Day address was greeted with abuse at the mention of acknowledging traditional landowners.
Most people — the decent ones there — were simply stunned at the brazen, unashamed vitriol. And didn't want to start a shouting match and further escalate the disturbance.
But in a small act of defiance, one woman called out 'always was, always will be' to a modicum of applause.
If you have an issue with Indigenous Australians and welcomes and acknowledgments, this was never the forum for it.
One of the main offenders of all this nonsense it seems was a known neo-Nazi – I won't dignify him by mentioning his name – who also screamed 'you're a traitor' at an ex-serviceman.
His young acolytes, for whom the process of evolution seemed to have bypassed, joined in the insults. Oinking at police and shouting 'hail Ned Kelly' and 'death to the police'.
Even I was called a traitor. Dunno why.
One was even wearing a poppy. Go figure.
Normally, I'd say that I support anyone standing up for what they believe in. But these are neo-Nazis. We have laws to deal with this sort of extremism.
We are lucky to live in a civilised society where shouting abuse during a solemn remembrance just ain't the way.
To quote a great Australian proverb: 'You dickhead.' 'Emotion in the air': PM, Dutton's powerful Anzac Day messages Ian Royall Reporter and Opinion Editor
Ian Royall is a general news reporter and opinion editor for the Herald Sun, with more than three decades' experience in journalism, home and abroad. Covers MotoGP too.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mercury
6 hours ago
- Mercury
AFL news 2025: Tasmania Devils team latest, Macquarie Point Stadium updates, Premier Jeremy Rockliff no-confidence motion
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News. Devils chief executive Brendon Gale says the 'no stadium, no team' condition for Tasmania's AFL entry remains crucial, stressing Hobart and Launceston's major venues are still 'not fit' to 'underpin a team in the big league on a sustainable basis'. Gale on Fox Footy's AFL 360 on Tuesday night remained defiant his club was still 'on track' to enter the AFL in 2028, despite a state government bombshell this week casting doubt over the Devils' future. Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff on Wednesday morning was hit with a no-confidence motion, which will continue to be debated in state parliament on Thursday. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. Opposition leader Dean Winter, who filed the no-confidence motion, wrote to AFL chief executive Andrew Dillon amid the parliamentary chaos on Wednesday and reaffirmed the Labor Party's support for the new Macquarie Point stadium build and the Devils' entry into the AFL. But Winter's move was based off claims the Rockliff Government had mismanaged the state's budget and bungled key infrastructure projects, including the proposed stadium. Should Rockliff fail to stave off the no-confidence motion, it's possible Tasmania will be pushed to a snap election, which could derail the new stadium plans and put the 19th AFL licence in jeopardy. The AFL on Wednesday reiterated it remained steadfast that a 'clear requirement' for Tasmania's inclusion is 'a new 23,000 seat roofed stadium at Macquarie Point'. That agreement is between the AFL and the state government, with the stadium needing to clear passage of both Houses of Parliament. Premiership Brisbane Lions coach – and Tasmanian football hall of fame legend – Chris Fagan said the AFL 'should let the team come in and then sort the stadium out' in the long-term, saying the Devils should just 'use facilities that are available' in Launceston and Hobart. 'It would be such a tragedy if the team itself doesn't go ahead because there wasn't a new stadium when there are other football fields down there that AFL footballers currently play on,' Fagan told the Herald Sun. 'The surfaces are fantastic. 'But I think it is only a noisy minority who don't want it (new stadium) anyway. The vast majority of Tasmanians I think do want it. 'Once you have the team in there, then these things become easier.' Tasmania Football Club CEO Brendon Gale. Picture: Linda Higginson When asked on Fox Footy's AFL 360 if the 'no team, no stadium' policy to introduce Tassie was 'too ambitious' and that 'too many stumbling blocks' had been placed in front of the key stakeholders, Gale said: 'No, I just think it's been a difficult concept to explain. 'Firstly, there's no good time to build a stadium around the world. They're always big and they're expensive, and there's always a whole range of other priorities … Whether it's Adelaide or Perth Stadium, they're difficult to get through and get popular support. 'I guess that's compounded by the fact that people in Tasmania think: 'Well, we've got two perfectly good stadiums in Hobart and Launceston, why can't we just have those?' And they're reasonable stadiums and they've been fit for purpose. But they're not fit for the purpose of providing sustainable commercial business model to underpin a team in the big league on a sustainable basis. 'It's hard to explain in seven or 10 seconds, but once you do have the time and space to explain, you know, why it is important – and then also the whole range of other benefits that will be created and will be unlocked – people tend to come around. But it's not easy.' The anguish of the impact of the political turmoil on the Devils was personified on Wednesday by club general manager of marketing, corporate affairs and social impact Kath McCann – the Devils' longest-serving official – who broke down in tears at a press conference. 'This club is powered by our future generations, by our kids and by our grandkids,' a teary McCann said. 'It's an opportunity to bring this state together, it's an opportunity to create pathways. 'I've got 50 students out here in my sight line, they power us every single day — and they will keep doing that and we're going to play on. We want to see this team become a reality because our young people deserve it.' Premiership Eagle Will Schofield was blown away by McCann's passion and 'powerful words'. 'This is more than just a footy club. This is something for an entire state, an entire generation of Tasmanians coming up behind it,' Schofield told Fox Sports News' AFL Tonight. 'It's a real instance of politics getting in front of people. This is a move that's going to change the state – and the football followers specifically in Tasmania, the people. So whether it be adults now or kids in future generations, being able to put this stadium together and this team together, it's more than just a game of footy. 'The cheques and balances will get done, but what's really sad is it seems like politics is getting in front of the people – of which I think a lot want this stadium and this team to come through. 'Knowing how big a football state Tasmania is, it'll be really sad for that to be lost.' Originally published as 'Politics in front of people': Great in awe of 'powerful words' as boss explains roadblock to Devils' stadium alternative
Mercury
12 hours ago
- Mercury
HAVE YOUR SAY: The big Devils questions
Don't miss out on the headlines from Sport. Followed categories will be added to My News. Tasmania's political upheaval has put the state's AFL team in jeopardy. But what are your views on the team and the stadium? Have your say and answer the big questions here. The survey closes at 12pm on Friday, June 13. AFL As Tasmania faces political upheaval and a new election which could spell trouble for the AFL's potential 19th team, the Devils have vowed to fight on. Sport After a Sunday night eating KFC and watching a movie with his young son, a much loved local sportsman went to sleep and never woke up. Now an event has been named in his honour.
Herald Sun
12 hours ago
- Herald Sun
Former Whittlesea mayor Aidan McLindon told suspension is ‘unlawful'
Don't miss out on the headlines from North. Followed categories will be added to My News. A former Melbourne mayor who was suspended under new powers recently created by the state government wants to challenge the decision in the Supreme Court. Whittlesea mayor Aidan McLindon was suspended for six months on April 16 following a recommendation by Local Government Minister Nick Staikos. It was the first time the power had been used since it was introduced in October as part of amendments to the Local Government Act 2020. The change allows the Local Government Minister to recommend a councillor be suspended if they are found to create a serious risk to health and safety or prevented the council from performing its functions. In a written statement provided to the Herald Sun Mr McLindon said he had received advice from senior layers suggesting Mr Staikos had acted 'unlawfully'. 'As a result of this advice I will be applying to the Supreme Court to judicially review the actions of the Minister,' Mr McLindon wrote. Mr Staikos said Mr McLindon was suspended following a report by municipal monitors appointed to Whittlesea Council and other information provided. 'As the matter is expected to be subject to litigation, it would be inappropriate to comment any further,' Mr Staikos said. Mr Staikos recommended the sanction against Mr McLindon six weeks after Whittlesea chief executive Craig Lloyd banned the mayor from attending council premises in person — including the meetings he chaired — after he was accused of intimidating staff and other councillors. The ban followed a vote of no confidence in Mr McLindon by the city's other councillors. Immediately after his suspension Mr McLindon said he was being punished for speaking up for rate freezes and against rainbow flags being hoisted at childcare centres which no one else had the 'courage' to do. He denied being a 'bully' and 'aggressive', saying he had no arguments with staff and the accusations against him were false. '(The suspension) should send shivers down the spine of every democratically elected councillor in this state to say your jobs are no longer safe,' he said. 'Because what we have witnessed now is that if you ask a question, if you ask where the money is going … they will mobilise bureaucracy against you.' Following the suspension the state government announced a commission of inquiry into Whittlesea council to address 'potentially serious and systemic' governance issues. The four month independent inquiry began on May 19 and will examine matters affecting good governance at the council and any legislative, regulatory or other reform needed to address the issues occurring since the local elections last year. Mr Staikos said he believed a commission of inquiry was needed after receiving a letter co-signed by 10 councillors asking for an urgent intervention. 'The situation at the City of Whittlesea is unprecedented — including the unanimous no-confidence motion in the mayor and his subsequent ban from council premises for occupational health and safety reasons,' he said. 'We want Victorians to have confidence in their local councils. This inquiry will help to identify any changes needed to ensure the council is operating as required and in the best interests of its local community.'
