Only one delivery in two years at Thandikudi GH on Kodaikanal hills, reveals RTI reply
Due to insufficient doctors and facilities at Thandikudi Government Hospital at Kodaikanal hills, only one delivery has been performed in the last two years, said a Right To Information (RTI) Act reply.
Thandikudi GH, one of the three GHs in the hills, caters to the need of several hundreds of people, mostly Scheduled Tribes, residing in areas of Mangalamkombu, Malaiyakadu, Kottakombu, Kadukuthadi Pudur, among others.
For the immediate medical assistance of the tribal people residing in those areas, Poolathur Primary Health Centre (PHC) best serves their needs, said the residents. But, for serious health conditions, pregnancies and accident treatments, the patients have to visit either of the three GHs – Thandikudi, Pannaikadu and Kodaikanal.
For the people residing around the Thandikudi GH, accessing the other two GHs in the hills would mean travelling more than 25km to 30km.
As the sole doctor at Thandikudi GH, due to the insufficient doctors and health workers, could not serve all the people, refers them either to GHs at Pannaikadu and Kodaikanal, located more than 25km to 30km away.
Backing the claim of the people, a RTI data gathered by Madurai based health activist A. Veronica Mary specified that the Thandikudi GH has only one doctor in place of the sanctioned post of three doctors.
While only 11 postings of pharmacists, nurses, technicians, of the 18 postings are filled, two positions of doctors and seven positions of paramedical staff remained vacant, the RTI reply added.
Despite the hospital having 20 beds and having recorded an outpatient visit of 65,679 in 2023 and 75,780 in 2024, only a handful of people have been admitted as inpatients.
Such patients, who wanted to get admitted for delivering babies, treated for accident injuries, were referred to hospitals in places like Kodaikanal, Badlagundu and Dindigul, said Ms. Veronica Mary.
'As the hospital has ultrasound scan machine to monitor the condition of the foetus during the pregnant women prenatal tests, due to the unavailability of a radiologist, pregnant women are referred to other hospital even for their periodical monthly check ups,' she alleged.
To substitute for the vacant positions and to manage the burden, the existing doctor must rush to the hospital on 'call duty' even during odd hours, she stated.
When the pregnant tribal women had to get admitted to hospital during their labour pain, they had to rush to the far away hospitals through the only mode of transport – bus, Ms. Veronica Mary noted.
Due to unawareness about getting prior admission in hospital for delivery, most of the tribal women, instead of taking long-distance travel, preferred to deliver babies in their houses, she pointed out.
'Though they deliver their babies safely and mishaps are hardly reported, thanks to assistance of village elders, the hospital exists for such purposes,' she added.
A health official in the district said the ultrasound machine was installed and a used one from a different hospital.
'As it collapsed recently, it is currently not in use,' the official added.
Regarding doctors, the official said that as the GH was located in a very remote area, doctors preferred not to work there.
'Though appointments were due to the unwillingness of doctors, the positions still remain vacant,' the official noted.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
Pharma department refuses to name 30 doctors in bribery tangle
Representative image Thirty doctors who accepted foreign travel and hospitality worth Rs 1.9 crore from pharma company AbbVie in Feb-March 2024 have faced no action from NMC because the department of pharmaceuticals (DoP) has refused to make their names public and is yet to forward the names to the commission. The Uniform Code for Pharmaceutical Marketing Practices (UCPMP) bars pharma firms from offering travel or hospitality to healthcare professionals. Though the committee constituted by DoP found the foreign trips for doctors to be a violation of the law in Dec 2024, the names of the doctors had not been sent to NMC till May 8 this year, a response to an RTI application has revealed. Responding six months after receiving another RTI application seeking the names, the pharma department claimed the requested information "involves disclosure of names or personal information and also is not of public interest" and is accordingly not provided under section 8(1)(j) of RTI Act. In May 2024, the department had received a complaint that AbbVie sponsored a pleasure trip disguised as medical conferences to Monaco and Paris, with evidence including flight tickets and hotel bookings. DoP constituted a special audit committee to audit AbbVie and forwarded the complaint to the Ethics Committee for Pharma Marketing Practices of pharma association, Organisation of Pharmaceutical Producers of India (OPPI). by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Switch to UnionBank Rewards Card UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo Though OPPI's committee found no irregularities in AbbVie's sponsorship, the special audit exposed "explicit contravention" of UCPMP. DoP's apex committee examined the audit and concluded AbbVie had violated UCPMP. However, in its Dec 23, 2024 order, it let off AbbVie with just a "reprimand". However, in response to an RTI query to NMC in May this year, the panel informed the applicant "the list of 30 doctors is yet to be received by this commission". Ophthalmologist Dr KV Babu, who filed the applications, said, "DoP is shielding the doctors by refusing to disclose names and failing to follow up on its own committee's recommendation." "The only punishment so far is reprimanding the pharma company in a case where the department's own special audit and apex committee found clear-cut violations. Yet, the department is shielding the guilty doctors by refusing to reveal the names and claiming that there is no public interest in making the names public. And worse, they haven't even bothered to implement the apex committee's recommendation that the doctors' names be forwarded to the NMC to take action," said Dr KV Babu, an ophthalmologist and RTI activist who filed the RTI applications with the NMC and the DoP.
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Chandigarh administration proposes reduced security deposit for group home for mental health patients
1 2 Chandigarh: On the contentious issue of the 'exorbitant' security deposit for the Group Home for persons with mental disabilities, the Chandigarh administration is finally relenting and will reduce the deposit required for admission to the home. On the directions of the Punjab and Haryana high court, the administration called a meeting of the governing body of the UTTHAAN Group Home Society on Friday to discuss the quantum of the security deposit. "In the meeting, the administration proposed staggering the security deposit in terms of the category of the room – ranging from Rs 10 lakh to Rs 20 lakh," said Damanjeet Singh, Governing Body member (Family representative), UTTHAAN Group Home Society, who attended Friday's governing body meeting. Currently, the security deposit amount is Rs 20 lakh for all categories of rooms. Instead of Rs 20 lakh for everyone, the administration has proposed a category-wise security deposit. For the suite, it is proposed to remain the same at Rs 20 lakh; for the single room resident, it would be Rs 15 lakh; and for the double room resident, it is proposed to be Rs 10 lakh. The UT proposal will be submitted for the approval of the Punjab Governor and UT Administrator Gulab Chand Kataria, and after his nod, it will be submitted to the Punjab and Haryana High Court. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo On May 19, the high court, terming the security deposit of Rs 20 lakh for admission to the Group Home as "exorbitant," directed the administration to reconsider it. The bench of Chief Justice Sheel Nagu and Justice Sumeet Goel instructed the administration to "apply its mind on the aspect of the quantum of security amount of Rs 20 lakh, which deprives admission into the said Mental Illness Home even to deserving mental health patients merely because of a paucity of funds. " The court observed, "After hearing learned counsel for the rival parties, especially on the question of the quantum of security deposit of Rs 20 lakh required for admission of mental health patients in Group Utthaan Society and testing the same on the anvil of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, particularly Sections 18, 19, 20, and 21 of the Act, mandating every person suffering from mental illness to be treated with dignity, reasonableness, and without any discrimination, the quantum of security deposit of Rs 20 lakh is exorbitant. " In 2018, the parents and guardians of mental health patients demanded the setting up of a Group Home for mental health patients. Though the construction of the group home was completed, it is yet to become operational. Parents/guardians seek further reduction On the administration's proposal, parents and guardians have sought a further reduction. A parent, on the condition of anonymity, said, "As per the latest proposal, this works out to approximately equivalent to five years of monthly fees, which is still too much. Parents have been asking for a reduction of the security deposit equivalent to one year's fee." Parents and guardians have been demanding the security deposit to be fixed at Rs 4 lakh for suite residents; Rs 3 lakh for single room residents; and Rs 2 lakh for double room residents. "This is broadly in line with the security deposit being taken by NGO-run Group Homes across India," contend parents. Deposit row In 2022, the Chandigarh administration finally decided to set up such a group home in Sector 31. The group home building was completed in 2024. In October 2024, in the first meeting of the governing body, the security deposit was fixed at Rs 40 lakh for a suite, Rs 30 lakh for a single room, and Rs 20 lakh for a double room. This was opposed by the parents and guardians. In June 2024, the administration set it at Rs 20 lakh for types of rooms. Follow more information on Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad here . Get real-time live updates on rescue operations and check full list of passengers onboard AI 171 .
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
5 years on, new polyclinic hospital building in Pinjore remains incomplete
Panchkula: In a telling reflection of the sorry state of affairs, the construction of a new building for the polyclinic hospital in Pinjore, approved five years ago with a budget of Rs 7.52 crore, remains stalled. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now According to the public works department (PWD), the scope of the project expanded beyond the original plan. Initially, three floors were to be constructed within the sanctioned budget, but five floors were eventually built, even as the building is an unfinished state. "The approved amount has nearly been exhausted, so a revised estimate for the remaining work has been prepared and sent to the state government. Once approval is granted, the remaining construction will be completed," stated the executive engineer of the PWD construction division in response to an RTI query. The administrative approval for the project was granted on July 14, 2020. However, due to delays and mismanagement, the incomplete building is now deteriorating and will likely require additional maintenance and incur further costs. The existing hospital building, constructed during the British era, is too small to accommodate the current staff and patient load. With the new facility in limbo, residents are forced to rely on this cramped, outdated structure. Basic medical services are lacking; for instance, there is no X-ray facility, compelling patients to travel to Panchkula civil hospital, Chandigarh hospitals, or private facilities for even routine diagnostics. "The construction work has been halted for about one and a half years and has not resumed. The unfinished building is slowly falling into disrepair, yet neither the government, the health department, nor the local administration is taking any responsibility," said Vijay Bansal, an area resident and state president of Shivalik Vikas Manch. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now "The BJP govt has only shown dreams of providing employment, health, and education facilities to the residents of Kalka assembly constituency in its tenure of about 11 years, while the ground reality is telling something else. Development work is not happening fast in Kalka assembly constituency. Therefore, Pinjore-Kalka area has lagged in all other areas including employment, health, and education," alleged Bansal, who is also a Congress leader and wrote to the chief minister and health minister demanding health facilities in Kalka, Pinjore, and Morni area as soon as possible.
