DOJ launches California Title IX investigation over transgender athletes in youth sports
With the national spotlight shining on a transgender athlete in Southern California pursuing a championship, federal prosecutors are putting pressure on the state and a local school district for allowing that chase to happen in the first place.
The U.S. Department of Justice announced on Wednesday that it has opened an investigation into whether a California state law complies with Title IX.
In August 2013, then-Gov. Jerry Brown signed AB 1266 into law. The policy is intended to prevent sex-based discrimination in California's schools, preventing them from excluding gender groups from classes and extracurricular programs.
One specific section of the bill, however, is now under fire from the current administration.
"A pupil shall be permitted to participate in sex-segregated school programs and activities, including athletic teams and competitions, and use facilities consistent with his or her gender identity, irrespective of the gender listed on the pupil's records," AB 1266 states, requiring schools to adhere to each student's preferred gender identity rather than their sex assigned at birth.
Now, the DOJ is investigating whether this clause violates Title IX.
Title IX, in the words of the DOJ, ensures "equal educational opportunities and prevents discrimination based on sex in federally funded schools and athletic programs." Administration officials claim that allowing transgender girls to compete in girls' athletic competitions undermines the rights of cisgender athletes as an issue of fairness.
Title IX exists to protect women and girls in education. It is perverse to allow males to compete against girls, invade their private spaces, and take their trophies," said Harmeet K. Dhillon, Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights. "This Division will aggressively defend women's hard-fought rights to equal educational opportunities."
The announcement cites the ongoing legal battle surrounding two former athletes at Martin Luther King Jr. High School in Riverside. One of which alleges she lost a spot on the school's cross-country team to a transgender teammate, violating her Title IX rights as a female athlete.
The administration of President Donald Trump made its stance clear on that lawsuit Wednesday and threw its support behind it, sending legal notices of its investigation to California Attorney General Rob Bonta, State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond, and the California Interscholastic Federation.
The DOJ also sent a notice to the Jurupa Unified School District as an openly transgender track and field athlete pursues a state title for one of its schools.
AB Hernandez of Jurupa Valley competes in the girls high jump during the CIF Southern Section Division 3 Track and Field preliminaries at Nathan Shapell Memorial Stadium at Yorba Linda High School on May 10, 2025 in Yorba Linda, California.
Getty Images
AB Hernandez, a junior at Jurupa Valley High School, placed first at the CIF Southern Section Masters Meet in both the girls' long and triple jump events. The wins ensure Hernandez a spot at the CIF State Track & Field Championships in Clovis on Saturday and Sunday.
In response, the CIF announced Tuesday that it was introducing a pilot program for the 2025 state meet that will create extra spots for cisgender athletes "who would have earned the next qualifying mark" to have an opportunity to compete. Gov. Gavin Newsom, who himself has said it's "deeply unfair" to allow transgender girls to compete, called the program reasonable on Tuesday.
The JUSD said in a statement to CBS News this week that it allowed Hernandez to compete for JVHS as required by state law.
Hernandez has been subject to national scrutiny, including from the president himself. Trump took to his Truth Social platform this week to criticize California leadership, including Newsom, for allowing Hernandez to compete on the girls' team.
"This week a transitioned Male athlete, at a major event, won 'everything,' and is now qualified to compete in the 'State Finals' next weekend," Trump wrote. "As a Male, he was a less than average competitor. As a Female, this transitioned person is practically unbeatable. THIS IS NOT FAIR, AND TOTALLY DEMEANING TO WOMEN AND GIRLS."
Trump also said he was considering to withhold federal funding from the state if Hernandez was allowed to compete at the state finals.
While speaking with CBS News, a spokesperson for Hernandez called Trump's lashing out "bullying and discriminatory."
"This person was voted into an office to work for all the people, and you're gonna spend your time picking on a child," said Kathie Moehlig, the founder and executive director of Trans Family Support Services
As of Wednesday, it's not yet clear if attempts to remove Hernandez from the weekend's state meet will be successful.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
17 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Bipartisan deals on voting and election changes are rare. It just happened in one swing state
LAS VEGAS — Facing a legislature dominated by Democrats, Republican Gov. Joe Lombardo stood before Nevada lawmakers earlier this year with a message that some did not expect to go far: 'Set aside partisan politics.' It was a plea that might have seemed more aspirational than realistic, given the country's deep polarization. Yet it set the stage for one of the session's most unexpected outcomes — a bipartisan agreement to bring voter ID requirements to the perennial battleground state by next year's midterm elections.
Fox News
20 minutes ago
- Fox News
Adam Silver talks mid-market NBA Finals, new All-Star game format and the Mavs lottery
The Oklahoma City Thunder and Indiana Pacers will square off in the 2025 NBA Finals starting on Thursday night at the Paycom Center. It's a matchup of two teams who play in mid-level markets, which always creates the conversation about how the sport's ratings will fare outside of NBA diehards. On Wednesday's edition of "Breakfast Ball," NBA Commissioner Adam Silver offered up his take on why the matchup is great for the NBA. "At the end of the day, we are a league of relatively small markets. The goal is to have a league where every team is in position to compete," Silver said. "It's been intentional, from our standpoint, to create a system, a collective bargaining agreement [CBA], that allows more teams to compete. We're going to have to go through a process of getting to the point where people are accustomed to tuning into the finals because the two teams deserve to be there, and it's the best basketball. "If I asked somebody if they were going to watch the Super Bowl, they wouldn't say 'who's playing?' It's a national holiday. That's nirvana. If the Knicks are in the finals, there's a segment of our fan base that's going to watch that may not watch if it's other teams, but my job is to get people to love and follow this game, so that if you're a huge basketball fan, you should want to tune in to the finals because that's the best basketball." It's the first time that the Thunder have appeared in the NBA Finals since 2012 and the Pacers' first trip to the championship round since 2000. Here are some other notable tidbits from Silver's appearance: The 2025 NBA Draft Lottery had plenty of fireworks, as the Dallas Mavericks — who were 11th in the lottery seeding with a 1.8 percent chance of getting the No. 1 pick — won the lottery. Meanwhile, the Utah Jazz, who had the worst record in the NBA, fell from first to fifth, and the Washington Wizards fell from second to sixth. Dallas is expected to take Duke star and 2024-25 AP Player of the Year Cooper Flagg with the No. 1 pick. The Mavericks, shooting up from No. 11 to No. 1 in the draft order after trading Luka Doncic to the Los Angeles Lakers in February, drew criticism from the basketball world about the authenticity of the NBA Draft lottery. Silver provided his perspective on that narrative. "The worst-performing team had a 14 percent chance of winning [the lottery], which means there was an 86 percent chance they wouldn't get it," Silver said. "Dallas had roughly a two percent chance [to win it]. The team that lost the most had a seven times better chance. Two percent is two percent. It's going to happen. When people say 'and therefore the lottery was broken,' I have a different view. "The purpose of the lottery is to disincentive teams from tanking. Here, you had a team — regardless of whatever people think of that [Dončić] trade — that was trying to win. Then, Kyrie [Irving] got injured. Then, Anthony Davis got injured, and so, then they found themselves in the lottery. Odds are odds, and that's how it turned out." The NBA has dabbled in several All-Star game formats in recent memory, the most recent one seeing four teams playing against each other in a tournament. Those teams were made up of two NBA All-Star teams, a Rising Stars team and a "World Team." While Silver said that he wasn't "exactly sure what the format will be" for the 2026 All-Star Game, the commissioner expressed that he felt this year's "4-Nations Face-off" was a "huge success" and could serve as a potential model for the NBA. The "4-Nations Face-off" saw the United States, Canada, Finland and Sweden compete in a round-robin event earlier this year, with Canada defeating the United States in overtime of the title game. The NHL has several players who grew up outside the United States, primarily in Canada, while the NBA has several superstars who played internationally before coming to the NBA (e.g. three-time MVP Nikola Jokic, two-time MVP Giannis Antetokounmpo and Doncic). On that note, each of the last two No. 1 picks in the NBA Draft (Victor Wembanyama and Zaccharie Risacher) were players who competed professionally in France, with each of the first two selections in the 2024 NBA Draft (Alex Sarr, who played in Australia prior to being selected, was the No. 2 pick) being international selections. Is the United States losing its luster as the basketball empire of the globe? "I think there are things that Europe is doing better than we are in terms of training. I feel a bit defensive about the American players because it's not for a lack of a work ethic," Silver said. "In Little League, you have pitch counts for young pitchers. If you look at what's happening in AAU, in many cases, you have young players playing 6-8 games for two-to-three days at these tournaments. And I get it, if you're a young player and that's the game that Rick Pitino's coming to or whatever else, and you and the people around you feel he needs to see you play and your knee's throbbing because you're 15 years old, you're still going to play. "And I think it's another area that the NBA needs to get more involved in, and we've had these discussions with the NCAA just to have more oversight over youth basketball, because there's nothing more important to us than making sure that those elite players grow up to be team basketball players and not just have great skills but understand how to win games." Silver has been the NBA Commissioner since succeeding David Stern in February 2014. Want great stories delivered right to your inbox? Create or log in to your FOX Sports account, and follow leagues, teams and players to receive a personalized newsletter daily!
CBS News
20 minutes ago
- CBS News
Brenda Tracey speaks out after latest lawsuit involving former Michigan State University coach Mel Tucker
Rape survivor and activist Brenda Tracy is suing Michigan State's Board of Trustees for mishandling the case involving former Michigan State University football coach Mel Tucker. Tracy accused Tucker of sexual harassment. The allegations became public after a USA Today report in September 2023. In a sit-down interview with CBS News Detroit on Wednesday, Tracy says she wants justice. "I'm seeking accountability for what has happened to me. I feel that I've been harmed," she said. "I was then sexually harassed by a person who pretended to be an ally to survivors of sexual violence. If it wasn't true, would be it would be almost unbelievable, right?" The 51-page lawsuit filed Tuesday details interactions between Tracy and Mel Tucker dating back to 2021, including a phone call between the two during which Tucker allegedly pleasured himself without her consent. Tucker has maintained that the pair had a consensual relationship, which Tracy has denied. The new lawsuit alleges that the Board of Trustees shared information about the investigation into Tracy's sexual harassment complaint, which would breach the university's "duty of care." It explicitly names Trustees Rema Vassar and Dennis Denno as defendants and alleges they likely leaked Tracy's name to new outlets and others. "I think people underestimate my resilience, and they underestimate my determination," Tracy said. "There's been this lack of transparency, not giving over your phone, not cooperating with investigators, that kind of thing, like you are trustees. The word trust matters." Tracy is seeking compensatory and punitive damages. She says since the case broke, she's been unemployed, and her nonprofit is no longer active. "My reputation has been destroyed. Personal relationships have been harmed. My character has been harmed. There's too many things really to count. I have issues with safety, my mental health, my emotional well, being like, there's just nothing in my life that hasn't been touched in a drastic, harmful way," she said. CBS News Detroit contacted MSU about the lawsuit; the university declined to comment. Efforts to get a statement from Vassar and Denno also went unanswered. "I'm not going to give up on any of this. So, I think it's interesting that people think that they can, you know, bully me or threaten me or make fun of me, call me names, stalk me, harass me into silence, because that's not going to happen," Tracy said.
