Watch: This innovative schoolboy try is dividing opinion – should it stand?
Who would have expected a 'try' in a New Zealand schoolboy match between Marlborough Boys' College and Nelson College to go viral, globally. But then the nature of it was so unusual it had record-breaking referees and armchair experts alike weighing in.
In the clip shared by Sky Sports NZ, you can see that with the attacking side, Marlborough, lining up a shot at goal when the kicker clips the ball off the tee to the far left of the field, where a team-mate is waiting on the wing. With the ball rolling into the in-goal area, the Marlborough attacker can touch down while the opposition try to scramble out from under their own posts.
The try was given by the match officials.
Try or No Try? 🤔
Gotta love schoolboy rugby!
First XV Rugby LIVE with #SkySportNZ pic.twitter.com/T2fcvayRhN
— Sky Sport NZ (@skysportnz) May 29, 2025
Debate has raged since, on the validity of the score. Former international referee Nigel Owens – who has overseen 100 Test matches – waded in online, posting on X: 'No try. You must make a genuine attempt to kick at goal before the try can be allowed to stand. This clearly wasn't.'
Owens then added, in response to another user querying what the sanction should be, he replied 'PK [penalty kick] void scrum.'
The point continually raised is whether once indicating to shoot for the posts, you must go for the posts. According to World Rugby's law book, under rule 8.20, it says: 'If the team indicates to the referee the intention to kick at goal, they must kick at goal. The intention to kick can be communicated to the referee or signalled by the arrival of the kicking tee or sand, or when the player makes a mark on the ground.'
Some have hailed the ingenuity of the play, however.
You may see echoes of the moment at the 2007 World Cup, when England were playing Tonga. Jonny Wilkinson had the ball on the spot where the referee signalled a penalty, when he spotted space in front of Paul Sackey. Kicking crossfield, the winger raced to touch down and earn England another try.
Back then, however, Wilkinson had not told the officials he would go for goal and there was no signal.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
38 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Disturbing video shows footy fans taking 'run it straight' craze up a notch just days after it cost teenager his life
Shocking footage has emerged of footy fans taking the lethal 'run it straight' trend to dangerous new levels at an NRL match. The run it straight trend involves people charging directly at each other to mimic a rugby-style collision. It gained popularity on social media with official competitions popping up in Sydney and in New Zealand but has drawn criticism for its dangerous nature. The trend turned deadly last week after New Zealand teenager Ryan Satterthwaite tragically lost his life attempting the challenge. He sustained a serious head injury during an impromptu game with friends and passed away in hospital on May 26. His death has prompted widespread warnings from health experts and authorities about the dangers of this viral trend, but it seems to have fallen on deaf ears at Four Pines Park, formerly known as Brookvale Oval in Manly. During a recent NRL match at the venue, a series of spectators decided to take on the run it straight challenge on the back of the hill. However they decided to ramp up the danger by using the actual hill to speed up the action. One participant was filmed chugging a drink before roaring and charging down the hill, only to be ironed out by another participant wearing a Manly Sea Eagles jersey. The footage has quickly drawn criticism following the death of Satterthwaite in New Zealand. 'Glad to see we've learnt from the poor blokes passing in New Zealand last week,' one viewer posted, tongue firmly in cheek. 'Would love to know how many ended up at northern beaches hospital,' posted another. 'Intelligence below the charts,' added another. Despite the obvious dangers, the warnings and the death of Satterthwaite, the video still attracted plenty of attention from people loving the trend. Events have popped up in Australia and New Zealand with cash prizes on offer, but they have been getting postponed and cancelled in recent weeks 'My son was there. He loved it,' one viewer posted with a series of laughing emojis. 'It's called fun. You need to leave the indoors more,' another fired back at a commentator pointing out Satterthwaite's death. 'I'm not opposed to this,' posted another. It comes after former dual-code footy star Sonny Bill Williams had to walk back comments he made online that appeared to endorse the trend. Williams shared footage from his playing days with the Bulldogs, colliding with Penrith's Joel Clinton with the video captioned 'old school what a hit'. He added: 'Playing run it straight before it was called run it straight.' Williams later apologised after learning about Satterthwaite's death. 'I put a video up last night, and I just want to ask for forgiveness of the young fulla that passed away,' Williams said on his social media account. 'Please excuse me for my insensitivity. I did not know that had happened. 'I want to talk about it for a second right now. 'I've been asked to collab with the Run it Straight people, or a couple of people and I haven't. 'Simply because I wouldn't put my kids in it. 'I have safety concerns and that's just my thoughts on it.' Several 'Run It Straight' events in South Auckland were cancelled due to safety concerns and lack of permits following the teenager's death. The Māngere-Ōtāhuhu Local Board raised concerns over concussion risks and unregulated contact. One event at Williams Park was scrapped after organisers failed to book the venue or seek council approval. Organisers instead held a meet-and-greet at Sylvia Park following the death of Satterthwaite.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Former Exeter flanker Ewers retires aged 34
Former Exeter flanker Dave Ewers has retired from rugby 34-year-old came up through Exeter's academy ranks and was a key part of the side that reached six consecutive Premiership finals and won the 2020 European Champions Cup. Injury kept him out of Exeter's 2017 Premiership final win over Wasps, but he started in their 2020 final victory against the same opponents having also started the Champions Cup final the week was called up to the England squad in February 2016, but a series of injuries meant he never went on to win an England made 226 Exeter appearances and scored 40 tries before joining Ulster in the summer of 2023. The Zimbabwe-born forward has spent the past season playing for Cape Town-based side Stormers in the United Rugby Championship where he played nine times. "Thank you to Rob (Baxter, Exeter director of rugby) and everyone involved at Exeter for giving me the opportunity all those years ago, was a special journey going from the Championship to winning the double in 2020," Ewers said on social media as he announced his retirement., external"To all the boys, thank you for all the memories, I feel nothing but blessed to have experienced everything along the way with you all, on and off the pitch."We shared some incredible memories that I will never forget. "A special mention to all the backroom staff of everywhere I've been, and especially Exeter where I had all my injuries. Thank you for getting me back on the pitch. "To all the fans, near and far, thank you for all the support over the years, it's meant a lot to me."
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Glamorous TV footy presenter Tiffany Salmond reveals the reason for huge career setback as she struggles to find work after making one simple move
NRL presenter Tiffany Salmond has revealed the reason why she has vanished from footy broadcasts this season, despite starting the season on camera in New Zealand. Salmond has previously worked for New Zealand media outlets RNZ and Sky, while also doing sideline coverage of Warriors NRL matches as a freelancer for Fox Sports and Triple M. She recently shared her horror experience of being the victim of a deepfake AI attack that circulated fake media claiming to be her carrying out explicit acts that never happened. Now viewers are asking why she is not present on NRL broadcasts, despite starting the season in her usual sideline post at Warriors games. Salmond appears to have made the mid-season move from Auckland to Sydney in April, with a post from four weeks ago that included the caption: 'Left the home advantage'. Her profile has also been updated to say 'Kiwi in Sydney'. Now, Salmond has posted an image at the iconic Bondi Icebergs Pool, the historic lap pool located at the south end of Bondi Beach overlooking the ocean. She uploaded the image with the caption: 'My first Sydney winter,' with a white heart emoji. 'Had to come back [to the pool] today.' She also posted an image enjoying the warm Australian sun in a bathing suit. After that, Salmond posted a News Corp snippet sharing the video of her deepfake attack and text that revealed she had moved to Australia but had yet to appear on a Fox League NRL broadcast. 'The ongoing support never goes unnoticed,' she posted. 'It's frustrating when politics gets in the way of doing the work you love. 'But to still feel this much demand and backing from so many is something I never take for granted. Thank you for continuing to stand with me while I keep building what's next.' Speaking to Daily Mail Australia, Salmond said was grateful for the large amount of viewers calling for her return to NRL coverage. 'Since my last on-air role, I've been incredibly grateful - and honestly humbled - by the ongoing public support and the way viewers have continued to call for my return,' she said. 'It's not something I take lightly, and I'm very aware of how rare that kind of genuine audience connection is in this industry. 'While I've always been proud of the work I've delivered, unfortunately, industry politics have played a role in limiting on-air opportunities, as is sometimes the case in this business. 'But I've stayed focused on building what's next, and there are some really exciting opportunities now opening up, particularly in entertainment, as well as in sport as I continue to expand my career here in Australia.' It comes after Salmond previously shared a follower's comment that read: 'It's all true we want Tiff back on the NRL coverage'. 'The comments on that video have meant so much,' she said in a video of herself walking down a Sydney street. 'Even knowing that a sideline role is pretty interchangeable and I barely had much screen time, to still be receiving this kind of support, all this time later, mid season, it's humbling. 'So, thank you. And I'm sure you will be seeing me back on your screens very soon, whatever capacity that may be in.' There has been a flood of support for Salmond on her Instagram account, where she has almost 40,000 followers. 'You are the best in the business. You don't just ask generic questions, cliches and you know what you're talking about and always seem to have a good relationship with whoever you interview. We need more like you reporting on the game,' one follower posted. 'I'm so glad I'm not the only one who's missed you on the NRL coverage,' another posted. 'The comments are because your great at what you do Tiff. Hope you come back soon,' another well-wisher commented.
