Trump doubles down on plan to empty Gaza. This is what he has said and what's at stake
CAIRO (AP) — Behind U.S. President Donald Trump's vows to turn Gaza into a 'Riviera of the Middle East' lies a plan to forcibly drive a population from its land, rights groups say, warning it could be a war crime under international law.
Trump doubled down this week on his vows to empty Gaza permanently of its more than 2 million Palestinians, saying they would not be allowed to return and suggesting at one point he might force Egypt and Jordan to take them in by threatening to cut off U.S. aid.
Whether it's serious, a negotiating tactic or a distraction, Palestinians have roundly rejected the idea of leaving. Some say Trump's talk normalizes their erasure and dehumanization, amplifying the idea that they have no connection to their land or right to their homes.
'He is talking as if the Palestinians are cattle, you can move them from one place to another. They have no agency, they have no say,' said Munir Nuseibah, a professor of international law at Jerusalem's Al-Quds University.
The plan
Trump has billed the plan as being for the Palestinians' own benefit after Israel's 16-month campaign demolished entire neighborhoods and left much of Gaza unlivable. In its place, Trump has promised them a 'beautiful new land' elsewhere.
The United States would then take over the territory and rebuild it as a 'Riviera' for the 'world's people.'
Palestinians have made clear they don't want to leave Gaza, one part of their homeland that remains for them, along with pockets of the West Bank, after the Mideast's 1948 and 1967 wars. Despite Gaza's devastation, Palestinians have shown a determination to stay and rebuild with international help promised in the U.S.-brokered ceasefire with Israel.
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict in many ways is rooted in the 1948 war surrounding Israel's creation — during which hundreds of thousands of Palestinians were expelled from or forced to flee their homes in what is now Israel — and the 1967 war, when Israel captured the West Bank, east Jerusalem and Gaza. Palestinians want those territories for a future state.
The ambiguity
Trump has left it ambiguous how Palestinians would be removed or what would happen if they refused to go.
Asked by reporters at the White House on Monday if the U.S. would force Palestinians out, Trump replied: 'You're going to see that they're all going to want to leave.'
At one point, he said a rebuilt Gaza would be a place for anyone — possibly including Palestinians — to live, and administration officials have said Palestinians' removal would be temporary.
But Trump contradicted that in an interview with Fox News Channel that aired Monday. Asked whether Palestinians would have the right to return to Gaza, he replied: 'No, they wouldn't because they're going to have much better housing. In other words, I'm talking about building a permanent place for them.'
In a post Thursday on his Truth Social site, Trump said Israel would turn over Gaza to the U.S. 'at the conclusion of fighting.' By that time, he wrote, all the Palestinians 'would have already been resettled in far safer and more beautiful communities.'
Resettled how? Trump hasn't said.
Fighting in Gaza has been paused a ceasefire. There are fears Israel could renew its campaign to destroy Hamas if the two sides can't reach an agreement over a second phase of the deal, including the big question of how Gaza will be governed.
The ceasefire is already precarious after Hamas accused Israel of violating the truce and said it would pause releases of hostages. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu then threatened to withdraw from the deal if the militant group does not release more hostages on Saturday.
Forced displacement?
With Palestinians refusing to go, Trump's ambiguity raises fears they would be forced to.
Calls for a mass transfer of Palestinians were once relegated to the fringes of political discourse in Israel.
But the idea has gained traction in the mainstream — the result of frustration from years of failed peace efforts, recurring rounds of violence, and the painful images of the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas-led attack that triggered the current war. Israeli leaders have talked of 'voluntary' migration.
The Geneva Conventions forbid 'mass forcible transfers' from occupied lands 'regardless of their motive.' The International Criminal Court — where the U.S and Israel are not members — also holds that 'forcible transfer' can be a war crime or, in some circumstances, a crime against humanity.
Forcible transfer was among the crimes that Nazi leaders were charged with in the Nuremberg trials after World War II. It was also among the acts for which some Bosnian Serb leaders were convicted by a U.N. tribunal over atrocities during the 1990s Balkan wars.
Adam Coogle, deputy director of Human Rights Watch's Middle East & North Africa Division, said he didn't know if Trump's statements would turn into policy, 'but the statement of intent is very concerning.'
'The moving out of the entire Palestinian population, any movement of a people in occupied territory out of that territory, is forced displacement,' he said. If done with intent, he said, it could be a war crime.
Amnesty International echoed that, saying forcibly expelling Palestinians is a war crime and could be a crime against humanity.
Nuseibah pointed to rulings by the U.N. court for the former Yugoslavia and other international bodies saying that 'any type of pressure or duress' to leave constitutes forcible transfer.
'It doesn't have to be at gunpoint,' he said.
Asked by a reporter Tuesday about criticism that moving Palestinians out of Gaza could be 'ethnic cleansing,' Trump did not directly answer, repeating that they would go to 'a beautiful location, where they will have new homes and can live safely.'
The White House pointed to those comments when asked specifically about the potential that the permanent relocation of Palestinians is a war crime.
The response
Many Palestinians have been staggered that Trump takes it on himself to speak on their behalf.
'Why don't they just ask us what we want?' said Nuseibah. 'It is dehumanizing.'
Raji Sourani, a leading rights lawyer from Gaza, said Trump's stance was 'Kafkaesque.'
'This is the first time ever in history that the president of the United States speaks publicly and frankly to commit one of the most serious crimes,' said Sourani, who left Gaza for Egypt after Israeli airstrikes destroyed his home in the early days of the war.
Sourani accused Trump of aiming to 'complete the genocide' he said was begun by Israel.
The International Court of Justice is considering arguments that Israel's campaign in Gaza constitutes genocide. Israel denies the accusation, saying it is acting in self-defense to destroy Hamas.
As proof of their commitment to stay, Palestinians point to the flood of hundreds of thousands of people returning to homes in Gaza under the ceasefire — even to ones that were destroyed.
On Monday, Hatem Mohammed set up a tarp to shelter his family from a cold rain on the ruins of their destroyed home. Their home lies in the so-called Netzarim corridor, a strip of land where troops leveled large areas to create a closed military zone during the war, before their withdrawal over the weekend.
'This is our land, this is our identity and that of our fathers and grandfathers,' Mohammed said. 'Trump wants to deny our identity. No, our identity remains.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
25 minutes ago
- Axios
Threats to Tesla's revenue are piling up
Tesla faces fresh risks to a big income stream: sales of regulatory credits to other automakers under vehicle emissions and efficiency rules. Why it matters: Tesla's credit sales were $595 million last quarter and totaled $3.36 billion in the five quarters through Q1 of 2025. The credits are awarded to companies like Tesla that exceed emissions standards. Producers of gas-powered vehicles buy them to help meet various CO2 and mileage standards. The latest: Republicans on the Senate's commerce committee late last week proposed ending civil penalties under the Transportation Department's fuel economy rules. It's part of the committee's portion of the budget "reconciliation" bill — the top GOP and White House legislative priority. The provision would "modestly" cut auto prices by ending penalties on automakers that now "design cars to conform to the wishes of DC bureaucrats rather than consumers," a GOP summary states. The intrigue:"This Senate action would effectively end the market for CAFE credits," Chris Harto, a senior policy analyst at Consumer Reports, tells Axios via email. Dan Becker, who heads the Safe Climate Transport Campaign at the Center for Biological Diversity, noted: "Why buy credits if Trump gives you a get out of CAFE free card?" Driving the news: Separately, DOT on Friday issued an "interpretive rule" that bars consideration of EVs when it sets these mileage rules. It's a step toward crafting replacement standards, DOT said. This paves the way for less aggressive requirements — and less need for buying credits. State of play: Several buckets of credits benefit Tesla, the dominant U.S. EV seller. EPA emissions standards, Transportation Department fuel economy mandates, and California's ambitious clean cars program all provide opportunities. European emissions rules also generate credits. The big picture: The regulatory credit market was already facing risks before all the news late last week. EPA is planning to rescind Biden-era EPA carbon emissions rules for model years 2027 and onward. The House-passed reconciliation bill and the Senate GOP proposal would also nix them. And the House bill pulls back Biden-era DOT mileage rules. Both chambers have passed measures that end EPA's approval of California's auto emissions rules. Threat level: Potential loss of credit revenues comes at a perilous time for Tesla. Its sales have slumped in recent quarters, and CEO Elon Musk's rightward turn and alliance with Trump are among the reasons why, analysts say. The House plan ends $7,500 consumer purchase subsidies for EVs under the Democrats' 2022 Inflation Reduction Act. By the numbers: Credit revenues exceeded Tesla's overall profit last quarter — in other words, it would have been in the red without them. Yes, Q1 was atypically weak for Tesla, but consider Q4 of 2024, when Tesla reported $2.13 billion in profits that were helped along by $692 million in credit sales. In Q3, those numbers were $2.17B and $739M, respectively. Friction point: More broadly, the meltdown of Tesla CEO Elon Musk's relationship with Trump also creates new and unpredictable risks for the billionaire entrepreneur's business empire.
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
NIH employees publish ‘Bethesda Declaration' in dissent of Trump administration policies
In October 2020, two months before Covid-19 vaccines would become available in the US, Stanford health policy professor Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and two colleagues published an open letter calling for a contrarian approach to managing the risks of the pandemic: protecting the most vulnerable while allowing others largely to resume normal life, aiming to obtain herd immunity through infection with the virus. They called it the Great Barrington Declaration, for the Massachusetts town where they signed it. Backlash to it was swift, with the director-general of the World Health Organization calling the idea of allowing a dangerous new virus to sweep through unprotected populations 'unethical.' Bhattacharya later testified before Congress that it – and he – immediately became targets of suppression and censorship by those leading scientific agencies. Now, Bhattacharya is the one in charge, and staffers at the agency he leads, the US National Institutes of Health, published their own letter of dissent, taking issue with what they see as the politicization of research and destruction of scientific progress under the Trump administration. They called it the Bethesda Declaration, for the location of the NIH. 'We hope you will welcome this dissent, which we modeled after your Great Barrington Declaration,' the staffers wrote. The letter was signed by more than 300 employees across the biomedical research agency, according to the non-profit organization Stand Up for Science, which also posted it; while many employees signed anonymously because of fears of retaliation, nearly 100 - from graduate students to division chiefs - signed by name. It comes the day before Bhattacharya is due to testify before Congress once more, in a budget hearing to be held Tuesday by the Senate appropriations committee. It's just the latest sign of strife from inside the NIH, where some staff last month staged a walkout of a townhall with Bhattacharya to protest working conditions and an inability to discuss them with the director. 'If we don't speak up, we allow continued harm to research participants and public health in America and across the globe,' said Dr. Jenna Norton, a program officer at the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases and a lead organizer of the Declaration, in a news release from Stand Up for Science. She emphasized she was speaking in a personal capacity, not on behalf of the NIH. The letter, which the staffers said they also sent to US Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and members of Congress who oversee the NIH, urged Bhattacharya to 'restore grants delayed or terminated for political reasons so that life-saving science can continue,' citing work in areas including health disparities, Covid-19, health impacts of climate change and others. They cited findings by two scientists that said about 2,100 NIH grants for about $9.5 billion have been terminated since the second Trump administration began. The NIH budget had been about $48 billion annually, and the Trump administration has proposed cutting it next year by about 40%. The research terminations 'throw away years of hard work and millions of dollars,' the NIH staffers wrote. 'Ending a $5 million research study when it is 80% complete does not save $1 million, it wastes $4 million.' They also urged Bhattacharya to reverse a policy that aims to implement a new, and lower, flat 15% rate for paying for indirect costs of research at universities, which supports shared lab space, buildings, instruments and other infrastructure, as well as the firing of essential NIH staff. Those who wrote the Bethesda Declaration were joined Monday by outside supporters, in a second letter posted by Stand Up for Science and signed by members of the public, including more than a dozen Nobel Prize-winning scientists. 'We urge NIH and Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) leadership to work with NIH staff to return the NIH to its mission and to abandon the strategy of using NIH as a tool for achieving political goals unrelated to that mission,' they wrote. The letter called for the grant-making process to be conducted by scientifically trained NIH staff, guided by rigorous peer review, not by 'anonymous individuals outside of NIH.' It also challenged assertions put forward by Kennedy, who often compares today's health outcomes with those around the time his uncle John F. Kennedy was president, in the early 1960s. 'Since 1960, the death rate due to heart disease has been cut in half, going from 560 deaths per 100,000 people to approximately 230 deaths per 100,000 today,' they wrote. 'From 1960 to the present day, the five-year survival rate for childhood leukemia has increased nearly 10-fold, to over 90% for some forms. In 1960, the rate of measles infection was approximately 250 cases per 100,000 people compared with a near zero rate now (at least until recently).' They acknowledged there's still much work to do, including addressing obesity, diabetes and opioid dependency, 'but,' they wrote, 'glamorizing a mythical past while ignoring important progress made through biomedical research does not enhance the health of the American people.' Support from the NIH, they argued, made the US 'the internationally recognized hub for biomedical research and training,' leading to major advances in improving human health. 'I've never heard anybody say, 'I'm just so frustrated that the government is spending so much money on cancer research, or trying to address Alzheimer's,' ' said Dr. Jeremy Berg, who organized the letter of outside support and previously served as director of the National Institute of General Medical Sciences at the NIH. 'Health concerns are a universal human concern,' Berg told CNN. 'The NIH system is not perfect by any stretch of the imagination, but has been unbelievably productive in terms of generating progress on specific diseases.'
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Calif. to sue over National Guard deployment at protests
Good morning, all. If your neck starts bothering you from all that screen time this week, try one of these stretches. Now, on to the news. Subscribe to get this newsletter in your inbox each morning. California Gov. Gavin Newsom said his state would sue the Trump administration today after it deployed 2,000 National Guard troops to L.A. over the weekend to quell protests against immigration raids. The deployment: Trump invoked a law under Title 10 of the U.S. Code to transfer National Guard control from California to the federal government in order to protect ICE — the first time since 1965 that they've been deployed without a state governor requesting it. [CNN] The protests: They began Friday after ICE detained at least 44 people in four raids. The ensuing protests grew increasingly violent, with demonstrators throwing rocks, blocking freeways and burning cars. Police responded by firing tear gas and using flash-bang grenades. [USA Today] Newsom responds: Newsom asked Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to rescind the order, calling the deployment 'unlawful.' Trump's border czar, Tom Homan, said the raids would continue and threatened arrest for anyone who obstructs. 'Arrest me,' Newsom said. [Politico/NBC News] 🏀 Thunder rebound Thunder star Shai Gilgeous-Alexander tallied 34 points in Game 2 of the NBA Finals last night, leading his team to a decisive 123-107 victory against the Pacers and tying the series 1-1. SGA credited his team for the win. [Yahoo Sports] ➡️ Freedom Flotilla crew seized Israel seized a boat carrying humanitarian aid and detained Greta Thunberg and other activists who attempted to break Israel's long-standing blockade on Gaza, where nearly 2 million Palestinians are at risk of famine. [AP] 🍳 Egg recall The August Egg Company issued a voluntary recall of 1.7 million dozen of its brown cage-free eggs and brown certified organic eggs distributed in nine states. The FDA has linked the eggs to a salmonella outbreak that's sickened at least 79 people. [Delish] 🎭 Tony Awards highlights Sunset Blvd. star Nicole Scherzinger won Best Leading Actress in a Musical, Jonathan Groff straddled Keanu Reeves while performing and Oprah mentioned the Patti LuPone drama. Here are the most memorable moments. See who won. [Time/Variety] 🦓 Runaway equine After more than a week on the run, 'Ed,' the escaped zebra whose escapades went viral, was captured yesterday and airlifted to safety. See the photos. [USA Today/People] 📺 On the tube: Celebs and music stars gather for the 2025 BET Awards, airing at 8 p.m. ET on BET. Kendrick Lamar leads with 10 nominations, but here's who else is nominated. [Billboard] 🏒 On the ice, the Panthers and the Oilers try to break their 1-1 series tie in Game 3 of the Stanley Cup Final at 8 p.m. ET on TNT. [USA Today] ⚾ On the field, the I-5 rivalry continues when the Dodgers take on the Padres at 9:40 p.m. ET on the MLB app. [AP] ☀️ And don't forget to: Read your daily horoscope. Play the crossword. Check the forecast in your area. In 1993, Jurassic Park had its world premiere. More than 30 years later, Scarlett Johansson, a self-proclaimed 'geeked-out fangirl' of the film is set to star in the franchise's seventh installment, Jurassic Park: Rebirth. It's a casting that was 15 years in the making. [Hollywood Reporter] Psst: Father's Day is this Sunday. If you haven't gotten something for Dad yet, Yahoo Gifting Editor Amanda Garrity has some ideas. When you buy through links in this article, Yahoo may receive compensation. Amanda: If you can get your hands on the Nintendo Switch 2, then you'll be Dad's favorite. Other buzzy buys that I'm seeing include Lego's all-new Pixar lamp set, a smart meat thermometer and Hoka recovery slides. Amanda: Act fast and you'll still be able to get a custom photo book from Papier or this coffee table book from Wonderbly, which compiles newspaper headlines from Dad's birthday throughout the years. It's pretty cool! Amanda: I have tons in this gift guide! Every dad needs this leakproof backpack cooler ahead of the summer. Yahoo readers are also buying these battery storage systems and barbecue resting blankets in droves — what can I say: Dad loves a practical buy! Need more ideas? Amanda's got you covered. Sir J. Starks recently surprised his wife, Maurissa, with a six-minute Sephora shopping spree to celebrate their anniversary. The staff and fellow shoppers quickly joined in to help her fill her basket. 'The support staff just converged like the Avengers. It was wild,' Starks said. [People] Have a great day. See you tomorrow! 💡 P.S. Before you go, your daily advice: Give yourself at least three hours between dinner and bedtime to allow for proper digestion and improve the quality of your sleep. [Delish] About The Yodel: The Yodel is a morning newsletter from Yahoo News. Start your day with The Yodel to get caught up on weather, national news, politics, entertainment and sports — in four minutes or less. Did you like this morning's newsletter? Subscribe to have it sent to you on weekdays. By signing up, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
