Christian teacher who said ‘LGBT is a sin' loses court battle
A Christian teacher who told Year 7 pupils that being LGBT was a sin has lost a High Court fight.
Glawdys Leger made the comments to her pupils during a religious studies lesson at Bishop Justus CofE School in Bromley, south London, in February 2022.
She showed a presentation on human rights and the class had a discussion on 'allyship', which led to Ms Leger saying that being LGBT was 'not fine' and her pupils should put God before such ideology, a professional conduct panel found.
The panel also found the 44-year-old said being LGBT was a sin and transgender people were 'just confused'.
One of the pupils complained to her mother about the comments and Ms Leger was suspended in March 2022 before being dismissed two months later.
In December 2023, the panel found her actions amounted to unprofessional conduct, with the finding then published on the Teaching Regulation Agency's website. Ms Leger was not prohibited from teaching in future.
Ms Leger brought legal action at the High Court in London against the Department for Education over the panel's findings.
She argued the panel failed to put her comments in context and that the school's duty to provide a broad and balanced curriculum did not apply to her as an individual teacher.
She also said the decision to publish the finding was unlawful as it infringed on her privacy.
But her case was dismissed by Mrs Justice Lang on Thursday who said Ms Leger's criticisms of the panel's findings 'do not disclose any error of law, as opposed to mere disagreement'.
She said in a written judgment: 'The [panel] and the secretary of state made a lawful decision that publication of the findings was a justifiable and proportionate sanction for her unacceptable professional conduct.'
'Very distressing'
A previous hearing was told Ms Leger's comments were recorded by an 11-year-old pupil who had been advised by her mother to note down any 'transphobic' remarks.
The mother then complained to the school, saying Ms Leger's comments were 'very distressing' for her child as she is 'exploring who she is – as many children are at this age', Mrs Justice Lang said.
Ms Leger argued to the High Court that the panel's publication had interfered with her human rights because, although she was not prohibited from working, the publicity of the decision would make it 'difficult, if not impossible, to obtain new employment'.
But Mrs Justice Lang said the panel was compelled to publish its finding and 'went no further than it considered justified'.
The published decision will become inaccessible after two years, even to employers, she added.
'This was indeed a Christian school, but the claimant's own evidence was that she had been unwilling to support that school's policy,' she said.
'The result was the nuanced finding that while 'Ms Leger's comments lacked respect for the right of others' this did not derive 'from a lack of a tolerance' nor had she any 'intention of causing distress to pupils'.
'That said, her 'actions were at risk of upsetting pupils in the lesson' and her 'choice not to present a balanced view undermined the school community's aspiration to provide a supportive environment for children who may be exploring sexual identity'.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Police chief says homophobia apology could ‘unfairly impugn' past officers
Greater Manchester Police 's Chief Constable, Stephen Watson, has declined to apologise to the LGBT+ community for historical homophobia within the force, a move criticised by campaigners as an "insult". Human rights charity the Peter Tatchell Foundation requested all forces apologise for decades of LGBT+ victimisation. Twenty-one other forces have issued formal apologies. Mr Watson stated that a sweeping apology could be seen as "superficial" and "unfairly impugn" past officers, while acknowledging GMP did not always meet expected standards. Peter Tatchell highlighted the force's troubling history under then-Chief Constable James Anderton in the 1980s, during the Aids crisis, when officers targeted gay venues. Mr Tatchell argues that an apology is an act of justice and healing which could foster trust and encourage LGBT+ people to report crimes.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Greater Manchester Police chief refuses to apologise for past homophobia in ‘insult' to LGBT+ community
The chief constable of Greater Manchester Police (GMP) has refused to apologise to the LGBT+ community for historic homophobia in the force. Campaigners said it was an 'insult' after 21 other forces have issued formal apologies over their past conduct, adding that GMP was 'involved in some of the most extreme unlawful victimisation of LGBTs by any UK force'. Human rights charity the Peter Tatchell Foundation first issued calls to all forces to say sorry for 'decades-long victimisation' of the LGBT+ community in June 2023. However, in a recent letter, seen by The Independent, its chief constable, Stephen Watson, declined to 'accede to your request for a general apology', adding it could be seen as 'superficial and merely performative' and could 'unfairly impugn' the service of past officers. The director of the foundation, Peter Tatchell, who was this week named in The Independent 's Pride List 2025 for his gay rights activism, said: 'This refusal to apologise is an insult to the LGBT+ community, who suffered so much at the hands of the Manchester police in decades past.' Mr Tatchell has this week again written to CC Watson, appealing once again for him to apologise – noting the troubling history of the force under the late Chief Constable Sir James Anderton in the 1980s. At the height of the Aids crisis, Mr Anderton said gay men were "swirling about in a human cesspit of their own making", resulting in calls for his resignation. 'Greater Manchester Police has a particularly troubling homophobic history that deserves specific acknowledgement and apology,' Mr Tatchell said. 'Under Chief Constable James Anderton in the 1980s, the force became synonymous with open hostility towards the LGBT+ community.' He claimed Mr Anderton's comments were not 'isolated rhetoric' and the force targeted gay venues in raids in the 1980s, which in some cases led to gay and bisexual men being outed and subjected to homophobic insults, threats and violence. Mr Tatchell added: 'To now refuse to apologise adds insult to injury. Apologies are not symbolic—they are acts of justice and healing. They show leadership and humanity. They tell survivors of police witch-hunts: 'We see you, we acknowledge the harm we caused, and we are sorry.' 'Twenty-one other forces have recognised that acknowledging past wrongs helps rebuild LGBT+ trust. It will encourage more LGBTs to report hate crime, sexual assaults and domestic violence, which is what we all want. 'Not saying sorry undermines LGBT+ confidence in the police and will damage the police's reputation among LGBTs. 'We are not suggesting all past officers were bad or blaming today's officers. An apology is about taking responsibility for homophobic police behaviour in previous decades and saying sorry.' Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley was the first to apologise in 2023, in a move which was welcomed by Mr Tatchell for drawing 'a line under past Met persecution'. A string of others subsequently followed suit, including Merseyside Police's former chief constable Serena Kennedy, who issued their "sincere apology and deepest regret" for "historical prejudice". Others include Dorset and North Yorkshire Police. In his refusal letter, dated April 2025, CC Watson, who was appointed in 2021, said GMP is proud to serve its many diverse communities and strives to understand their past experiences with the force. He said the force has made 'considerable' progress over the past 40 years and takes a zero-tolerance approach to discrimination. He wrote: 'I am, of course, sorry that GMP, and those police bodies which preceded the presently formed GMP prior to 1974, didn't always perform to the standards deserved by those whom we serve. 'It is also the case, however, that over these many decades, literally thousands of police officers have performed their duties with decency, professionalism and compassion. 'Whilst I acknowledge that you are not seeking an apology for officer's having upheld the laws of the day, it would nevertheless be quite unjust for me as the current chief constable to cast some sort of sweeping assertion as to the general conduct of the force over a prolonged period of time, particularly when the period in question is now so dated that virtually no serving officer in the entire force can speak to the period with any personal knowledge. 'Such an apology could well be seen, even by the intended recipients, as both superficial and merely performative. 'It would unfairly impugn the faithful and valued services of past officers; and any such apology would likely make little or no difference to developing contemporary practice which is, as you acknowledge, currently very good and which carries the confidence both of our current LGBTQ+ community and our own staff association. 'With regret, therefore, I find that I cannot accede to your request for a general apology.'
BBC News
3 hours ago
- BBC News
Ex-Leeds mayor loses home after High Court battle
The home of a former lord mayor of Leeds has been seized by the UK law enforcement agency responsible for tackling organised crime and drug National Crime Agency (NCA) won a High Court battle with Abigail Marshall Katung over the rights to the house on Sandmoor Drive in house had been previously owned by a businessman who was suspected of money laundering offences. He handed it over in 2020 as part of a deal with the councillor Mrs Katung, who was not aware of the accusations made against the home's former owner, said she would appeal against the decision. During the court hearing, Mrs Katung said she had entered into an agreement with the previous owner to buy the house in 2015. Mrs Katung said she had paid him about £400,000 of the contracted £1m purchase price, but the remaining sum was never court heard the majority of the funds were sent from Nigeria, where Mrs Katung was born, to the UK using an informal money transfer service which she described as the "black market", although she said it was not 6 June the High Court ruled, despite the payments, Mrs Katung had no legitimate interest or right to the property, which will now be transferred to the his ruling Mr Justice Jay said there were "telling omissions" from Mrs Katung's evidence, adding that he was "not satisfied that she was a particularly reliable witness".In a statement Mrs Katung said her account was "consistent". The NCA will be entitled to damages for Mrs Katung's use of the house since 2020, as well as to its Burgess, head of asset denial at the NCA, said a "substantial sum would be returned to the public purse" following the Katung said she had made "full disclosure" of the ruling prior to it becoming public knowledge, adding: "Whilst this is dreadfully upsetting to me and my family, I have not sought to hide away. "I want to continue to represent my constituents, it is the most satisfying task I have ever undertaken and it is a complete privilege to be able to do so. "I recognise that enquiries will have to be undertaken in order to preserve public confidence in the political system in which I operate. I will cooperate with that process fully and unreservedly."Mrs Katung became Leeds' first lord mayor of African descent when she took over the ceremonial role for a 12-month term in May has lived in the city since she came to the UK to study at the University of Leeds in 2000 and has represented the Little London and Woodhouse ward since being elected in 2019.A spokesperson for the Labour Party said an internal investigation into Mrs Katung was taking place.A Leeds City Council spokesperson said they were unaware of case, adding: "We are currently examining the High Court judgement and are unable to comment further at this time." Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
