Virginia Beach man charged in Amber Alert abduction, fatal crash is not competent for trial, judge says
VIRGINIA BEACH — A man charged with stabbing his ex-wife and stepdaughter, abducting his three biological kids and then causing a crash that killed the youngest child has been ruled incompetent to stand trial at this time.
Virginia Beach Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Judge Jennifer Shupert made the ruling during a court hearing Thursday for Dana Plummer, according to prosecutors. As a result, Plummer will be sent to a state psychiatric hospital, where staff will work to restore his competency. He will return to court July 31 for a hearing to update the judge on his status.
To be competent to stand trial in Virginia, a defendant must be able to understand the charges and proceedings that they face, and be able to assist with their defense. The most common problems with incompetent defendants stem from mental illness or intellectual disability. Medication, therapy and education are the typical tools used to restore them to competency. It's extremely rare for a defendant to be declared not restorable.
Plummer, 36, was arrested last August after he got involved in a police chase and crashed his SUV off a highway in Maryland. Plummer's 16-month-old daughter was killed, and his two sons were injured.
State police had issued an Amber Alert after Plummer allegedly went to his ex-wife's home, stabbed her and her 12-year-old daughter, and then fled with his children. His vehicle was located hours later by state police in Northern Virginia, who followed him into Maryland. Troopers were attempting to pull Plummer over when he crashed into two other vehicles.
Plummer also was injured. He was extradited to Virginia after being released from a hospital and has been held without bail in Virginia Beach since then.
Virginia Beach police first became concerned about Plummer several months before the abduction and crash, according to court records. Officers reported seeing him display paranoid behavior while armed with a shotgun in a restaurant with his sons. They later obtained a court order that prevented Plummer from possessing or buying firearms, and required him to turn over any that he owned, which he did.
Less than two weeks before his alleged crime spree, Plummer's 14-year career with the Navy ended when he was 'separated' from the service. A Navy spokesperson refused to say at the time whether it was a voluntary or involuntary action.
Jane Harper, jane.harper@pilotonline.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
American Military News
3 hours ago
- American Military News
Pics: Navy JAG officer threatens Jan 6 and ICE agents: Report
A U.S. Navy Judge Advocate General (JAG) Officer has been accused of allegedly threatening January 6 and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents in a Saturday post on social media. According to The Daily Caller, U.S. Navy JAG Officer Benjamin France allegedly tweeted, 'And we will hunt down every J6 and ICE agent again,' on Saturday. In a Tuesday post on X, formerly Twitter, Sam Shoemate, a retired U.S. Army Chief Warrant Officer 2 and a current intelligence officer, shared a screenshot of France's tweet. 'Meet Benjamin France, aka 'Benny.' Benny made a comment threatening to 'hunt down every J6 and ICE agent' three days ago on X,' Shoemate wrote. 'Why should we care that Benny is threatening federal agents? Because Benny is an active duty Navy JAG Officer.' In addition to sharing the screenshot of France's threat against January 6 and ICE agents, the intelligence officer also shared pictures of France's profile on LinkedIn, which feature a professional headshot of the JAG officer and a photo of France being sworn into the U.S. Navy JAG Corps. Shoemate explained that after France was 'identified and called out' on social media, he 'nuked' his social media account. Sharing screenshots of France's X account, Shoemate tweeted, 'Normally I wouldn't care about comments like this, but since Benny decided to threaten federal agents, I'll post his comments directed @SecDef as an added bonus.' READ MORE: Fmr. Navy second-in-command convicted of bribery One of the screenshots shared by Shoemate includes a set of posts directed against Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and Defense Department Press Secretary Kingsley Cortes. In one post, France allegedly claimed that both Hegseth and Cortes 'are a joke at the DOD.' 'An 0-4 guardsman should never be in charge of all American forces,' France added. 'An embarrassment to the military and the nation.' In another post, France wrote, 'Can't wait for your ass to eventually be fired when Hegseth eventually drinks himself into a coma. You worthless piece of sh-t.' Shoemate explained that the JAG officer's chain of command was notified regarding the threats France allegedly posted on social media. 'This kind of threatening behavior towards agents, who are already under fire, simply cannot be allowed, especially from an officer whose job is to provide legal advice to his command and holds sway over policy that affects potentially thousands of sailors,' Shoemate tweeted. A U.S. Navy spokesperson confirmed to The Daily Caller that the Navy is aware of the JAG officer's alleged social media posts and that the Navy is currently looking into the situation.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Navy sailor who vanished from Virginia barracks found dead, another sailor held in her death
A body has been found and confirmed to be that of missing Navy sailor Angelina Resendiz, and another sailor is in pretrial confinement in connection with her death. Resendiz, 21, was last seen the morning of May 29 at her barracks at the Naval Station Norfolk in Virginia. Virginia State Police issued a critically missing person alert for her last week. A body discovered by the Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS) on Monday in a wooded area in Norfolk was confirmed to be Resendiz by the local medical examiner on Tuesday. A Navy sailor, who was not identified, has charges pending under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, the NCIS said. "NCIS remains committed to uncovering the facts surrounding the tragic death of Seaman Resendiz to ensure accountability and justice," the department said. No further details were released and the investigation is ongoing. The Resendiz family said her disappearance has 'left a void in their hearts' and they 'refuse to let her suffering be in vain,' a spokesperson for the family told NBC affiliate WAVY of Norfolk. 'The family is calling on the assistance of the United States government, Senator Mark Warner, Senator Tim Kaine, the Hampton Roads congressional delegation, home congressman Vicente Gonzalez, and President Donald J. Trump to address the systemic issues that allowed her to vanish without justice since May 29, 2025,' the statement said. Resendiz's mother, Emeralda Castle, was not notified that her daughter vanished through official channels, the spokesperson said. "Her daughter's colleagues, friends, and even authorities knew she was missing, but the response was minimal, and after her friends filed a missing person's report when her commander would not, they showed little compassion or understanding," the statement said. The family is calling for Congress to investigate Resendiz's death and for reform within the Navy's notification protocol. The NCIS statement said it investigated the case as soon as the agency learned of her disappearance. This article was originally published on
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
She Disappeared From a Navy Base — and Turned Up Dead. Family Says Military 'Showed Little Compassion'
The family of Angelina Petra Resendiz, a Navy sailor who was found dead in Virginia this week, says they were not told about her disappearance — and want someone to take accountability for her death. Angelina was last seen at her barracks in Norfolk on May 29, according to Virginia State Police. Her body was found on June 9 in an off-base wooded area in Norfolk by the Naval Criminal Investigative Service, PEOPLE previously reported. A spokesperson for NCIS previously told PEOPLE that a Navy sailor had been placed in 'pretrial confinement' in connection with Angelina's death. Related: Missing Sailor's Body Identified After She Disappeared from Barracks — and Navy Has Suspect in Custody 'Angelina was a kind and compassionate young woman who brought light into our lives,' Esmeralda Castle, Angelina's mother, said in a statement, adding that her disappearance has left 'a void in their hearts' and that they refuse to let her suffering be in vain. Castle claims that her family wasn't promptly notified of Angelina's disappearance, only learning about it informally through her daughter's staff and media coverage. 'Colleagues, friends, and even authorities knew she was missing, but the response was minimal,' Castle said in her statement. 'And after her friends filed a missing person's report when her commander would not, they showed little compassion or understanding.' Castle wants Congress to investigate Angelina's death and make sure that in the future, the Navy notifies families properly and promptly instead of relying on 'unofficial sources like the media.' 'The Navy's failures threaten all families and the integrity of our military system,' Castle said. 'Congress must reform these processes to prevent future tragedies, for the safety of all families.'Angelina's family and loved ones have started a GoFundMe to help Castle with any financial needs. 'Angie's mother hopes to search these woods surrounding the base and hopes to have a protest calling for reform of the US Military's treatment of missing women cases,' the fundraiser says. The Navy did not immediately return PEOPLE's inquiry for comment. Read the original article on People
