Why is the LAPD opposing Trump's Marine deployment in Los Angeles?
United States President Donald Trump has ordered the deployment of Marines in Los Angeles to quell protests that have erupted against the arrests of 44 people on Friday for violating immigration laws.
Trump on Monday also doubled the strength of National Guard forces that his administration has deployed in the country's second largest city to 4,000 soldiers.
His administration has justified the deployments by arguing, in part, that local authorities were failing to ensure the safety of law enforcement officials and federal property.
But the deployment of the Marines – coming on the back of the move to send the National Guard to Los Angeles – has sparked criticism, not just from Trump's political opponents like California Governor Gavin Newsom but also from the Los Angeles police.
The Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) has said the deployment of Marines will make its job harder. Here's what the dispute is about, and why the LAPD argues that the deployment of military forces could complicate its work:
The Marines are a branch of the US armed forces and are a component of the Navy. The Marine Corps was first established in 1775.
Its soldiers are trained for land and sea operations and have a particular focus on amphibious warfare, which refers to attacks launched from ships onto shore.
US citizens or legal residents who have a high school diploma and are aged 17 to 28 are eligible to enlist for the Marines. They have to undergo an initial strength test to be recruited. Recruits undergo about 13 weeks of initial training to become a part of the Marine Corps. Once a year, each Marine undergoes a battle-readiness test with a focus on physical readiness and stamina.
There are 172,577 active duty Marine personnel in the US as well as 33,036 reserve personnel as of 2023, the latest data released by the US Department of Defense.
The US military's Northern Command released a statement on Monday saying it had activated a Marine infantry battalion in Los Angeles that was on alert over the weekend. About 700 Marines with the 2nd Battalion, 7th Marines and 1st Marine Division will 'seamlessly integrate' with National Guard troops deployed in the city, it said.
Initially, the LAPD was involved in quelling civil unrest due to the protests, starting on Friday. On Saturday, Trump deployed about 2,000 National Guard soldiers to Los Angeles County, defying objections by Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass.
After the Marine deployment announcement, Pentagon spokesperson Sean Parnell said an 'additional' 2,000 National Guard soldiers would also be mobilised in addition to the 2,000 who had been sent to the city over the weekend.
On Monday, Police Chief Jim McDonnell released a statement saying the LAPD had not received a formal notification that the Marines would be coming to LA.
'The possible arrival of federal military forces in Los Angeles absent clear coordination presents a significant logistical and operational challenge for those of us charged with safeguarding this city,' he said.
McDonnell added that the LAPD and its partners 'have decades of experience managing large-scale public demonstrations, and we remain confident in our ability to do so professionally and effectively'.
The LAPD boss urged open and continuous communication between all law enforcement agencies involved to avoid confusion and escalation.
History indicates that a lack of communication, coupled with differences in approach based on different agencies' training, can inflame already tense situations that law enforcement officials confront.
While the US routinely sends its Marines on overseas missions, it is rare for the US president to deploy Marines to quell a domestic crisis.
The last time this happened was in 1992 in Los Angeles during protests against the acquittal of four policemen who had been filmed beating Rodney King, a Black man. Six days of riots broke out, and 2,000 National Guard soldiers and 1,500 Marines were deployed in the city. The riots in 1992 resulted in the deaths of 63 people and widespread looting, assaults and arson, unlike the ongoing protests, which have been largely peaceful.
On one occasion in 1992, LAPD officers and Marines were called to respond to a domestic disturbance at a local home.
When they arrived, a shotgun was fired out the front door. A police officer yelled, 'Cover me,' which to the police means to prepare to shoot if necessary but to hold one's fire. For Marines trained for combat, 'cover me' means to use firepower. The Marines shot more than 200 bullets instantly as a response to the officer. Three children were inside the home at the time. While no one was killed, federal soldiers were withdrawn from Los Angeles shortly after this.
While the deployment of US Marines to Los Angeles in 1992 was carried out in coordination with state and local authorities, they are now being sent against the wishes of the state government, Bass and the LAPD.
That compounds the risks that could follow, experts said.
'If the administration escalates to active duty troops, especially without coordination with state leaders, it would amount to a militarization of civilian protest, not a restoration of order,' attorney Robert Patillo said in a written statement to Al Jazeera. 'That move could violate the First Amendment rights of peaceful protesters and would likely inflame tensions on the ground, not resolve them.'
The First Amendment of the US Constitution guarantees the freedom of speech and assembly.
Reports from LA suggest that the National Guard troops who have been activated are barely being used in the city, raising questions about whether the deployment of Marines or additional National Guard soldiers is really necessary.
Al Jazeera's Rob Reynolds, reporting from LA, said Monday's protests organised by unions in the city centre were peaceful.
'[The National Guard] didn't engage with the protesters. They didn't do much of anything other than stand there in their military uniforms,' Reynolds said.
On his personal X account, Newsom posted that the initial 2,000 National Guard soldiers were not given food or water. Of them, only 300 were deployed while the rest were sitting in federal buildings without orders, he said. Al Jazeera could not independently verify this.In another post, Newsom wrote that 'the Secretary of Defense is illegally deploying [the Marines] onto American streets.'On Monday, Newsom announced that he had filed a lawsuit against Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth 'to end the illegal takeover' of the National Guard. Trump's federalisation of the National Guard on Saturday marked the first time in 60 years that a US president has activated the guard in defiance of a state governor's wishes.
'For Trump to deploy regular armed forces, such as the marines, would require him to clear another legal hurdle. He would have to invoke the Insurrection Act, which is very rare and would escalate the situation to a constitutional crisis,' Gregory Magarian, professor of law at Washington University's School of Law in St Louis, Missouri, told Al Jazeera in an emailed statement.
So far, it is unclear whether Trump invoked the Insurrection Act to deploy the Marines. To activate the National Guard, he did not invoke the Insurrection Act but a similar federal law, Title 10 of the United States Code.
'While the Insurrection Act technically gives the president the authority to deploy active-duty military forces under extreme conditions, we are nowhere near the legal threshold that would justify sending in the marines,' Patillo said.
Hegseth wrote in an X post that Marines had been deployed 'due to increased threats to federal law enforcement officers and federal buildings'.
'We have an obligation to defend federal law enforcement officers – even if Gavin Newsom will not,' Hegseth wrote.
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said in an X post on Monday that Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials, who have been leading the immigration arrests, will 'continue to enforce the law' despite the protests.
Over the weekend, the LAPD arrested 50 protesters: 29 on Saturday and 21 on Sunday.
Local news outlets have reported protests against the arrests have also begun in at least nine other US cities, including New York, Philadelphia and San Francisco.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Jazeera
4 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Elon Musk says he ‘regrets' social media attacks on Trump
Tech billionaire Elon Musk has expressed regret over his broadsides against United States President Donald Trump following the spectacular public falling out between two of the world's most powerful men. 'I regret some of my posts about President @realDonaldTrump last week. They went too far,' Musk said in a post on X on Wednesday. Musk's expression of regret comes after he made a series of extraordinary attacks on Trump, including an unsubstantiated claim that his administration has refused to release files on convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein in order to protect the president. More to follow…
Al Jazeera
4 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
‘You don't know if you'll return home': Immigration raids shake Los Angeles
Los Angeles, California — On a warm Tuesday afternoon in East Hollywood, Payo grilled up heaping plates of chicken, carne asada, potatoes and ribs at the food stall where he works. He moved here three years ago from the state of Oaxaca in southern Mexico. He has a one-year-old daughter in the United States. But in the country that he now calls 'home', even doing his job now feels dangerous. For millions of undocumented migrants in the US, fear and uncertainty about the future are fixtures of life. Yet with the administration of US President Donald Trump launching a series of aggressive immigration raids and calling in the National Guard and more than 700 US Marines to crack down on protests that have followed, the last several days have felt different to Payo and residents of neighbourhoods in Los Angeles with large immigrant communities. 'I feel tense. It's a bit of a risk even being out here on the street,' says Payo, who requested that only his first name be used. Still, he feels he has little choice but to continue his work, to support his daughter, as well as family back in Mexico. 'I've never felt like this before during my time here,' he says. 'When you leave your house, you don't know if you'll return home.' East Hollywood is located several miles from downtown Los Angeles, which has been the site of large demonstrations and protests, some of which have turned violent and included clashes with law enforcement, since last Friday. Local officials have accused Trump of seeking to escalate the situation rather than helping restore calm. Residents of the neighbourhood say that the streets have been quiet, with fewer people venturing outside amid heightened fears over immigration raids and arrests. 'People aren't going out as much. They're not going to work because they're afraid,' said Jose Medina, who works as a cleaner at a hospital and first came to Los Angeles from El Salvador about 45 years ago. He says the city's status as a metropolis with a large Latino community is part of what drew him there. According to a 2023 census survey, Spanish is spoken in nearly 40 percent of Los Angeles households, and the city's ties to Latin America are as old as the United States itself. 'It's a beautiful city, a city of working people,' says Medina, noting that immigrant workers often take on demanding jobs such as construction, landscaping and cleaning services. Immigration raids across Los Angeles and the state over the last several days have frequently targeted workplaces, adding to the feeling of anxiety in immigrant communities. So, too, has the aggressive nature of the Trump administration's approach to enforcement. 'What you see in the news and in the statements is that they're going after the most violent criminals, but we know that's a lie and that's not what's happening. We're seeing agents coming into a Home Depot and picking up everyone, not even investigating,' said Jose Madera, director of the Pasadena Community Job Center, which offers support for day labourers. 'With day labour, if you miss one day of work, that's the rent, or that's food on the table for your children and your family,' he added, of the economic cost of staying home from work due to fear over immigration raids. 'That's the decision that every day labourer and every migrant person has to make.' He also said that the due process rights of those detained and deported also seem to have been ignored. The parents of a 23-year-old man deported to Mexico after being arrested on Friday told The Washington Post newspaper that he signed what he believed was a form consenting to a COVID-19 test, but may have been a document agreeing to his deportation. Sensitive locations that have traditionally been exempted from immigration enforcement activities, such as courthouses, have also been subjected to raids. Los Angeles school district officials said on Monday that school security will set up safety perimeters around schools so that families can feel secure as they attend student graduations. Marlene Marin, the owner of a hair salon in East Hollywood who has lived in the city for 35 years and is originally from the Peruvian capital of Lima, said that the last several days have reminded her of the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, when people stayed in and the streets were largely empty. 'People have a lot of anxiety. We don't have many clients coming in,' she said. 'There is an economic impact when people don't want to go out to the stores and the shops.' On Tuesday evening, Mayor Karen Bass declared a curfew in the downtown area of Los Angeles in what she said was an effort to halt vandalism and looting. 'There are some bad people burning police cars,' said Marin. 'But I don't think the people doing that are immigrants.' In a speech on Tuesday, Trump leaned into incendiary rhetoric, promising to 'liberate' the city from 'animals' and 'a foreign enemy'. US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), the federal agency largely tasked with immigration raids, shared a picture on social media showing immigration agents flanked by heavily armed soldiers detaining a man. But contrary to Trump's narrative, studies have repeatedly shown that migrants are less likely to commit crimes than those who are born in the US. 'People are here looking for something better, to support their families,' says Payo, standing under a tent that shields him from the afternoon sun as smoke pours off the grill in East Hollywood. Throughout Los Angeles's history, a tradition of robust dissent and immigrant activism has frequently brought local figures and movements into confrontation with federal authorities. During the 1980s, the city became a key part of the country's sanctuary movement, which offered support for refugees fleeing violence in countries like El Salvador and Guatemala, where military governments, with the backing of the United States, were carrying out campaigns of brutal violence. When a Roman Catholic priest named Father Luis Olivares offered refugees and undocumented workers physical sanctuary inside the La Placita church near the city's historic centre, immigration officials threatened to raid the church if Olivares continued to defy the federal government. Eventually, the government didn't follow through on the threat. But Mario Garcia, a professor of Chicano studies at the University of California at Santa Barbara who wrote a biography on the life of Olivares, says that the Trump administration has pushed an aggressive interpretation of executive power with few comparisons in modern US history. '[Ronald] Reagan's policies in the 1980s on immigration did not include the militarisation of INS [the Immigration and Naturalization Service], the predecessor of ICE. It did not include using the National Guard and the Marines to put down protests in support of the undocumented and Central American refugees,' he said in an email to Al Jazeera. Garcia believes that Trump isn't done yet and that his recent moves may be laying the groundwork for something even more dramatic: the declaration of martial law. 'Los Angeles has a long history of protesting against unconstitutional efforts to repress free speech and mass peaceful protests,' he said. 'As a city of immigrants, Angelenos recognise and support the work and contributions of immigrants, whether documented or undocumented.'
Al Jazeera
5 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Curfew in LA as protests against Trump's immigration crackdown continue
A nighttime curfew was in force in Los Angeles as local officials sought to get a handle on protests that United States President Donald Trump claimed were an invasion by a 'foreign enemy'. 'I have declared a local emergency and issued a curfew for central Los Angeles to stop the vandalism, to stop the looting,' Mayor Karen Bass told reporters on Tuesday. One square mile (2.5 square kilometres) of the city's more than 500-square-mile area will be out of bounds until 6am (13:00 GMT) for everyone apart from residents, journalists and emergency services, she added. Small-scale and largely peaceful protests began on Friday in Los Angeles as anger swelled over intensified arrests by immigration authorities. At their largest, a few thousand people have taken to the streets, but smaller groups have used the cover of darkness to set fires, daub graffiti and smash windows. Overnight on Monday, 23 businesses were looted, police said, adding that more than 500 people had been arrested in recent days. Protests have also sprung up in other cities around the United States, including New York, Atlanta, Chicago and San Francisco. Trump has ordered 4,000 National Guard soldiers to Los Angeles, along with 700 active-duty Marines, in what he has claimed is a necessary escalation to take back control, despite the insistence of local law enforcement that they could handle matters. The Pentagon said the deployment would cost US taxpayers $134m. 'What you are witnessing in California is a full-blown assault on peace, on public order, and national sovereignty,' Trump told troops at Fort Bragg, a military base in North Carolina. 'This anarchy will not stand. We will not allow an American city to be invaded and conquered by a foreign enemy.' California Governor Gavin Newsom said Trump's shock militarisation of the city was the behaviour of 'a tyrant, not a president'. In a livestreamed address, Newsom called Trump a 'president who wants to be bound by no law or constitution, perpetuating a unified assault on American tradition'. 'California may be first, but it clearly will not end here.' In a filing to the US District Court in Northern California, Newsom asked for an injunction preventing the use of troops for policing. Trump's use of the military is an 'incredibly rare' move for a US president, said Rachel VanLandingham, a professor at Southwestern Law School in Los Angeles and a former US Air Force lieutenant colonel. US law largely prevents the use of the military as a policing force – absent the declaration of an insurrection, which Trump again mused about on Tuesday. Trump 'is trying to use emergency declarations to justify bringing in first the National Guard and then mobilising Marines,' said law professor Frank Bowman of the University of Missouri.
