Top bar body slams ED's 'chilling message to legal community' to senior advocate
The Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association on Monday castigated the Enforcement Directorate (ED) summoning senior advocate Arvind Datar after he gave legal advice to a firm.
The notice, which was subsequently withdrawn by the ED, was issued to Datar after he reportedly gave legal advice to Care Health Insurance on the ESOP (employee stock ownership) issued to former Religare Enterprises Chairperson Rashmi Saluja.
The SCAORA said such a notice was a "chilling message to the legal community at large and threatens the foundational right of every citizen to receive independent legal counsel without fear or intimidation".
Advocate and president SCAORA Vipin Nair said the ED action was not only unwarranted but also reflected a disturbing trend of investigative overreach that threatened the independence of the legal profession and undermined the very foundation of the rule of law.
"Datar is a respected Senior Advocate of unimpeachable integrity, who has consistently upheld the highest standards of professional conduct and legal ethics,' said SCAORA secretary Nikhil Jain in the statement.
Summoning a senior member of the Bar for discharging his professional responsibility, he said, was a misuse of authority and an affront to the sanctity of the advocate's role.
'The independence of the judiciary and the independence of the Bar are twin pillars of our constitutional democracy. The effective functioning of courts is impossible without fearless and independent advocates. When investigative agencies resort to coercive measures against advocates merely for giving legal opinions, they do not just target individuals, they strike at the institutional structure that ensures justice," the statement added.
The SCAORA further said undermining the professional independence of advocates ultimately threatened judiciary's independence.
It also pointed to several judgments shielding advocates from the purported actions of their clients for merely giving legal opinions.
'The ED's action conflates legal advice with criminal complicity, a proposition that is constitutionally untenable and legally unjustifiable,' it said.
If advocates can be subjected to coercive measures for providing legal advice, it would paralyse the functioning of the legal system and erode public confidence in the justice delivery mechanism, it added.
Though the summon was withdrawn by the ED, the SCAORA lodged its "strong protest" against the "arbitrary exercise of executive power".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
31 minutes ago
- India Today
ED summons Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister's brother in money laundering probe
The Enforcement Directorate has summoned Congress leader DK Suresh, younger brother of Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar, for questioning in connection with a money laundering case linked to an alleged cheating operation by a local woman. Official sources said on Tuesday that Suresh has been asked to appear before the agency on June 19 to record his statement under the provisions of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA).advertisementSuresh had previously filed a complaint with the Bengaluru police, stating that his name was being 'misused'. The Enforcement Directorate is also understood to have recorded MLA Vinay Kulkarni's statement as part of the ongoing probe. The federal agency arrested 33-year-old Aishwarya Gowda in April, following searches on her and Congress MLA Vinay Kulkarni. According to an official statement issued at the time, the agency said Gowda claimed to have close ties with 'high-profile' politicians and allegedly defrauded several individuals by promising high returns on investments in gold, cash and bank deposits. She reportedly used the name of DK Suresh and claimed to be his money laundering case against Gowda, her husband Harish KN, and others stems from a series of FIRs registered at different police stations in Karnataka. The FIRs allege that the accused engaged in a criminal conspiracy to defraud multiple people by collecting gold, cash and bank transfers in exchange for a promise of high Enforcement Directorate said that the accused failed to return the money or provide the promised returns, and that Gowda allegedly threatened victims who pursued legal action by claiming links with senior political leaders. During the searches, officials reportedly seized digital evidence, documents related to the laundering activities, and Rs 2.25 crore in legislator, speaking to the media after the ED raids, denied any wrongdoing. He said that any financial dealings with Gowda, if they existed, would be traceable through proper financial the raids on MLA Vinay Kulkarni, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah condemned the agency's action, calling it a politically motivated move. 'The ED raids are the outcome of politics of vengeance. Centre carries out these kinds of raids,' he Chief Minister questioned why similar action had not been taken against leaders from the BJP. IN THIS STORY#Karnataka#Bengaluru
India Gazette
an hour ago
- India Gazette
Robert Vadra skips ED summons again
New Delhi [India], June 17 (ANI): Businessman Robert Vadra, who was summoned by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in connection with a money laundering probe, is not appearing before the agency on Tuesday, according to sources close to him. Businessman Robert Vadra, who was summoned by ED is not appearing before them today. According to Sources close to him, he is travelling abroad and will join the investigation after his return. On June 12, Advocate Suman Jyoti Khaitan, counsel for businessman Robert Vadra addressed the media through a virtual press conference to clarify his client's absence from the Enforcement Directorate (ED) appearance in a money laundering case. Khaitan, speaking via Zoom, said recent media reports wrongly implied that Vadra was evading ED summons. 'These reports are misleading. Vadra developed flu-like symptoms and was advised to undergo a COVID-19 test, which he has taken. He is following all necessary health precautions,' Khaitan stated. Reaffirming Vadra's cooperation with the investigation, Khaitan said, 'He has willingly offered to join the probe through virtual mode and has previously submitted voluminous documentation to the ED.' The lawyer further stated that Vadra's prior appearances, including a three-day questioning in April in a separate money laundering case linked to a 2008 Haryana land deal. Vadra, the husband of Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, was summoned by the ED recently in connection with a case involving UK-based arms dealer Sanjay Bhandari. Sources said Vadra sought a deferment of the summons and will be given a new date for recording his statement under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA). In 2023, the ED filed a chargesheet alleging that Bhandari purchased and renovated a property at 12, Bryanston Square, London, on Vadra's instructions and with his financial support--an allegation Vadra strongly denies. He has dismissed the case as a 'political witch hunt' aimed at 'harassing him for political reasons.' The agency is also probing Vadra in another money laundering matter linked to land transactions in Bikaner, Rajasthan, where he and his mother have previously been questioned. (ANI)
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
2 hours ago
- Business Standard
Vadra skips ED summons again, cites court's permission to travel abroad
Robert Vadra, the businessman husband of Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, skipped his scheduled deposition before the Enforcement Directorate for the second time in a money laundering case linked to UK-based arms consultant Sanjay Bhandari, official sources said on Tuesday. Vadra's lawyer said his client was travelling abroad with the "prior" permission of the court to attend his daughter's graduation ceremony. He was asked to appear on Tuesday (June 17) after he failed to do so on June 10. The federal probe agency may issue him a fresh date after examining his reply. The permission to travel (on June 17) was obtained well before the service of the latest summons and an intimation has been sent to the ED also, advocate Suman Jyoti Khaitan said. "Mr Vadra has repeatedly stated that he is available to extend his fullest cooperation with the ED as he has done on all prior occasions, both upon his return from abroad and also for recording his statement through video conference during his stay abroad if required by them," he said. The businessman had skipped the June 10 summons saying he had flu-like symptoms on June 9 and had undertaken a Covid test as per protocol. The agency is understood to be summoning Vadra to record his statement under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) and subsequently file a charge sheet in the case. The federal probe agency had questioned the businessman for three consecutive days in April in a separate money laundering case linked to alleged irregularities in a 2008 land deal in Haryana. He is being investigated in three money laundering cases by the ED. Bhandari (63), an alleged associate of Vadra, fled to London in 2016, soon after the Income Tax Department raided him in Delhi. A UK court earlier this month refused an application filed by the Indian government seeking permission to appeal in Britain's Supreme Court against the discharge of Bhandari in an extradition case, virtually ruling out chances of him being brought to the country to face the law. The ED filed a charge sheet in this case in 2023, alleging that Bhandari acquired the 12, Bryanston Square house in London in 2009 and got it renovated "as per the directions of Robert Vadra, who provided the funds for the renovation". Vadra has denied that he owns any London property directly or indirectly. Terming the charges a "political witch hunt", Vadra said he was being "hounded and harassed" to subserve political ends. The ED is also investigating Vadra in a separate money laundering case linked to alleged financial irregularities in a land deal in Rajasthan's Bikaner.
