What the case of a young man accused of violent crimes reveals about Victoria's new bail laws
If you want to understand the debate about bail reform in Victoria – and the gulf between the position taken by the Allan government and the recommendations of experts – you could do worse than consider the case of an alleged youth offender known as MMA.
His case has straddled the recent changes in bail laws: he was granted bail in the Victorian supreme court only days before they were introduced to parliament, and then had to apply for an extension of that bail last week under the new laws.
He also represents other concerns about Victoria's justice system that have been met with state government responses that some experts consider counterproductive, expensive, reactionary, and failing to address the social issues that drive youth offending.
MMA (which is his court ordered pseudonym) has no criminal record but he faces serious charges allegedly committed while he was aged 17.
Police allege he stomped on someone's head at a shopping centre, leaving them unconscious and stealing their shoes. On the same day, he allegedly pushed over one police officer and stood over them with clenched fists.
While on bail for these offences, he is alleged to have committed six robberies, possessed a large machete and been involved in multiple assaults.
He was arrested and bailed again in September last year. Police allege he committed two more robberies and an armed robbery in the following fortnight.
He was released on bail again later that month, allegedly breached his conditions and was then granted supervised bail in October.
MMA attended five of eight scheduled appointments and was expected to attend court in December. He allegedly failed to show up.
Police allege that he was involved in an aggravated carjacking, when a rideshare driver was threatened with a machete, and other offences.
He was remanded in custody until he appeared before Justice James Gorton for a bail application in the supreme court on 5 March.
Youth Justice opposed bail.
Its concerns included that MMA told them he did not want any bail conditions with a curfew and would rather 'return to the community on a sentenced order', he refused to engage in an assessment, and could only live with relatives where alleged co-offenders also resided.
He maintained connections with young people known to Youth Justice and told them he has 'issues with multiple young people from opposing 'gangs'' and allegedly committed numerous physical assaults while on remand, including on Youth Justice staff.
But he also told Youth Justice staff he wanted to get a job and did not want to let his family down.
'The allegations, if correct, reveal an ongoing preparedness to engage, repeatedly, in violent and threatening behaviour, including with the use of weapons, against members of the public,' Gorton found.
'The applicant's history also reveals, if the allegations against him are correct, that his engagement with police, the laying of charges and being subject to a summons to answer an offence and even the imposition of bail conditions have not operated in the past to prevent his continuing to offend in the same way.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
'The applicant, to date, has not been precluded from offending by a fear of the criminal justice system.'
Gorton found there was a real risk MMA would 'reoffend and endanger the safety or welfare of others or interfere with the administration of justice' if he was released on bail.
Under the previous bail laws, Gorton had to consider the need to impose 'the minimum intervention required in the circumstances with the remand of the child being the last resort'.
Youth Justice, over the course of the bail application, changed its position to support supervised bail.
Gorton found that even if MMA was found guilty of the offences, he may spend longer on remand than the time he would be sentenced to.
The judge also found that perhaps the most important factor was that MMA had been in custody for the three previous months, and that it had a 'potential deterrent effect'.
Gorton granted bail for two weeks on 14 strict conditions, including a curfew, complying with Youth Justice programs, not communicating with people alleged by police to be gang members, and reporting to a police station three times a week.
Last week, MMA was back before Gorton.
He mostly complied with the conditions: police showed up three times during the curfew from 9pm and 6am and he was there each time, he reported to the local police station four times (instead of the required six), 'fully engaged' with youth justice programs, and otherwise 'had no involvements with police'.
All this while MMA was working 42 hours a week, almost 40km away from home.
But Gorton now had new laws to consider. While there remained a need to impose on a child 'the minimum intervention required in the circumstances', the remand of a child was no longer to be seen as 'a last resort'.
Despite the new laws, Gorton said, he still had to consider MMA's age and maturity at the time of the alleged offences, the need to strengthen and preserve his relationship with his family, and the importance of supporting him to live at home or in a safe, stable and secure living arrangement.
He also had to consider the importance of supporting him to engage in education, training or work, the need to minimise the stigma to him resulting from being remanded in custody, the likely sentence should he be found guilty, the need to ensure that the conditions of bail are no more onerous than are necessary, and recommendations or information contained in any report provided by a bail support service.
He said MMA remained an unacceptable risk of reoffending without the strict conditions and extended his bail on those conditions for a month.
There is nothing simple about alleged youth offenders such as MMA, despite how those who are charged with offences such as robberies and using machetes are portrayed on the nightly news or on the social media reels of influencers.
Locking alleged offenders like these up, experts say, often just momentarily delays their offending, rather than challenging them to change their lives. It is the difference between burning a containment line to control a fire and putting it out.
The signs in MMA's case, Gorton said, were 'good and positive'. It will take far longer than two weeks to see what new bail laws will mean for other alleged youth offenders like him, or how they will help a state government desperate to be seen as tough on crime.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
17 hours ago
- The Guardian
Pepper spray use in youth prisons irresponsible amid racial disparities, watchdog warns
The rollout of synthetic pepper spray for use to incapacitate jailed children is 'wholly irresponsible' while black and minority prisoners are more likely to be subjected to force than white inmates, a watchdog has said. Elisabeth Davies, the national chair of the Independent Monitoring Boards, whose members operate in every prison in England and Wales, said the justice secretary, Shabana Mahmood, should pause the use of Pava spray in youth offending institutions (YOIs) until ministers had addressed the disproportionate use of force on minority prisoners. 'There is clear racial disproportionality when it comes to the use of force,' she told the Guardian. 'It is therefore, I think, wholly irresponsible to expand use-of-force measures before disproportionality issues are addressed.' Mahmood authorised the rollout of Pava across YOIs in England and Wales in April amid growing demands from the Prison Officers' Association (POA) to protect staff from attacks. The government's 'use of force' evaluation report, published in April, found black prisoners were nearly twice as likely as white prisoners to experience Pava and baton use. Using official data to March 2023, the report found that 409 of every 1,000 black inmates were subjected to use of force, compared with 208.6 per 1,000 white prisoners. Davies urged ministers to hold back on rolling out Pava spray in the youth system until the racial disparities were properly addressed. 'We've got evidence that the growing reliance on visible weapons – such as the rollout of Pava spray in the male youth state and the trial of Tasers in the adult male prison state – is deeply concerning for people with lived experience,' she said. 'Our board members have been told that the visible presence patterns make [prisoners] feel constantly afraid, and that's increasing tension rather than easing it.' According to the IMB's national annual report, released on Wednesday, black prisoners at HMP Elmley on the Isle of Sheppey in Kent were significantly more likely to have force applied to them than white prisoners. At HMP Birmingham, the category B jail once known as Winson Green, there was evidence of 'clear racial disparities in the use of force', despite the diversity of prison staff and the introduction of cultural awareness training. Amid a deepening overcrowding crisis, some prison officers will be trialled with stun guns this summer, while the Conservatives have said some should be given access to live ammunition. It follows an attack on three officers at HMP Frankland by Hashem Abedi, a terrorist involved in the Manchester Arena bombing. Davies said prison officers showed 'remarkable bravery' in challenging conditions but the majority of assaults were actually between inmates. 'We're seeing violence driven by overcrowding, by mental health crisis and rapid drug use,' she said. 'One of the most effective ways to reduce violence is through strong and respectable relationships between staff and prisoners.' Squirted from a canister, Pava spray, or pelargonic acid vanillylamide, causes searing pain and discomfort in the eyes for about 40 minutes and a burning sensation to skin. It was rolled out in men's prisons in England and Wales in 2018. There are three publicly run YOIs and one that is privately run, holding young offenders up to the age of 21. According to government statistics covering 2022, most children in prison were from ethnic minorities. Data obtained in April by the Howard League through freedom of information requests showed that black men were almost three times more likely to be sprayed with Pava than white men in prison, and young black men under the age of 25 were five times more likely to be sprayed than their white counterparts. Responding to Davies, Mark Fairhurst, the national chair of the POA, said IMB members were 'not the ones on the receiving end of life-changing injuries' from violent youths. 'It would be wholly irresponsible of the government not to give my brave colleagues the protections they need when dealing with violence,' he said. 'Using the ethnicity or age of offenders to excuse their violent behaviour is shameful … Nobody should ever enter their workplace and be expected to become a victim.' A Youth Custody Service spokesperson said: 'Pava will only be used as a last resort to protect staff and young people from serious harm, such as violent incidents involving weapons. Staff will receive specialist training, and every use will be closely scrutinised with strict controls in place.'
The Herald Scotland
a day ago
- The Herald Scotland
Death never takes a holiday but you do: 10 best crime books for summer
Ambrose Parry, Canongate, £18.99, Canongate, out now Writers Chris Brookmyre and Dr Marisa Haetzman (Image: Getty Images) Why has STV or BBC Scotland not given us a small screen version of Parry's Raven and Fisher Victorian murder mysteries? Budget - or the lack of it - is, presumably, the boring answer. But this splendid series, now drawing to a close, is tailor-made for a TV adaptation. Set in Edinburgh's medical community in the mid-1800s, this is the fifth and final volume in a series of wonderfully crafted entertainments by husband-and-wife duo Chris Brookmyre and Marisa Haetzman, operating under the Ambrose Parry nom de plume. Victorian virtues turn out to be anything but in this gripping story which takes in photography, pornography and people trafficking. White City Dominic Nolan, Headline, £10.99, July 3 Out in paperback at the start of July, this is crime fiction as historical epic. Inspired by a real-life event - the Eastcastle Street robbery of a Post Office van in London in 1952 - this sweeping novel takes the temperature of the capital in the post-war years, culminating in the Notting Hill riots at the end of the decade. More James Ellroy than Agatha Christie, it's bleak, brutal and often thrilling. It's about cops and robbers - and how close both those sides can be - as well as postwar housing, Rachmanism (Peter Rachman is one of just a number of real-life people who appear in its pages; see also Lady Docker), racism and politics at the margins. Both vivid and visceral, it's a rewarding reminder of just how ambitious crime fiction can be. The Good Liar, Denise Mina, Harvill Secker, £16.99, July 31 Oh, this is also very good. Published at the end of July, Denise Mina's new book is a reminder of just how potent a writer the Glasgow author is. The Good Liar is a standalone novel that is embedded in the worlds of forensic science and the law. Doctor Claudia O'Shiel is a blood spatter expert who becomes involved in the investigation of a brutal double murder in an opulent London townhouse. The chief suspect is a Viscount who's never out of the papers. What follows is a novel about grief (O'Shiel has recently lost her husband), the seductive nature of the British establishment and moral compromise. It's sharp, clear-eyed and clever. Rum Punch, Elmore Leonard, Penguin, £9.99, out now 'Sunday morning, Ordell took Louis to watch the white-power demonstration in downtown Palm Beach. ''Young skinhead Nazis,' Ordell said, 'Look, even little Nazi girls marching down Worth Avenue. You believe it?'' Rum Punch, Elmore Leonard (Image: Penguin) Ah, I'd forgotten what a joy it was to read Elmore Leonard. Since the author's death in 2013 he has slightly slipped out of the public eye, but Penguin has now added him to its Modern Classics Crime and Espionage series. The first three of 14 books - Rum Punch, The Switch and Swag - are out now and they're essential reading. Rum Punch is the source material for Quentin Tarantino's film Jackie Brown, which is fine and all, but the original is better. Leonard is one of the great prose stylists of the late 20th century. And these handsomely designed reissues are a wonderful excuse to become reacquainted with one of crime fiction's true originals. The Cut Richard Armitage, Faber, £18.99, August 28 Richard Armitage (Image: PA) Actor Richard Armitage (The Hobbit, Captain America) made something of a splash with his debut thriller Geneva in 2023. This follow-up is a tricksy, time-switching story about High School rivalries and a teenage murder, jumping between then (the 1990s) and now. At times the result pushes hard against the border of believability, but you do keep reading to find out what really happened in the past and what's going to happen in the present. The Man Who Died Seven Times, Yashuhiko Nishizawa, Pushkin Vertigo, £14.99, August 14 More tricksy, time-switching entertainment. On steroids. In fact Yasuhiko Nishizawa's crime novel - translated by Jesse Kirkwood - qualifies for that Doctor Who description, 'wibbly wobbly timey-wimey'. The man in the title is Hisataro's grandfather. He's dead on the first page and then comes back to life a few pages later. That's because for some reason his grandson regularly relives certain days over and over. And so when his grandad is killed - yes, it's murder - he decides to try and change the course of events. But it proves more difficult than he imagines. This is puzzle fiction for want of a better description. It has no other purpose than to entertain. It succeeds at that. Like a Bullet Andrew Cartmel, Titan Books,£9.99, July 8 Like a Bullet by Andrew Cartmel (Image: Titan Books) This year has been a bumper one for Andrew Cartmel fans. There's already been a new Vinyl Detective book - Underscore, the eighth in this hugely entertaining series. And next month sees the third in his Paperback Sleuth series in which our morally ambivalent heroine Cordelia Stanmer tracks down rare paperbacks and somehow becomes embroiled in the odd spot of murder as a result. In her latest adventure she is tasked with finding copies of a pulp wartime series originally published in the late 1960s and early 1970s. In fine condition, it goes without saying. (Not mint condition. That's for coins, stamps, comics and records.) In doing so she meets dodgy brothers, one-armed ex-military men and an author with a taste for Bettie Page and bondage. It's a brisk amuse-bouche of a book, one that wears its learning lightly. Very moreish. The Diary of Lies, Philip Miller, Polygon, £9.99, August 7 The third Shona Sandison thriller is full of spies, conspiracies, government secrets, the newspaper industry and, inevitably, murder. Plenty, then, for our journalist heroine to get her teeth into. Miller, formerly arts correspondent of this parish, has proven himself a very able crime writer in recent years. Among the many admirers of his last novel, The Hollow Tree, was David Peace, author of the Red Riding Quartet, and The Damned United no less. Murder Takes a Vacation, Laura Lippman, Faber, £9.99, August 14 Mrs Blossom is, as the title implies, going on holiday. A cruise down the Seine. Quite something given that she has never left the United States before. It's just a pity that there has to be a murder at the start of it. Veteran crime writer Laura Lippman has taken a minor character from her Tess Monaghan series and placed her front and centre in this cosy crime story. It works perfectly well enough as such, but, really, what makes this essential is that at heart it is a nuanced and clever character study of a flawed, decent woman in her sixties coming to terms with grief and a growing sense of adventure. Mrs Blossom is a delight to spend time with. Oh, and by the way, you may well come away from this with a newfound interest in the abstract artist Joan Mitchell and the ceramics of American industrial designer Russel Wright. A Particularly Nasty Case, Adam Kay, Orion, £16.99, August 28 Not out until the end of August, former doctor Adam Kay has - as his publisher points out - 'decided to stop writing about saving people's lives and start killing them off instead.' Everyone from Russell T Davies to the aforementioned Chris Brookmyre and Joanna Lumley are raving about this development. Chapter 26 is entitled 'Autopsy-turvy'. How you respond to that may tell you whether you'll like it or not. (It made me smirk.)
The Independent
a day ago
- The Independent
Youth accused of killing Leo Ross told his trial will not take place next week
The trial of a teenage boy charged with stabbing to death 12-year-old Birmingham schoolboy Leo Ross has been put back until next year after a review hearing in the case. The 15-year-old youth, who cannot be named because of his age, had been due to face a jury trial at Coventry Crown Court next week accused of murdering Leo, who was stabbed in the stomach on a riverside path in January. The accused, wearing a T-shirt and jogging bottoms, spoke only to confirm his name and that he understood directions being made by High Court judge Mr Justice Wall during a 20-minute hearing in Coventry on Wednesday. He was not asked to enter any pleas and was remanded in custody until a further mention hearing at the same court next month, with a provisional four-week trial re-fixed to start on February 9. Leo, a pupil at the Christ Church, Church of England Secondary Academy in Yardley Wood, died after being taken to hospital from The Shire Country Park in Hall Green, where members of the public had summoned the emergency services. Appearing in person after being brought to court from youth detention accommodation, the defendant is further charged with possessing a bladed article, assaulting a woman on October 22 last year, seriously assaulting a woman on January 19 and January 20, and assaulting a woman on January 21. Adjourning the case after hearing submissions from prosecutor Rachel Brand KC and defence lawyer Alistair Webster KC, Mr Justice Wall allowed the youth to remain seated. The judge said the delay was 'not the fault of anybody' and told the defendant a trial was not likely to take place until early next year. The judge said: 'You are not going to be tried next week. 'It (the case) will next be back in court on the 28th of July for me to be given an update. We are going to find you a trial date as soon as we can. We will do it as soon as possible.' In a statement issued shortly after his death, Leo's family said: 'We want everyone to know what an amazing, kind, loving boy Leo was. 'Not only has Leo's life been taken, all of our lives have as well. Leo will be truly missed by all of us. He was loved so much by everyone.'
