logo
Washington Supreme Court decision against Lowe's could significantly impact self-service retail

Washington Supreme Court decision against Lowe's could significantly impact self-service retail

Yahoo13-03-2025

This story was originally published on MyNorthwest.com.
The Washington Supreme Court has ruled that a lawsuit against Lowe's Home Centers can proceed after a woman was injured by falling merchandise in one of its stores, finding that the company may be liable under a 'reasonable foreseeability' exception to traditional premises liability laws.
This ruling comes with potentially significant implications for self-service retail stores like Lowe's.
The case, Galassi v. Lowe's Home Centers, LLC, stems from a 2020 incident in which Hwayo Jenny Galassi was shopping for garden supplies at a Lowe's store. While she was selecting a roll of fencing from a high shelf, another roll fell on her, breaking her toe. No employees or other customers were present at the time, and the area of the store lacked video surveillance.
Galassi sued Lowe's, arguing the store's self-service method of displaying heavy fencing rolls on high shelves created an unreasonably dangerous condition that it should have foreseen because it stands to reason that customers were likely to handle and improperly restock the items.
Lowe's denied responsibility, asserting that it had no 'actual or constructive notice' of a hazardous condition before the incident. The company argued that under traditional liability law, it could only be held liable if it knew or should have known about the dangerous condition beforehand. Since no prior complaints or reports of unsafe shelving existed, Lowe's claimed it could not be found negligent.
A trial court granted summary judgment in favor of Lowe's, agreeing that the store had no notice of the specific unsafe condition. However, the Washington Court of Appeals reversed the decision, ruling that Lowe's method of operation could make the risk of falling merchandise reasonably foreseeable, even without direct notice of the hazard.
On Thursday, the Washington Supreme Court affirmed the appellate ruling, finding that Galassi's claim should proceed to trial.
The court noted that self-service retail stores — where customers frequently handle and move merchandise without employee supervision — can create inherent risks that businesses have a duty to address.
'A trier-of-fact could find the alleged unsafe condition in this case was reasonably foreseeable due to the nature of Lowe's business and its methods of operation. Yet, there is also contrary evidence, such as a lack of prior similar incidents, from which a trier-of-fact could reach the opposite conclusion. As a result, the Court of Appeals correctly held that there is 'a genuine issue of material fact regarding whether the (reasonable foreseeability) exception to traditional notice requirements applies,'' the Washington State Supreme Court wrote.
This ruling simply rejects a summary judgment dismissing the case. It does not, however, mean Lowe's should be held liable.
Indeed, the Court found: 'The fact that Lowe's summary judgment strategy was unsuccessful in this case does not relieve plaintiffs of their burden of proof. It is merely a case-specific outcome in accordance with the well-established rule that 'if the moving party does not sustain its burden, summary judgment should not be granted, regardless of whether the nonmoving party has submitted affidavits or other evidence in opposition to the motion.''
The ruling allows Galassi to proceed with her case before a trial court. A jury may ultimately determine whether Lowe's was negligent in its store design and product placement.
The decision could have broad implications for retailers that rely on self-service displays, potentially increasing their responsibility for customer safety.
The case will now return to the lower court for further proceedings.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

North Providence hit with an explosive lawsuit alleging town resources were used for mayor's personal properties
North Providence hit with an explosive lawsuit alleging town resources were used for mayor's personal properties

Boston Globe

time11 hours ago

  • Boston Globe

North Providence hit with an explosive lawsuit alleging town resources were used for mayor's personal properties

'The plaintiff began to experience increased concern and severe stress about doing work on defendant Lombardi's properties during scheduled work hours,' the lawsuit states. 'The plaintiff became concerned that he was being directed by defendant Lombardi and defendant Fuoroli to do something wrong or potentially illegal.' Get Rhode Map A weekday briefing from veteran Rhode Island reporters, focused on the things that matter most in the Ocean State. Enter Email Sign Up Talk about the possibility of a lawsuit has quietly dominated North Providence political circles for months ever since Charbatji's lawyer, Lisa Holley, claiming that Charbatji was unlawfully terminated by the town. Advertisement Lombardi, a Democrat who is best known for his hands-on, outspoken approach to local politics, has been notably quiet about Charbatji's claims. The town hired prominent attorneys John Tarantino and Anthony Traini, and Lombardi would only say that the matter had been referred to the town's insurance company. Advertisement Now that the actual lawsuit has been filed, Lombardi remains uncharacteristically tight-lipped. 'They better know what they're talking about,' Lombardi said Tuesday before declining to comment further. Fuoroli could not be immediately reached for comment. But the lawsuit speaks volumes. Charbatji claims that he was hired by the town's department of public buildings in July 2017 after he performed contract work on Lombardi's summer home in Narragansett. He was previously running a private contracting company called 'Mike's Remodeling,' but said he took the job because Lombardi told him it would come with a lot of overtime and good benefits, according to the lawsuit. The suit claims that Charbatji performed work on Lombardi's summer home in Narragansett, a separate rental property in Narragansett, two different commercial properties that house Lombardi's personal business, Luxury Cleaners, in North Providence and Lincoln, a different commercial property in North Providence, and Fuoroli's personal property in North Providence. Charbatji claims most of the work took place during town hours, though he occasionally did jobs for Lombardi on his own time. The accusations from Charbatji are all the more audacious because of how blatant the work requests allegedly were. Charbatji claims that Lombardi would visit or call him during work hours to request work be done on his properties, and at times when Charbatji wouldn't make it back to North Providence to clock out using a fingerprint scanner, Fuoroli would indicate on a computer generated time sheet that Charbatji 'forgot.' If you're keeping score at home, that would be timecard fraud on the public's dime. But it didn't stop there, according to Charbatji. The lawsuit also claims that Fuoroli regularly used the town's credit card from Lowe's to purchase materials that Charbatji would use on both Fuoroli's and the mayor's personal properties. In one example, Charbatji claims he met Fuoroli at Lowe's to pick up material for a flooring project at one of Lombardi's properties in Narragansett. Advertisement Charbatji also claims that he installed decorative molding on a cabinet in Lombardi's summer house – once again purchased using the town's Lowe's card – at the request of the mayor's wife. He also claims to have replaced a furnace at Luxury Cleaners in Lincoln while he was supposed to be working for the town. The relationship between Charbatji and Lombardi apparently began to sour in 2022 when Charbatji was seeking a pay raise from the town, the lawsuit states. At one point, Charbatji claimed that he told Lombardi that he 'was very uncomfortable doing the work on his personal properties while he was supposed to be working on town of North Providence buildings.' Charbatji claims that on the same day that he was prepared to tell the town's human resources director about the work he had done on Lombardi and Fuoroli's properties, he fell ill and was treated for chest pains. Charbatji wound up going out on medical leave for several months, but was informed on Nov. 18, 2022, that he was being terminated for 'unauthorized and unexcused leave,' the lawsuit states. Lombardi, he claims, sent a North Providence police officer to Charbatji's home to deliver the notice. Charbatji says he never got the chance to tell his side — until now. As for Lombardi, we're still waiting. Dan McGowan can be reached at

Nissan, Walmart dial back Stonewall Columbus sponsorships for Pride 2025
Nissan, Walmart dial back Stonewall Columbus sponsorships for Pride 2025

Yahoo

time2 days ago

  • Yahoo

Nissan, Walmart dial back Stonewall Columbus sponsorships for Pride 2025

COLUMBUS, Ohio (WMCH) — Stonewall Columbus said a few corporations that previously backed the Pride march and festival are cutting off support this year amid efforts to roll back diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. Densil Porteous, executive director of Stonewall Columbus, said the organization has seen a reduction in corporate sponsorships totaling about $150,000 for this year's Pride celebrations. Notably, companies such as Lowe's, Walmart, Nissan, and Anheuser-Busch, which supported Stonewall's events in 2024, are not participating this year. Out in Ohio: Stonewall Columbus gets ready for Pride 2025 'This trend aligns with a broader national pattern where corporations are reevaluating their diversity, equity, and inclusion commitments amid political pressures and economic uncertainties,' Porteous said. Lowe's, Walmart, and Anheuser-Busch didn't respond to NBC4's request for comment. Nissan said in a statement it's 'currently reviewing all marketing and sales spending — including select consumer auto shows, sports properties and other entertainment activations — to maximize both efficiency and breakthrough effectiveness.' Despite these setbacks, Porteous said, 'The support from our community and remaining partners has been heartening.' Anticipating some shifts in economic support, Porteous said the organization worked to secure a $276,000 grant from the Franklin County Board of Commissioners to offset the shortfall. List: 2025 Pride Month events, festivals in central Ohio Porteous noted many local businesses and organizations continue to stand with Stonewall, as the organization has raised additional support from the community totaling about $34,000. The organization's Pride events remain scheduled as planned, with the march taking place at 10:30 a.m. on June 14. 'We anticipate a vibrant turnout, celebrating under this year's theme, 'United in Power,'' Porteous said. Learn more about the Stonewall Columbus Pride march and festival on 'Out in Ohio,' NBC4's streaming show amplifying the voices, stories and work of Ohio's LGBTQ+ community. Stonewall is losing some corporate backing as several other central Ohio Pride festivals have also had their sponsors dial back. The Union County Rainbow Coalition, host of Marysville's Pride Fest, said it has encountered funding challenges as the coalition has spoken out against anti-LGBTQ+ rhetoric. That advocacy has yielded a drop in support from some local companies, organizers Christian Downey-Thompson and Betty Elswick said. The Rainbow Coalition has forged ahead with the Marysville Pride Fest, taking place June 14 from 3 to 9 p.m. in Partners Park, in part because of several Marysville families who stepped up to replace those local businesses with even larger donations. The coalition was also the recipient of prize money from Folx Health, an online healthcare provider for LGBTQ+ people. Locals paint rainbow fence at German Village bar that had Pride flags stolen The Westerville Queer Collective, the group behind Westerville's Pride Festival, said this June's festival has about the same number of sponsors as last year, even though the collective has needed 'to do a little bit of extra campaigning' in the wake of President Donald Trump's reelection and anti-LGBTQ+ proposals at the Ohio Statehouse. Delaware Ohio Pride, the organizers behind the city of Delaware's Pride festival, told NBC4 in March that some local entrepreneurs who previously backed the organization have cut off support and no longer offer their businesses as event space since Trump's reelection. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Italian Yacht Builder Ferretti Is Involved in an Espionage Case
Italian Yacht Builder Ferretti Is Involved in an Espionage Case

Yahoo

time2 days ago

  • Yahoo

Italian Yacht Builder Ferretti Is Involved in an Espionage Case

International intrigue at one of the world's largest yacht builders? The Italian Ferretti Group was the setting for a spy-vs-spy scenario that reportedly included private detectives shadowing an executive of the Italian builder's primary Chinese investor and recording devices hidden in several offices, according to Bloomberg. The discovery of this board-level surveillance has prompted two criminal cases, now in the hands of Italian prosecutors. In April 2024, Xu Xinyu, an executive director at Ferretti SpA, noticed two men in an SUV outside Ferretti's headquarters in Milan. Xu also sits on the board of the Weichai Group, which acquired the Ferretti Group in 2102, when the builder of Riva Yachts, Custom Line, CRN, and other brands was in financial trouble. More from Robb Report Say Hello to Robb Report en Español, the New Benchmark for Global Luxury in Spanish A Luxe Midcentury Duplex in London's Mayfair Just Listed for $25 Million Red Sox Legend David Ortiz's Former Miami Mansion Lists for $11.5 Million Xu also observed the pair following him while visiting hotels in the city, Bloomberg reported. He hired a counter-surveillance company, which reportedly found a listening device and signal amplifier hidden in his office. Other devices were found in the offices of Ferretti's Chinese-Italian translator and board secretary. The story cites unnamed sources who claimed relations between Weichai and some executives at Ferretti had deteriorated because of a proposed stock buyback program that would have allowed the repurchase of 10 percent of the shares. The buyback plan was briefly examined by the Italian government under a special 'golden' provision that allows it to oversee 'strategic' Italian brands with foreign ownership. A very small percentage of Ferretti's boat production is for the defense sector, thereby placing it in the strategic category. The Chinese members of the Ferretti board, comprised of six Chinese and three Italians, were initially against the buyback proposal, according to the sources. That decision, according to Bloomberg, caused dissension between Ferretti CEO Alberto Galassi and some members of the board. In March 2024, Galassi formally notified the Italian oversight committee of the buyback initiative. But that was earlier than the Chinese directors had expected. Bloomberg's sources say they thought the Chinese board members worried that Galassi could be using 'the golden share rule to sideline them by seeking allies in the Italian government.' The stock buyback proposal was withdrawn by the end of the month. Ferretti issued a statement denying that Galassi had gone against the board's wishes, according to Bloomberg. It said the notification 'was carried out with the formal and definitive approval of the Board of Directors.' The statement went on to say that 'the relationship between the shareholders and the company is excellent, marked by ongoing collaboration and mutual respect.' Ferretti did not immediately respond to Robb Report's request for comment. Following the discovery of the surveillance on Xu and others, some of the board members reportedly suspected it might have originated with Ferretti's upper management. Xu initiated a criminal case against 'persons unknown' in May 2024, for unauthorized access to a computer system and unlawful interference in private life. In January 2025, following an internal investigation, the Ferretti Group filed its own complaint with the Milan prosecutor's office. 'Ferretti SpA considers itself an aggrieved party, having been wronged by the unlawful and improper installation of surveillance devices within its offices,' the statement said. Ferretti says there is no tension between it and Weichai. 'The shareholder and the company have enjoyed a relationship of mutual esteem and full, constructive collaboration for over 10 years,' the brand said in a statement to Bloomberg. The cases remain in the initial stages of investigation, with no certainty that any criminal charges will be pursued. Best of Robb Report The 2024 Chevy C8 Corvette: Everything We Know About the Powerful Mid-Engine Beast The World's Best Superyacht Shipyards The ABCs of Chartering a Yacht Click here to read the full article.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store