logo
Washington Supreme Court decision against Lowe's could significantly impact self-service retail

Washington Supreme Court decision against Lowe's could significantly impact self-service retail

Yahoo13-03-2025

This story was originally published on MyNorthwest.com.
The Washington Supreme Court has ruled that a lawsuit against Lowe's Home Centers can proceed after a woman was injured by falling merchandise in one of its stores, finding that the company may be liable under a 'reasonable foreseeability' exception to traditional premises liability laws.
This ruling comes with potentially significant implications for self-service retail stores like Lowe's.
The case, Galassi v. Lowe's Home Centers, LLC, stems from a 2020 incident in which Hwayo Jenny Galassi was shopping for garden supplies at a Lowe's store. While she was selecting a roll of fencing from a high shelf, another roll fell on her, breaking her toe. No employees or other customers were present at the time, and the area of the store lacked video surveillance.
Galassi sued Lowe's, arguing the store's self-service method of displaying heavy fencing rolls on high shelves created an unreasonably dangerous condition that it should have foreseen because it stands to reason that customers were likely to handle and improperly restock the items.
Lowe's denied responsibility, asserting that it had no 'actual or constructive notice' of a hazardous condition before the incident. The company argued that under traditional liability law, it could only be held liable if it knew or should have known about the dangerous condition beforehand. Since no prior complaints or reports of unsafe shelving existed, Lowe's claimed it could not be found negligent.
A trial court granted summary judgment in favor of Lowe's, agreeing that the store had no notice of the specific unsafe condition. However, the Washington Court of Appeals reversed the decision, ruling that Lowe's method of operation could make the risk of falling merchandise reasonably foreseeable, even without direct notice of the hazard.
On Thursday, the Washington Supreme Court affirmed the appellate ruling, finding that Galassi's claim should proceed to trial.
The court noted that self-service retail stores — where customers frequently handle and move merchandise without employee supervision — can create inherent risks that businesses have a duty to address.
'A trier-of-fact could find the alleged unsafe condition in this case was reasonably foreseeable due to the nature of Lowe's business and its methods of operation. Yet, there is also contrary evidence, such as a lack of prior similar incidents, from which a trier-of-fact could reach the opposite conclusion. As a result, the Court of Appeals correctly held that there is 'a genuine issue of material fact regarding whether the (reasonable foreseeability) exception to traditional notice requirements applies,'' the Washington State Supreme Court wrote.
This ruling simply rejects a summary judgment dismissing the case. It does not, however, mean Lowe's should be held liable.
Indeed, the Court found: 'The fact that Lowe's summary judgment strategy was unsuccessful in this case does not relieve plaintiffs of their burden of proof. It is merely a case-specific outcome in accordance with the well-established rule that 'if the moving party does not sustain its burden, summary judgment should not be granted, regardless of whether the nonmoving party has submitted affidavits or other evidence in opposition to the motion.''
The ruling allows Galassi to proceed with her case before a trial court. A jury may ultimately determine whether Lowe's was negligent in its store design and product placement.
The decision could have broad implications for retailers that rely on self-service displays, potentially increasing their responsibility for customer safety.
The case will now return to the lower court for further proceedings.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Corporate support for Pride is dwindling nationwide. In NC, it's a mixed bag
Corporate support for Pride is dwindling nationwide. In NC, it's a mixed bag

Yahoo

time2 days ago

  • Yahoo

Corporate support for Pride is dwindling nationwide. In NC, it's a mixed bag

Pride Month has long been an occasion for companies and institutions to display their support for the LGBTQ+ community, whether it be for profit or for principle. It's often a trivial gesture, but it can have a meaningful impact for a community that had long been relegated to the shadows of society. But more recently, that support has waned amid a regressive political climate that has made many companies rethink their commitments to diversity, equity and inclusion. A survey conducted by the national risk management firm Gravity Research found that around 39% of companies said they would reduce their engagement around Pride Month this year. Some of the top reasons for the change were the Trump administration, conservative activists and conservative policymakers, the survey found. Major corporations, including Mastercard and Pepsi, have pulled their sponsorship of major Pride events or avoided the topic on social media. In North Carolina, the results are mixed. Take Lowe's, which is based in Mooresville. Lowe's hasn't yet acknowledged Pride Month on its social media — a marked difference from past years when it openly embraced the occasion. That's not unexpected, given that Lowe's has already announced an end to many of its DEI initiatives. Last year, the company said it would no longer participate in surveys conducted by LGBTQ+ groups and ended its support of outside events like festivals, parades and fairs. (Lowe's had previously been a longtime supporter of Charlotte's annual Pride festival.) But surprising or not, it's reflective of a growing trend away from publicly embracing the LGBTQ+ community. Charlotte-based Bank of America also has remained quiet about Pride so far. In past years, Bank of America has been vocal about celebrating the occasion on social media and honoring its LGBTQ+ employees with the hashtag #BofAPride, but that support has been absent this year. Compare that with Truist, which posted in celebration of Pride on its Facebook and Instagram accounts. For North Carolina's professional sports teams, the results are mixed, too. While the Carolina Panthers and Charlotte Hornets both celebrated the start of Pride on social media, the Carolina Hurricanes have not. In fact, the team has remained largely silent about Pride since 2023 — the Hurricanes are one of just a handful NHL teams to not acknowledge it this year — a decision that has disappointed many fans who feel a simple acknowledgment of the occasion is not too much to ask. The same goes for the state's largest cities. The city of Charlotte posted on its social media accounts at the beginning of Pride, in addition to updating its profile picture to a rainbow version of the city's crown logo. The cities of Raleigh and Greensboro, however, did not. This move toward silence comes at a time when things like Pride celebrations and flags are under attack from lawmakers across the state. Legislation has been introduced at the state level that would effectively ban the display of Pride flags in government buildings, while some counties have passed ordinances governing public events that some interpret as targeting Pride events or drag performances. Of course, a social media post is just that: a social media post. It's not going to defeat anti-LGBTQ legislation, or save gay kids from being bullied, or change the country's attitude towards transgender people — at least not on its own. From some companies, it's just a lot of empty words or glorified virtue signaling. But public support for any marginalized group can be meaningful, especially when it happens on a large scale. And when institutions cower in the face of political pressure to stay silent, they're just letting the bullies win. It makes real change all the more difficult. Ultimately, it's not the silence that is the problem. It's the fact that the silence is new — a sudden absence of the public support and acceptance that existed before. It feels like another step backward during a time when progress feels like it's constantly stuck in reverse.

Guilford County Schools bond dollars will only get half of priority projects done
Guilford County Schools bond dollars will only get half of priority projects done

Yahoo

time4 days ago

  • Yahoo

Guilford County Schools bond dollars will only get half of priority projects done

GUILFORD COUNTY, N.C. (WGHP) — Think back to 2020 and 2022 when you had a question on your ballot about bond dollars for the school district. Voters approved $2 billion for Guilford County Schools to make massive and much-needed updates to its facilities. The master plan came out in 2019. Those were pre-pandemic prices. But now, in 2025, things have changed, and there is no way the district will get all 51 of their top priority projects done with the cash they have on hand. 'The writing was kind of on the wall,' Superintendent of GCS Dr. Whitney Oakley said. She said when they returned from the pandemic, they knew this would be tricky, but in the 2021 to 2022 school year, it really sunk in that this is the new reality of pricing. 'No one had a crystal ball about construction. I can't go to Lowe's and get a piece of wood or go to the gas station and fill up for what it cost in 2019,' Oakley said. Now, with tariffs on the table, pricing is even more unpredictable. 'We are constantly evaluating how far those dollars will go, how we can use some strategies like replicating a building plan … If you think about the Allen Jay and Sumner that are coming up, they have the same layout, which saves in design,' Oakley said. In the 2019 facilities master plan, there are 51 priority projects listed to use the bond dollars. But because of rising costs, Oakley said they won't get very far down that list with the $2 billion. There are four projects no longer needed, so Oakley expects they will make it to about halfway down to project 25 on the list, which leaves about 25 projects in limbo. 'It was decades in the making, and it is going to take decades to get out … I think we need to think about how we make a more predictable stream to be able to continue to do the work because the buildings didn't get in that condition overnight,' Oakley said. It starts with the ballot. Oakley said she wants to see bond referendums more often to keep cash flowing. 'I think putting energy and resources behind being able to say what dollars are for on the ballot increases transparency, increases accountability, and our community stands behind public education,' Oakley said. You can look at the list of priority projects to see if your school's project could be funded. Today, everything before project 25 should be funded. With tariff impacts, that could change. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Lowe's to Participate in Virtual Fireside Chat Hosted by Oppenheimer & Co. Inc.
Lowe's to Participate in Virtual Fireside Chat Hosted by Oppenheimer & Co. Inc.

Yahoo

time4 days ago

  • Yahoo

Lowe's to Participate in Virtual Fireside Chat Hosted by Oppenheimer & Co. Inc.

MOORESVILLE, N.C., June 4, 2025 /PRNewswire/ -- Lowe's Companies, Inc. (NYSE: LOW) announces that Marvin R. Ellison, chairman and chief executive officer, and Brandon J. Sink, chief financial officer, will participate in a virtual fireside chat hosted by Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. What: Marvin Ellison and Brandon Sink to participate in virtual fireside chat hosted by Brian Nagelfrom Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. When: 1:30 p.m. ET on Wednesday, June 11, 2025 Where: Visit Lowe's Investor Relations at for the video webcast A link will be displayed under "Events & Presentations" How: Watch live online – the archived webcast will be available at the same location approximately24 hours after the conclusion of the live event About Lowe's Lowe's Companies, Inc. (NYSE: LOW) is a FORTUNE® 100 home improvement company serving approximately 16 million customer transactions a week in the United States. With total fiscal year 2024 sales of more than $83 billion, Lowe's operates over 1,700 home improvement stores and employs approximately 300,000 associates. Based in Mooresville, N.C., Lowe's supports the communities it serves through programs focused on creating safe, affordable housing, improving community spaces, helping to develop the next generation of skilled trade experts and providing disaster relief to communities in need. For more information, visit LOW-IR Contacts: Shareholder /Analyst Inquiries: Media Inquiries:Kate Pearlman Steve Salazar704-775-3856 View original content to download multimedia: SOURCE Lowe's Companies, Inc. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store