Family of Autistic Teen Shot 9 Times by Police Launch Lawsuit
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
The family of 17-year-old Victor Perez, an autistic teenager who was shot nine times by police officers in Idaho earlier this year, is suing the Pocatello Police Department (PPD) over claims that officers violated the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
Perez, who was non-verbal and also had cerebral palsy, died from his injuries after being shot multiple times by officers from the PPD following a violent outburst at his family's home on April 5.
Officers were called by a neighbor who saw Perez holding a knife and arrived at the scene to subdue him but used deadly force instead of non-violent means of intervention. Perez's family has said they believe they could have solved the outburst without police intervention.
Civil rights attorney John Burris, who is representing the Perez family, says the officers violated the ADA as they knew about Perez's disability. The ADA states that officers who know they are dealing with a disabled person must use non-lethal tactics.
Newsweek has contacted the PPD for comment via their voicemail. Law firm Burris Nisenbaum Curry and Lacy has also been contacted via their website for comment.
In this image taken from video, police are seen shortly before opening fire Victor Perez on the other side of a fence on April 5 in Pocatello, Idaho.
In this image taken from video, police are seen shortly before opening fire Victor Perez on the other side of a fence on April 5 in Pocatello, Idaho.
AP Photo/Brad Andres via AP
Why It Matters
This lawsuit could impact how police handle situations involving people who find it more difficult to advocate for themselves.
What To Know
On April 5, Pocatello police were called to Perez's family home as he was having a violent outburst.
This was not the first time they had been called to his home due to his behavioral struggles, and according to the lawsuit, they had paperwork noting Perez's intellectual and physical disabilities.
Footage released by police of the incident shows officers arriving to his home, guns drawn. Footage then shows police yelling at Perez several times to "drop the knife." In the video, Perez is on the ground but then stands up to take a step towards police, who were on the other side of a chain fence.
This is when police opened fire on Perez, who according to local news station KTVB not only had several disabilities but also did not understand English, shooting him multiple times.
The video released by police also includes the 911 call from the neighbor who said: "He is trying to stab everyone, it looks like." The caller then says, "This guy, he seems pretty drunk." The caller may not have known about Perez's disabilities.
The footage does not show police attempting to use de-escalation tactics or any other form of non-lethal violence prevention. Police told KTVB at the time that they were not made aware that Perez was having a mental health crisis. However, the family's lawyers are now saying the police had records of his mental and physical state.
Perez was rushed to hospital after being shot nine times and had operations including an amputation to remove the bullets. However, doctors could not save his life, and Perez was taken off life support.
The footage was released by Pocatello Mayor Brian Blad in order to answer public questions about how the shooting occurred.
PPD Chief Roger Schei said at the time: "The risk [to the police officers] was immediate," as justification for the shooting.
However, Burris is saying the potential risk posed by Perez still disregards the ADA given the police department's prior knowledge of Perez's disabilities.
Autistic Self Advocacy Network (ASAN), a nonprofit advocacy organization, has spoken out against the use of "autism training" for police officers, saying "an hour of learning about autism cannot overcome months of training that teaches police that in uncertain situations, the first thing they should do is escalate force to exert control."
"There have been cases where police who have been through autism-specific training still went on to shoot and kill autistic people they were called to help."
Zoe Gross, director of ASAN, told Newsweek: "There are several steps we as a society can take to stop police violence against disabled people. We can reduce the likelihood that disabled people will have contact with police by promoting alternatives to policing. This may look like funding crisis intervention teams staffed with EMTs, social workers and mental health professionals.
"These teams can respond to calls involving people in crisis or distress instead of sending police to intervene in these situations. Other alternatives to policing include peer respite and counseling, safe consumption sites, and housing and food assistance. All these alternatives must receive adequate funding, and one step towards that is to reduce the share of municipal funds that police departments currently receive."
What People Are Saying
Zoe Gross, director of Advocacy at the Autistic Self Advocacy Network (ASAN), told Newsweek: "We must increase community oversight of police forces and make it easier to hold police accountable for violence by ending the policy of qualified immunity, which makes it very difficult to sue when police harm someone. People who want to see less police violence can advocate for policy changes like these."
Gross added: "Police often profile or target autistic people, especially Black autistics and other autistic people of color. They may claim that someone with auditory processing issues is 'refusing to follow commands' that they do not understand; that someone who cannot speak is refusing to cooperate; or that someone making repetitive movements is making threatening gestures or is drunk or high. When autistic people do not understand or cannot follow a police officer's instructions, or moves in a way that police perceive as erratic or threatening, police may immediately escalate to using force, including sometimes killing the autistic person."
Attorney John Burris told the press: "[Officers] arrived on the scene just like gangbusters and within moments, not minutes, not hours, no effort to give the young man any opportunity to locate where he was or to self-identify with these officers; They shot and killed him."
Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador told the media at the time of the shooting: "As with all such matters, the Office of the Attorney General will conduct a thorough and impartial review once the Eastern Idaho Critical Incident Task Force completes its investigation."
What Happens Next?
The police in this lawsuit may receive additional legal aid due to the Trump administration, as President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing the Justice Department to explore a program that could involve law firms providing pro bono assistance to police officers accused of wrongdoing.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
14 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Jury retires to decide verdict in Australia's mushroom murder trial
Jury members retired Monday to decide the fate of an Australian woman accused of murdering three members of her husband's family with a toxic mushroom-laced beef Wellington lunch. The 12-person panel has been locked away to decide whether Erin Patterson is guilty or not, beginning their deliberations after a nine-week trial intently followed by a global audience. "You must decide whether any of her statements were untrue," judge Christopher Beale said in his final instructions. "You should consider all of the evidence in the case and draw reasonable conclusions based only on the evidence you accept. "Do not guess." Jurors must reach a unanimous verdict -- guilty or not guilty -- for each of the four charges Patterson faces, Beale said. The 50-year-old is charged with murdering her estranged husband's parents and aunt in July 2023 by spiking their beef-and-pastry meal with death cap mushrooms -- the world's deadliest fungi. She is also accused of attempting to murder a fourth guest -- her husband's uncle -- who survived the classic English dish after a long stay in hospital. The 14-person jury was reduced to 12 by ballot before they started debating a verdict at the court in Morwell, southeast of Melbourne. They will be sequestered at night during the deliberations. Patterson has steadfastly denied all charges against her, saying the poisoning of the beef Wellington -- cooked in individual portions -- was a mistake. The trial has focused in forensic detail on the events surrounding the meal at her property in the farming village of Leongatha in Victoria state. Her lunch guests that afternoon were Don and Gail Patterson, the elderly parents of her long-estranged husband Simon. Places were also set for Simon's maternal aunt Heather and her husband Ian Wilkinson, a well-known pastor at the local Baptist church. - 'Uncomfortable' - Simon was urged to come but he declined on the eve of the fatal lunch because he felt "uncomfortable". Within days of the meal, his parents and aunt had died of organ failure. Of the four guests, only the pastor survived. The prosecution alleges Patterson deliberately foraged for death cap mushrooms and hid them in the meal, intending to kill her lunch guests. She took care not to consume the fatal mushrooms and faked being sick after the lunch in a bid to avoid suspicion, the prosecution says. But Patterson's defence lawyer said it was a "terrible accident" and she never intended to kill or harm anyone. "I didn't deliberately put death cap mushrooms in the meal," Patterson said in her testimony to the court. She only lied to authorities in panic after the lunch, including about the source of the mushrooms, for fear of being held responsible, her defence said. Patterson told police investigating the deaths that she did not own a food dehydrator, allegedly used to prepare the death cap mushrooms. Security footage showed Patterson dumping a dehydrator at a nearby rubbish facility, and forensic tests found trace amounts of death cap mushrooms on the appliance. "I agree that I lied because I was afraid I would be held responsible," Patterson said during the trial. Patterson ate some of the same dish as her guests but did not fall as sick, her defence argued, saying she suffered from an eating disorder and made herself vomit afterwards. djw-sft/hmn
Newsweek
2 hours ago
- Newsweek
Stonewall Shooting: Everything We Know
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. At least two people were injured in a shooting outside New York City's historic Stonewall Inn following a LGBTQ+ pride parade on Sunday. One person was shot in the head and taken to hospital in a critical condition, according to New York broadcaster WABC. Another person was wounded in the leg, but it is not clear whether they were shot. New York Mayor Eric Adams wrote on X, formerly Twitter: "Saddened to learn about the shooting by the Stonewall Inn tonight as Pride celebrations were winding down. During a time when our city should be rejoicing and celebrating members of our diverse LGBTQ+ community, incidents like this are devastating." The Stonewall Inn in New York. At least two people were injured in the shooting on Sunday. The Stonewall Inn in New York. At least two people were injured in the shooting on Sunday. AP This is a breaking story. More to follow.
San Francisco Chronicle
2 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Israel's strike on Iran's Evin prison sparks fear for political prisoners
BEIRUT (AP) — Sayeh Seydal, a jailed Iranian dissident, narrowly escaped death when Israeli missiles struck Tehran's Evin Prison, where she was imprisoned. She had just stepped out of the prison's clinic, moments before it was destroyed in the blasts. The June 23 strikes on Iran's most notorious prison for political dissidents killed at least 71 people, including staff, soldiers, visiting family members and people living nearby, Iranian judiciary spokesman Asghar Jahangir said Sunday. In the ensuing chaos, authorities transferred Seydal and others to prisons outside of Tehran — overcrowded facilities, known for their harsh conditions. When she was able to call her family several days ago, Seydal pleaded for help. 'It's literally a slow death,' she said of the conditions, according to a recording of the call provided by her relatives, in accordance with Seydal's wishes. 'The bombing by the U.S. and Israel didn't kill us. Then the Islamic Republic brought us to a place that will practically kill us,' she said. Activists fear Israel's attacks will lead to crackdown Iran's pro-democracy and rights activists fear they will pay the price for Israel's 12-day air campaign aiming to cripple the country's nuclear program. Many now say the state, reeling from the breach in its security, has already intensified its crackdown on opponents. Israel's strike on Evin — targeting, it said, "repressive authorities' — spread panic among families of the political prisoners, who were left scrambling to determine their loved ones' fates. A week later, families of those who were in solitary confinement or under interrogation still haven't heard from them. Nobel Peace Prize laureate Narges Mohammadi, a veteran activist who has been imprisoned multiple times in Evin, said that Iranian society, "to get to democracy, needs powerful tools to reinforce civil society and the women's movement.' 'Unfortunately, war weakens these tools,' she said in a video message to The Associated Press from Tehran. Political space is already shrinking with security forces increasing their presence in the streets of the capital, she said. Fears of looming executions Many now fear a potential wave of executions targeting activists and political prisoners. They see a terrifying precedent: After Iran's war with Iraq ended in 1988, authorities executed at least 5,000 political prisoners after perfunctory trials, then buried them in mass graves that have never been accessed. Already during Israel's campaign, Iran executed six prisoners who were sentenced to death before the war. The Washington-based Human Rights Activists in Iran documented nearly 1,300 people arrested, most on charges of espionage, including 300 for sharing content on social media in just 12 days. Parliament is fast-tracking a bill allowing greater use of the death penalty for charges of collaboration with foreign adversaries. The judiciary chief called for expedited proceedings against those who 'disrupt the peace' or "collaborate' with Israel. 'We know what that means. That means show trials and executions,' said Bahar Ghandehari, director of advocacy and media at the New York-based Center for Human Rights in Iran. Prisoners scattered after the strike Evin Prison, located in an upscale neighborhood on Tehran's northern edge, housed an estimated 120 men and women in its general wards, as well as hundreds of others believed to be in its secretive security units under interrogation or in solitary confinement, according to HRA. The prisoners include protesters, lawyers and activists who have campaigned for years against Iran's authoritarian rule, corruption and religious laws including enforcement of Islamic attire on women. Authorities have crushed repeated waves of nationwide protests since 2009 in crackdowns that have killed hundreds and jailed thousands. The strikes hit Evin during visiting hours, causing shock and panic. Seydal, an international law scholar who joined protest movements over the past two decades and has been in and out of jail since 2023, recounted to her family her near brush with death in the prison clinic. The blast knocked her to the ground, a relative who spoke to Seydal said, speaking on condition of anonymity for fear of reprisals. Visiting halls, the prosecutor's office and several prisoner wards were also heavily damaged, according to rights groups and relatives of prisoners. One missile hit the prison entrance, where prisoners often are sitting waiting to be taken to hospitals or court. 'Attacking a prison, when the inmates are standing behind closed doors and they are unable to do the slightest thing to save themselves, can never be a legitimate target,' Mohammadi said. Mohammadi was just released in December when her latest sentence was briefly suspended for medical reasons. During the night, buses began transferring prisoners to other facilities, according to Mohammadi and families of prisoners. At least 65 women were sent to Qarchak Prison, according to Mohammadi, who is in touch with them. Men were sent to the Grand Tehran Penitentiary, housing criminals and high-security prisoners. Both are located south of Tehran. Mohammadi told AP that her immediate fear was a lack of medical facilities and poor hygiene. Among the women are several with conditions needing treatment, including 73-year-old civil rights activist Raheleh Rahemi, who has a brain tumor. In her call home, Seydal called Qarchak a 'hellhole.' She said the women were packed together in isolation, with no hygiene care, and limited food or drinkable water. 'It stinks. Just pure filth,' she said. 'She sounded confused, scared and very sad,' her relative said. 'She knows speaking out is very dangerous for her. But also being silent can be dangerous for her.' On Sunday, Sayeh made another call to her family, saying she was briefly taken back to Evin to bring her belongings. The stench of 'death' filled the air, her relative quoted her as saying. The 47-year-old Seydal was first sentenced in 2023. In early 2025, her furlough was canceled, and she was assaulted by security and faced new charges after she refused to wear a chador at the prosecutor's office. A brother disappears Reza Younesi's father and younger brother, Ali, have both been imprisoned at Evin for years. Now the family is terrified because Ali has disappeared. Ali, a 25-year-old graduate of a prestigious technical university, was serving a 16-year sentence for "colluding to commit crimes against national security.' The sentence, widely criticized by rights groups, was reduced but then the Intelligence Ministry launched a new case against him on unknown charges. Days before the strike on Evin, Ali was dragged out of his ward and taken to an unknown location, according to his brother. After the strike, their father, Mir-Yousef Younesi, saw no sign of Ali as he and other prisoners were transferred to the Great Tehran Penitentiary. The father managed to get a call out to his family, in a panic. Disappearances in Evin are not uncommon. Guards sometimes remove political prisoners from wards for interrogation. In some cases, they are sentenced in secret trials and executed. After the strikes, Swedish-Iranian academic Ahmadreza Djalali, sentenced to death in 2017, was transferred from the Tehran prison to an undisclosed location, according to Amnesty International, which expressed fear he could be executed. Reza Younesi said the family lawyer was unable to find out any information about his brother or the new charges. 'We are all worried,' he said, speaking from Sweden where he is an associate professor at Uppsala University. 'When there is no information from a prisoner, this almost in all cases means that the person is under interrogation and torture.' 'All hope is gone' Mehraveh Khandan grew up in a family of political activists. She spent much of her childhood and teen years going to Evin to visit her mother, rights lawyer Nasrin Sotoudeh, who was imprisoned there multiple times. Her father, Reza Khandan, was thrown into Evin in December for distributing buttons opposing the mandatory headscarf for women. Now living in Amsterdam, the 25-year-old Mehraveh Khandan frantically tried to find information about her father after the strike. The internet was cut off, and her mother had evacuated from Tehran. 'I was just thinking who might die there,' she said. It took 24 hours before she got word her father was OK. In a family call later, her father told how he was sleeping on the floor in a crowded cell rife with insects at the Grand Tehran Penitentiary. At first, she thought the Evin strike might prompt the government to release prisoners. But after seeing reports of mass detentions and executions, 'all this hope is gone,' she said.
