Phil Gould criticism of Billy Slater decision to axe Daly Cherry-Evans for Origin II
Don't miss out on the headlines from Maroons. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Phil Gould has doubled down on his criticism of Billy Slater's decision to axe Queensland captain Daly Cherry-Evans and claimed the Maroons will be lucky to score two tries in what will be 20-point Origin II humiliation.
The Maroons need to win Wednesday night's second game in Perth to keep the series alive and avoid back-to-back series defeats.
Queensland has lost the past three Origin matches in convincing fashion and has only scored one try in the last two games – both on home turf at Suncorp Stadium.
Staring down the barrel of a fourth straight loss, and second series defeat, Slater wielded the selection axe on 26-game halfback and skipper Cherry-Evans for the must-win match in Perth.
The decision was controversial given Queensland hasn't dropped a captain mid-series since Trevor Gillmeister in 1996.
• TRANSFER TARGET: THE PLAYER YOUR CLUB NEEDS BEFORE WINDOW SLAMS SHUT
• WATCH: THE TEENAGE SUPERSTARS DESTINED FOR NRLW GREATNESS
• HOW JOURNALIST HELPED ORIGIN STAR SAY GOODBYE TO DYING MOTHER
The Maroons forwards were also badly beaten in Game One, yet Slater only made one change to his pack in dropping bench backrower Beau Fermor, who was given 16 minutes on debut.
Cherry-Evans has provided little comment on the decision other than to admit it was 'tough' to receive the news he had been dropped.
Daly Cherry-Evans' Origin career is effectively over after his game two axing. Picture:Phil Gould doubled down on his criticism of the decision. Picture: NRL Imagery / Scott Davis
It is understood he was shattered by the call, especially after the ill-disciplined performance Queensland dished up in Game One that gave him little good ball to attack with.
'Gus' Gould is the most successful NSW coach in State of Origin history, winning six series from eight attempts.
He has made numerous comments condemning the decision to dump 'DCE' in favour of Tom Dearden and reiterated his stance on Monday.
'He doesn't get that goodbye moment after a great career, they've said goodbye for him,' Gould told 100% Footy.
'He doesn't get to stand there on the field after a win, loss or draw at the end of the series and say 'this is my last time'.
'They've made their mind up for him, I think it's been pretty unceremonious actually. I think it's very, very ordinary, to be honest.'
Dearden has been elevated from the bench utility role to halfback to provide Queensland with a more direct attacking style than the scheming Cherry-Evans.
He will form a new-look halves combination with new captain Cameron Munster at five-eighth.
But Gould predicted Queensland would still struggle to score points at Optus Stadium, where they been smashed 38-6 (2019) and 44-12 (2022) in recent games.
'I can find four or five tries for New South Wales but I'm struggling to find two tries for Queensland,' he said.
'I think it'll be four or five tries to one or two, if they all kick the goals, 30-12 would be my scoreline.
'I don't think it will be close. Sorry, I know you all want a decider but I don't think it's going to happen.'
Originally published as Phil Gould doubles down on criticism of Billy Slater's decision to axe Daly Cherry-Evans from Maroons for Origin II
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
19 minutes ago
- 7NEWS
Queensland coach Billy Slater hits back at Aaron Woods in emotional response to ‘grub' comment
Billy Slater has referenced late Queensland coach Paul Green in delivering a pointed takedown to Aaron Woods over the former NSW prop's 'grub' claims. In a dramatic precursor to State of Origin II, Slater questioned former NSW forward Woods's right to have a voice in the media after copping heat from him last week. The under-pressure Maroons coach also played down the spotlight on his own job, as Queensland fight to stay in the series at Optus Stadium in Perth on Wednesday night. But Slater saved the most poignant response to a question around Woods's comments. Woods made headlines last week when he labelled Slater a grub on Sydney radio, pointing to the fact he kicked then Wests Tigers prop John Skandalis in a game in 2006. Asked about the issue on Tuesday, Slater questioned reporters if they really wanted him to answer before unleashing on Woods with a rally-like speech. 'When you hold a position in the media or in our game, I feel that's a privilege. And with that privilege comes a responsibility,' Slater said. 'I sit in that position most weeks and you amplify your voice to millions of people. You're not talking to your mates in the pub. 'I know Aaron Woods. 'I actually ran into him three or four weeks ago at a footy game and he didn't voice that opinion then. He actually brought his son over to introduce him to me. 'When you degrade someone personally in a derogatory manner, you probably don't deserve one of those privileged positions that we're all in.' Slater was then interrupted by an applause from the crowd at Perth's public press conference, before telling them 'I'm not done yet'. 'You don't know what people are going through,' he continued. 'And although I might be able to handle it, the next person mightn't be. Maybe our last coach didn't. 'I believe the character of a person is judged more on what they say about people and how they treat people, than what an individual says to create attention.' Green took his own life in 2022, one year after coaching the Maroons in the 2021 series. A post-mortem found the North Queensland premiership-winning coach had been living with a 'severe' and undiagnosed case of Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy. Tuesday's press conference was expected to centre around Slater's fight to keep the Maroons in the series and avoid a second straight defeat to NSW after last year's capitulation. Slater has made a number of bold calls ahead of Wednesday night, headlined by the axing of captain Daly Cherry-Evans and Tom Dearden's move to the No.7 jersey. Before a question was even asked by the press at Tuesday's press conference, a member of the crowd yelled out 'you're under pressure Billy'. 'What is pressure? To me, the opposite of pressure is comfort,' Slater said. 'So you're either comfortable or you're in a pressure situation. And I think you earn that opportunity, whether it's a player or a coach. 'To be in this environment, you've earned that pressure. Because it means so much to the people of our states, it means so much to the people involved in the game. 'But of course there's pressure. There was pressure in grand finals. There was pressure in state of origin games and there still is. 'And the day there's no pressure, I'll be a bit worried.'
West Australian
28 minutes ago
- West Australian
State of Origin: Queensland coach Billy Slater welcomes pressure cooker of must-win game
Queensland may look to have their backs against the wall on the eve of State of Origin game two in Perth — but Maroons coach Billy Slater is looking only at the opportunities presenting themselves. New South Wales have the upper hand in the best-of-three series ahead of Wednesday night's Optus Stadium blockbuster between the two great rivals, but Slater said his side were ready to right the wrongs of game one. The ex-Melbourne Storm great said the pressure was palpable — but was quick to point out it was a good thing. 'What is pressure like? To me, the opposite of pressure is comfort, so you're either comfortable or you're in a precious situation, and I think you earn that opportunity,' he said. 'Whether it's a player or a coach to be in this environment, you've earned that pressure and because it means so much to the people of our states, it means so much to the people involved in the game, of course there's pressure. 'The day there's no pressure, I'll be worried.' Queensland are yet to taste victory in WA, having fallen in the previous two Perth Origin clashes in 2019 and 2022 by scores of 38-6 and 44-12. And since taking over as Maroons coach in 2022, this is the first time Slater's team have faced a 1-0 deficit in Origin. 'What a great opportunity, right? We haven't won over here. We've had a couple of poor performances the last time Queensland have played here, and we haven't won a series on the road since being 1-0 down,' Slater said. 'That's a great opportunity for this group, and it's also an outcome, it's a big picture focus. We're really focused on the little things — we didn't quite get the little things right in game one.' Given Laurie Daly's side's dominant 18-6 win at Suncorp Stadium, you could forgive the Blues for cutting relaxed figures on Tuesday, but NSW skipper Isaah Yeo warned his side against complacency. 'Being captain, it's all about your preparation and getting that right, so I wouldn't be doing the right job if I was too busy worrying about that (complacency),' he said. 'The preparation obviously had its challenges at the start of the week, but it was probably similar for us in game one.' Wests Tigers five-eighth Jarome Luai is back in the no.6 jersey for NSW in the absence of Mitch Moses, bolstering an already star-studded backs group. He will be reunited with his former Penrith Panthers partner in the halves Nathan Cleary, who said he was looking forward to playing alongside his ex-teammate. 'It's sinking in again I get to play alongside him. We've played in big games together in the past,' he said. 'Him going him to another club and then versing him just the other week, was a weird experience to be honest. 'He brings that energy that everyone sees, he's definitely not afraid of the moment or big games.'
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Canterbury preview: A nice book of rides has jockey Jason Collett poised to boost his premiership standing
Jockey Jason Collett is more than happy with the way this season has gone so far including a Group 1 win and is looking to close it out with a bang. Collett currently sits third in the metropolitan jockeys premiership and while James McDonald holds a commanding lead with 81 winners, Collett is just three behind Zac Lloyd with 58 wins and is looking to close the gap. 'I'm really happy with the way the season has gone so far,' said Collett. 'Obviously, winning the Doncaster was huge. It's such a big race. 'I want to try and win any Group 1 but to achieve that was such a huge. 'On the whole, I'm third in the premiership, I'm happy with the stake money I've earnt so it's been a good season.' POINT SCORE (2 c Blue Point - Hill of Grange) runs away from his rivals at @kemblaraces for Amanda Turner, giving @DarleyStallions BLUE POINT a 6th SH 2yo winner this season ðŸ'µ The colt was a $150k buy for his trainer from @Middlebrookstud at the @mmsnippets Gold Coast Yearling… â€' ANZ News (@anz_news) May 31, 2025 The Form: Complete NSW Racing thoroughbred form, including video replays and all you need to know about every horse, jockey and trainer. Collett has a nice book of rides at Canterbury starting with the Gary Portelli -trained Kilbrannan in the Myplates Handicap (1250m). He rode the two-year-old in his last trial at Warwick Farm before the colt debuted with a handy third to Point Score at Kembla with his brother-in-law, Andrew Calder, in the saddle. 'I've had a wee bit to do with the family. Obviously, he is a half-brother to Fireburn and Kintyre and he is a similar type. 'He's got a good attitude and shows a bit of ability. 'He trialled quite nicely when I rode him at Warwick Farm leading into his first run. 'Stepping up a bit further this week will help. 'He's a raw type and whatever he does this week, he will improve again. 'There's a hot favourite in this race of Chris Waller's (Central Coast) but I do like this horse going forward.' Collett partnered the Ciaron Maher -trained So Long Farewell in his first two runs this campaign including a second to Kundabung on the Kensington two runs back. They reunite in the Maurice At Arrowfield Plate (1550m). 'His last run for me was really good on the Kenso. I rode him a bit quieter and he started to put it together late and attacked the line well,' he said. 'I see they rode him up close last start and it may not have been to his liking because he wasn't as strong late. A dominant victory to Kundabung who breaks his maiden at start number three at Randwick today!🙌 @cwallerracing | @aus_turf_club â€' SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) May 14, 2025 'This distance this week is what I think he will need but it may be a case of making sure he does it right in the first half of the race so he runs on.' The Richard and Will Freedman -trained Miss Jones is an acceptor in the TAB Plate (1250m) and also Maiden Handicap at Gosford on Thursday. Collett was aboard first-up when fourth behind Regimental Colours over 1100m at Warwick Farm and feels a step up in distance is ideal. 'She battled away okay first-up,' he said. 'She has an abundance of early speed so I'd like to make use of that and put her up on the speed. The Canterbury track will suit her style 'There are a couple of handy types in the field but I think she is a good hope.' Collett had his first feel of Fioprospero in a Randwick barrier trial last Friday and was happy with the gelding's effort when sixth in the mid-preparation heat ahead of the Benchmark 72 Handicap (1900m). 'It was a tick over trial to get him ready for this,' he said. 'I don't know too much about his form with most of his runs up in Queensland this campaign but I was happy with his trial.' His final ride is Miss Hades in the Benchmark 72 Handicap (1550m). 'She has won at this level in earlier campaign so she does have the ability, she just needs to recapture that,' he said. â– â– â– â– â– Trainer Matthew Smith is pleased with preparation of new recruit Fioprospero and is looking to the gelding to build on it when he steps out at Canterbury. The son of Fiorente kicked off his first preparation for Smith with a sixth behind Debello over an unsuitable 1400m at Kembla on March 4 before heading to Queensland and scoring back-to-back wins at Eagle Farm over 1830m and 1805m. The six-year-old was then just behind the placegetters on the Kensington in late April and the Gold Coast on May 10. 'He's been racing in great form this preparation,' said Smith. 'Most of his runs have been up in Queensland and he won a couple of races at Eagle Farm. 'We just gave him a little freshen up after his last run and trial last week. Fioprospero settled last and wide and worked to the line strongly to finish a three length sixth behind Last Command in the 1200m heat under Jason Collett who will ride him in the Ole Kirk @ Vinery Stud Handicap (1900m). Fioprospero makes it two wins in a row at Eagle Farm! 2ï¸�⃣ @baileywheeler05 | @mcsmithracing | @BrisRacingClub â€' SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) April 5, 2025 'I was really happy with that trial,' he said.' 'He gives me the impression that he will run a mile and a half so we will look to step him up.' Smith has liked what he seen of Golden Straand in trackwork and his trials and the colt pleased his trainer with his debut second to Sapphire Rose over 1100m at Wyong on June 8. The son of the late Snitzel steps out for his second start in the TAB Plate (1250m) for three-year-old maidens with Jay Ford to ride. 'I quite like this horse and I was happy with his debut run,' Smith said. 'He's a colt that we have brought along slowly. 'He's also in at Gosford on Thursday so I will work out which race suits him better at this stage and we try and build his confidence.' Smith final runner is Serene Nic in the Traffic Warden @ Darley Handicap (1550m). The five-year-old should be forgiven for her last start sixth at Hawkesbury on a heavy track and has since trialled very well when third to Jamberoo at Warwick Farm on May 27. 'She was terrific first-up and at her next start, she ran as expected being second-up off a decent break,' he said. 'She just didn't perform at Hawkesbury last start so we gave her a freshen up. 'She was very consistent last preparation and this is the sort of race she can run very well in.'
