NAB boss slammed for 'peak boomer' advice for building wealth as everyday Aussies battle a housing crisis
The long-serving former chief economist of one of Australia's big banks has come under fire for comments widely criticised as tone-deaf and out of touch.
Alan Oster, who retired in March after 32 years with NAB, shared his views on building wealth in a recent interview with the Australian Financial Review.
His advice? Invest in property and wait.
'Buy a good property and hold it, is basically the bottom line,' he told the publication.
'We've still got some property down in Portsea and we tend not to sell under normally about 15–20 years.'
But his comments sparked immediate backlash.
'This is funny because Oster [thinks] this is helpful... advice but it's effectively a Paris Hilton singlet saying 'don't be poor',' wrote journalist Mark Di Stefano on X.
Di Stefano jokingly referenced the infamous doctored image of Paris Hilton, where her shirt was edited to read 'Stop being poor', and subsequently went viral.
In reality, the shirt originally said 'Stop being desperate'.
Oster's remarks follow the reported sale of his five-bedroom home in Melbourne's affluent suburb of Brighton.
The property was said to have fetched around $5.5million, reportedly roughly double its 2012 purchase price.
Oster told news.com.au that the reported figure was inaccurate, though he did not provide an alternative price.
According to realestate.com.au, the current median house price in Brighton is just over $3million.
Alex Joiner, Chief Economist at IFM Investors, described Oster's remarks as a 'misstep,' saying they highlighted a disconnect from reality for first-home buyers.
'People struggling to buy a home won't like to be told by a Brighton resident how to get a home,' Joiner said.
He added that Oster had benefited from 'structurally lower interest rates, financial deregulation, multiple enormous property booms, and discounted rates and fees from his employer'.
Olster recently sold a home in Brighton (pictured) - one of Melbourne's most exclusive areas
Cameron Kusher, Director of Economic Research at Real Estate Australia, also criticised the piece, saying, 'It wasn't a great read'.
'Most people could only dream of owning a Brighton home. Most buy at much lower prices in much worse locations, and prices haven't risen like they have in Brighton.'
Other readers were less forgiving.
'It's an indictment on this country when the long-serving chief economist of a major bank is reduced to recommending buying luxury property rather than offering any critical analysis,' one wrote.
'Wow, can really see why he was a chief economist. "Buy a good property and hold it",' one person wrote sarcastically.
'Thank goodness there's no housing crisis in Australia and properties are generally affordable, or this article would be pure tumbrel remark,' another commented.
'Peak boomer,' someone else simply replied.
The comments come just weeks after a global housing study ranked five major Australian cities among the 20 least affordable in the world.
Sydney was ranked the second most unaffordable city globally, behind only Hong Kong. Adelaide came in 6th, Melbourne 9th, Brisbane 11th, and Perth 18th.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
44 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Hays shares plummet as hiring slowdown hammers recruiter's profits
Hays shares plunged to their lowest level in around 14 years on Thursday after the recruitment company warned profits would more than half this year. The London-based business expects to achieve about £45million in pre-exceptional operating profits for the quarter ending June 2025, compared to analyst predictions of £56.4million and down by more than 57 per cent on last year. Hays told shareholders it faced 'more challenging' conditions in the permanent employment market, with heightened economic uncertainty weighs on client and candidate confidence levels. Shares in the company plummeted 11.5 per cent to 62.15p by midday, making them the FTSE 250 Index's worst performer. Hays shares have lost more than 40 per cent over the last year and have not traded at this level since December 2011. Elevated interest rates, high energy prices, and tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump are cooling global job markets, leading to lower income for recruiters. Hays anticipates reporting a 9 per cent like-for-like decline in net fees, including a 14 per cent drop in permanent fees. In its largest territory, Germany, the group forecasts a 5 per cent decrease due to major headwinds facing the country's automotive sector, such as lower sales and profits, as well as intense competition from Chinese electric vehicle manufacturers. Hays also expects to announce falls of 9 per cent for the Australia and New Zealand region and 13 per cent for the UK and Ireland. Approximately 276,000 jobs have been lost in Britain since Chancellor Rachel Reeves' Autumn Budget, according to figures released last week by HMRC. The Budget included a 6.7 per cent rise in the National Living Wage to £12.21 per hour and an increase in employers' National Insurance contributions from 13.8 per cent on annual wages above £9,100 to 15 per cent on salaries exceeding £5,000. It told investors on Thursday: 'We expect current challenging market conditions to persist into FY26 and remain committed to delivering our focused strategy. 'Our initiatives to improve net fee productivity in real terms and back-office efficiency will be important drivers of medium-term profit recovery when the market recovers.' Hays downsized its own consultant headcount by 5 per cent during the opening three months of 2025, with some redundancies happening in the British Isles. Fellow London-listed recruiters Robert Walters and PageGroup have also recently cut their staff numbers. Russ Mould, investment director at AJ Bell, said: 'Companies are clearly worried about the economic outlook, and they're reluctant to take on full-time staff, potentially not replacing anyone lost to natural turnover. 'At the same time, individuals are worried that if they move job, they'll be in the 'last in, first out' firing line if companies look for new cost savings.'
Finextra
an hour ago
- Finextra
Maile Carnegie to retire from ANZ
ANZ today announced Maile Carnegie has decided to retire as Group Executive Australia Retail on 1 July 2025 to focus on non-executive roles after a distinguished 33-year executive career. 0 Mrs Carnegie first joined ANZ in 2016 as Group Executive Digital Banking, where she was responsible for improving the digital experience for the bank's customers, along with Group responsibility for Marketing. Since 2022, Mrs Carnegie has led ANZ's Retail business in Australia, which services more than six million customers. ANZ Chief Executive Officer Nuno Matos said: 'Since joining ANZ in 2016, Maile has had a significant impact across payments, marketing, digitisation and most recently leading our retail business in Australia. 'When I joined ANZ last month Maile informed me of her desire to transition to a non-executive career outside the bank. I wish to extend my appreciation for her efforts in supporting my early days as CEO. On behalf of everyone at ANZ, I wish her well with the next phase of her career and thank her for all her efforts.' Current Suncorp Bank CEO Bruce Rush has been appointed Acting Group Executive Australia Retail & Suncorp Bank while a global search is undertaken. Mrs Carnegie will assist with a comprehensive transition through July. Having joined Suncorp Bank in 2010 from Santander UK, Mr Rush is an experienced retail banker who has held senior roles across strategy, deposits, and home lending. He has been CEO of Suncorp Bank since August 2024. Mr Matos added: 'Bruce is an experienced retail banker who has done an outstanding job as CEO of Suncorp Bank. His appointment will also assist with the migration of Suncorp Bank customers to ANZ, while we conduct a global search for the next leader of our retail business in Australia.'
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Victoria Liberals bail out John Pesutto with $1.5m loan to avoid bankruptcy
The Victorian Liberal party will provide a $1.5m loan to former leader John Pesutto to ensure he can pay Moira Deeming's legal fees and avoid bankruptcy. The loan was debated by the 19-member administrative committee on Thursday night and ultimately endorsed after a secret ballot, which was proposed to limit any factional retribution within a deeply divided party. Deeming, also a Liberal MP, successfully sued Pesutto for defamation after he falsely implied she sympathised with neo-Nazis and white supremacists. She has expressed dismay that a loan was even considered and argued the use of party money to cover Pesutto's debts was 'against the grain of everything we believe as Liberals'. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email But Pesutto's supporters believe the loan is reasonable as his actions as opposition leader should have been indemnified. They also argue it will avoid a costly byelection in his seat of Hawthorn, which many insiders fear they will lose. The loan will help Pesutto pay Deeming's $2.3m in legal fees, which were financed by NSW property developer Hilton Grugeon. The remaining amount has been secured through private donors, the majority of whom remain so far undisclosed. The loan will be facilitated by the party's investment vehicle, Vapold, and come with several strict conditions. They include Pesutto offering his superannuation savings as collateral, securing personal guarantors and committing to ongoing fundraising efforts, with all proceeds to go towards repaying the principal of the loan. Pesutto would also be required to commit to a long-term repayment plan, with the loan to initially carry a commercial interest rate of about 6%. His supporters believe the party may reap $1m in interest by the time the loan is repaid. The 19-member committee included Davis, federal frontbencher Dan Tehan, former party president Greg Mirabella, and the party's treasurer, Karyn Sobels, who is also one of Vapold's directors. The vote count is not yet known due to the secret ballot but several Liberal sources, who declined to be named given the sensitivity of discussions, said many committee members were strongly opposed to it before the meeting began. Details of the proposed loan were not shared with committee members known to be opposed to it before the meeting. Some members have argued party money should be saved for trying to win elections, not to settle internal disputes. Others argue the loan will be deeply unpopular with rank-and-file members who have made their opposition clear in emails. Battin refused to answer questions about the loan during a press conference before the meeting, repeating his previous comments that his conversations with Deeming and Pesutto would 'remain confidential'. Battin said he was hoping to move on from the saga, 'whatever the result', and was determined to focus on things that 'are important to Victorians'. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion 'I don't want to talk about it,' Battin said. 'Victorians don't want to talk about it. They want to talk about what's happening in crime. Victims [of crime] ... don't give two hoots what's happening inside the Liberal party. They care [that] someone came into their house with a knife or a gun to steal their car.' Last week, Deeming offered delayed payment of the $2.3m in legal costs on the condition her preselection was secured by the Liberal party, among other demands. The request was denied. Preselections for the upcoming 2026 state election are expected to begin later this year and Liberal party sources expect Deeming would face a challenge for the top spot of the western metropolitan ticket. Grugeon made a separate offer to Pesutto of a $1m, three-year loan, with monthly interest repayments, secured by his family home that is not in his name. Grugeon's offer also came with a condition that Pesutto not challenge for leadership of the Liberal party room during the loan period. If he did, Grugeon would immediately call in his debt. Pesutto declined the offer and told colleagues it was 'inappropriate to entertain it'. When contacted by Guardian Australia, Grugeon said he received legal advice before making the offer and that 'I have done nothing wrong'.
