logo
The Scientific Reason Why ChatGPT Leads You Down Rabbit Holes

The Scientific Reason Why ChatGPT Leads You Down Rabbit Holes

CNET3 hours ago

That chatbot is only telling you what you want to believe, according to a new study.
Whether you're using a traditional search engine like Google or a conversational tool like OpenAI's ChatGPT, you tend to use terms that reflect your biases and perceptions, according to the study, published this spring in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. More importantly, search engines and chatbots often provide results that reinforce those beliefs, even if your intent is to learn more about the topic.
For example, imagine you're trying to learn about the health effects of drinking coffee every day. If you, like me, enjoy having exactly two cups of joe first thing in the morning, you may search for something like "is coffee healthy?" or "health benefits of coffee." If you're already skeptical (maybe a tea purist), you might search for "is coffee bad for you?" instead. The researchers found that framing of questions could skew the results -- I'd mostly get answers that show the benefits of coffee, while you'd get the opposite.
"When people look up information, whether it's Google or ChatGPT, they actually use search terms that reflect what they already believe," Eugina Leung, an assistant professor at Tulane University and lead author of the study, told me.
The abundance of AI chatbots, and the confident and customized results they so freely give you, makes it easier to fall down a rabbit hole and harder to realize you're in it. There's never been a more important time to think deeply about how you get information online.
The question is: How do you get the best answers?
Asking the wrong questions
The researchers conducted 21 studies with nearly 10,000 participants who were asked to conduct searches on certain preselected topics, including the health effects of caffeine, gas prices, crime rates, COVID-19 and nuclear energy. The search engines and tools used included Google, ChatGPT and custom-designed search engines and AI chatbots.
The researchers' results showed that what they called the "narrow search effect" was a function of both how people asked questions and how the tech platforms responded. People have a habit, in essence, of asking the wrong questions (or asking questions in the wrong way). They tended to use search terms or AI prompts that demonstrated what they already thought, and search engines and chatbots designed to provide narrow, extremely relevant answers, delivered on those answers. "The answers end up basically just confirming what they believe in the first place," Leung said.
Read more: AI Essentials: 29 Ways to Make Gen AI Work for You, According to Our Experts
The researchers also checked to see if participants changed their beliefs after conducting a search. When served a narrow selection of answers that largely confirmed their beliefs, they were unlikely to see significant changes. But when the researchers provided a custom-built search engine and chatbot designed to offer a broader array of answers, they were more likely to change.
Leung said platforms could provide users with the option of a broader, less tailored search, which could prove helpful in situations where the user is trying to find a wider variety of sources. "Our research is not trying to suggest that search engines or algorithms should always broaden their search results," she said. "I do think there is a lot of value in providing very focused and very narrow search results in certain situations."
3 ways to ask the right questions
If you want a broader array of answers to your questions, there are some things you can do, Leung said.
Be precise: Think specifically about what exactly it is you're trying to learn. Leung used an example of trying to decide if you want to invest in a particular company's stock. Asking if it's a good stock or a bad stock to buy will likely skew your results -- more positive news if you ask if it's good, more negative news if you ask if it's bad. Instead, try a single, more neutral search term. Or ask both terms and evaluate the results of each.
Get other views: Especially with an AI chatbot, you can ask for a broad range of perspectives directly in the prompt. If you want to know if you should keep drinking two cups of coffee a day, ask the chatbot for a variety of opinions and the evidence behind them. The researchers tried this in one of their experiments and found they got more variety in results. "We asked ChatGPT to provide different perspectives to answer the query from the participants and to provide as much evidence to back up those claims as possible," Leung said.
At some point, stop asking: Follow-up questions didn't work quite as well, Leung said. If those questions aren't getting broader answers, you may get the opposite effect -- even more narrow, affirming results. In many cases, people who asked lots of follow-up questions just "fell deeper down into the rabbit hole," she said.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

iOS 26 Might Be Apple's Riskiest Redesign Yet
iOS 26 Might Be Apple's Riskiest Redesign Yet

Gizmodo

time30 minutes ago

  • Gizmodo

iOS 26 Might Be Apple's Riskiest Redesign Yet

It's official, Apple's big software redesign is here, and all of your devices are about to look a lot different. At WWDC 2025 Apple unveiled 'Liquid Glass,' which is its own Apple way of saying, 'Your iPhone is getting a lot more bubbly.' The big visual overhaul changes the look of the UI inside Apple devices across the board, including your iPhone, MacBook, Apple Watch, and even your Apple TV 4K streaming box. And while the full gamut of Apple products is affected by the visual vibe shift, it's iOS that will probably catch the most attention—and for good reason. For one, lots and lots of people use iPhones in America, and even the slightest tweak to the UI can affect people on a mass scale. Secondly, from what I can tell without seeing the redesign for myself, iOS seems to be the most heavily impacted by the new design. I mean, seriously, check this out: Today, we're announcing our most beautiful software design change yet with Liquid Glass. And for the very first time, it's coming to iOS 26, iPadOS 26, macOS 26, watchOS 26, and tvOS 26 at once! — Greg Joswiak (@gregjoz) June 9, 2025 While Apple doesn't state it explicitly, the redesign seems to be heavily influenced by what some designers might call 'glassmorphism,' which is a visual style in UI that incorporates lots of opaque menus and, unlike Apple's current flat 'neumorphic' design, adds a bit of shape to icons that were previously kind of 2D. See (ironically) other operating systems from, *cough, cough* Microsoft, if you want another example of what glassmorphism might manifest as. Someone more knowledgeable than I could probably nerd out over the new look with a few thousand words, but a design maven I am not. When I look at Liquid Glass, I see things in a simpler light. I see mostly one thing: risk. On one hand, that risk is exciting. I think Apple's UI is due for an update. By Apple's own estimation, the last visual overhaul was way back in iOS 7, when iPhones still had a physical home button and 'Obamacare' was still a topic of political discussion. Not only that, but Apple, for good reason, has been accused a lot in recent years of not attempting to push the boundaries like it once did under the leadership of Steve Jobs and Jony Ive. A good way to show people you're not afraid to try something new is to, well, try something new. That's exactly what Apple did; it took a risk on a redesign that changes some pretty core elements of your iPhone's UI—icons, menus, you name it. But just like any bold new endeavor, there are going to be some tradeoffs. One of those tradeoffs, in this case, may be accessibility. As many of you have already noted, there are some visual quirks to Apple's glassmorphic era, and legibility may be at stake. As much as I actually like the look aesthetically of Apple's new Liquid Glass overhaul, I think there are going to be some big haters, and I can't exactly blame them. Having clear windows may look future-forward, but when that design encounters, say, I don't know, text on a page, things can get a little messy. What you get, at times, is a visually muddled menu that conflicts with other elements on a page. I'm not jumping to any conclusions yet since I haven't really seen the redesign for myself or how it interacts with web pages or apps, but objectively, it seems like there isn't as much contrast as Apple's previous look. One thing I've definitely noticed so far is that subtle differences in where a menu lands in an app or web page can make a huge impact. For instance, check out this picture. apple just introduced "Liquid Glass" design in iOS. it's beautiful, futuristic… and completely unreadable. what are we doing here? 😵‍💫 — Kalash (@amikalash) June 9, 2025 I don't know about you, but what I see is a blurry, visual disaster. But, if you check out the video this screenshot is pulled from, just a second makes all the difference. Here's the same visual demonstration, but the menu is offset just slightly on the text underneath. I feel like there's a pretty big difference in legibility here. It's not perfect by any means, and I certainly wouldn't call it accessible, but it looks a lot better. This is all to say that I think there will be subtle differences that determine whether you're seeing something clear, pleasing, and visually distinct or if you're looking at a garbled glassmorphic mess. From what I can tell, there will also be different Liquid Glass styles to choose from, which may affect the accessibility of menus. There's also the fact that this redesign doesn't officially launch until the fall, so anything could change. How you feel about Liquid Glass is obviously up for debate, but one thing is clear (pun intended), and that's that whatever Apple is doing with the iOS redesign and Liquid Glass writ large is definitely a bigger risk than past overhauls. To risk accessibility or legibility on a platform as big as iOS takes some real vision—whether good or bad. Let's just hope that the vision, for the sake of everyone out there with an iPhone, isn't quite as blurry or illegible as some of these early looks might suggest.

Apple unveils iOS 26 with Liquid Glass interface at its Worldwide Developers Conference
Apple unveils iOS 26 with Liquid Glass interface at its Worldwide Developers Conference

CBS News

time33 minutes ago

  • CBS News

Apple unveils iOS 26 with Liquid Glass interface at its Worldwide Developers Conference

Apple kicked off its annual Worldwide Developers Conference on Monday with an array of announcements on new features coming this fall via iOS 26, its latest operating system upgrade. Leading the pack is a new user interface enhancement called Liquid Glass. CEO Tim Cook and other Apple executives used words like "beautiful," "gorgeous" and "delightful" to describe changes on the horizon for its devices. And while they emphasized a fresh user interface and elevated app features, they also reassured users that the tools would remain familiar and accessible. Read on for details on the latest bells and whistles coming to Apple's user interface. iOS 26, iPadOS 26, macOS Tahoe 26 Apple is adopting a new nomenclature for identifying its operating systems, one that is more straightforward than its previous numbering system. Rather than iOS 19, Apple's next iPhone iOS will be called iOS 26 to align with the upcoming year. iOS 26, along with iPadOS 26, macOS Tahoe 26, watchOS 26, and tvOS 261 are slated to be released as free updates in September 2025. Design upgrades, including Liquid Glass Alan Dye, Apple's vice president of human interface design, calls the new OS, the company's "broadest design update ever." A hallmark feature of the new OS is Liquid Glass, described by the company as an "expressive material" meant to mimic the qualities of glass. The dynamic new interface make apps, widgets and docs appear translucent, allowing users to see multiple layers of their screen at once. Liquid Glass also creates more movement on your interface by morphing into your display. For example, as messages pop up on your home screen, the time display starts to shrink to accommodate them. The color of Liquid Glass also shifts depending on the content on your screen and adapts between light and dark environments. "From navigating apps to system experiences like the lock screen notifications and control center app icons have been crafted with multiple layers of Liquid Glass and come to life in light mode, dark mode, colorful, new tints, or an all new clear look," said Dye during the company's keynote Monday. Apple Intelligence Apple also delivered long-awaited updates to Apple Intelligence, the company's artificial intelligence system that's now integrated with ChatGPT. AI-powered features arriving this fall include Live Translation, which automatically translates messages as they're being received. "So if you're making plans with some new friends while studying abroad, your message can be translated as you type and delivered in their preferred language, and when they respond, each text can be instantly translated for you," said Leslie Ikemoto, an engineering director at Apple said at the conference Monday. Visual Intelligence, another AI tool, allows users to take a screenshot of an image they see online — say, a cute sweater they come across on one of their apps — and then look up where to find a similar design online. They can also ask ChatGPT specific questions about the image, such as, keeping with the example of the sweater, "What material is this made of?" Another feature builds on Apple broad selection of emojis by giving users the power to combine and personalize existing emojis to create their own unique expressions. In their presentation, Apple showed how someone could merge the lightbulb emoji with the sloth emoji to indicate they were the last one to get a joke, for example. Still lingering on Apple's to do list is new AI integrations for Siri. Apple introduced updates to the voice assistant at last year's conference, but the full suite of upgrades for the voice assistant have yet to take effect. "We're continuing our work to deliver the features that make Siri even more personal," said senior vice president of software engineering Craig Federighi on Monday. "This work needed more time to reach our high quality bar, and we look forward to sharing more about it in the coming year." In a research note, Wedbush tech analyst Dan Ives noted that the Apple Intelligence rollout has been slower than expected, but also estimates that over the next few years, 25% of the world population will access AI through an Apple-powered device. "While many on [Wall] Street are heading into WWDC as underwhelming given the slower-than-expected rollout of Apple Intelligence, we disagree with this bearish narrative and strongly believe this will be the start of AI monetization period of the Apple ecosystem as the company will continue to lay the foundation through its new operating system updates across Mac, iOS, iPad and others with its '26" update,'" Ives said. contributed to this report.

Is There an Azstarys Shortage?
Is There an Azstarys Shortage?

Health Line

time37 minutes ago

  • Health Line

Is There an Azstarys Shortage?

Azstarys is a prescription drug used to treat ADHD. Some ADHD medications have recently been in short supply. Learn whether Azstarys is affected and how to check its availability. Azstarys is not currently listed in the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) drug shortages database. Here's what to know about why some ADHD medications may be hard to find and how to check for drug shortages. Is there a shortage of other ADHD drugs? In recent years, several ADHD medications have been in short supply. A few examples include Adderall, Concerta, Ritalin, and Vyvanse. It's not yet clear when these shortages will fully resolve. These shortages have affected both brand-name and generic versions of the drugs. As a result, some people have worked with their doctor to switch to a different medication or adjust their ADHD treatment plan. To check the current status of Aztarys and other ADHD medications, visit the FDA drug shortages website. How do ADHD drug shortages affect people? Shortages of ADHD medications can make it harder for people to stick with their treatment plan. This can cause ADHD symptoms to return or become more difficult to manage. A lack of consistent access to ADHD medication may also increase stress and affect mental health. Other possible effects of disrupted access to ADHD medication include: difficulty focusing or completing daily tasks increased impulsivity or emotional outbursts difficulty falling or staying asleep withdrawing from social, family, or work activities If you're having trouble filling a prescription for an ADHD medication, talk with your doctor or pharmacist. They may recommend alternatives or adjust your treatment plan based on what's available. What causes a drug shortage? Several factors can lead to a medication being in short supply. Common causes of ADHD drug shortages include: Increased demand: More people receiving diagnoses of ADHD have led to greater demand for medications. This can strain manufacturers and reduce availability at pharmacies. Regulatory limits: Stimulant medications used to treat ADHD, including Azstarys, are controlled substances. The Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) sets yearly production limits for these medications. If demand rises suddenly, these limits may contribute to shortages. Supply chain issues: Shortages of raw materials, packaging supplies, or labor can delay the manufacturing and availability of ADHD drugs. When multiple ADHD medications are in short supply at the same time, it can be especially hard for pharmacies to keep any option in stock. Even when generic forms are available, they may be affected by the same issues as brand-name drugs. As a result, generics may be just as difficult to find during a shortage. How can I check whether Azstarys is available near me? Azstarys is not currently listed by the FDA as being in shortage. However, some people may still experience delays when trying to fill their prescription. Availability can vary depending on your pharmacy, location, and insurance plan. If you're having trouble finding Azstarys, start by talking with a pharmacist. If possible, visit the pharmacy in person. Some pharmacies may not share inventory details for ADHD medications over the phone. You can also check pharmacy websites or apps, which sometimes offer tools to look up availability online. Keep in mind that availability may change as new shipments arrive. You can also check with your insurance provider. If Azstarys isn't available through your plan's preferred pharmacy, your insurer may be able to help you locate another pharmacy. In some cases, you may want to reach out to the drug manufacturer for information about availability in your area. To learn more about contacting the manufacturer, visit the Azstarys website.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store