Behind the composition of collegium picks
New Delhi On May 5, the Supreme Court of India published details of all 221 persons recommended for appointment as high court judges by the Supreme Court Collegium (SCC) between November 2022 and April 2025, of which 29 are pending approval from the government. For the first time, the Court officially disclosed the caste and religion of each person recommended, along with their relation to sitting or retired high court/Supreme Court judges. The data covers recommendations made under the tenure of two Chief Justices—Justice DY Chandrachud, who served from November 2022 to November 2024, and Justice Sanjiv Khanna, who took over in November 2024. Behind the composition of collegium picks
High court judges are appointed by the Supreme Court collegium, which includes the Chief Justice of India and two senior-most judges of the Supreme Court. During this period, the collegium led by justice Chandrachud approved 170 of 303 proposed candidates, while the collegium under justice Khanna approved 51 of 103. Proposals to the collegium are made by the high court collegium comprising the chief justice of the high court and two senior-most judges.
Of the total 221 recommendations, 167 (75.57%) are from the General (non-SC-ST-OBC) category. The number of appointees from Other Backward Classes (OBCs) stands at 39 (17.65%). The list has also given categories within OBCs such as MBC (most backward class), BC, BC-A, and BC-B. Eight recommendations (3.62%) are from the Scheduled Castes (SC), and seven (3.17%) are from the Scheduled Tribes (ST). 31 of the 221 recommendations (14%) were from a community which is a religious minority.
The data also shows the gender composition of recommendations. A total of 34 women were recommended for appointment as High Court judges—28 during justice Chandrachud's tenure and six under justice Khanna. Among the 34 women, 21 belong to the General category, 10 are from OBC communities, and three are from SC/ST groups. Five of the 34 women are from a minority religious community.
Under justice Chandrachud, 130 of 170 recommendations came from the General category, 28 from OBC, seven from SC, and five from ST. Under justice Khanna, 37 of 51 recommendations until April were from the General category, 11 from OBC, one from SC, and two from ST.
The High Courts of Allahabad and Gujarat each saw 21 recommendations, the highest among all courts. They were followed by the Bombay High Court, which had 19 new judges recommended during the same period.
Only 14 out of the 221 total recommendations (6.3%) were for people related to sitting or retired Supreme Court or High Court judges. Only one of these 14 recommendations is pending approval from the government. This is the recommendation for Rohit Kapoor, whose father-in-law (Amar Dutt Sharma) is a retired judge of the Punjab and Haryana high court.
Some family connections among those recommended stand out. Nupur Bhati, appointed to the Rajasthan High Court in January 2023, serves alongside her husband, who is also a judge in the same court. Deeptendra Narayan Roy, appointed to the Gujarat High Court in October 2024, is the son of former Supreme Court judge G.N. Ray, who served from 1991 to 1998. Bibhu Datta Guru, appointed to the Chhattisgarh High Court in August 2024, is the brother-in-law of sitting Supreme Court judge Prashant Mishra. Yogendra Kumar Purohit, a judge of the Rajasthan High Court, has two brothers-in-law who serve as judges in the same court.
To be sure, the number of recommendations of family members could possibly be higher if all family relations were included. The data uploaded on May 5 considers only eight kinds of relations: father, mother, brother, sister or their counterparts in the family of in-laws. No separate details for spouse were mentioned.
What makes the list released on Monday unique is the fact that it is the first effort at providing granular demographic data on recommendations of the Supreme Court collegium giving a clear picture of the social and institutional composition of these recommendations.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Israel is putting more women on the front line to help fix its manpower problem
GOLAN HEIGHTS—Days ago, an Israeli search-and-rescue team in Gaza spent hours drilling through concrete and plying aside rebar to recover the body of a fallen soldier buried under rubble in Khan Younis. The combat unit had been following a commando brigade in Gaza, recovering the bodies of dead soldiers on the battlefield. It is a routine task in the Israeli military, but it was unique that this team was made up mostly of women. 'A year and a half ago, I would never have dreamed of leading a combat team within Lebanon or Gaza," said a petite 25-year-old major. 'I think the war proved to all of us how much we are capable of." She is among a growing number of women serving on the front lines of Israel's military. Before the Hamas-led Oct. 7, 2023, attack that spurred the war, women were trained for combat, but left mostly to guard within Israel's borders or run checkpoints in the West Bank, considered less dangerous tasks. Now, they are entering the battlefield in Gaza, Lebanon and Syria in ways many previously thought impossible. Today, one in five combat soldiers is a woman, a ratio higher than many other modern Western militaries, experts say, and one which helps relieve Israel's acute manpower shortage after 20 months of war. Israel's military is made up largely of volunteer reservists, placing the burden of the war on regular working people, often with young families. Still, full equality in the military remains a challenge. The military last week cut short a pilot program to integrate women into Israel's main infantry units for 'expected low effectiveness," after finding that the 23 female trainees were suffering injuries and were 'not expected to meet the required standards of combat and physical fitness." The Israeli military has been pushing to recruit ultra-Orthodox Jewish men into its ranks as a solution to the manpower problem. The military and most of the country supports drafting ultra-Orthodox men, who are largely refusing to comply with a recent Supreme Court ruling that overturned their longstanding draft exemption. In light of this, integrating women eases pressure to free up men for other fighting roles. But with many of the military's core combat positions still closed to women or dominated by men, integrating women means it is only a partial solution to the manpower problem. Israel has for decades had one of the highest female representations among modern militaries, standing at about one-third overall, according to the military's most recently available data. It quickly drew on women ahead of its 1948 founding war out of a mix of socialist ideology, nationalism and necessity, experts say. Israel later scaled back women's roles until the 1990s, when Border Guard units opened their ranks to female fighters and a Supreme Court case forced the air force to recruit female pilots. Today, just over half of the military's combat roles are open to women, and 90% of overall roles. This high ratio of women in combat-designated roles is unusual for modern militaries. The U.S., although it has opened most military roles to women, still has a lower overall percentage of female forces at 18%, and therefore at the front lines. Israel is also one of the few countries that subjects women to a broad-based draft at age 18, just like men. Today, women represent 21% of Israel's combat-classed forces, jumping from 14% right ahead of the war and up from 7% a decade earlier, according to Israeli military data. The military said that it has about 4,500 female recruits in combat roles, driven by both an expansion in offerings to women and increased female demand to go into combat professions. 'There are three reasons militaries look to put women in combat roles: ideology, equality and necessity," said Jacob Stoil, chair of applied history at the Modern War Institute at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, who emphasized he was speaking from his personal research and not on behalf of the Army. 'You'll see women serving in combat roles when one of those three are the case," he said, adding that in Israel all three apply. The search-and-rescue unit that the young major belongs to is a mixed-gender fighting force specialized in excavating collapsed structures and evacuating the wounded. Ahead of the war, the unit was mostly relegated to West Bank security-keeping roles, also considered a less dangerous task. After Oct. 7, the unit was sent to the front lines in Gaza and embedded with commando units. When the war expanded to Lebanon, women were sent on front-line missions there too. The military plans to expand the unit by opening a new company in August. Since first being admitted in 2008, women have grown to fill about 70% of its combat roles, officers in the unit said. Women's conscription into combat units has long been a subject of debate in Israel. Some believe that the risk of torture or rape if captured puts women in a uniquely dangerous position. Others argue it hurts male morale, and that it creates additional challenges for some religious men who don't want to be in the same unit as a woman. Perceptions began to change after the Oct. 7 attack, when three all-female tank crews in the Caracal Battalion, meant to patrol Israel's border with Egypt but not enter enemy territory, raced through the desert to fight off Palestinian militants in and around Israeli communities under siege. Israel's military said that it has about 4,500 female recruits in combat roles. The Israeli military's then-chief-of-staff Herzi Halevi took notice at the time, saying that their 'action and fighting" against Hamas on Oct. 7 answers critics of women's integration into fighting forces. The search-and-rescue unit's base in Zikim also came under attack, and seven soldiers died fending off militants. Among the rescuers sent to recapture and secure the base was a 21-year-old lieutenant. She and other relief forces held off militants for two days before tanks arrived to back them up, she said. Shortly thereafter, she was attached to Israel's equivalent to the Navy SEALs as part of the initial phase of Israel's ground invasion, helping them hunt for underground tunnels in Gaza. She doesn't think she would ever have been given such an opportunity before Oct. 7. 'I think that they just realized how powerful we are," she said. 'They realized we can actually do it."
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Punjab govt working for wellbeing of underprivileged sections, says CM Mann at loan waiver event
Amritsar, Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann on Sunday said his government is working untiringly for the wellbeing of the state's weaker and underprivileged sections. Addressing a gathering after handing over loan waiver certificates to the beneficiaries here, Mann said the previous governments in the state waived loans of the affluent people but didn't bother about the welfare of the poor. 'For the first time in the history of Punjab, this reprieve is being extended to the underprivileged and weaker sections of society,' Mann said. The loan waiver scheme worth ₹67.84 crore has benefited around 4,800 families of loanees of the Punjab Scheduled Castes Land Development and Finance Corporation , the chief minister said. On June 3, the Punjab Cabinet gave its nod to waive loans amounting to ₹67.84 crore taken by over 4,000 Dalit families from the PSCFC. Mann said the waiver covers all loans disbursed by the PSCFC up to March 31, 2020, offering significant relief to SC and Divyangjan loanees. The move will benefit 4,727 loanees for an aggregate amount of ₹67.84 crore. The scheme will cover all the loanees, including 4,685 defaulting loanees and 42 regular loanees, government sources said. Addressing the gathering, Mann said 'no due certificates' will be issued by the state government and the full amount of ₹67.84 crore comprising principal, interest and penal interest calculated as of April 30, 2025, will be reimbursed to the PSCFC by the state government. The loanees who previously availed benefits under the earlier waiver schemes are also eligible for coverage under this initiative, Mann said. No recovery proceedings will be initiated against the loanees and their accounts will be considered fully settled as of the cut-off date, he added. According to the 2011 Census, Scheduled Castes constitute 31.94 per cent of Punjab's total population and many members of this community have availed loans from the PSCFC to set up self-employment ventures aimed at economic upliftment. However, Mann said some borrowers were unable to repay their loans due to circumstances beyond their control, leading to defaults. These families could not repay their loans due to circumstances such as demise of the main earning member, prolonged illness, or having no other source of income, etc. Recovering these loans from such people was unjust, so the state government has decided to waive them, the chief minister said.
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Deadline for Karnataka SC survey extended to June 22 due to poor response in Bengaluru
Due to a lack of strong participation within Bengaluru city limits for the ongoing survey of Scheduled Caste (SC) communities in Karnataka, the government has extended the survey deadline to June 22. This is the third extension granted since the survey was launched on May 5. The purpose of the survey is to determine the exact population numbers of 101 castes classified under the Scheduled Caste category in the state, which will then be used to provide internal reservations for these communities. Compared to other districts in Karnataka, where nearly 100 per cent of the SC population was surveyed, only 46 per cent of the SC population in Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) limits participated in the survey, according to details shared by the one-man commission under Justice Nagamohan Das. The estimated SC population in Karnataka for 2025 is approximately 1.16 crore, which constitutes about 12 per cent of the total community population. In Bengaluru alone, there are around 13.62 lakh SC people. However, only 6.29 lakh of them participated in the survey, Across the entire state, there is a 90 per cent progress in the survey, as 1.05 crore of the 1.16 crore people from the SC community have taken part in the survey, according to the commission. While May 19 was set as the last date for the door-to-door survey when it was launched on May 5, it was extended till the end of May due to poor response in urban areas. Due to this, several groups from SC communities petitioned the commission to extend the last date of the survey further. The commission is facing another problem as the teachers roped in to carry out the exercise were relieved after the academic year began in the first week of June. Until June 22, SC families can register themselves at Scheduled Caste Survey Karntaka Website or visit Karnataka One, Bengaluru One, or BBMP ward offices to enrol in the exercise. The survey is being carried out based on the recommendations of the one-man panel, which found that there is no empirical data on the population of various castes within SC communities, without which internal reservation cannot be provided. The SCs are classified into four categories in the state: SC left, SC right, touchable communities and others.
