Relatives of Venezuelan detainees in CECOT find comfort in support group, with no release in sight
On May 18, relatives of the Venezuelan migrant detainees in El Salvador's mega prison CECOT, announced to a WhatsApp group the death of Marlene Ramirez, a grandmother who raised one of the men currently detained there, Jonathan Mendoza Ramirez. Her family said she had died of a heart attack, unable to endure the emotional stress of not being able to communicate with her grandson. She could no longer take it, they said.
Since the Trump administration in March removed a group of Venezuelan migrants alleged to be gang members to El Salvador for indefinite detention, a WhatsApp virtual community has come into being, made up largely of mothers of the detainees. The group grew one by one, as the mothers found out about their sons' whereabouts, largely from videos posted on social media by the president of El Salvador, Nayib Bukele. The videos showed the Venezuelan men arriving from the U.S. in shackles, being frog-marched off the plane and into CECOT. Inside the prison, they were forced to kneel as their heads were shaved by guards.
"I can't recount these videos or else I fall into a serious depression," said Jetzy Arteaga, the creator of the WhatsApp group. Her son, Carlos Cañizalez Arteaga, is one of the Venezuelan migrants transferred to CECOT in March. "I try to block them, so that I can go on about my day, but only a mother in this situation can understand why these images hurt so much." On days when she can't keep the images out of her thoughts, Arteaga says she can't get out of bed and turns to other mothers in the group chat.
"When one of us is down, we go to their house, run their errands and pick up their other kids from school," says Arteaga. "They're all over Venezuela, and I understand that today, it might be them needing help, but tomorrow it might be me in the hospital."
Jetzy Arteaga, creator of a Whatsapp support group for mothers whose sons are being held in CECOT, a maximum security prison in El Salvador. Her son, Carlos Cañizalez Arteaga, standing behind her, is being held at CECOT.
Photo provided by Jetzy Arteaga
Arteaga created the group to communicate with other mothers because she says she needed answers. "I was in a state of disbelief, and I was waiting for the U.S. government to say my son was transferred by mistake," said Arteaga. "The U.S. is a country that follows their laws, and when their investigation concludes my son is not a gang member, they'll release him."
Records that prove his lack of criminal gang activity in Venezuela, however, have not led to Carlos' release. The group says it has grown and now includes relatives of 170 of the migrant men detained in El Salvador.
"The first thing I do every morning is check the group chat, and we ask for updates and prayers," said Analia Burbano, whose nephew Victor Andres Ortega Burbano, is being held in CECOT. She says she constantly scrolls through social media to see if there are any updates or photos of her nephew in prison.
Undated photo of Analia Burbano with her nephew, Victor Andres Ortega Burbano, who is being detained in CECOT, in El Salvador.
Photo provided by Analia Burbno
Burbano says she is now speaking on behalf of her nephew because his mother is emotionally and physically unable to do so. "Ever since she saw the video of Victor at CECOT, she fell into a depression, does not get up from bed, does not eat and cries every day," said Burbano. "She is very frail."
Burbano says her nephew's arrest and transfer came as a surprise, since Ortega had been granted Temporary Protected Status that allowed him to legally work in the U.S. According to immigration documents reviewed by CBS News, Ortega's TPS was approved for June 2024 through last month, in April.
The group frequently makes trips to Miramar, Venezuela, to pressure officials to demand the release and deportation of the men back to their country. The chat serves as a venue to plan the next protest or opportunity to publicize the men's plight at events like those held by the United Nations.
"We all have our ups and downs, but through this process, we make sure that none of us let the negative thoughts linger for long," said Anyi Yohana Casares Jimenez, mother of Jason Alfredo Silva Casares. On March 13, Jimenez says she received the last call from her son, desperately asking her to send over documents proving he didn't have a criminal record in Venezuela. She never heard from him again.
Jason showed up at the U.S. southern border in August 2024 after receiving an appointment through the CBP One app, but remained in detention because immigration agents were suspicious of his crown tattoo, according to his mother. "There's not a day that I don't search social media for any new videos of him inside CECOT."
The three mothers all claim their sons are not part of Venezuela's Tren de Aragua gang, but they do fault the men's tattoos for causing their imprisonment.
"It was the argument I always had with my son," said Arteaga. "I always asked what his need for a tattoo was." Her son tattooed his mother's name "Jetzy" on his wrist, a tattoo that now serves as evidence of gang affiliation, according to court documents.
It's now been more than two months since these men were taken to El Salvador and the U.S. government continues to deport anyone who is in the country illegally after President Trump promised to deport "the worst of the worst".
"All we can do is trust that this nightmare will soon end," said Burbano.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
an hour ago
- The Hill
State Dept. sued over Trump deal to house migrants in El Salvador prison
A coalition of democracy groups sued the State Department Thursday, challenging the Trump administration's agreement with the government of El Salvador to house more than 200 migrants deported to a notorious prison. The groups, represented by the left-leaning legal organization Democracy Forward, said the government took 'unprecedented action' to transport migrants living in the United States 'beyond the reach of U.S. law.' El Salvador is reportedly being paid some $15 million by the Trump administration to house migrants in the country. The lawsuit marks the first legal challenge to the deal between Trump and Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele. 'That action shocks the conscience,' Democracy Forward lawyer Jessica Anne Morton said in the complaint. 'It also violates the law.' The suit cites the extreme conditions within the CECOT mega prison, known by its acronym in Spanish, where prisoners sleep in crowded cells with bunks three levels high, and are not allowed to go outside or have visitors of any kind. 'Executive branch leaders have stated that the government plans to continue availing itself of the Agreement, sending more people, including potentially U.S. citizens, to indefinite detention in what is an effective black site,' Morton wrote. The challengers alleged that the State Department's actions bypass federal immigration law and international treaties while violating constitutional rights to due process, legal counsel and protection against cruel and unusual punishment. They say the Administrative Procedure Act requires agency actions, like the agreement, to be 'both reasonable and reasonably explained.' 'The Agreement is neither,' the complaint reads. During a trip to El Salvador to visit the mistakenly deported Kilmar Abrego Garcia, Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) was told financial considerations were at play as they kept the man locked away. Van Hollen had pressed Salvadoran Vice President Félix Ulloa about why Abrego Garcia was being imprisoned when he had no criminal history in either country. 'His answer was that the Trump administration is paying the government of El Salvador to keep him at CECOT,' Van Hollen said during an April trip to the Central American country. Numerous migrants have challenged Trump's plans to deport them to El Salvador, including under the Alien Enemies Act, but the suit is the first to challenge the agreement between the two countries. Five groups brought the lawsuit: Robert F. Kennedy Human Rights, the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL), Immigrant Defenders Law Center, Immigration Equality and California Collaborative for Immigrant Justice. Skye Perryman, Democracy Forward's president and CEO, called the practice 'unAmerican' in a statement. 'Our lawsuit makes clear: No president—past or present—can buy their way out of the Constitution to disappear people behind a paywall of impunity,' she said.
Bloomberg
2 hours ago
- Bloomberg
Trump Faces New Lawsuit Over Migrants Sent to Salvadoran Prison
The Trump administration is facing a new legal challenge to its arrangement with El Salvador to send migrants — and potentially US citizens — to a mega-prison infamous for its dangerous and unsanitary conditions. The case, filed in federal court in Washington, is the first to directly target the State Department's agreement to pay millions of dollars to house people arrested in the United States in El Salvador's prison system, including the Centro de Confinamiento del Terrorismo, known as CECOT.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Judge cites Kafka in giving Venezuelans held in El Salvador chance to challenge removal
When a judge starts a lengthy ruling by quoting from Franz Kafka's 'The Trial,' a novel associated with an absurd legal ordeal, that could be a bad sign for the government. And so it was, in the 69-page opinion Wednesday from U.S. District Judge James Boasberg. It marked a step toward righting the Trump administration's wrong of sending scores of Venezuelan immigrants to a notorious Salvadoran prison without due process. While citing what he called the administration's 'troubling conduct throughout this case,' Boasberg said U.S. officials must facilitate the ability of a class of at least 137 plaintiffs, held in El Salvador's Center for Terrorism Confinement (CECOT), to seek habeas corpus relief, so that they can challenge their removal under the Alien Enemies Act. They didn't get due process when the government summarily sent them to that foreign prison in March, so they need to get it now. The chief federal judge in Washington, D.C., left open how exactly that will happen, giving the government a week to tell him how it plans to carry out his directive. President Donald Trump's invocation of the 1798 act, whose factual and legal bases for deporting alleged Venezuelan gang members have been called into great doubt, still hasn't been resolved by the Supreme Court. Boasberg didn't seek to resolve that underlying issue Wednesday, instead focusing on the fact that the men didn't even get a chance to challenge their removal. 'Perhaps the President lawfully invoked the Alien Enemies Act. Perhaps, moreover, [government] Defendants are correct that Plaintiffs are gang members. But — and this is the critical point — there is simply no way to know for sure, as the CECOT Plaintiffs never had any opportunity to challenge the Government's say-so,' he wrote. 'In our nation — unlike the one into which K. awakes — the Government's mere promise that there has been no mistake does not suffice,' the Obama appointee wrote, referring to Kafka's protagonist. The judge said the government 'plainly deprived these individuals of their right to seek habeas relief before their summary removal from the United States.' He added that while the litigation still needs to fully play out, 'significant evidence has come to light indicating that many of those currently entombed in CECOT have no connection to the gang and thus languish in a foreign prison on flimsy, even frivolous, accusations.' Separate litigation is pending over Boasberg's inquiry into possible contempt for the government violating his previous order in March to halt deportation flights. Boasberg's latest ruling comes as the administration resists facilitating the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, as ordered by another judge — whose order the Supreme Court endorsed — in separate ongoing litigation. The Salvadoran native was also illegally deported to that country, but not under the Alien Enemies Act. In yet another case of a wrongly deported person under this administration, the government on Wednesday managed to return a Guatemalan man referred to as O.C.G. in court papers; his case was litigated separately from both the Abrego Garcia case and the Alien Enemies Act cases. U.S. immigration agents sent him to Mexico, initially claiming he said he wasn't fearful of going to that country, but then admitting that they didn't have a witness who could back up that claim. So the administration knows it can remedy a wrongful removal. But given that the CECOT plaintiffs, like Abrego Garcia and unlike O.C.G., are being held by a foreign government, don't expect the government to go along with Boasberg's order before exhausting all appellate options — including up to the Supreme Court, though even the justices have reminded the administration of the need to comply with due process. We should know the government's stance at least within a week, when its notice is due to Boasberg by June 11 on how it intends to facilitate the ability of the CECOT plaintiffs to seek habeas relief, unless the administration seeks a more immediate appeal of Boasberg's order. Separately, the administration has a pending emergency application to the Supreme Court, seeking the ability to more speedily deport people to so-called third countries where they aren't from, in litigation stemming from the government's bid to send immigrants to war-torn South Sudan. An order from the justices in that case could come anytime. Subscribe to the Deadline: Legal Newsletter for expert analysis on the top legal stories of the week, including updates from the Supreme Court and developments in the Trump administration's legal cases. This article was originally published on
