VAR should not get involved in penalty decision
Everton manager David Moyes said the video assistant referee should not have intervened after a late penalty decision in his team's favour against Manchester United was overturned.The sides contested a thrilling 2-2 draw on Saturday, but the Toffees thought they had a golden chance to win it in injury time when referee Andrew Madley awarded a penalty after Ashley Young went down in the box.There appeared to be a shirt pull by United defender Matthijs de Ligt, with Harry Maguire also in close proximity.But after being told to review the incident on the pitchside monitor, Madley decided to change his original decision.Moyes said: "If it's absolutely clear and obvious he should go to the screen, but I didn't see that - he pulled his jersey."I thought the referee made the correct decision at the time and he should have stuck with it."I think for everybody who watches football we are all looking forward to a referee saying 'no I am sticking to what I have done'. They are being told they are absolutely wrong."We have seen very few say 'it is a penalty kick'. If it was absolutely clear and obvious and it is wrong, then that is what we have got VAR for."
What happened?
The scoreline was level and with five minutes added on both sides were aiming to secure victory late on in an enthralling contest.In the 94th minute, Idrissa Gueye's thumping drive was pushed back into the danger area by Amadou Onana and a combination of Maguire and De Ligt appeared to bring down Young.Replays showed there was clearly a touch on the veteran full-back, but was there enough contact to send him tumbling to the turf?The Premier League Match Centre said:, external "VAR checked the referee's call of penalty to Everton for a challenge by Maguire on Young and deemed that no foul had been committed and recommended an on-field review."The referee overturned the original decision and play restarted with a drop ball."Asked about the Premier League's explanation, Moyes said: "So did they look at the shirt pull? So they only mentioned the bit they needed to and not the shirt pull? It looked to me as though the shirt pull was enough."I am not an expert on VAR, I can only tell you what I have seen. You shouldn't be getting away with pulling jerseys. From the touchline I thought he had gone over somebody's leg."United manager Ruben Amorim added: "I think it was a soft touch from what I saw. I think it was a soft penalty, it was clear."Everton fans were left irate by the decision and loudly jeered Madley when he went down the tunnel at full-time.
'Enough of a tug' or 'soft'? Pundits are split
Everton had gone two up in the first half courtesy of goals from Beto and Abdoulaye Doucoure, but United hit back in the second period through Bruno Fernandes' delightful free-kick and Manuel Ugarte's first goal for the Red Devils.There was edge-of-the-seat drama late on when it appeared like Everton had the chance to win it from the spot, but that opportunity was snatched away, and a real split emerged between the broadcast pundits on whether a penalty should have been confirmed.Former Everton winger Theo Walcott said on BBC Radio 5 Live: "I totally agree with the referee, I don't think that was a penalty. Naturally [when you are challenged] you don't fall that way."Former Manchester United defender Phil Jones added on BBC Radio 5 Live: "It is very, very soft, but Maguire does get a tug of the shirt on Young. He has made a mess of it."Former Manchester United defender Rio Ferdinand said on TNT: "I was fearing the worst when VAR got involved. I was surprised it wasn't given. The contact is there. When you put your hands on someone you give the referee a decision."Former Scotland striker Ally McCoist said on TNT: "You know something, I can see why he's not given it, but I would have given it. I think there's enough of a tug on him [Ashley Young]."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
19 minutes ago
- Wales Online
Swansea City in dialogue with Nottingham Forest over O'Brien as chief clears up transfer links
Swansea City in dialogue with Nottingham Forest over O'Brien as chief clears up transfer links Swansea haven't given up hope of a reunion next season and director of football Richard Montague has now confirmed the latest Lewis O'Brien did well at Swansea City (Image:) Swansea City's director of football Richard Montague insists the door hasn't yet been closed on a possible return for Lewis O'Brien this summer. The midfielder spent a hugely successful six-month loan spell with the Swans last season, starting all 16 games for the club after arriving in January and producing a string of eye-catching performances in the process. The 26-year-old has one year left on his current contract at Nottingham Forest, and the prospect of him breaking into their first-team plans appear slim, despite his exploits for the Swans. Sign up to the Swansea City WhatsApp service to get breaking news and top stories sent to your phone A host of Championship clubs have taken an interest, while Spanish giants Valencia are also understood to be admirers of the midfielder, but his next move remains shrouded in uncertainty. O'Brien is understood to have enjoyed his time in south Wales, and has similarly enjoyed a good relationship with head coach Alan Sheehan. Finances have already been mentioned as a key stumbling block were Swansea to show an interest in bringing him back, but Montague says the door is by no means closed on a possible reunion, adding that the club have already held discussions with his parent club. Article continues below "We have had good conversations with Forest," he added. "They were really good to deal with last season, they sent us a really nice message to thank us for how well Lewis did with us, which was great to receive. "We have a good dialogue with them. The ball is a little bit in their court at the moment because of Lewis' contract situation. He is on a Premier League salary and there needs to be some give in some sense to make it work for us. "But it's definitely an option that's still on the table. "We are talking to Lewis and having good conversations with Forest. We would love to be able to do something. It's just timing and matching it all up with the financial realities." Central midfield is an area the club are targeting in this window, although it seems they are not pursuing a deal for Lincoln City's Ethan Erhahon. Swansea had a bid for the 24-year-old knocked back earlier this month, and club insiders at the time indicated the Swans had ended their interest and moved on to other targets. Reports elsewhere later claimed the Swans were still circling for the Scotland under-21s international. However, those suggestions appear to be wide of the mark for now. 'We have talked about so many players and quite a lot have got to the point where we have spoken to agents or clubs," Montague continued. 'There isn't anything concrete in that one. I am happy to say he has been a player who has been lists but it's not progressing any further at this stage.' In terms of possible interest in their own players, Montague says there hasn't been any approach for midfield pair Goncalo Franco and Jay Fulton, both of whom have been the subject of speculation recently. Franco is understood to have caught the eye of clubs in England, Germany and Portugal, while Fulton has recently been linked with a move to Plymouth Argyle. 'Jay did unbelievably well for us when he came into the team at the back end of the season," Montague said. "He gave us some great minutes and is an unbelievable character. 'He is a senior player, which is probably lacking a bit in that age profile now with some of the key departures we had. 'Jay is an important player for us and there is no news about any offers or movement with Jay.' On Franco, he added: "I am aware of gossip and rumours. There is so much noise around this time of the year which is understandable because need things to write about. 'But until we have anything concrete, there is nothing for me to say about it. Sign up to our Swansea City newsletter here. 'He has obviously had a brilliant season and we would love to keep him here, so let's hope that's how it stays.' As well as central midfield, a centre-back is believed to be near the top of the summer wishlist - even if out-of-contract start Harry Darling decides to commit his future the club. Article continues below Swansea are already set to complete the signing of former Bolton Wanderers captain Ricardo Santos, but are actively look at further options, with Ben Cabango currently the only recognised senior centre-back on the books right now. They are also understood to have cast an eye over FC Sion's Gora Diouf in recent months, but he now doesn't appear to be a serious target as things stand.
BBC News
19 minutes ago
- BBC News
Kelly signs for Juventus after loan
Lloyd Kelly has made the permanent switch to Juventus following a short loan spell with the Serie A former England Under-21 defender signed for the Magpies on a free transfer in June 2024 after his contract with Bournemouth he joined Juve on loan in February after making just 10 Premier League appearances. The Italian giants had an obligation to buy for £ say they are still in discussions with striker Callum Wilson and third-choice goalkeeper John Ruddy, who are set to be out of contract later this Jamal Lewis - signed from Norwich City in a deal worth up to £20m in 2020 - is leaving the club.
Reuters
27 minutes ago
- Reuters
Manchester United boost profit forecast after Europa League run lifts ticket sales
June 6 (Reuters) - Manchester United (MANU.N), opens new tab raised their annual core profit forecast on Friday as the club's strong performance in the Europa League drove ticket sales and broadcast revenue. United forecast adjusted core profit of between 180 million pounds ($244 million) and 190 million pounds for the year ending June, up from an earlier projection of between 145 million and 160 million pounds. Ticket sales jumped more than 50% to 44.5 million pounds in the three months to March as the club had a good run in the Europa League, before losing the finals to Tottenham Hotspur. United had their worst Premier League season since they were relegated in 1974 and hopes of participating in a European competition next season were dashed after they lost the Europa League final. "We had a difficult season in the Premier League, which we all know fell below our standards and we have a clear expectation of improvement next season," CEO Omar Berrada said in a statement. United's absence from European competitions, which are lucrative sources of broadcasting revenue, deals a huge blow to the club's future finances and has drawn anger and disappointment from fans worldwide. Jim Ratcliffe, who holds a stake of about 29% in the club and runs their football operations, has taken steps to revive the club's fortunes, including by cutting jobs, raising ticket prices and stopping free lunches at staff canteens. Those benefits are expected to be realised from the first quarter of the new fiscal year starting July, the club said on Friday. United reported a net loss of 2.7 million pounds for the three months ended March 31, compared with a loss of 71.5 million pounds a year earlier. ($1 = 0.7383 pounds)
