Man (36) who murdered partner after beating her 'beyond recognition' jailed for at least 19 years
A man who was repeatedly violent to his partner before killing her has been jailed for a minimum of 19 years.
Natasha Melendez, aged 32 and formerly from Venezuela, was attacked at her home in Lisburn, Co Antrim, on March 22nd, 2020, and died from her injuries on April 1st of the same year.
Advertisement
John David Scott (36), with an address listed as Maghaberry Prison, was sentenced at Belfast Crown Court on Friday having earlier entered a plea of guilty to her murder.
The court heard she had been beaten 'beyond recognition' and had died after a 'devastating stroke' which was the result of damage to a major artery supplying blood to her brain.
Prior to her death, Ms Melendez had expressed a fear that Scott, the father of one of her four children, would kill her.
The sentencing hearing was observed via video link by her mother Maria Mejias in Florida as well as other relatives.
Advertisement
Mr Justice O'Hara said the murder of Ms Melendez was the end result of Scott's 'repeated violence against her'.
Scott also pleaded guilty to the charges of grievous bodily harm with intent, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, and common assault against Ms Melendez.
These charges span a period between December 1st, 2019, and March 2020.
The court was told they included an 'exceptionally violent' incident in which Scott threw a vacuum at the victim, and also jumped hard and repeatedly on her prone body while holding on to a headboard, resulting in broken ribs and facial swelling.
Advertisement
In a separate incident, Scott was said to have attacked Ms Melendez while she was in a car before she got out and escaped to an off-licence.
The court heard staff at the premises reported that she asked them not to contact police as she was afraid he would kill her.
The judge said: 'Guess what, she turned out to be right.'
The prosecution said it was a domestic violence case, involving gratuitous violence with extensive and multiple injuries on a vulnerable victim before her death.
Advertisement
It said the murder was the accumulation of cruel and violent behaviour over a period of time.
The judge said the only mitigating factors he could recognise were 'some signs of remorse' as well as the 'horrible childhood' Scott had endured which led to addiction and mental health problems.
However he said personal circumstances carry less weight in murder cases.
The judge said he did not regard the case as 'anywhere near the borderline between murder and manslaughter'.
Advertisement
Mr Justice O'Hara said Ms Melendez was a 'particularly vulnerable young woman', adding that Scott had acknowledged a disparity in their sizes.
'In addition to that, she was a drug addict who he beat up again and again and again until he killed her.'
The judge said that while Scott had said he had suffered injuries, there was no evidence that he had been injured by her hands to any degree of note.
He said the evidence showed that when he attacked her, he inflicted extensive and multiple injuries on her before the final assault.
The judge accepted the murder was not premeditated but added that it was a foreseeable end result of how he had treated her.
He said: 'What on earth did he think might happen to her if he beat her up again and again and again and again?
'She begged the staff in the off-licence not to call the police because she was afraid he would kill her, and that is exactly what he did.'
The judge said he had received 'exceptionally moving' victim impact statements from Ms Melendez's mother, two of her aunts, and one of her children.
He said her mother found it impossible to put into words the 'suffering the cruel murder has caused' and that her grandchildren had struggled to find peace.
Ms Melendez's teenage son said he was made fun of and bullied when his mother's murder was reported.
He said: 'I will never know if my mum would have been able to get better and I could have spent more time with her.
'I had to start secondary school without my mum knowing, and I think of all the big things in my life she will miss out on.
'I just feel like my life will never be the same without her and every birthday I see as a constant reminder of her.'
Reading a pre-sentence report from the probation service, the judge said Scott had expressed that Ms Menendez did not deserve what happened to her and said: 'I genuinely loved her to bits.
'I want forgiveness I need to do right by her. That's why I pleaded guilty. I took her from her family and kids.'
In arriving at the length of the sentence, the judge was asked to take note of delays in proceedings due to the 'unusual' impact of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Scott was initially arrested on March 26th, 2020, but was not interviewed until January 2022.
In the middle of that 22-month period, he was also in custody in relation to assault of police officers.
In effect, the court heard that he was in custody for the matters relating to Ms Melendez alone for approximately 12.5 months – but the exact time would be worked out at a later stage.
Announcing his decision, the judge put a provision that that period would be taken off the sentence – as there would be no administrative way for the prison service to declare that as a period of remand.
It was not open to the judge to implement consecutive sentences for the other offences to which Scott pleaded guilty, but he was able to use them as an aggravating factor in arriving at the final tariff.
Scott was given a life sentence with a minimum tariff of 19 years before his release can be considered.
The judge said this would be reduced at a later date to account for the time he spent in custody in relation to the matters during the pandemic, when a final determination on the exact number of days had been made.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
35 minutes ago
- BBC News
Daughter of Benidorm attack victim in plea for answers
The daughter of a British man who died after being attacked by a stranger in a Spanish resort city in 2018 has renewed her call for information to help find his killer. Mike Rydings, 48, from Wythenshawe in Manchester, was celebrating a friend's 50th birthday and watching the World Cup at a bar in Benidorm when he was set upon in the early hours of 23 June. His daughter Hayley Barker said witnesses saw him backing away "with his hands up" before he was punched in the face, leaving him with a broken nose and serious head injures after falling on to the concrete. Mr Rydings was treated in a Spanish hospital before being moved to Salford Royal, but died 14 months later. Ms Barker said an investigation by both Spanish and Greater Manchester Police (GMP) had failed to find identify the attacker, despite GMP interviewing a range of British holidaymakers who were at the Hippodrome Bar at the time. "It makes me feel angry," she told BBC Radio Manchester. "My dad was stolen from me in such cruel circumstances, whoever has done this still gets to live their life."We can't move forward as such because we don't have justice." She called for anyone who may have new information that could help to contact GMP. "It would mean the world - we'd actually get some answers, it's what we deserve as a family," Ms Barker said. GMP said while the investigation was the responsibility of Spanish authorities, they were ready to assist if required. She said her father was 5ft 10ins (1.55m), had a stocky build and was wearing a red Hugo Boss t-shirt and glasses at the time of the attack. While Ms Barker said she had great memories of her dad being "the life and soul of the party" before his attack, her children had no memory of him. She said she was pregnant with her first child, a daughter, when Mr Rydings was attacked. "He never even got to hold her because of the condition he was left in before he passed away," she said. "In 2022 I had a son who would have been his only grandson, so that was very sad." Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
BBC News
35 minutes ago
- BBC News
'Women are dying while domestic murder reviews plod along'
"There are women dying while these reviews are plodding along."Poppy Devey Waterhouse was 24-years-old when she was murdered by her ex-boyfriend Joe was described by her family as "a bright button" who loved to travel and who was excited about the next chapter of her instead, this was "cruelly and senselessly cut short", when Atkinson failed to come to terms with the end of their three-year repeatedly stabbed Poppy in a rage at their flat in Leeds in 2018 using a kitchen knife that left her with more than 100 has taken more than five years for a Domestic Homicide Review (DHR) to be completed to find out whether lessons could be learnt from Poppy's has been a process which her mother, Julie Devey, from Frome in Somerset, describes as "excruciating"."You have no idea it's going to be like that," she said."You get the review and you read it and as I turned the pages, I couldn't understand it, it wasn't Poppy's voice, it was his voice, it was all about him." The review into Poppy's death was published by the Home Office in May - more than five years and eight versions said that the final report was "vastly different" to how the first one was written."We are very happy with how its written [now]," she added."He [Atkinson] is represented in it, but it's not 'poor me, poor me'. There are a few recommendations, but they were small things."Atkinson, 25, who admitted Poppy's murder, was jailed in 2019 for a minimum of 15 years and 310 Poppy's death, a DHR was commissioned by Safer Leeds, a safety partnership made up of local organisations including the council, police and health care found Poppy's death was neither predictable or review recommended raising awareness of domestic abuse and delivering a public or education focused campaign on the risks that might be present during the separation of a relationship. This would include recognising what could be considered obsessive, controlling and stalking behaviour. If you are affected by any of the issues raised in this story, support and advice is available via BBC Action Line. Every domestic killing or suicide involving people aged 16 and over in England and Wales is subject to a DHR, recently renamed as a domestic abuse-related death review (DARDR).They examine the role of professionals who had contact with the victim or the perpetrator before an attack, but do not issue Office guidance states the reviews, which make recommendations to help prevent other people being killed by partners or family members, should be finished within six BBC research has revealed just 1% of reviews into domestic abuse-related deaths in England and Wales are being completed in the recommended time, with most taking years. But for Julie, it was not only delays that made the review process difficult."There were endless examples of language used [in the report] that took away the responsibility from his decision making," she said."It was arduous, you'd send it back with recommended changes and then it would come back, and you'd have to do it all over again."Poppy needed to be the centre of this review - as her mum I had to represent her."Despite this, Julie - who has also been campaigning for tougher sentences for those who commit domestic murders - believes DHRs are important as it has provided the family with a thorough picture of the last few months before Poppy died."But the length of time they are taking is excruciating," she added."The idea is to find out if the death was preventable or predictable, and to come up with recommendations to save other lives."There are women dying while these are plodding along."A Leeds City Council spokesperson said Safer Leeds has been improving the review processes and expressed its "apologies for the delays in completing this review"."Unfortunately, the process involved does not lend itself to completion within six months with reviews often having to be paused. There are a number of factors that can cause a delay to a report, including coronial or judicial processes and we recognise that this does add to a family's trauma," they said. Julie is one of a number of bereaved families that the BBC has spoken to who have criticised the length of time the reviews Jane Monckton-Smith, a criminologist specialising in domestic homicide at the University of Gloucestershire, said when done properly DHRs can bring about real change."I do think there are ways that we could make them more efficient and perhaps more effective," she said."I'm not sure we need a big panel of people sitting for multiple meetings for every review."Prof Monckton-Smith, who has chaired several reviews, said six months - the recommended time for completion - is "too short" but four or five years is "far too long" for families to wait. Minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, Jess Phillips, said DHRs offer "a really important opportunity" for agencies to improve their safeguarding practices and ultimately prevent these deaths from happening."But we know that more needs to be done to ensure these reviews are effective and timely, which is why we are cracking on with action to improve the way they are undertaken," she government is now creating a new oversight board with publicly appointed members to make the process for reviewing reports faster, she added. Julie said that during conversations with Safer Leeds it has "taken onboard several ideas that we thought would help other families and those writing it". "One simple thing we asked for was that a photo of the victim is always present when the DHR is being completed, so it takes it away from being an administrative task and so the victim is the centre of all the conversations taking place," she said."We also thought there should always be a person on the panel who is from a women's organisation to ensure there is no victim blaming language."Leeds City Council added that every review is now reviewed at draft stage by a senior manager specifically to ensure that it "focuses on the voice and life of the victim and not the perpetrator"."Safer Leeds will continue to work to improve the timeliness of reports, putting bereaved families at the forefront of the review," it added.
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Mom of three murdered girls' share bizarre Father's Day tribute to killer ex who suffocated them
The mother of the three young girls who were allegedly killed by her now-missing ex-husband shared a bizarre Father's Day tribute to him before their tragic deaths. Whitney Decker made a 20-second video featuring a slideshow of photos of her daughters, Paityn Decker, 9, Evelyn Decker, 8, Olivia Decker, 5, and their father, Travis Decker. The video was made as a Father's Day tribute to her veteran ex-husband who is now wanted on suspicion of murdering their three daughters. Her attorney, Arianna Cozart, provided the video to People. It's unclear when the video, which features Pharrell Williams ' song Happy, was posted. Paityn, Evelyn and Olivia's bodies were found at a campsite in Leavenworth on Monday, after Travis failed to return them after his visitation on Friday. The girls were found 20 miles from their Washington home with their wrists bound with zip ties and each having been suffocated with a plastic bag. Travis reportedly suffers from 'complex PTSD' and 'other mental issues,' and has since been on the run after vanishing into the woods. Yet, the girls' mother spoke out through Cozart and alleged that their murder 'was a tragedy that could've been completely' avoided had officials intervened. She believes 'something broke inside' of Decker and that he 'would not have done what he did if he was himself', Cozart revealed in a heartbreaking statement early Thursday morning. 'He clearly had some sort of break and everything that he had been living with, everything that had been bottled up inside of him for so long as far as trauma, just won out,' Cozart told the Seattle Times. The attorney, speaking on behalf of Whitney, also noted that it was uncharacteristic of Decker not to return his daughters after a scheduled visitation. His 'declining mental health' and 'out-of-character behavior' should have prompted 'enough concern' for an Amber Alert, Cozart argued. She believes authorities should have acknowledged the sisters were 'missing' and in 'substantial danger', even though Decker 'didn't issue an overt threat'. Court documents state that when Whitney reported her daughters missing on Friday, she 'expressed concern' over his out-of-character actions and his alleged deteriorating mental state. Whitney told police Decker was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder and believes he did not take medication for the condition, according to court documents. The father-of-three was supposed to seek mental health treatment and anger management counseling as part of a parenting plan, but there was no sign he had followed through, the documents show. Whitney stated in September divorce proceedings that he had been 'struggling to maintain stability' since they separated and it was beginning to affect their daughters. She said that at times he would have the girls sleep at an armory while he was in the National Guard, despite her objections, according to the Seattle Times. She also said Decker - was prone to 'outbursts' and would come into her house yelling for the girls - would sometimes fail to pick up after promising to do so. 'I do not want to keep Travis from the girls at all,' Whitney wrote in the court filing. 'To the contrary, I have bent over backwards to facilitate that relationship. 'But I cannot have our girls staying in what is essentially a homeless shelter, at times unsupervised, with dozens of strange men or staying in a tent or living in his truck with him, both in extreme temperatures and unknown areas for their safety.' But still Whitney reiterated to authorities how she did not believe her ex was dangerous and said he loved his daughters. She said the girls had a, 'good relationship with Decker and enjoy their time with him,' and noted that he had never failed to return the girls before, according to a police affidavit. She said when Decker went to pick up the girls Friday, he was 'quieter than usual' which was 'out of character' for him. He had also allegedly been talking about getting rid of his dog due to housing and financial struggles. On Tuesday, a judge issued a warrant for Decker's arrest and ordered he be held without bail. Authorities swarmed the Rock Island Campground on Monday evening after finding Decker's truck. Chelan County Sheriff's Office deputies found the girls' bodies about 75 to 100 yards from the truck. Police believe the girls died from asphyxiation and reported that their wrists were zip-tied, court documents state. Decker's truck had two bloody handprints on the tailgate, and inside were personal items including blankets, food, car seats and a wallet on the center console, police said. The campground also showed signs of recent activity, with a tent and a cooler located a short distance away, but Decker was nowhere to be found.
