Trio face jury verdict in tense retrial ten years after the gruesome 'Toolbox murder' of an Aussie man and woman
For hours, three men played video games and drank whiskey as Cory Breton and Iuliana Triscaru lay bound in a toolbox nearby.
The pair had been beaten, stabbed and choked before they were stuffed into the two metre-long container.
They were likely 'screaming for their lives' when the toolbox was later dumped in a lagoon south of Brisbane in January 2016.
Almost 10 years later, Stou Daniels, Davy Malu Junior Taiao and Trent Michael Thrupp were found guilty of the pair's murder for a second time.
They faced a retrial in Brisbane after the Court of Appeal set aside murder convictions in July 2024.
Mr Breton, 28, and Ms Triscaru, 31, had been lured to a residential unit at Kingston, south of Brisbane, before being attacked by a group of men.
'It was torturous. They were assaulted when they arrived and throughout the day... while bound with cable ties and duct tape,' Crown prosecutor Nathan Crane told the weeks-long trial that concluded with Friday's verdicts.
They were attacked, interrogated and threatened over a drug dealing dispute.
When Ngatokoona Mareiti arrived at the unit to buy drugs, Mr Breton and Ms Triscaru were sitting bound on the couch.
Sent away to buy whiskey, by the time Mareiti returned she could not see the pair and assumed they were in the toolbox at the unit.
They drank and played video games as the bound pair were held captive in the container nearby.
'We drank the alcohol... they had a PlayStation there,' Mareiti told the jury.
Cloths and bleach used to clean bloodstains in the unit were thrown into the toolbox before it was taken away with Mr Breton and Ms Triscaru still inside.
The terrified pair made so much noise as the container was being moved, music from an awaiting ute was turned up in a bid to conceal it.
'The transition of the toolbox to a HiLux utility vehicle attracted attention from those present at the unit complex - there was noise emanating from the toolbox,' Mr Crane said.
'There was music used from the HiLux to cover up the sound.'
Thrupp either threw the toolbox weighed down by concrete into nearby Scrubby Creek or was present when it happened, Mr Crane said.
Daniels and Taiao were also liable for murder by forcing the victims into the toolbox hours before their deaths, he said.
Police divers found the bodies locked in the toolbox submerged in the creek two weeks later.
'Most likely the two... were alive and screaming for their lives when they were placed in the creek,' Justice Peter Davis said in 2020 when sentencing Tuhirangi-Thomas Tahiata, who drove the ute to the creek.
'It is haunting to imagine the moment that the toolbox slipped under the water, plunging the night into silence.'
Daniels, Taiao and Thrupp each pleaded not guilty to two counts of murder at their retrial.
The jury on Friday returned its verdict after deliberating since 10.45am Wednesday.
The trio will be sentenced on Thursday.
Overall seven men and a woman were charged over what became known as the 'toolbox murders'.
Tahiata received a life sentence for murder, unsuccessfully appealing the conviction in April 2024.
Mareiti, Webbstar Latu, Tepuna Tupuna Mariri and Waylon Ngaketo Cowan Walker were found guilty of manslaughter.
However, Walker had his convictions overturned in July 2024.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
35 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Ex reality star charged with murder after her partner was found dead in a unit
A woman who starred on Beauty and the Geek has been charged with murder after a man's body was discovered in a home in Port Lincoln, South Australia. Emergency services were called to the property on Flinders Highway at about 3:25pm local time on Thursday following reports of a small fire. When crews arrived, they found a man dead inside the residence. A 34-year-old woman was arrested at the scene and later charged with murder. The Courier Mail reported on Friday that the woman was once a contestant on reality show Beauty and the Geek. South Australia Police have confirmed the victim and the accused were known to each other and had been in a relationship. The woman was refused police bail and remains in custody. Detectives from the Major Crime Investigation Branch and officers from the Forensic Response Section were flown into Port Lincoln to assist local authorities with the investigation. 'I can reassure members of the community that this is not a random incident,' SA Police State Operations Service Assistant Commissioner Ian Parrott told reporters. 'We understand that the female who has been arrested and the deceased male both lived at this address,' he said. 'It is still very early stages of this investigation and it's likely that the Major Crime investigators and the forensic response members will be there most of today.' Assistant Commissioner Parrott said a cause of death had not yet been determined and no further details could be released, as the victim's family had not yet been notified. The woman did not apply for bail and has been detained under the Mental Health Act. She is expected to return to court in December. A suppression order preventing the publication of any information that could identify the woman, the victim, or the specific details surrounding the man's death was issued. The suppression order is set to be reviewed by the court next week.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Sister of film director, 69, found dead in her Camden home wrapped in a blanket with tape over her mouth appears in court charged with her murder
The sister of a film director discovered dead in her Camden flat, wrapped in a blanket and with tape over her mouth, has appeared in court charged with her murder. Jennifer Abbott, 69, was found in her north London home on June 13 after not being seen for days. This morning her sister Nancy Pexton, 69, of Westminster, appeared at Highbury Corner Magistrates' Court. She did not enter a plea and was remanded in custody ahead of a crown court appearance next week. Officers from the Met Police had been called by the London Ambulance Service to a report of an unresponsive woman in a flat in Mornington Place. Ms Abbott, who was professionally known as Sarah Steinberg, was found wrapped in a blanket with tape over her mouth, neighbours claimed The award-winning director was last seen by neighbours walking her beloved corgi Prince, who was described as 'her life'. Prince was found locked in the bathroom after being on its own for up to three days but survived. A post-mortem examination gave Ms Abbott's cause of death as sharp force trauma. Neighbours said they regularly saw her walking her pet corgi in the area with one describing her as 'exuberant' and 'vivacious'. Her next door neighbour Laura, 34, said: 'She was a movie star. She was in a couple of movies. She used to live in Beverly Hills. 'I live right next door to her. She was a friend of mine. I used to walk her dog when she was sick.' Another Neighbour Billie Currie, 63, said: 'She was always walking the dog and was really nice. She was quite reserved but very friendly. A friend had told how Ms Abbott had been in Hollywood earlier in her career where she directed the movie War of the Gods. 'She got interviewed in LA about this movie,' she said. 'She was known as Jenny or Janet and was quite mysterious.' Scotland Yard previously said officers were investigating whether Ms Abbott's death was linked to a diamond-encrusted Rolex missing from her home.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Mother of Ava White, 12, who was murdered over petty Snapchat row condemns 'monster' teenage killer's lack of remorse after he posted selfie to site from behind bars
The mother of murdered 12-year-old Ava White today branded the teenager who killed her in a petty row over Snapchat video a 'monster' after he posted a selfie on the same platform from behind bars. Harry Gilbertson - who was 14 when he fatally stabbed Ava - was unmasked by Mail Online today as he turns 18. Ava's campaigning mother Leeann, who has dedicated her life to tackling knife crime, said it was 'important the public know who he is' now that he is legally an adult. To her fury, despite the fact that he's currently serving a minimum 13-year sentence for murdering Ava in November 2021, muscle-bound Gilbertson managed to upload an image of himself onto Snapchat. For her family it was particular hurtful because the argument which led to Gilbertson stabbing the schoolgirl in the neck was sparked by his refusal to delete a Snapchat video he had made of Ava and her friends. They had been in Liverpool city centre to watch the Christmas lights switch-on - but instead 'unique and hugely popular' Ava was left bleeding to death on the pavement. Ava's mother today slammed Gilbertson for brazenly flaunting his bulked-up physique on the same social media site. 'The picture was taken on Snapchat,' she said. 'The same social media that he posted the video of Ava on before he murdered her. 'He has never shown any remorse.' She added: 'I don't call him by his name. I call him the monster.' And Ms White, 42, demanded to know how Gilbertson had managed to evade prison rules and access the internet from within the secure unit where he is serving a life sentence. 'I know he got read the riot act for that,' Ms White added. 'They told me he used a tablet that was supposed to be for educational purposes to post it and that there was a glitch in the prison systems that allowed him to get on to the Internet, but I just don't buy that. 'It's disgusting, he didn't even get any extra time added on to his sentence.' Gilbertson was convicted of Ava's murder in 2022 - but the trial judge refused calls from Ava's family and the Press for him to be named, saying the risk to his family, in particular his younger siblings, was too great. Today, however, the Mail can identify and picture Gilbertson for the first time on his 18th birthday. Ava's mother, Leeann White, 42, said: 'It is important the public know who he is. 'The public know everything about Ava – her name was splashed everywhere when she died. 'Why shouldn't everyone know what he did? Why should he be protected? 'He was the one in the wrong, he was the one who went out that night with a knife. 'He's never shown any remorse. 'I know he was only a child himself when it happened but children know right from wrong and my child knew not to pick up a knife and stab someone. 'His name needs to be out there to act as a deterrent to others who might be thinking about carrying knives.' Ms White said that she now believed that 'with hindsight' Mrs Justice Yip, who presided over Gilbertson's trial at Liverpool Crown Court, had been right to prevent him from being named initially. 'If the judge had named him then he would probably be getting a new identity on his 18th birthday so, in a way, I am glad she didn't,' Ms White added. 'I definitely don't want that. 'I've waited all this time for his name to be out there. If he was given a new identity and I didn't know who he was, I don't think I would be able to go on living.' Ava had been given permission to stay out late to see the lights turned on when they encountered a group of boys including Gilbertson on November 25, 2021. She became angry when he filmed her and posted it online. Ava - who attended Notre Dame Catholic College in Everton - demanded Gilbertson delete the video from Snapchat. But an argument developed and he stabbed her in the neck with a three-inch flick knife. Gilbertson told jurors he carried the knife to make himself 'feel big'. He claimed he stabbed her in self-defence. But the court heard he 'grinned' as Ava lay dying, before running off to discard his coat and the weapon. Jurors rejected his version of events and convicted him of Ava's murder. Mrs Justice Yip was told Gilbertson was de-sensitised to violence after witnessing his father attack his mother at home. He had also been made the subject of a community resolution notice four months before Ava's murder for hitting a police community support officer on the head. At the time of Ava's death he was awaiting trial for assaulting two women and was known to police who were concerned he was being groomed into a criminal gang. Sentencing Gilbertson, who has attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and attended a special school, Mrs Justice Yip highlighted the role social media played in the case, saying it was tragic 'something so small' as a Snapchat video had left a girl dead. She told him: 'There is only one reason why Ava is dead and that is because you chose to carry a knife and you chose to get it out and use it.' Ms White told the Mail she agreed with Esther Ghey, 38, whose 16-year-old daughter Brianna was also stabbed to death by teenagers, that the Government needed to do more to protect children from dangers associated with social media sites. Ms White added: 'I've met Esther and agree with her campaigns. 'All social media does is cause harm and distress. Everything children are exposed to on there is frightening.' Although almost four years have passed since Ava's death, Ms White said she finds it really hard to cope with the loss of her youngest child. The mother-of-two tearfully added: 'I'm really up and down. 'Some days I'm okay, other days are really bad and I can't stop crying. 'It doesn't get any easier, it seems to get harder as time goes on. 'It really was so senseless what happened to Ava. 'I don't agree with violence at all, but I'm always thinking "Why couldn't he have just pushed or shoved her?" 'She was only 12, he was 14. She was a girl and he was a boy. 'Why didn't he just push her, he didn't have to stab her in the neck.' She said the Ava White Foundation, which she set up in the wake of her daughter's murder, 'keeps me going'. The not-for-profit organisation campaigns against knife crime and aims to fund and deliver specialist bleed packs to schools, youth clubs, pubs and train and bus stations in the North West. It also visits schools to educate schoolchildren on the dangers of carrying knives and to teach life-saving skills. 'To be honest, I don't know where I would be without it,' Ms White, a former shop assistant, added. 'It gives me a reason to get up in the morning. 'I know I have to do this for Ava and it keeps me going each day until I get home.' A Ministry of Justice spokeswoman today said: 'This was an horrendous crime, and our thoughts remain with the family of Ava White. 'No victim should ever have to see their perpetrators appearing online. 'We've put in place tough measures to clamp down on the use of social media in prisons and have committed to review how we could extend these controls to all places of custody.' Under prison rules, inmates - including children - face 'sanctions' if they are caught in possession of a mobile phone or other illicit device with internet access.
