logo
Sean 'Diddy' Combs trial live updates: Cassie Ventura faces cross-examination in federal sex trafficking case

Sean 'Diddy' Combs trial live updates: Cassie Ventura faces cross-examination in federal sex trafficking case

Yahoo15-05-2025

The trial of Sean 'Diddy' Combs continues in Manhattan federal court on Thursday, with Cassie Ventura, his former girlfriend, returning to the witness stand for the defense's cross-examination.
The 55-year-old hip-hop mogul is facing charges of sex trafficking, racketeering conspiracy and transportation to engage in prostitution. Federal prosecutors say that for decades, Combs abused, threatened and coerced women to participate in marathon sexual encounters called "freak offs" and used his business empire, along with guns, kidnapping and arson, to conceal his crimes.
During two days of direct questioning from prosecutors, Ventura told the court her decade-long relationship with Combs was frequently marked by violence and physical abuse, describing in detail the drug-fueled "freak offs" that would take days to recover from. Jurors were also shown a 2016 surveillance video of Combs hitting, kicking and dragging Ventura in the hallway of a Los Angeles hotel.
Combs has pleaded not guilty. If convicted, he could face life in prison. He is being held without bail in a Brooklyn jail. A jury of 12 New Yorkers and six alternates will decide his fate. The trial is expected to last at least eight weeks.
Follow the live blog below for the latest updates on the trial, culled from various reporters and news organizations in the courtroom, including the Associated Press, CNN, the New York Times and NBC News.
If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic violence, you can call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-SAFE (7233). Find more resources here.
During her direct testimony, Cassie Ventura said that when she tried to break it off with Combs, he threatened to end her career by releasing videos of her participating in "freak offs."
During cross-examination, however, defense lawyer Anna Estevao asked Ventura whether it was fair to say her explosive 2023 lawsuit against Combs effectively ended his career. The lawsuit was quickly settled out of court for $20 million, but it was followed by dozens of similar suits and led to this federal criminal case.
"When your lawsuit was publicized in November 2023, you understood that his career was ruined at that point, right?" Estevao asked in court.
"I could understand that, yeah," Ventura replied.
As the defense continued to have Ventura read her messages to Combs from the beginning of their relationship, Ventura smiled.
"It's making me giggle because it's from 2007," Ventura said after defense attorney Anna Estevao showed her an email she sent Combs 18 years ago.
"I know," Estevao said. "We're taking you back."
The 2007 message to Combs said, "I never felt so loved, safe and empowered since we've come together." But then, Ventura added, "On the other hand, you're constantly weary of me ..."
'It was usually, like, a one-way street when it came to messages like this,' Ventura testified.
The defense continued showing more sexually explicit messages between Ventura and Combs regarding "freak offs" early on in their relationship.
Some of the messages included logistics, like buying candles at a pharmacy before the "freak off." In one message, Ventura asked Combs if he had any more pills.
In another message to Combs in 2009, Ventura wrote, "We used to freak off when we were so in love. There were no questions asked, it felt right, like it literally made sense for the next step in our life together. I get nervous that I'm just becoming the girlfriend that you get your fantasies off with and that's it. I don't get the other part. ... Anymore at least."
The defense appears to be using email and text messages between Ventura and Combs in an attempt to show that she was a willing participant in the "freak offs," undercutting the narrative established during her direct testimony that she was coerced into them by Combs.
"I'm always ready to freak off lolol," Ventura wrote in one 2009 message.
'I can't wait to watch you. I want you to get real hott,' Combs wrote to Ventura in another exchange.
'Me Too, I just want it to be uncontrollable,' Ventura replied.
Combs's family is in the courtroom again today. His mom, Janice Combs, 85, and his three sons, Quincy Brown, 30, and Christian, 25, and Justin Combs, 29, are all seated in the spectator's gallery.
CNN reported, citing a source close to the family, that Combs's twin daughters, Jessie and D'Lila, have missed court because they're traveling for their high school prom this weekend.
Read more about the Combs family from Yahoo: Hollywood has distanced itself from Sean 'Diddy' Combs. His children remain his most loyal supporters.
After defense attorney Anna Estevao asked Cassie Ventura what made her fall in love with Combs, the questions turned to how Ventura felt she had earned Combs's trust and what she did to please him.
"To make him happy, you told him that you wanted to do 'freak offs'?" Estevao asked.
"No," Ventura replied. "There's a lot more to that."
The "freak offs" refer to the drug-fueled sex parties Combs organized, which have been discussed throughout the trial. Ventura previously testified she never wanted to participate in "freak offs."
The defense showed another text exchange from Ventura to Combs in 2009, where they discuss having a "freak off" with an escort named Jules.
"I'm always ready to freak off lolol," Ventura wrote.
Amid his ongoing sex trafficking trial, Sean "Diddy" Combs is facing a new civil lawsuit by a woman who alleges he raped her in 2001.
According to People magazine, the suit was filed in New York County Supreme Court on Wednesday by a woman who identified herself as Jane Doe. She claimed that during a night out with Combs, her friend and others, on or around July 31, 2001, they stopped at his apartment where he forcefully led her into his bedroom, put one hand around her throat and said, "I'm going to suck the life out of you."
After releasing her neck, she alleged Combs held her arm down "while using his other hand to swiftly unbuckle his belt and pants, before pulling out his erect bare-skinned penis which appeared to be the length and girth of a large tootsie roll."
She told him to stop but he allegedly ignored her, "slid her underwear to the side, and forcefully engaged in vaginal intercourse with her without her consent and against her will."
The lawsuit alleges that she "suffered physical abuse, emotional abuse, trauma, injury, and psychological damage, as a result of the defendants' intentional, negligent, and criminal actions." She is seeking a jury trial and unspecified damages.
The defense has presented its first pieces of evidence — loving messages between Cassie Ventura and Combs.
Anna Estevao, an employer for Combs, had Ventura read several messages the two exchanged early on in their relationship.
"I miss you sooo much and I'd fly wherever you needed me whenever!!!!!!!" Ventura wrote in an email to Combs in 2008.
"I love you sooooo much it makes me cry," Combs messaged her in August 2009.
As the messages were shown on the monitor to the court, Ventura testified that she called Combs "Pop Pop," and he sometimes called her "Baby Girl" or "BG."
"Going to sleep now so it can be tomorrow faster and you can be home," Ventura wrote to Combs in April 2010. "Love you!!!"
"Love my baby," Combs responded.
Returning to the witness stand for the third straight day, Cassie Ventura was questioned by the defense for the first time.
Defense attorney Anna Estevao began the cross-examination by asking a series of yes-or-no questions about Ventura's relationship with Combs.
Estevao: "You loved him?'Ventura: 'I did.'Estevao: 'And you believe that he loved you as well?'Ventura: 'Yes.'
Ventura then answered affirmatively when asked if her love for Combs explained why it hurt "so badly" when he lied and cheated on her.
Here's what to expect at Sean Combs's criminal sex trafficking trial on Thursday:
Court resumes at 9:30 a.m. ET.
Cassie Ventura, Combs's former girlfriend and the prosecution's star witness, is expected back on the stand for cross-examination from the defense.
Defense attorney Anna Estevao told Judge Arun Subramanian that the defense team expects their cross-examination will take all day and likely go into Friday.
Testifying for more than 10 hours over two days, Ventura described in detail the grueling "freak offs" she said she took part in at Combs's direction.
She also recounted the years of physical and emotional abuse she endured during her decade-long relationship with Combs, including several violent assaults.
Court is expected to conclude at 5 p.m. ET.
Cassie Ventura's testimony has concluded for the day, and her cross-examination is scheduled to begin on Thursday at 9:30 a.m. ET.
Defense attorney Anna Estevo told Judge Arun Subramanian that the defense team expects their cross-examination will take all day tomorrow and likely go into Friday, but it should be completed by the end of the week.
Ventura has spent the last two days recounting the more than 10 years she spent in an on-and-off relationship with Sean "Diddy" Combs.
During Wednesday's testimony, Ventura described several violent situations she faced with Combs, including when he assaulted her in a hotel hallway in 2016 and the first time he beat her, sometime in 2007 or 2008. She testified that he pressured her into "hundreds" of drug-fueled sex performances known as "freak offs," which subsequently caused her to develop an addiction to opiates. Ventura recalled how she did not feel that she had the resources to leave Combs when she wanted to and did not feel safe asking her friends or family for help.
She also told the jury that Combs raped her after a dinner in 2018, at the end of their relationship, where they had what she'd interpreted as a "closure conversation."
The prosecution told Judge Arun Subramanian that it has no further questions for Cassie Ventura at this time.
Ventura concluded her direct testimony by estimating she had been in "hundreds" of "freak offs" during her relationship with Sean Combs and hasn't been involved in any since they broke up in 2018. She testified that she settled her lawsuit against Combs for $20 million.
While the prosecution has pushed for cross-examination to begin today, the judge has called for the defense to start questioning Ventura tomorrow.
After two days on the stand, Cassie Ventura finally broke down Wednesday afternoon while answering questions about why she decided to go to rehab and trauma therapy in 2023.
"I was spinning out," she said. "I didn't want to be alive anymore at that point."
Ventura said she decided to start writing a book about her relationship with Sean Combs after she went to rehab. She said her mom helped her write it.
"I really wanted Sean to read the information. I wanted him to understand what I had to learn to understand over that period," she said.
Editor's note: If you or someone you know is struggling with mental health, you can dial or text 988 or visit 988lifeline.org for free, confidential support.
Cassie Ventura testified that she agreed to see Sean Combs for dinner in Malibu, Calif., in August 2018 for what she thought was a "closure conversation" at the end of their relationship. Ventura said she had started seeing her now-husband, Alex Fine, around that time.
Ventura said Combs was playful and somewhat romantic during their dinner, and he drove her home.
"Then he raped me in my living room," she said. "I just remember crying and saying 'no,' but it was very fast."
She said she was consensually intimate with Combs once more after that, but the relationship officially ended around that time. Ventura said they had some sporadic contact afterward until March 2019, when Combs sent her a message that referred to "iPads full of skeletons," which she interpreted as referring to the sexual videos they had recorded.
As Cassie Ventura continues to testify about what she describes as Sean Combs's violence throughout their relationship, she noted his physical abuse was not limited to her.
She said she personally witnessed him assaulting his own employees and assistants, from punching one man in the head to dragging another woman, known in the trial as "Mia" or "Victim-4," out of bed during a trip.
Ventura said her friends weren't safe either. She said she watched Combs once attack a friend by holding her over a 17th-floor balcony — an incident that was mentioned in her 2023 civil lawsuit as well as a 2024 lawsuit filed by fashion designer Bryana "Bana" Bongolan. Ventura said she watched Combs hit one of her best friends with a wooden hanger in 2018, which ended their 17-year friendship.
In response to Sean Combs's reaction to Cassie Ventura dating Scott Mescudi, also known as rapper Kid Cudi, Ventura said she ended the relationship in early 2012.
"Too much danger, too much uncertainty of what could happen if we continued to see each other," she said.
Ventura testified that Combs had threatened to blow up Mescudi's car, hoping that Mescudi and his friends would be present when it happened. She mentioned the allegation in her 2023 lawsuit, claiming, "Around that time, Kid Cudi's car exploded in his driveway." Through a spokesperson, Mescudi told the New York Times that one of his cars did explode in early 2012. "This is all true," the spokesperson said.
The indictment from last year that led to Combs's arrest states he used arson to control victims.
In the courtroom, Ventura testified that the three met at the Soho House after she broke up with Mescudi. She said Mescudi asked, "What about my vehicle?" to which Combs replied, "What vehicle?"
Cassie Ventura testified that she went to see her mother in Connecticut in December 2011 after Sean Combs had allegedly beaten her and that her mom took photos of her bruises.
But during the same visit, Ventura said she lied to her mother by saying it was "the first time" she had been assaulted by Combs.
And Ventura said she had not told her mother about the "freak offs."
'I couldn't hurt her like that,' Ventura said. 'You can't justify it to anyone. Especially not your mom.'
Cassie Ventura testified that in late 2011, she met the rapper Kid Cudi (whose real name is Scott Mescudi) and they soon began dating.
When Sean Combs found out about her new relationship during one of their "freak offs," Ventura said he lunged at her with a wine bottle opener. She fled to another hotel and called Mescudi on a "burner" phone to pick her up.
She said Combs subsequently threatened to release two "freak off" videos and have someone "hurt" Ventura and Mescudi while he was out of the country.
Ventura sent an email to her mom and one of Combs's employees detailing the alleged threats.
Ventura said Combs became violent with her after a party at a Los Angeles nightclub in 2009 and started calling her names. She testified that she drunkenly punched him in the face after hearing him insult her — "as hard as you can hit somebody when you're drunk like that," she testified — and he responded by throwing her to the floor of the car and stomping on her face.
When they arrived at Combs's house, she tried to run away, but Combs's security staff caught her and brought her in. She said she did not recognize herself when she looked in the mirror.
She testified that Combs told her she needed to stay in a hotel with security to recover. She said she wanted to stay at Combs's house instead of a hotel, but he said no. She explained that even when she felt ready to leave the hotel after staying there for about a week, she felt like she couldn't.
"I didn't have the resources I needed to get out and move, to get out and not have anybody stop me," she said. "I understood Sean's capabilities, his access to guns and the threats that he made prior to that."
Ventura said she didn't feel comfortable potentially getting other people involved by telling them what was happening. She said her mom read a gossip item online about the nightclub incident and called Ventura to ask if it was her.
"I didn't tell my mom the truth because I was ashamed, but I also felt like at that point I didn't know what was going to happen," Ventura said. "I didn't want to put my mother in danger of knowing anything of that magnitude."
Cassie Ventura testified about the physical violence in her relationship with Combs, stating that the first incident was around 2007 or 2008. (The two first met in 2005 when she was 19 and he was 37.) Ventura said she saw Combs flirting with someone else at a group dinner, and when they got into his car after the meal, she said "he knocked me around and was just really mean."
Ventura said Combs hit her on the side of the head, causing her to fall to the floor of the car in front of security staff and his driver.
"I was just shocked," she said.
Ventura said that she initiated some of the physical fights throughout their relationship, but she said Combs was never injured after those incidents. But when he got physical with her, she said she would get bruises and would sometimes hide out for days afterward.
She said that there were multiple employees who witnessed Combs's abuse, including members of his security team, his management team and his assistants. She testified that at least one assistant had told her that they quit because of how Combs treated her.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Former MTV VJ Ananda Lewis' final text message revealed as CNN reporter breaks down on air
Former MTV VJ Ananda Lewis' final text message revealed as CNN reporter breaks down on air

New York Post

timean hour ago

  • New York Post

Former MTV VJ Ananda Lewis' final text message revealed as CNN reporter breaks down on air

Stephanie Elam is sharing insight into her friendship with the late Ananda Lewis. The former MTV VJ and talk show host died at age 52 following a lengthy battle with breast cancer. On Friday, the CNN correspondent, 51, spoke candidly about Lewis while on air with fellow CNN anchor Sara Sidner, 53. In October 2024, the trio sat down to discuss both Sidner's breast cancer diagnosis and Lewis' with the correspondent undergoing traditional treatment while the former television personality opted for a more holistic approach. Advertisement 9 Stephanie Elam talks about Ananda Lewis live on CNN. CNN 'One thing I want everyone to know is that she was at peace with this decision,' Elam said of Lewis' choice in treatment. 'She had come to grips with it.' Elam added she visited Lewis the day before she passed, noting her condition declined rapidly. Advertisement 'We thought we had weeks and it turned out that it turned into days and it turned out it was just a matter of hours,' the journalist revealed. 'It happened very quickly how things changed.' 9 Stephanie Elam and Sara Sidner on CNN. CNN Elam then became emotional while reading Lewis' last text message to her. 'She texted me and said things had taken a different turn than she would have liked,' Elam explained. 'This is part of the text she sent me: 'You know my feelings on this. We all go. These bodies are on loan and must be returned. We come in love and choose to leave it with love as well.' And then she goes on to say, 'I love you my wonderful lifelong bestie of besties.'' Advertisement Elam added that Lewis was 'my ride or die.' 9 Ananda Lewis and Stephanie Elam. stephelamtv/Instagram 'I love my girl, but she was hard-headed,' Elam admitted. 'She wanted to do it her own way despite the fact that so many of us close to her wanted her to try the way that [Sidner] did it. But this is what she wanted to do and she was totally at peace with it.' On Instagram, the tv host penned an emotional tribute to her longtime pal. Advertisement 'She was good energy and joy. She was fiercely loyal and deeply loving. She was an awesome mother, a dedicated auntie to my daughter, a giving human and she was my best friend for two-thirds of our lives,' Elam began alongside a montage of pictures of the two throughout the years. 9 Stephanie Elam shares a throwback pics of herself with Ananda Lewis. stephelamtv/Instagram 'We met at the very beginning of freshman year at our beloved @howard1867 Howard University,' she continued. 'She was 18 and I was 17. Our bond was quick and easy. Two young women from California beginning four years together in Washington DC. We were so tight, we celebrated our graduation together at an Indian restaurant with both of our families.' Looking back at their bond over the years, Elam added, 'We were there for each other in the big moments and the quiet everyday ones – the no makeup mommying days and our annual 'framily' traditions with our kids – which we never missed.' 'I was so proud of her when she agreed last fall to disclose more about her breast cancer path in conversation with me and @sarasidnertv,' she confessed about their sit down conversation. 'I truly believe they saved lives by being so open.' 9 Stephanie Elam poses with Ananda Lewis. stephelamtv/Instagram 'If only we knew that would be our last time on camera together – or that last summer would see our last beach day, or last autumn our final trip to the fall festival, our last solo convo this spring,' Elam heartbreakingly shared. 'But last night I got to hold her hand and tell her how much I love her. Please know she was at peace with her passing.' 'I'm so glad she's no longer in pain but I'm not quite sure how to life this life without her.' Advertisement Lewis' sister, Lakshmi, first revealed the devastating news in a Facebook post on Wednesday. 9 Ananda Lewis. Paul Redmond 9 Stephanie Elam and Ananda Lewis. . stephelamtv/Instagram 'She's free, and in His heavenly arms,' Lakshmi wrote beneath a black-and-white picture of Lewis. 'Lord, rest her soul.' Advertisement The MTV alum shared her Stage 3 breast cancer diagnosis in an Instagram post in October 2020. 'This is tough for me, but if just ONE woman decides to get her mammogram after watching this, what I'm going through will be worth it,' Lewis captioned the video – which explained she was diagnosed with breast cancer two years prior. In her October 2024 conversation with Elam and Sider, she said, 'My plan at first was to get out excessive toxins in my body. I felt like my body is intelligent, I know that to be true. Our bodies are brilliantly made. I decided to keep my tumor and try to work it out of my body a different way. I wish I could go back.' 9 Ananda Lewis poses on the red carpet. WireImage for BET Network Advertisement 9 Ananda Lewis during Frida Kahlo Tequila Launch in 2005. WireImage In an issue of Essence published earlier this year. Lewis stated that 'prevention is the real cure.' Lewis is survived by her and son, Langston, 14, who she shares with Will Smith's younger brother, Harry Smith.

U.S. files suit against New York State over courthouse arrest law
U.S. files suit against New York State over courthouse arrest law

UPI

timean hour ago

  • UPI

U.S. files suit against New York State over courthouse arrest law

The Department of Justice has named New York Gov. Kathleen Hochul (pictured) and Attorney General Letitia James as the defendants in the lawsuit filed Thursday with the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of New York that seeks to have New York's "Protect Our Courts Act" ruled unlawful. File Photo by Tannen Maury/UPI | License Photo June 13 (UPI) -- The federal government has filed a suit against the state of New York over a law that has kept ICE enforcement out of its state courthouses. The Department of Justice has named New York Gov. Kathleen Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James as the defendants in the lawsuit filed Thursday with the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of New York that seeks to have New York's "Protect Our Courts Act" ruled unlawful. The act, signed into law in December of 2020, provides a "privilege against civil arrest" for anyone traveling to or from, or involved in court proceedings, whether that be for themselves or in support for family or household members when they need to appear in court. The law further states that only judicially signed orders or warrants can be executed in court buildings, and such warrants must also be reviewed by the court, which then determines where and when a warrant can be executed, and how it may be implemented. U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi said in a press release Thursday that New York is "employing sanctuary city policies to prevent illegal aliens from apprehension." She added that the suit "underscores the Department of Justice's commitment to keeping Americans safe and aggressively enforcing the law." Chair of the New York State Senate Judiciary Committee Sen. Brad Hoylman-Sigal responded to the legal action with astatement Thursday in which he called the lawsuit "baseless and frivolous, and "part and parcel of the Trump administration's ongoing assault on the rule of law in New York." Hoylman-Sigal also insisted that the Protect our Courts Act is "well within the established purview of state law," and doesn't apply to federal or immigration courts, and permits Immigration and Customs Enforcement to make arrests with valid judicial warrants. "At a time when masked ICE officials are roaming the state and lawlessly detaining New Yorkers without any due process, the law preserves access to justice and participation in the judicial process," Hoylman-Sigal said. Hel was one of two New York legislators who wrote a letter to state Attorney General James in March when someone was allegedly detained by federal law enforcement while inside a state courthouse. Assistant Attorney General Brett Shumate also said in the Justice Department press release that the act allows New York to obstruct "federal law enforcement and facilitates the evasion of federal law by dangerous criminals, notwithstanding federal agents' statutory mandate to detain and remove illegal aliens."

From a Russian prison, US schoolteacher tells lawyers he was grabbed by Moscow's soldiers
From a Russian prison, US schoolteacher tells lawyers he was grabbed by Moscow's soldiers

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

From a Russian prison, US schoolteacher tells lawyers he was grabbed by Moscow's soldiers

By Lucy Papachristou LONDON (Reuters) -A 73-year-old American jailed by Russia as a mercenary for Ukraine protested his innocence when his U.S.-based legal team and family finally tracked him down in April, months after he vanished into the vast Russian prison system, they said. Stephen Hubbard, a retired schoolteacher, was sentenced last October to almost seven years in a penal colony after a court found him guilty of serving in a Ukrainian territorial defence unit against Russian forces, tasked with manning a checkpoint. Russian state media reported that he had entered a guilty plea in the closed-door trial. The U.S. Embassy in Moscow has not been granted consular access to Hubbard, a State Department spokesperson said, adding that U.S. officials have requested his immediate release. Martin De Luca, his U.S.-based lawyer, told Reuters it was not until this April that his legal team learned Hubbard was being held in a facility in the Mordovia region, east of Moscow. "The first thing Hubbard wanted to talk about when he was able to make contact with the outside world was: 'It's not true,'" said De Luca, who made his first public comments on the case to the New York Times this week. "They (Russian soldiers) grabbed him from his house. He was not in any combat or military unit", De Luca recalled Hubbard saying. Joseph Coleman, a son from Hubbard's first marriage who lives in Cyprus, said he spoke to his father in prison by phone for less than five minutes on May 28. "He did sound a little down," Coleman told Reuters. "He said, 'I'm tired of being a slave.'" At least eight other Americans are currently imprisoned in Russia, which has stepped up arrests of alleged mercenaries for Ukraine since its 2022 invasion of its neighbour. But Hubbard is the only one designated by the U.S. as "wrongfully detained," making him a top candidate to be returned in any future prisoner exchange. The Kremlin said last month the two sides were discussing a possible swap involving nine people on each side. A document written on the letterhead of the IK-12 penal colony, signed by a prison official and seen by Reuters, says that Hubbard is incarcerated there. Russia's federal prison service did not respond to an emailed request for confirmation from Reuters. Other U.S. citizens previously jailed in Russia have been incarcerated in the same region. VIDEO CLUES Hubbard, a Michigan native who taught English abroad for decades, had moved to Izium in eastern Ukraine in 2014 to be with a Ukrainian girlfriend, but by 2022 he was living there alone, his family said. Russian forces captured Izium in April 2022. After his arrest, his family struggled to establish what had happened to him. They caught glimpses of him in videos posted online in pro-war Russian Telegram channels. One showed what appeared to be a staged interrogation. In another, Hubbard appeared with his hands zip-tied and whimpered as a man slapped him with a plastic sandal. His sister, Patricia Hubbard Fox, identified her brother in both videos in conversations with Reuters. The agency could not verify when and where the videos were taken. "He is so non-military," Hubbard Fox told Reuters last year, expressing doubt that her brother would have taken up arms for any state. "He never had a gun, owned a gun, done any of that... He's more of a pacifist." TRACKING HIM DOWN After Hubbard's trial, De Luca and his team at a U.S. law firm began working to secure his release. They picked up the case in late February. It wasn't easy to find him, De Luca said. "Russia is still a functioning country. There are laws, bureaucracies, processes that get followed," he said. The team located Hubbard at the penal colony in Molochnitsa, a very small town about a seven-hour drive from Moscow. De Luca said the team has been able to call Hubbard three times since April. He described him as weak after months living in a prisoner-of-war camp.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store