MP's chilling message over NHS dentistry – 'it's abandonment not healthcare'
Mirror's Dentists for All campaign has been praised in the House of Commons debate as an MP blamed a 'conspiracy of silence' around the crisis in getting an NHS dentist
MPs have told how their constituents are having their lives blighted by oral health problems because they cannot get an NHS dentist. A debate in the House of Commons heard about children suffering agonising toothache and a woman in her 40s losing half her teeth.
Labour backbench MP Melanie Onn MP was granted a Parliamentary debate on the crisis and paid tribute to the Mirror 's Dentists for All campaign. Ms Onn said: 'Currently one in three people in deprived areas experience tooth decay. This is a shocking statistic that simply must be addressed. Over 260,000 people have signed a petition led by the British Dental Association, the Women's Institute and the Daily Mirror calling on the Government to urgently deliver on their promise to reform NHS dentistry. This demand could not be more urgent.
'Catherine, one of many constituents who have written to me with issues around dental provision locally, had been with her dentist for over a decade. During the pandemic a simple missed appointment, that was cancelled by the surgery itself, saw her removed from her regular appointments. She has since been unable to join other practices and told that waiting lists will take two years.
'In the meantime she has suffered devastating deterioration to her oral health, losing all of her back teeth, suffering an infected crown, bridge and facing the real fear of losing her top teeth too. Catherine is only in her 40s. She was quoted £14,000 privately for treatment. She simply cannot afford that. She has had to endure constant pain that no-one should have to bear.'
Currently the NHS budget for England is only enough for around half of the population to get treated. The 'flawed' NHS payment contract sees dentists make a loss on some procedures and has caused an exodus to the private sector. Contract reform is a key demand of the Mirror campaign which is putting pressure on the Treasury to fully fund the service after over a decade of real terms cuts under the Tories.
Chris Webb, Labour MP for Blackpool South, told the Commons: 'Anyone who has had tooth ache knows the unbearable agony in those moments. There's nothing worse. But imagine watching your four-year-old child suffer that same pain, and imagine that they can't be helped. This was the reality of my constituent Louise, a single mum.
'Louise got in touch with me at breaking point to watch her son suffer through constant distress, crying in agony, unable to sleep, refusing to eat. When she managed to see an emergency dentist she was told he would need between four and eight teeth extracted but the wait time for the procedure was up to two years. Louise was left with no choice but to manage her son's pain with Calpol. That's not healthcare. It's abandonment.'
The £3 billion NHS dentistry budget for England is only enough to treat around half of the population. Some 13 million people are living with an 'unmet need' for dental care according to official data. Recent polling suggested that among those who could not get an NHS dental appointment, 26% performed DIY dentistry such as yanking out their own teeth and 19% went abroad for treatment.
Lizzi Collinge, the Labour MP for Morecambe and Lunesdale, said: 'We don't have to look far to see the root of the problem. I speak, dentists have been telling us for years that the NHS dental contract is not fit for purpose. The contract creates perverse incentives that's also discouraged from treating the patients who need them the most.'
Dr Andrew Murrison, Conservative MP for South West Wiltshire, said: 'There's been a conspiracy of silence all these years over NHS dentistry. What the Government has to get to grips with is whether it intends that dentistry should continue to be a universal part of our NHS or not, and whether it's going to be exempted from the universality that has characterised the provision of health care services in this country since 1948.
'What I am recommending to the minister is that we are each honest with the public because at the moment we have this pretence around NHS dentistry that says 'of course you have the right to have your teeth fixed at no cost to you'. In reality, in most parts of the country, mine included, that is a complete fiction.'
Lack of funding and the outdated payment system means most dental practices are no longer accepting new adult patients. The incoming Labour government had promised to reform the dental contract but negotiations have been held up by the Treasury which has been reluctant to commit to a substantial funding boost.
Responding on behalf of the Government, health minister Karin Smyth said: 'Let's be clear there are no perfect pay models and careful consideration is being given to any changes to the complex dental system so that we deliver genuine improvements for patients and the profession.
'It is an immense challenge. There are no quick fixes and no easy answers, but people across the country deserve better access and we're determined to make that happen. Rescuing NHS dentistry will not happen overnight. It will take time, investment and reform, but improving access to NHS digital is key to our mission to get the NHS back on its feet and fit for the future."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
STEPHEN POLLARD: Labour's created an atmosphere where the hard working middle class are now fair game for bigotry
That an eight-year-old can be refused healthcare on the NHS because of the school he attends is deeply troubling. It shows that the service once described by Margaret Thatcher 's Chancellor Nigel Lawson as 'the closest thing the English people have to a religion,' has become a battleground for class war where children seeking treatment are seen as the enemy of the proletariat. That includes my children. I am lucky enough to be able to pay for them to attend private schools. I pay the fees on top of my taxes, of course. Now it seems the NHS regards my kids as non-citizens to be shunned.
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Victory for Darlington nurses as they win landmark battle for a female-only hospital changing room
Eight pioneering nurses who formed their own union to defend the rights of women have won a landmark battle for a female-only changing room. The Darlington nurses launched a legal action saying transgender policies put them at risk, deprived them of dignity and breached their human rights. They claimed a biological male colleague identifying as a woman called Rose stared at their breasts as they were getting undressed and lingered too long in the changing room. One nurse had a panic attack after Rose repeatedly asked when they were alone, 'Are you getting changed yet?' Now, with their case heading to the courts, Health Secretary Wes Streeting has intervened, ordering Darlington Memorial Hospital to give the women their own room. One of them, Bethany Hutchison, said they 'hugely appreciate' the action 'to restore our safety and dignity in the workplace in line with the law'. And she said the nurses would not 'stop until this action is extended urgently to female workers across the NHS without any unnecessary delay'. The Darlington nurses sued their NHS trust a year ago, winning overwhelming support across the country. 'Millions of women stand with them,' said Their victory comes after it emerged last week that NHS chiefs have been forced to rip up their pro-trans guidance after it was rendered illegal by the Supreme Court. The NHS Confederation, which represents trusts, has quietly withdrawn guidance telling hospitals that they should allow trans people to use their chosen lavatories and changing rooms. A senior NHS England official visited Darlington Memorial Hospital unannounced last week and described the changing facilities for female staff as 'inadequate'. The official apologised to one of the Darlington nurses, promising to act 'with speed' by providing male, female and gender-neutral changing rooms, adding: 'We want you to feel comfortable and safe.' Last year, after raising concerns the nurses were told by HR that they needed to get 're-educated', 'compromise' and 'be more inclusive'. After the nurses publicised their claim, the County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust gave them a 'temporary' office for changing into uniforms. However, supporters of the nurses said that the office had no lockers and opened on to a public corridor, resulting in the women branding it as 'dehumanising' and 'humiliating'. When their union was reluctant to lend its support, the eight nurses formed their own, the Darlington Nursing Union and submitted their proposals for a way forward to Mr Streeting. Their guidelines provided 'a fair and manageable way forward to protect safe single-sex spaces for all NHS staff in line with the equality law'. In addition, it respected the rights of those with the protected characteristic of 'gender reassignment', legally known as 'transexuals'. Tory leader Kemi Badenoch backed the nurses saying: 'A woman should never be forced to get undressed in the presence of a man. The case of the Darlington Nurses is yet another example of women being demonised and patronised for raising legitimate concerns about single-sex spaces.' Mr Streeting was forced to wait until after April's Supreme Court ruling that the word sex in the Equality Act means biological sex before making his latest intervention row. Last month it was revealed that even before the Supreme Court ruling, the Royal College of Nursing had written to the Darlington trust saying they were acting unlawfully. The letter ordered the trust to provide single-sex changing rooms 'without delay.' Andrea Williams, chief executive of the Christian Legal Centre, said: 'A climate of fear has pervaded the system and many from top to bottom have been intimidated into silence and inaction. Equality and diversity policies have been weaponised to silence dissent and to prevent women's safety and dignity being protected in the workplace. 'We are grateful for the action from Wes Streeting and NHS England in this matter and pray that they will now quickly follow this through so that the nurses can return to the female changing rooms without delay.'
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE The NHS recoups just £29million for treating European patients... while forking out £1billion in return
The Government is failing to recoup what could amount to millions of pounds each year from European countries for treating their citizens on the NHS, The Mail on Sunday can reveal. The Department of Health and Social Care charged European nations just £29.5million last year to pay for their citizens to be treated in Britain's hospitals. Yet the UK's bill for the healthcare costs of British pensioners and holidaymakers treated in European hospitals came to nearly £1billion in the same period. Critics say it raises concerns that the Government is allowing the NHS to be 'taken for a ride' by Europe on healthcare costs. While European nations bill the Government for care provided to Britons based on hospital invoices, the MoS has learned UK officials compile bills for countries based on 'estimates' of costs incurred by the NHS to treat their citizens. Campaigners say the true figure is likely to be significantly higher. And while the NHS is failing to get the best deal possible for taxpayers – Chancellor Rachel Reeves is preparing a £30billion boost to the health service at the expense of the police and councils. The revelations come after the MoS revealed in April that hospitals in England had written off £256.4million owed by overseas visitors for NHS procedures. Alp Mehmet, chairman of Migration Watch UK, said: 'The problem lies in our total inability to monitor non-UK nationals' use of the NHS, a scandalous failure to secure payments due, and naivety when dealing with the EU which has so often taken us for a ride.' Tory MP Joe Robertson, a member of the Health and Social Care Select Committee, said: 'It beggars belief that the NHS has no record of the cost of care it provides to foreign nationals. 'Our NHS is not supposed to be a subsidised health service for the rest of Europe but plainly that's what it is becoming.' There is a 'reciprocal agreement' for healthcare in Europe, which means all citizens in the European Economic Area (EEA) are entitled to some, or all, of their healthcare needs to be paid for by their home nation when abroad. While European health systems, which usually charge upfront, are good at logging such details, the NHS is not – hence the rough estimates. The figures, which come from a Freedom of Information request by the MoS, reveal the NHS billed Spain £6.7million during 2023/24 and paid back around £441million. Some £225million went to Ireland and £186million to France – but the NHS billed just £17million and £11million in return. Germany received £10.9million and paid back £3.5million to the UK. And there are also more British visitors to Europe (63million) every year than European visitors to the UK (26million). But the gap between what the UK pays, and what it bills back, has worsened over the last decade. In 2014/15, the UK claimed back £49.7million from Europe but in 2023/24, it was £20.2million less, a drop of 40 per cent. And bills for Britons treated abroad have risen by 40 per cent, from £674.4million in 2014/15 to £948.9million last year. Mr Robertson said he had written to the Public Accounts Committee to look at this subject and 'force the Government's hand'. A Department of Health spokesman said the UK charges EU nations when their citizens use the NHS as part of a deal which ensures Britains 'can also get healthcare when visiting Europe'.
