
FRC housekeeping can help preserve classic championship
The adage "perfect is the enemy of good" was surely somewhere in Jim Gavin's Football Review Commitee philosophy.
When they set about this task, getting everything perfect the first time was always going to be impossible.
Attempting to do so would have been a huge barrier to the breakneck speed with which they executed their mission.
For someone as detail orientated as Jim Gavin appears to be, this allowance for imperfection and adapting as things develop could not have rested particularly easy.
To minimise issues, the group were exhaustive in their attempt to reason out every change and the myriad of knock-on consequences.
While the continuous tweaks during the Allianz League frustrated many, their overall success was remarkable and allowed them to put their rule amending pens away ahead of the championship.
Since then we have all got to sit back and enjoy the results of the group's labours. Drawing a direct cause and effect between the enhancements and the great championship we are experiencing to date is open to accusations of bias.
The fact that the championship is more open, that there were great games under the previous rules, and that teams are simply too inexperienced with the new rules to wrestle the game back under their control means that a definitive conclusion on the direct impact of the rules cannot be drawn.
Even the greatest contrarian would have to admit though that the coincidence of the rule changes and the quality of games we are seeing is notable. The exciting thing is that we are only reaching the stage where, over the past 10 to 20 years, the good football usually starts.
And this is the thing. We are also reaching the stage where the line in the history books are completed, a player's entire career finds their defining moment and supporters see their dreams come through.
My biggest dread over the next seven weeks is that a quirk in the rules becomes the decisive event.
Now, for me, is the perfect moment, between group stage and knockout games, for the FRC to do a bit of housekeeping.
There is much that can and will be debated as the game evolves under the new rules over the coming years, but there are things that have become evident and need to be tidied up as the outworkings which we have seen are presumably going against what the FRC envisaged.
My biggest dread over the next seven weeks is that a quirk in the rules becomes the decisive event
Most importantly for me is the rule that allows a touch by an opposition player to decrease a two-point effort's value to one.
Why is this very minor and infrequent rule the most important? The likelihood for it being game-deciding is perhaps greater than any other rule.
As we know, big games have a habit of coming down to the wire. In these scenarios, and with the hooter game in particular, teams know exactly what they or their opponent need.
If a player, at a critical moment, goes for that two-pointer and scores it, why should it be halved in value because an opposition player touches the ball?
I believe this rule came in to prevent the scenario that if a ball was dropping close to the crossbar and players jumped to assist/prevent it travelling over, it may be difficult to ascertain if it was touched and by whom or, more critically, if the touch was necessary for the ball to make it over the bar.
This type of thing is evidence of the extent to which the FRC went into the minutiae to try to avoid potential problems with its various enhancements.
The problem here is that in ensuring their rule didn't fall foul of the extremely rare scenario described, they ended up making it feel unnaturally complicated. If a touch is required to make a shot travel over the bar, then it should not be counted as a two-pointer. If an opposition player attempts to stop a shot but it still travels over, then it should count.
Moving onto the solo and go, that almost universally liked enhancement - albeit, ironically one which reduces kick passing and increasing control of possession - is almost too advantageous in some scenarios.
When a player can throw it out of the immediate location of the free kick to a team-mate taking it at full speed it is a huge advantage. We wouldn't allow a free-kick to be taken so loosely in relation to the position of the foul.
Similarly, the kick-out mark is having overly advantageous impact.
A theme to both of these is the massive impact of a 50m penalty - and the two-pointer option that carries - with any infringement against them. In combination, that gives them a game-defining ability.
Like it or not and trust me, this isn't just the Tyrone in me coming out, that means every team will be looking at playing 'smart' in such moments and drawing those 50m penalties. The thought of an All-Ireland final being decided on such would be a terrible end to a great championship.
The FRC has held its counsel for several weeks now, but I believe it's time to see Jim and his crew break out their pens for a bit of light editing.
This championship to date has been the best in 20 years. The rules have been central to that in my opinion. But, while they have defined it, it would be a real pity if they end up deciding it.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Derry still All-Ireland contenders says former All Star - but they must step up
Chrissy McKaigue insists that Derry remain All-Ireland contenders despite the woes of the past year - but says they must now step up. Paddy Tally's side face a season-defining All-Ireland series Group 4 tie with Dublin in Newry on Saturday knowing that a victory will guarantee them a spot in the knockout stages - but they haven't won a game in regulation time since beating Westmeath at the corresponding stage last year. Former Oak Leaf defender McKaigue, who announced his retirement last November, challenges the perception that Derry's showing in 2024 was disastrous, pointing out that they won the McKenna Cup and Allianz League while reaching the All-Ireland quarter-final and that he endured far worse seasons than that over the course of his lengthy innings with the county. He said: 'It was more so we didn't meet expectations. I'm not saying that everyone follows that narrative but it's amazing that narrative was depicted in so many areas and I felt Mickey Harte last year got a lot of scrutiny that was a wee bit over the top at times. 'I still feel that Derry are a contender for Sam Maguire. Maybe not this year in the same capacity as last year but do I feel that Derry squad will have the potential to be a contender for Sam Maguire in the next number of years? I do. 'I still think we're knocking there or thereabouts. I feel that the underage in Derry is really strong and you'll probably be yet to see a couple of the players that I'd be really excited about.' Having lost six and drawn one of their seven League games before losing to Donegal and Armagh in the Championship, Derry had a golden opportunity to get that elusive win over Galway last time out, though they just about scrambled a draw in the end. 'I think even the most ardent Galway supporter would say that they got out of jail with that one,' said McKaigue. 'Even with the nature of the new rules, the leads don't mean as much anymore but certainly for the vast majority of the game Derry played all the football, brought a huge amount of physicality and huge amount of intensity which is probably the first time they brought it this year to that level of consistency. 'But the worrying thing for Derry still is that they played seven games in the National League, Donegal in the Ulster Championship and now two games in the round robin. 'That's 10 games and they still haven't won a game yet. So they'd want to be clearing that one out fairly soon and the hard thing for Derry this year is all their games so far this year have been against Division One teams - that's probably a new thing in itself, so they've had a tough year from that point of view.' Tackling Dublin outside of Croke Park boosts Derry's chances on Saturday, says McKaigue, who feels that the Dubs will be very hard to beat if they get back to GAA headquarters. 'I just think Dublin will have a big say in this year's All-Ireland potentially. I hope they don't because that will mean that Derry will have been turned over. 'They're a different side without Con [O'Callaghan] too. He is their David Clifford, he is their leader, he does so much for them and gives them that composure and that settled feeling. 'I just think if there's one team that can cause you a lot of bother with the new rules in Croke Park, it's Dublin. A couple of their performances this year, like Derry in the League in Croke Park, they were awesome. They were very, very polished against Galway I thought also. 'For large parts of the game against Armagh, let's be honest, they were very impressive, bar the scoreboard. Sometimes we can get caught up in people's different analysis of the game. Armagh were worthy winners but Dublin still have a wee bit to work with.'


RTÉ News
a day ago
- RTÉ News
Burns: Moving All-Ireland finals to August on the cards
The prospect of the All-Ireland finals moving into August by 2027 and the potential reintroduction of replays for provincial finals remain live according to GAA president Jarlath Burns. The All-Ireland finals in both codes have been completed by the end of July since the split season template came into play three years ago. At the launch of this year's All-Ireland hurling championship at the Faithful Fields in Offaly yesterday, the GAA president pointed out that Croke Park was unavailable next August due to concert scheduling but said that the idea of the All-Ireland hurling and football finals moving back to the first and third weekends in August from 2027 was in the mix. And the GAA president also said he supported provincial final replays coming back on the calendar. Next year the All-Ireland SFC will have just two rounds which will save a week for the Allianz League. There will then be two weeks between the end of that competition and the start of the provincial championships. There is now also a train of thought to run the Joe MacDonagh Cup concurrently with the All-Ireland hurling championship. The nature of the match being decided on a penalty shoot-out has animated many hurling fans and administrators are now set to look at the issue of replays for provincial finals very closely in the coming weeks and months. Also speaking at the launch of the All-Ireland hurling series yesterday was Limerick playmaker Cian Lynch. The Patrickswell man wasn't aware there would be a penalty shoot-out to decide last weekend's Munster final until after extra-time. He congratulated Cork for the win but, from a personal point of view, he would prefer to see provincial finals go to a replay. "Hurling is such an instinctive game," he told RTE Sport. "It's an art form, it's an expression. Why do people play it? To let players go out and express themselves. It's because it's a 15-man game, it's a chance to have a man on the shoulder to pass the ball and keep the game moving. "But when it comes to penalties, other than the five guys and the goalie, there is the feeling of not being able to help if you're not taking a penalty. After playing 70 to 90 minutes of hurling, to have it based on standing over a penalty, that is tough. In my own mind I would maybe have another five minutes per half. Taking penalties is some responsibility, but great credit to the guys who were involved. "You would love to have another crack at it. Any team would but it's in the past now. We unfortunately didn't win. And Cork did."


RTÉ News
4 days ago
- RTÉ News
Adrian Mullen readying for another Tribal test against Galway
Kilkenny and Galway meet at Croke Park for a Leinster final on Sunday afternoon looking to see who can claim the best-two-out-of-three seasonal series between the sides. It's the third meeting of the pair in 2025 and the balance is currently, well, balanced with one win apiece. Galway gave the Cats a rare home defeat at UMPC Nowlan Park during their Allianz League encounter back in early February while the Black and Amber turned the tables on the opening week of the Leinster championship round robin stage with a commanding 12-point win at the same venue. Can Sunday's decider help split the difference? Kilkenny forward Adrian Mullen is expecting the tightest of finals. "Every game takes a life of its own," Mullen told RTÉ Sport this week. "Looking back to the league, they gave us a lesson in Nowlan Park. They won the league game, we won the round robin game – it's all to play for on Sunday. "Down through the years we've had ferocious games against Galway and there's usually not a puck of a ball between us. We're expecting the same this time around." The two counties finished with similar records after league campaigns that seemed to ask as many questions as they answered. Both won three and lost three during their six-game Division 1A campaigns although Kilkenny managed to eke out a +4 scoring difference. The Tribesmen's lopsided -24 score difference owed to a trio of heavy defeats at the hands of Cork, Limerick and Tipperary – all three, remarkably, by 12 points. Mullen, for his part, is just happy to have ticked an early seasonal objective off the list. Another provincial final reached. "Your objectives at the start of the year are to try and compete in every game and try win every game," Mullen said. "We've won a few games in the round robin, we're here in the Leinster final now and we're looking forward to Sunday." The defending provincial champs have blooded some youngsters throughout the league but some of their veteran performers have continued to stand tallest when needed most. "We're trying to blood a few of the younger lads who won the Under-20 championship a few years ago," Mullen said. "They're still trying to find their feet and it's up to a few of the experienced lads to be bringing them through and showing them the ropes. "All the lads are putting in a ferocious shift this year. You look at Huw Lawlor, Richie Reid, TJ Reid of course, all the lads putting it in – you can't ask for much more."