Greenpeace condemns Equinor-funded computer game aimed at UK schoolchildren
EnergyTown, aimed at children aged nine to 14, encourages players to build a city that will survive until 2050 by balancing energy, economy, environment and population wellbeing demands.
The game shows fossil fuels as part of a clean future energy mix, while players who start the game with a heavy reliance on renewable energy often fail to reach the mid-century milestone.
It comes as part of a school education programme launched in October 2023 by Equinor called Wonderverse, with the firm saying it has reached more than 81,400 UK pupils by the following July.
The deadline for schools to enter the 2025 nationwide EnergyTown competition is on Friday.
The Norwegian oil major, which is seeking to develop the controversial Rosebank oil field in the UK North Sea, has previously denied that the game is part of a lobbying campaign but rather the firm's ambitions to make young people curious about science and technology.
Greenpeace has fiercely criticised the game, claiming the fossil fuel company's support for the project is a 'cynical PR ploy'.
The PA News Agency has contacted Equinor for comment.
Mel Evans, head of Greenpeace UK's climate team, said: 'We know many young children know a lot about the climate crisis and what's driving it.
'If Equinor wants to win young hearts and minds, it should get serious about ditching fossil fuels and shifting to clean energy.'
Greenpeace highlighted a Wonderverse webpage that tells players how to improve their scores if their city fails before the mid-century mark.
While it says that players should think about phasing out non-renewable energy resources as the game progresses to improve its green score, they are also advised to invest in 'more reliable' fossil fuels, nuclear and hydrogen to power their cities.
It notes: 'If you're relying on electricity from renewable energy resources like wind and solar power, you may have less electricity due to these energy resources being less reliable.
'Therefore, your other facilities (such as the businesses and recreational tiles) may struggle to run.'
The page later adds: 'You should invest in a more reliable way to generate electricity, such as nuclear, oil, natural gas or hydrogen.
'It is important to consider that this may negatively impact your green score,' it adds. 'You should think about how you can phase out non-renewable energy resources as you progress later in the game.'
Last July, the nationwide EnergyTown competition saw 160 children take part and an 11-year-old boy in Walmley Junior School, Birmingham, win the primary school level contest.
In a statement at the time, Sue Falch-Lovesey, Equinor's UK Head of Social Value, said the competition 'showed a good level of understanding of the variety of energy sources our cities of the future will need'.
Greenpeace highlighted how Birmingham was hit by flash floods a week after the energy firm published the press release on its website.
Ms Evans said: 'Thanks to companies like Equinor, these children are living in homes with higher energy bills; living through summers of wildfires and droughts, and winters of increasingly worse flooding.
'The UK government should stop Rosebank, and should instead invest in the wind industry in the regions where workers and communities need to transition.'
After the regulator granted approval for Equinor to develop Rosebank in 2023, the Scottish Court of Session ruled the decision as unlawful in January this year.
Equinor is expected to reapply for its consent to drill at Rosebank once the Government's revised guidance on emissions produced by burning oil and gas is released.
EnergyTown was developed for the Equinor programme by the marketing agency We Are Futures, which has worked for other high-emitting firms like BP.
In a statement, Equinor said: 'The overall intention and aim for Wonderverse and EnergyTown is to provide schools and teachers with a suite of high-quality resources to help students learn more about where energy comes from, whilst building science subject affinity and the employability skills needed to successfully enter employment.'
The company said the programme has been awarded a green tick by the Association for Science Education, assuring the programme's quality for use in schools, and the game used data from the International Energy Agency to ensure the scenarios are realistic and representative of the UK's current energy system.
'The path to 2050 is complex,' it said.
'The game is designed to reflect this complexity and using the real-world data the game is based on, shows the energy transition is about balance, requiring a mix of sources over time.
'The development of the game is part of Equinor's ordinary activities and programmes to stimulate the interest in science and technology (STEM) among young people, and not developed as part of any Rosebank campaign.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
Planned AI datacentre in England could cause five times emissions of big airport
A vast new datacentre to feed Britain's rising demand for artificial intelligence could cause more greenhouse gas emissions than five international airports. Elsham datacentre in Lincolnshire is on course to cost £10bn and its 15 power-hungry computer warehouses are projected to release five times the carbon dioxide of Birmingham airport, including from take-offs and landings. A planning application for the facility nine miles east of Scunthorpe was submitted last month and a public consultation closes in three weeks. Documents estimate the datacentre would consume 3.7bn kWh of energy, with annual CO2 emissions of 857,254 tonnes when running at full tilt. This is based on the current mix of energy sources powering the National Grid. The datacentre will also create so much excess heat that glasshouses are being proposed with capacity to produce more than 10 tonnes of tomatoes a day. Global tech firms are struggling to meet their carbon-cutting goals. By 2030, carbon dioxide emissions from AI datacentres will be six times the 2023 level, according to research by the Öko-Institut in Germany. Greenpeace has called for commensurate renewable energy capacity to be added to national grids at the same time as new datacentres are built. Microsoft recently admitted that five years after it committed to becoming zero carbon by 2030, its total emissions had risen by 23% due to factors including AI expansion. This week Meta signed a 20-year deal with a nuclear power station in Illinois, while Amazon and Google are also investing in nuclear energy to fuel the race for AI dominance. Datacentres are needed to train AI models and run AI searches, which are now routinely offered to billions of people by Google and Meta and which require four to five times more computing power, according to estimates. Climate experts believe AI could help the fight against global warming by making power grids work more efficiently or accelerating the development of new zero-carbon technologies. Martha Dark, a co-executive director of Foxglove, a non-profit organisation based in London campaigning for 'a fairer tech future', said the Elsham planning application put two key UK government missions on collision course. 'The prime minister has talked up datacentres powering generative AI as the magic beans to miraculously sprout Britain's withered economy into life but also made a promise at the election to get toxic pollution out of our air and deliver net zero by 2050,' she said. 'It's decision time: does the government want an economic plan that's best for Britain, or one that's best for Amazon, Google and Meta?' Planning documents state: 'Elsham Tech Park Ltd will endeavour to purchase green power for the facility, where possible.' The backers believe CO2 emissions could be lower than the 850,000 tonnes a year figure if the National Grid becomes greener by the time the datacentre is due to be switched on in 2029. The developer has ruled out on-site renewables as impractical. If the system ran on biomass energy it would require the daily delivery of 100 large lorry loads of wood chips. Wind energy would require 10,000 20-metre wind turbines, while an area five times the size of the Glastonbury festival site would be needed if it were to be powered by photovoltaic panels. Sign up to Down to Earth The planet's most important stories. Get all the week's environment news - the good, the bad and the essential after newsletter promotion A government spokesperson said it was 'alert to the power demands which will drive AI development' and it would use 'responsible, sustainable sources', with advanced modular reactors, which create nuclear power, playing 'a particularly important role'. 'We're shaking up the planning rules to make it easier to build nuclear power stations across the country,' the spokesperson said. Peter Kyle, the secretary of state for science and technology, has called datacentres 'the engines of the AI age', and the government has said it is targeting a 'rapid build-out' to boost the UK's capacity for building and running AI models. Last month the deputy prime minister, Angela Rayner, overruled a local council that had rejected a plan for a £1bn datacentre at Abbots Langley in Hertfordshire, citing the 'clear and pressing need for new datacentre capacity'. Robert Waltham, the leader of North Lincolnshire council, which covers Elsham, said: 'You have to be aware of the management of resources but we also have to have significant investment in the UK, and AI is contributing to health and supporting the most vulnerable people. This is not just about Google search – AI is improving medical science and our productivity.' He cited the example of how the council was deploying AI chatbots to help older people stay on top of their medicines, enabling them to stay at home longer rather than moving into residential care. A spokesperson for Greystoke, which owns Elsham Tech Park Ltd, said the project would create 900 jobs. 'The region is an ideal location for AI datacentres due to the significant investment already made in developing the UK's most advanced clean energy cluster,' they said. 'It has access to a third of the UK's offshore wind energy as well as access to 66% of the UK's licensed carbon capture and storage.'
Scotsman
a day ago
- Scotsman
Warning over classroom game accused of 'brainwashing' UK schoolchildren
Campaigners have accused the educational game of targeting children with 'propaganda' 💻 Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... EnergyTown is an online city builder game aimed at helping UK schools teach pupils about the energy system It is funded by energy giant Equinor, and hosts yearly school competitions Materials associated with the game describe renewable energy sources as 'less reliable' Climate campaigners accuse it of targeting children with fossil fuel propaganda But Equinor says the game demonstrates how the green energy transition is about balance Environment campaigners have sounded the alarm over a free online game being marketed to UK schoolchildren - which they say is designed to make them feel more positively about fossil fuels. EnergyTown is funded by Norwegian energy giant Equinor. Aimed at children aged nine to 14, it comes with free educational resources to be used in lessons. It allows them to build and power a city that will survive until the year 2050 - while juggling factors like their 'green score', community happiness, and finances. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The game first launched in October 2023, and as of last year, Equinor said that it had reached more than 81,400 pupils across the UK. The game also holds a schools competition with a £1,000 cash prize, with this year's event set to close on Friday (June 6). But Greenpeace accuses it of being an attempt to 'brainwash schoolchildren'. The game suggests that oil can be part of a green energy mix, and in an online help page - titled 'how to improve your score in EnergyTown - on the game's Equinor-funded host site, it warns young players that renewable energy is 'less reliable'. The EnergyTown game is marketed towards UK schoolchildren, and funded by energy giant Equinor | (Image: National World/Adobe Stock/Getty/AFP via Getty) 'If you're relying on electricity from renewable energy resources like wind and solar power, you may have less electricity due to these energy resources being less reliable,' the page says. 'You should invest in a more reliable way to generate electricity, such as nuclear, oil, natural gas or hydrogen.' Equinor is also the majority owner of the controversial Rosebank oil and gas field development, 80 miles west of Shetland, which is thought to be the largest untapped oilfield in UK waters. In January this year, its consent was quashed by the Scottish Court of Session as unlawful, the BBC reports, meaning its owners must seek fresh approval from the UK Government before they begin extracting oil. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad But the project has been widely protested by campaigners, who say that new oil and gas projects are not compatible with the UK's climate commitments. 'We know exactly what Equinor is playing at,' Mel Evans, the head of Greenpeace UK's climate team, said. 'This so-called educational game is a thinly-disguised attempt to greenwash oil and gas by targeting children with fossil fuel propaganda. The bitter irony is that while fossil fuels may help build a 'sustainable' energy future in the game's fictional world, they're driving more devastating floods in some of these schoolkids' communities,' she continued. 'For that reason alone, this cynical PR ploy is doomed to fail. We know many young children know a lot about the climate crisis and what's driving it. If Equinor wants to win young hearts and minds, it should get serious about ditching fossil fuels and shifting to clean energy.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Equinor spokesperson Magnus Frantzen Eidsvold told us that the game was part of Equinor's ordinary activities and programs 'to stimulate the interest in science and technology (STEM) among young people, and not developed as part of any Rosebank campaign'. 'Equinor wants to contribute to ensuring the next generation is equipped with the skills needed to drive the energy industry and transition forward,' he continued. The game had been developed using data from the International Energy Agency (IEA), which verified the scenarios used in EnergyTown to 'ensure they are realistic and representative of the UK's current energy system'. The game was designed to reflect this complexity and showed that the energy transition was about balance, he added, requiring a mix of sources over time. 'The IEA forecast that fossil fuels may be required in 2050 especially in areas where renewables alone can't meet demand. EnergyTown is not about endorsing any one solution, rather it's about equipping the next generation with knowledge to make better decisions.' The game was developed by marketing agency We Are Futures, and was quality-asserted for UK schoolchildren by the Association for Science Education (ASE). We have approached both organisations for comment. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
Endangered sharks being killed at alarming levels in Pacific, Greenpeace claims, after cutting 20km of vessel's longline
Endangered sharks are being killed at alarming levels in the Pacific and industrial fishing is putting marine biodiversity at increasing risk, Greenpeace has claimed, after its activists disrupted a Spanish vessel operating north of New Zealand. The campaign group said activists on the Rainbow Warrior this week observed a longline fishing operation by the Playa Zahara in the South Fiji Basin. Georgia Whitaker, a senior campaigner with Greenpeace Australia Pacific, was on board during the operation. She claimed the activists watched as the vessel hauled in and killed three endangered mako sharks in half an hour. She said a small crew, including a trained shark handler, boarded a support boat to approach the Spanish vessel and released 14 animals caught on its line – among them eight near-threatened blue sharks, four swordfish and an endangered longfin mako shark. The activists also removed more than 210 hooks and 20km of longline. 'It was devastating seeing these beautiful creatures being caught, often on their gills, in their mouth, by huge baited hooks,' Whitaker said. 'They were fighting for their lives and then minutes later you'd see blood spilling over the side of the boat.' Whitaker said the vessel's crew told Greenpeace they were acting legally and primarily targeting swordfish. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email According to the European Union's reporting to the Western and Central Pacific Fisheries Commission (WCPFC), the Playa Zahara caught more than 600,000kg of blue shark in 2023 in the Pacific Southwest. Patricia Rodríguez, a spokesperson for Viverdreams Fish, the company that owns Playa Zahara, said in a statement the boat acted in accordance with international law and capturing species such as the mako shark and blue shark was not prohibited. 'The species mentioned by Greenpeace are within the quotas and limits allowed by the competent authorities, and the capture, handling and unloading procedures are controlled and documented, by all the systems established by the EU and Spanish authorities,' Rodríguez said. The statement accused Greenpeace of 'a campaign of disinformation', violating maritime laws, stealing the fishing gear and posing risks to crews on both vessels by its intervention. 'Our company is strongly committed to the sustainability of marine resources and regularly collaborates with scientists, independent observers and fisheries authorities to ensure compliance with conservation standards,' she said. A Greenpeace analysis has estimated that almost half a million blue sharks were caught as bycatch in the Pacific Ocean last year – the highest number recorded since 1991. The same report found nearly 70% of EU longline catches in the region in 2023 were blue sharks. World leaders will meet in Nice next week for the UN ocean conference to discuss the high seas biodiversity treaty, which Australia signed in 2023 but is yet to ratify. Greenpeace has urged the government to ratify the treaty within the first 100 days of its second term. The treaty requires 60 countries to ratify it before it comes into force, but as yet only 32 have done so. Shark fishing is a lucrative global trade, worth an estimated $1bn annually. Global demand for shark meat has doubled in the past two decades. Dr Leonardo Guida, a shark scientist with the Australian Marine Conservation Society, said the level of exploitation was alarming, given more than one-third of shark and ray species are threatened with extinction globally. 'Sharks are important in the ecosystem, they typically occupy the top of marine food webs,' he said. 'Steep population declines will cause food webs to potentially become unstable and ultimately collapse, there is a clear impact their loss could have on food security for a lot of nations.' Guida said the creation of no-take marine sanctuaries was essential – to preserve marine life and to understand how ecosystems respond to the combined pressures of overfishing and the climate crisis. 'These sanctuaries act as controls,' he said. 'They help us compare areas impacted by fishing with those that are not, which is critical to building resilience in ocean wildlife and managing our fisheries in a rapidly changing world, such that we reduce our impact on different species.'
