'Lost opportunity' — Jamus Lim weighs in on books from Yale-NUS College bagged for disposal
SINGAPORE: Workers' Party (WP) Member of Parliament Jamus Lim commented on an issue concerning books from the library of Yale-NUS College, hundreds of which were allegedly marked for recycling or disposal on May 20 (Tuesday).
The college is closing this year, with its final commencement having taken place last week. However, the outcry from students and alumni over the disposal of the books has resulted in an apology from the university.
The WP MP, an academic, weighing in through a social media post, said that he had learned at an early age from his mother to treat books with respect.
'As a child, my mother routinely warned me never to sit on books. The logic, according to her, was that books were an embodiment of knowledge. To sit on them would be to disrespect knowledge itself, an affront to the value and wisdom they carried. Till today, I still won't sit on a book, or even to treat it carelessly,' he wrote.
As both Assoc Prof Lim and his wife, a writer, are 'stout-hearted bibliophiles,' he added that it had been distressing for them to hear about the Yale-NUS Library books being 'unceremoniously discarded on a sidewalk, before they would then be shredded by a recycling service.'
He called it 'at the very least, like a lost opportunity,' citing reports that said when students who saw the books wanted to take them home, they were not allowed to do so. He also cited Steve Levitt and Stephen Dubner's book Freakonomics, which describes how 'the mere presence of books is associated with a child's success at school,' which other studies have corroborated.
'More generally, the whole sorry episode strikes me as yet another instance of how top-down decisions, made without widespread consultation with diverse stakeholders, can lead to undesirable outcomes. That's why advanced societies do best when they embrace the messiness and uncertainty of democratic processes, because the result, while still unlikely to satisfy everybody, may at least avert the most egregious missteps,' Assoc Prof Lim added. See also PSP expels member for offensive post against religion
He linked a change.org petition from Yale-NUS College alumni regarding the books that calls for clarity on the issue.
On Wednesday (May 21), Associate Professor Natalie Pang, University Librarian of NUS, was quoted in CNA as saying that excess books are either brought to other libraries or given away. Those that are not taken are recycled, a common practice with libraries.
The excess books from the Yale-NUS College Library were only offered to faculty and not to students.
'We understand later that many students were interested in having these books, and we would have usually acceded to their requests. We did not do so on this occasion and we apologise for the operational lapse,' she said, adding that a campus giveaway for the books is now being organised. /TISG
Read also: Unhappiness still being expressed over closure of Yale-NUS, despite assurances from Chan Chun Sing, MOE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
Chinese parents, students shift overseas education focus away from US amid geopolitical tensions
SHANGHAI: As six-year-old Sunny Zhao devours his lunch of fried rice, he watches an educational cartoon about cats in English. His mother Yoyo Zhang is right beside him, eager to help her child to master the language. "Be it Europe, the Americas, Japan, Southeast Asia, you can use English as a form of communication,' said the Chinese national, who works as a nurse. 'English is a widely used language so I hope he can learn English well. Be it for future work, travelling, or other activities, English will always be very important,' she told CNA. Only a small fraction of citizens in China can speak English fluently, despite students having to study it as a compulsory school subject. This means those proficient in the language will have a competitive advantage over their peers. Hence, parents like Ms Zhang have long sought out Western English-speaking countries – especially the United States – when looking to send their children overseas for education. But with geopolitical tensions and diplomatic upheavals in recent years, a subtle shift seems to be occurring – parents are more open to exploring options in other continents, such as Asia, for school. FALLING ENROLMENT IN US SCHOOLS According to a 2024 paper released this year by an agency under China's education ministry, the proportion of Chinese citizens returning with overseas university degrees from Asia between 2020 and 2023 rose from 21.61 per cent to 31.35 per cent. During that same period, the proportion of those returning from North America dropped from 25.62 per cent to 18.73 per cent. Chinese students have also been the target of US President Donald Trump since he returned to the White House in January, prompting many to rethink their higher education plans in America. Official data showed that nearly 280,000 students from China made up a quarter of all international enrolments in the US last year. Last month, the Trump administration moved to block Harvard University from enrolling international students and issued new measures targeting Chinese nationals, who made up a fifth of Harvard's foreign student intake in 2024. On Wednesday (Jun 4), Trump escalated his dispute with the Ivy League school by signing a proclamation to suspend international visas for new foreign students for an initial six months. A court has temporarily blocked the ban. As Sino-US ties worsen, concerns over safety have also emerged both in America and elsewhere in the West. Chinese student Rika Li, who speaks fluent English, had completed a year of undergraduate studies in the Canadian city of Montreal when she was assaulted in broad daylight about seven years ago. 'After that, I just didn't feel safe anymore living alone there. It left me with a kind of mental trauma,' she said. The 24-year-old, who became more proficient in English when she moved to Toronto for high school, then relocated to Japan to continue her university studies despite barely knowing how to speak Japanese. Ms Zhang also selected an Asian country for her son Sunny Zhao. Despite the boy's interest in ice hockey, she decided against sending him to North America where the sport is most popular. He is now enrolled in an international school in Singapore. 'We learned about Singapore from friends, and we also have relatives and friends living there,' said Ms Zhang on her decision. 'The living environment in Singapore is very suitable. It's beautiful; it's a garden city. And the educational environment there is also excellent.' INSPIRATION FOR FOREIGN EDUCATION CENTRES In fact, Singapore's system inspired some foreign education outfits in China to seize the business opportunity and attract students through its classes. For example, Shanghai-based One Academy teaches science and mathematics in English, based on Singapore's curriculum. Many of its students are enrolled there due to what their parents see as a way to stay ahead of the academic rat race in China. One Academy's co-founder Chow Chin Wei noted that last year, only about 1.5 per cent of Chinese students – or about 240,000 students – who took the notoriously tough gaokao (college entrance) examinations got into the top universities in China. 'The other 40 per cent go to the normal universities in China. So basically, you are looking at about 60 per cent that go … on the vocational route for these people. So, it's actually very competitive,' said Chow, a Singaporean who has lived in China for 14 years. His fellow co-founder Algene Tan added that many parents also worry about their children's job prospects. Currently, about three in 20 youths in China aged between 16 and 24 are unemployed. '(Parents) want the best for their child … Some of them might even, in their words, want to change the stars for their child,' Tan said. 'So a lot of them, from the get-go, they will start to tell us I'm sending my kid overseas.' To prepare her son for an English curriculum in Singapore, Ms Zhang enrolled her son into a mathematics enrichment class at One Academy. She said she sees vast benefits in studying abroad and becoming more fluent in English. 'Even in supermarkets, many product descriptions are in English,' she pointed out.
CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
Thai military prepared for 'high-level operation' if Cambodia border row escalates
BANGKOK: Thailand's military said it is ready to launch a "high-level operation" to counter any violation of its sovereignty, in the strongest words yet in a simmering border dispute with Cambodia that re-erupted with a deadly clash last week. The army said in a statement late on Thursday (Jun 5) that its intelligence gathering indicated Cambodia had increased military readiness at the border while diplomatic efforts were ongoing, describing that as "worrisome". Thai Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra held a meeting of the National Security Council on Friday and said that while the military was ready to defend Thai sovereignty, it understood the situation and when an escalation would be required. "The military has confirmed readiness for any scenario," she said. "But any clash will cause damage, so we will pursue peaceful means." "The government and military are working together, supporting each other," Paetongtarn added. The two governments had for days exchanged carefully worded statements committing to dialogue after a brief skirmish in an undemarcated border area on May 28 in which a Cambodian soldier was killed. Ahead of Friday's meeting, the army had said it was "now ready for a high-level military operation in case it is necessary to retaliate". "Operations of units at the border have been conducted carefully, calmly and based on an understanding of the situation to prevent losses on all sides, but at the same time, are ready to defend the country's sovereignty to the fullest extent if the situation is called for." Cambodia's government did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the Thai military statement on Friday. HISTORIC RIVALRY Although the two neighbours have a historic rivalry, their governments enjoy friendly ties, partly due to the close relationship between their influential former leaders, Thailand's Thaksin Shinawatra and Cambodia's Hun Sen, whose daughter and son respectively are now the prime ministers in their countries. The issue comes at a tricky time for the Pheu Thai Party-led administration in Thailand as it battles to revive a flagging economy that could be hit by steep US tariffs, while facing a challenge to its popularity having paused a signature cash handout to tens of millions of people. The party of the billionaire Shinawatra family has a troubled history with the Thai military, which twice toppled its governments in 2006 and 2014 coups. After Friday's security meeting, Thai armed forces chief Songwit Noonpackdee said the military supported the government's approach to settling the dispute peacefully. Defence Minister Phumtham Wechayachai said that in a meeting on Thursday with his Cambodian counterpart, Thia Saya, they discussed avoiding violence and proceeding with caution. He said he proposed that both sides retreat to positions previously agreed in 2024. Deadly clashes between Cambodia and Thailand last erupted in 2011 over the Preah Vihear, a 900-year-old temple at the heart of a decades-long row that has stirred nationalist sentiment on both sides. The International Court of Justice in 2013 ruled in favour of Cambodia in clarifying a 1962 decision to award it jurisdiction over the temple. Cambodia said this week it would refer disputes over four parts of the border to the ICJ and has asked Thailand to cooperate. Thailand says it does not recognise the court's jurisdiction.
CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
Stocks on guard for payrolls, Tesla tumbles as Trump-Musk bromance sours
SYDNEY :Asian shares slipped on Friday as investors hunkered down for the all-important U.S. payrolls report, while Tesla suffered huge losses on the very public feud between President Donald Trump and billionaire Elon Musk. A run of soft economic data this week has markets wary of a downside surprise in the monthly payrolls print due later in the day, which would add to fears of stagflation while piling pressure on the Federal Reserve to ease policy in a hurry. Tesla shares bounced 0.8 per cent in after-hours trading after tumbling a whopping 14 per cent overnight to wipe off $150 billion in market value. That came after Trump threatened to cut off government contracts to Elon Musk's companies as the once close relationship turned into a bitter open disagreement. There were signs that tempers may be cooling a bit, with Trump telling Politico that "it's okay" when asked about the relationship and that White House aides had scheduled a call on Friday with Musk to broker a peace. Nasdaq futures rose 0.3 per cent and S&P 500 futures gained 0.4 per cent, while the losses in European stock futures narrowed, with EUROSTOXX 50 futures down just 0.1 per cent. MSCI's broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan slipped 0.2 per cent on Friday away from its eight-month peak. It is still set for a weekly rise of 2.1 per cent. Chinese blue chips eased 0.2 per cent and Hong Kong's Hang Seng dropped 0.5 per cent as a call between Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping offered little clarity to ease ongoing trade tensions. "I think the fact that they are talking, the fact that there is a willingness to find a way through and the channels of communication are open is a positive," said Luke Yeaman, chief economist at the Commonwealth Bank of Australia. "But I think it's clear that there are still a lot of tensions in the relationship and that neither side wants to give too much away… There's not a lot of goodwill to work with to fundamentally improve the trade relationship." Most Asian shares are down slightly, but Japan's Nikkei is a rare bright spot in Asia, up 0.4 per cent, helping trim its weekly drop to 0.7 per cent. WAIT FOR PAYROLLS Weaker-than-expected labour market data, including a 47 per cent year-on-year jump in Challenger layoffs and a significant downside surprise in ADP's private payrolls, have dampened expectations for the payrolls report. Forecasts are centred on a rise of 130,000 jobs in May, with the unemployment rate holding steady at 4.2 per cent. Any unexpected weakness could bring the next U.S. rate cut forward and trigger a huge rally in Treasuries. Futures imply scant chances of a rate cut until September, which is about 93 per cent priced in, with another move likely to come in December. Yields on the benchmark ten-year Treasuries were flat at 4.3887 per cent, having risen 3 basis points overnight to bounce away from a one-month low. "We expect payrolls to lose additional momentum in May, printing a below-consensus 110,000," said analysts at TD Securities in a note to clients. "Markets have recently been singularly focused on tariffs and deficits, with macro taking a back seat in recent weeks. Our forecast may not be sufficient to catalyze this revamped focus on macro, but we expect downside surprises to generate a larger market reaction." The dollar was 0.2 per cent higher against its major peers on Friday just a touch above a six-week low as soft economic data dent the U.S. currency. The euro hit a six-week top of $1.1495 overnight after the European Central Bank cut rates but signaled that it was nearing the end of its year-long policy easing cycle. Investors have given up on a move in July, with the final move most likely to come in October or December. In commodities markets, oil prices were slightly lower but were headed for weekly gains on supply concerns. U.S. crude futures slipped 0.4 per cent to $63.12 a barrel but were up 3.8 per cent for the week. In precious metals, gold prices climbed 0.4 per cent to $3,366.78 an ounce. For the week, they are up 2.3 per cent.
