Walking with dinosaurs: Mystery of Pachyrhinosaurus mass grave in Canada
Hidden beneath the slopes of a lush forest in Alberta, Canada, is a mass grave on a monumental scale.Thousands of dinosaurs were buried here, killed in an instant on a day of utter devastation.Now, a group of palaeontologists have come to Pipestone Creek - appropriately nicknamed the "River of Death" - to help solve a 72-million-year-old enigma: how did they die?Trying to work out exactly what happened here starts with the hefty strike of a sledgehammer.Brute force is needed to crack open the thick layer of rock that covers what Professor Emily Bamforth, who's leading the dig, describes as "palaeo gold".As her team begins the more delicate job of removing the layers of dirt and dust, a jumble of fossilised bones slowly begins to emerge.
"That big blob of bone right there is, we think, part of a hip," Prof Bamforth says, watched on by her dog Aster - whose job today is to bark if she spots any nearby bears."Then here, we have all of these long, skinny bones. These are all ribs. And this is a neat one - it's part of a toe bone. This one here, we have no idea what it is - it's a great example of a Pipestone Creek mystery."BBC News has come to Pipestone Creek to witness the sheer scale of this prehistoric graveyard and see how researchers are piecing together the clues.Thousands of fossils have been collected from the site, and are constantly generating new discoveries.
The bones all belong to a dinosaur called Pachyrhinosaurus. The species, and Prof Bamforth's excavation, feature in a new landmark BBC series - Walking With Dinosaurs - which uses visual effects and science to bring this prehistoric world to life.These animals, which lived during the Late Cretaceous period, were a relative of the Triceratops. Measuring about five metres long and weighing two tonnes, the four-legged beasts had large heads, adorned with a distinctive bony frill and three horns. Their defining feature was a big bump on the nose called a boss.The dig season has just started and lasts each year until autumn. The fossils in the small patch of ground that the team are working on are incredibly tightly packed; Prof Bamforth estimates there are up to 300 bones in every square metre. So far, her team has excavated an area the size of a tennis court, but the bed of bones extends for a kilometre into the hillside."It's jaw dropping in terms of its density," she tells us."It is, we believe, one of the largest bone beds in North America."More than half of the known dinosaur species in the world are described from a single specimen. We have thousands of Pachyrhinosaurus here."
Palaeontologists believe the dinosaurs were migrating together in a colossal herd for hundreds of miles from the south - where they had spent the winter - to the north for the summer.The area, which had a much warmer climate than it does today, would have been covered in rich vegetation, providing abundant food for this enormous group of plant-eating animals."It is a single community of a single species of animal from a snapshot in time, and it's a huge sample size. That almost never happens in the fossil record," says Prof Bamforth.
Bigger beasts offering clues
And this patch of north-western Alberta wasn't just home to Pachyrhinosaurus. Even bigger dinosaurs roamed this land, and studying them is essential to try and understand this ancient ecosystem.Two hours drive away, we reach the Deadfall Hills. Getting there involves a hike through dense forest, wading - or doggy-paddling in the case of Aster - across a fast-running river, and clambering over slippery rocks.No digging is required here; super-sized bones lie next to the shoreline, washed out from the rock and cleaned by the flowing water, just waiting to be picked up.A huge vertebra is quickly spotted, as are bits of ribs and teeth scattered across the mud.
Palaeontologist Jackson Sweder is particularly interested in what looks like a chunk of dinosaur skull. "Most of what we find here is a duck-billed dinosaur called Edmontosaurus. If this is a skull bone, this is a dinosaur that's large - probably 30ft (10m) long," he says.The Edmontosaurus, another herbivore, roamed the forests like the Pachyrhinosaurus - and is helping palaeontologists build up a picture of this ancient land.Sweder is the collection manager at the Philip J Currie Dinosaur Museum in nearby Grande Prairie, where the bones from both of these giants are taken to be cleaned up and analysed. He is currently working on a huge Pachyrhinosaurus skull that's about 1.5m long and has been nicknamed "Big Sam".
He points to where the three horns should be at the top of the frill, but the one in the middle is missing. "All the skulls that are decently complete have a spike in that spot," he says. "But its nice little unicorn spike doesn't seem to be there."Throughout years working at the extraordinary site, the museum team has collected 8,000 dinosaur bones, and the surfaces of the lab are covered in fossils; there are bones from Pachyrhinosaurus of every size, from young to old.Having material from so many animals allows researchers to learn about dinosaur biology, answering questions about how the species grows and the make-up of the community. They can also look at individual variations, to see how one Pachyrhinosaurus could stand out from the herd – as may be the case with Big Sam and his missing spike.
A sudden devastating event
All of this detailed research, in the museum and at the two sites, is helping the team to answer the vital question: how did so many animals in Pipestone Creek die at the same time?"We believe that this was a herd on a seasonal migration that got tangled up in some catastrophic event that effectively wiped out, if not the entire herd, then a good proportion of it," Prof Bamforth says.All the evidence suggests that this catastrophic event was a flash flood - perhaps a storm over the mountains that sent an unstoppable torrent of water towards the herd, ripping trees from their roots and shifting boulders. Prof Bamforth says the Pachyrhinosaurus wouldn't have stood a chance. "These animals are not able to move very fast because of their sheer numbers, and they're very top heavy - and really not very good at swimming at all."Rocks found at the site show the swirls of sediment from the fast-flowing water churning everything up. It's as if the destruction is frozen in time as a wave in the stone.
But this nightmare day for the dinosaurs is now a dream for palaeontologists."We know, every time we come here, it's 100% guaranteed we'll find bones. And every year we discover something new about the species," says Prof Bamforth."That's why we keep coming back, because we're still finding new things."As the team packs up their tools ready to return another day, they know there's a lot of work ahead. They've only just scratched the surface of what's here - and there are many more prehistoric secrets just waiting to be revealed.The new series of Walking With Dinosaurs starts on Sunday 25 May at 18:25 BST on BBC One, with all episodes available on BBC iPlayer.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
21 hours ago
- The Guardian
Canadian infant born prematurely and with measles dies
A Canadian infant who was born prematurely and had measles has died, officials said on Thursday without confirming a cause of death, raising heightened concern about the virus's resurgence. Canada has recorded 2,755 measles cases – including 2,429 confirmed and 326 probable – according to federal health data updated on 2 June. The epicenter of the outbreak is the province of Ontario, where nearly 2,000 cases have been reported. Ontario's chief medical officer of health, Kieran Moore, said in a statement 'the infant contracted the virus before birth from their mother, who had not received the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine'. 'While measles may have been a contributing factor in both the premature birth and death, the infant also faced other serious medical complications unrelated to the virus,' he added. In March, Moore said the outbreak was 'disproportionately affecting some Mennonite, Amish, and other Anabaptist communities', partly due to lower rates of vaccination among those populations. If measles is confirmed as the cause of the infant's death, it would mark the first fatality linked to the current outbreak. After Ontario, the next hardest hit area is the western province of Alberta, with 632 confirmed cases, according to the federal data. Measles is a highly contagious respiratory virus spread through droplets when an infected person coughs, sneezes or simply breathes. Known for its characteristic rash, it poses a serious risk to unvaccinated individuals, including infants under 12 months who are not ordinarily eligible for vaccination, and those with weakened immune systems. It can lead to severe complications, including pneumonia, brain swelling, premature birth and in rare cases, death. Before widespread immunization programs were introduced in the early 1970s, hundreds died each year from the virus in Canada. It was considered eradicated in 1998, but cases continue to occur due to spread from other countries. The US is also confronting a significant measles resurgence, with a vaccine-skeptical Mennonite Christian community straddling the Texas-New Mexico border hit particularly hard. Donald Trump's health secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr has undermined confidence in the MMR vaccine – a highly effective shot he has falsely claimed is dangerous and contains fetal debris.
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
Weight loss drugs linked to higher risk of eye damage in diabetic patients
Weight loss drugs could at least double the risk of diabetic patients developing age-related macular degeneration, a large-scale study has found. Originally developed for diabetes patients, glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonist (GLP-1 RA) medicines have transformed how obesity is treated and there is growing evidence of wider health benefits. They help reduce blood sugar levels, slow digestion and reduce appetite. But a study by Canadian scientists published in Jama Ophthalmology has found that after six months of use GLP-1 RAs are associated with double the risk of older people with diabetes developing neovascular age-related macular degeneration compared with similar patients not taking the drugs. Academics at the University of Toronto examined medical data for more than 1 million Ontario residents with a diagnosis of diabetes and identified 46,334 patients with an average age of 66 who were prescribed GLP-1 RAs. Nearly all (97.5%) were taking semaglutide, while 2.5% were on lixisenatide. The study did not exclude any specific brand of drugs, but since Wegovy was only approved in Canada in November 2021, primarily for weight loss, it is likely the bulk of semaglutide users in the study were taking Ozempic, which is prescribed for diabetes. Each patient on semaglutide or lixisenatide was matched with two patients who also had diabetes but were not taking the drugs, who shared similar characteristics such as age, gender and health conditions. The researchers then compared how many patients developed neovascular age-related macular degeneration over three years. The study found that those who had been taking semaglutide or lixisenatide for at least six months had twice the risk of developing macular degeneration, compared with similar patients who were not taking the drugs. Patients who had been taking GLP-1s for more than 30 months had more than three times the risk. Diabetic patients who were older and/or had had a stroke had an even higher risk of developing macular degeneration if they were on these drugs, the authors found. Marko Popovic, a co-author of the study and physician in the department of ophthalmology and vision sciences at the University of Toronto, said: 'GLP-1 receptor agonists appear to have multiple effects on the eye, and in the case of neovascular age-related macular degeneration the overall impact may be harmful. 'Based on our data, I would advise exercising particular caution when prescribing GLP-1 receptor agonists to older [diabetic] patients or those with a history of stroke, as both groups were found to have an even higher risk of developing [the condition].' In an accompanying editorial, Brian VanderBeek, an associate professor of ophthalmology at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, said the findings suggested that large numbers of patients could be affected. 'This suggests as many as one in 1,000 GLP-1 RA users could progress to new age-related macular degenaration over unexposed patients: if this risk was carried over millions of users, those affected could end up being a sizable group of patients,' he said. VanderBeek said work needed to be done to determine if this only affects patients with diabetes or if those taking these drugs for weight management or other indications are similarly at risk. 'While certainly not outweighing the good these medications offer, prescribing physicians need to keep in mind the real and serious ocular adverse events that may occur.' A spokesperson for Novo Nordisk, which manufactures Ozempic and Wegovy, said: 'Patient safety is our top priority and we take any report about an adverse event related to the use of our medicines very seriously. We work closely with authorities and regulatory bodies from around the world to continuously monitor the safety profile of our products. 'These medicines have been extensively examined in Novo Nordisk's robust clinical development programs, including randomised controlled trials, which to date have not shown any observable treatment difference compared to placebo for macular degeneration or age-related macular degeneration. Therefore, Novo Nordisk does not conclude a causal relationship between GLP-1 RA use, semaglutide and age-related macular degeneration at this time.' Dr Alison Cave, the chief safety officer of the MHRA, a UK watchdog, said: 'Macular degeneration is not currently listed as a potential side-effect of these medicines. However, we keep the safety of these medicines under close review, including emerging evidence from scientific publications, and will take appropriate action where necessary. On the basis of the current evidence, the benefits of GLP-1 RAs outweigh the potential risks when used for the licensed indications.'
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
Nine ways to avoid food poisoning: microbiologists' tips for safe, healthy eating
Do you use the same kitchen sponge for days on end? Let your takeout pizza languish on the counter overnight? We all have questionable kitchen habits – but when it comes to food safety, shortcuts we think of as harmless can open the door to dangerous pathogens such as bacteria and toxins, according to microbiologists. Here's how experts suggest staying safer in the kitchen. 'Home cooks tend to underestimate how cross contamination can spread bacteria across the kitchen,' says Dr Siyun Wang, professor of food safety engineering at the University of British Columbia. E coli, salmonella and listeria can easily transfer from raw produce, meat and eggs to other points we touch, such as a refrigerator or faucet handle, where Wang's research has shown they may be able to linger for weeks. To avoid cross-contamination when cooking, wash your hands frequently and well – for 20 seconds under warm water, then dry them on a clean towel reserved especially for that purpose. Do not rinse raw meat, such as chicken, she says. Doing so may help spread harmful bacteria, including via tiny airborne water droplets. Sanitize surfaces: Dr Jae-Hyuk Yu, a professor of bacteriology at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, recommends using a bleach solution (one tablespoon of bleach per gallon of water), an Environmental Protection Agency-registered kitchen disinfectant, or an alcohol-based spray for sanitizing hard surfaces, especially after preparing raw meat. And when handling cleaning chemicals, use gloves and ventilate well. He recommends cleaning fridge shelves monthly and ensuring your fridge is consistently under 40F to prevent bacteria from lurking around. Cook meat thoroughly: Always cook meat to its proper internal temperature, per the United States Department of Agriculture's guidelines: 145F for whole cuts of beef, pork, lamb, veal and fish (with a three-minute rest for meat), 160F for ground meats, and 165F for all poultry. Yu uses plastic cutting boards, rather than wood, for meat. 'Even clean boards can harbor microbes in grooves,' he says, so wash any kind of board well with hot water and antibacterial soap after use. 'Sponges are notorious bacterial reservoirs,' says Yu. 'Cleaning a knife used on raw chicken with a sponge, then using that same sponge on other dishes, can absolutely spread dangerous pathogens.' If you must use a sponge, microwave it, wet, for one to two minutes once a day or run it through the dishwasher with a heat-dry cycle, he advises. Yu replaces kitchen sponges every one to two weeks, and personally prefers sanitizable dishcloths that can be changed daily and put through a hot laundry cycle. While it is convenient to thaw frozen meat at room temperature, doing so 'allows the outer layers to enter the 'danger zone' between 40F and 140F, where bacteria can multiply rapidly, long before the center is thawed,' says Yu. Instead, thaw meat in the refrigerator. If you want to cook the meat immediately, use the microwave or place it in a sealed bag and submerge it in cold water, changing the water every 30 minutes. These methods keep the temperature in a safe range and limit bacterial growth. Leaving food out at room temperature is 'essentially incubating the bacteria that are in that food', says an Idaho-based microbiologist and medical laboratory scientist certified by the American Society for Clinical Pathology who goes by the pseudonym Morticia to avoid harassment as she shares food science information online. This gives them time to produce enterotoxins that can lead to symptoms like vomiting. 'A lot of these toxins are heat stable,' she says. Reheating them may get rid of bacteria, 'but the toxins will still make you sick'. Morticia recommends being especially careful with starchy leftovers like rice and pasta, where Bacillus cereus, a nasty foodborne pathogen, can start to grow within hours if left out. If you're saving food for later, refrigerate it within two hours. If you're actively eating over time – say, at an indoor party – food can stay out for up to four hours. But in hot outdoor settings such as a barbecue, that window shortens, she explains. The Food and Drug Administration and USDA recommend keeping refrigerated leftovers no longer than three to four days. 'If you freeze food, it will stay safe to eat for a very long time,' Morticia says. 'Respecting these dates is one of the best ways of avoiding potential health problems,' says Dr Alvaro San Millan, an expert in bacteria at the National Center for Biotechnology in Madrid. Some foods, such as packaged snacks, may be fine to eat days or weeks after their best before date has passed, particularly if they're unopened or have been properly stored. But it's not always easy to tell if something has gone bad. 'If food smells or tastes funny, that's definitely a red flag,' says San Millan. But pathogens can accumulate without alerting our senses to trouble. 'Certain bacteria, such as salmonella, can produce infections in humans even if they are at a very low concentration in the food – so low that you could never appreciate any change in a sniff or taste test,' says San Millan. Most of the time, eating questionable food will probably only lead to some gastrointestinal discomfort, but 'if you are unlucky and get infected by bacteria such as Listeria or Salmonella, or intoxicated with botulinum toxin, you may be in serious trouble,' he says. Sign up to Well Actually Practical advice, expert insights and answers to your questions about how to live a good life after newsletter promotion Can you just get rid of the visible mold on cheese and eat the rest? 'It depends on the type of cheese,' says Wang. If you spot mold on soft cheese, such as cottage and cream cheese, 'the entire product should be discarded'. Mold can send microscopic threads throughout the cheese, contaminating more than what is visible on the surface. 'For hard cheese such as cheddar, you can cut off at least 1in around and below the mold spot and keep using it,' Wang says, because fungi aren't able to spread as quickly through denser textures. 'The knife should be kept away from the moldy part to avoid cross contamination,' she says. People have used food preservation techniques like salting and pickling for millennia. But simply adding preservative ingredients to a dish doesn't 'shield' it from bacteria. Spicy, salty or acidic elements might slow spoilage under specific conditions, as with jerky or sauerkraut, but don't guarantee protection from harmful pathogens. There have been listeria and salmonella outbreaks from pickles, for instance, notes Morticia. 'There isn't much of a difference in regard to bacterial contamination and pathogen transmission' when it comes to organic and conventional produce, Morticia says. However, when buying local, 'the supply chain is a lot shorter and fewer people are coming into contact with that food,' she says. This means 'you are at a lower risk of transmission of some pathogens,' she says. Unfortunately, individual consumers don't have total control over food safety – systemic factors have a significant impact on the quality of what we eat. The FDA has faced significant reductions in funding and staff, which 'could lead to gaps in inspection and monitoring', says Yu. Reports suggest that spending freezes are already limiting food safety inspectors' ability to travel to farms or acquire food samples for testing. For individuals at home, less regulatory oversight means higher stakes decisions at the grocery store. Common food categories such as meat, eggs, shellfish, sprouts, greens and seeded vegetables such as tomatoes and cucumbers are all relatively high-risk for contamination. 'Now is a good time for consumers to be more cautious,' says Yu, particularly with 'high-risk foods like leafy greens, especially bagged lettuce,' which is prone to contamination with pathogens such as salmonella, listeria and E coli because of the way the greens are mixed from different farms and mass-processed before packaging. Morticia has changed her eating habits to prioritize safety in light of weaker industry regulations. 'I went vegan in January, because most foodborne pathogens are zoonotic in origin, meaning they come from cows and pigs and chickens,' she says. She's also opting for more stir-fries and fewer salads. 'Cooking all of my foods significantly lowers risk,' she says.
