'I was attacked on CCTV - but the charge was dropped in a plea deal'
Warning: This article contains details readers may find upsetting
Liz Shanks installed cameras around her home to protect her prized collection of classic cars – but instead, they captured the escalating and violent domestic abuse carried out by her former partner.
The harrowing recordings show repeated attacks in which Chris Forrest strangles Liz, pins her to the ground, and throttles her against a wall in the driveway.
In one, he screams "you are going to die in my hands you wee cow" as she gasps for breath.
The videos proved pivotal in a 2022 court case when Forrest was jailed for 27 months for attacks on Liz spanning three years.
Faced with the CCTV evidence, Forrest pleaded guilty to four charges.
But as part of a plea negotiation, commonly known as a plea deal, prosecutors agreed to drop the other seven charges against him.
Liz, a 36-year-old firefighter from Blantyre in South Lanarkshire, says she was "devastated" when she discovered that those charges had been dropped.
My abusive ex-boyfriend was given a verbal warning
Faster justice scheme rolled out across Scotland
Poet reveals four-year domestic abuse ordeal
She is part of a group of abuse survivors who are calling for the law to be changed to ensure that victims are notified about plea negotiations agreed in their cases.
The leader of the Scottish Conservatives has backed the move, but Justice Secretary Angela Constance has indicated that she is not in favour.
Liz says that the first she knew about the plea deal was when she got a phone call to say that the court case was over.
"I said: 'Where was my say in this plea deal? Why wasn't I told or given a say?'
"I was devastated. I was left frustrated. Disbelief. And I struggled to get the information as to what particular attacks he'd pled guilty to.
"Much to my disappointment there was one in particular that had supporting CCTV which he got off with."
In that video, Forrest can be seen standing in the driveway waiting for Liz while cracking his knuckles.
When the car pulls up he launches into an attack, screaming at her and pulling the door open, before lunging into the driver's side.
Liz says Forrest strangled her inside the car for almost 10 seconds. The footage then shows him slamming the door on her foot and kicking the car window before dragging her terrified pet dog away by its lead.
Forrest was initially charged with assault to the danger of life for the attack. A not guilty plea was accepted.
"I just felt like part of my world had fallen apart," said Liz.
"I'd been fighting so long and so hard to see the end result for this."
She said that if he had been convicted on that charge, it would have given her "validation" - something that was really important for most victims.
Liz said that notifying victims of a plea deal would prevent them feeling like "a spectator" in the whole process.
She is part of a group of seven campaigners, featured in a BBC Disclosure documentary on domestic abuse last year, who are calling for more rights for victims going through the justice process.
Most of them say they were not informed of the outcomes of plea deals in their cases.
In these negotiations, a procurator fiscal can accept some not guilty pleas if the accused admits other charges.
Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay is attempting to get changes to the way plea deals are handled included in the new Victims, Witnesses and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill.
He said: "We're not against the use of plea deals but we think it's a basic requirement that there should be transparency around their use, and that victims should be given a full explanation as to when they're used, why they're used and the terms that are reached.
"Quite often what happens is charges are either watered down or indeed dropped altogether even where there's an abundance of evidence to support specific charges, so inevitably when people don't even get told about this, or perhaps find out by accident, it causes them additional distress."
Mr Findlay proposed two amendments to the bill, which would enshrine in law the requirement for a victim to be notified when a plea deal is reached in their case.
He failed to win support last time the bill was discussed at Holyrood, but intends to press the case again when it reaches its final stage of the parliamentary process.
Liz and other campaigners are writing to the justice secretary asking her to support those amendments.
Ms Constance outlined her opposition to this move at a recent justice committee hearing, saying it could "add complexity to the system that victims need to navigate".
And she added: "Removing individual choice could be traumatic when the victim has made an informed decision not to engage."
A Scottish government spokesperson said the justice secretary was willing to continue to consider what more could be done to ensure victims receive the information they are seeking.
The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service says plea deals avoid the need for a trial and the stress of witnesses having to give evidence.
A spokesperson said it was "committed to listening to victims whilst working with partners across the criminal justice system in the continual improvement of the communication process".
Dr Marsha Scott, the chief executive of Scottish Women's Aid, said it should be possible to engage with survivors in "a respectful and informed way".
"This not about forcing engagement with survivors, this is about opening the process to them so that it's transparent, so they understand what's happening and so that they can control as much as possible their engagement with the system.
"The plea negotiations or plea bargains are a significant area that needs improvement."
Simon Brown is president of the Scottish Solicitors Bar Association, which represents criminal defence solicitors.
He said complainers – the alleged victims in a case – should be notified of plea negotiations, but warned against further concessions.
"I think this issue becomes problematic when you have to ask for their consent," he said.
"Complainers don't have the necessary legal knowledge to know what is and isn't admissible in evidence.
"Obviously by the nature of being a complainer, they're going to be biased against anything resolving short of guilty."
Liz Shanks says she will continue campaigning for changes that will benefit abuse survivors, and has been working with the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service to develop policy and training around the issue.
She is expecting her first baby with a new partner, and says this shows that there can be light at the end of the tunnel.
"I know from what I went through that you're so low, you don't believe that something as good as that could happen to you," she adds.
"But life is so much better. And if I can take something negative and make it into something positive and help other people, it makes me feel better about what's happened to me."
If you've been affected by the issues in this story you can find information and support here on BBC Action Line.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Jewish student settles religious discrimination suit against Columbia
FIRST ON FOX: A Jewish student who alleged she was forced out of her graduate program in part because of her Shabbos observance has settled her religious discrimination lawsuit against Columbia University. The terms of the settlement in the lawsuit filed by The Lawfare Project and Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP were confidential, but Lawfare Project executive Ziporah Reich said it included financial compensation and other relief. "These outcomes reflect the power of legal action to bring about meaningful change, we are proud to stand behind a courageous student who chose to stand up for her rights," Lawfare Project Director Brooke Goldstein told Fox News Digital in a statement. A Columbia spokesperson confirmed the settlement, saying, "We have reached a mutually agreeable confidential settlement with Forrest that did not include any admission of liability." Trump Admin Alleges Columbia Violated Civil Rights Law With 'Deliberate Indifference' To Campus Protests Mackenzie Forrest, an Orthodox Jewish student from Florida, claimed she was forced out of the Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT) program at the Columbia School of Social Work (CSSW), after she requested that she be allowed to attend classes remotely out of concern for her safety amid widespread antisemitic campus unrest following the Oct. 7 Hamas terrorist attacks. Read On The Fox News App Forrest alleged that she attended the Columbia School of Social Work specifically because of her interest in the DBT program. However, when she informed the program's director, Andre Ivanoff, Ph.D., that she would not be able to engage in classroom activities that fall on the Jewish Sabbath shortly after she was accepted in Spring 2023, Ivanoff allegedly replied that that would be a "problem," court documents say. Columbia University Punishes Students Who Took Over Building During Anti-israel Protests The Jewish graduate student received further pushback regarding her religious practices when she informed Ivanoff that she would be unable to attend a weekend-long workshop on suicide risk assessment because it fell on Shabbos, also known as the Sabbath. Despite Forrest saying that she could attend the parts of the workshop that did not occur between Friday night to Saturday night, Ivanoff allegedly told her she would need a "dispensation" from her rabbi to attend the workshop. Eventually, Ivanoff decided he would assign her substitute coursework in lieu of the workshop when Forrest informed him he could not attend. Following the Oct. 7 attacks in 2023, Columbia's campus exploded into a hotbed of antisemitism. In light of what the plaintiff claimed was widespread verbal abuse and a physical assault of a pro-Israel student who was allegedly beaten with what appeared to be a broom, Forrest requested that she be allowed to attend class remotely out of fear for her safety. Not only was the grad student's request denied, but soon after she claimed she faced retaliation from the university. Despite being a straight-A student, Forrest was told she was at risk of failing the field-based internship portion of her curriculum, according to the claim. The Jewish student alleged that she had never previously been told she was under-performing by her academic advisor, whom she met with article source: Jewish student settles religious discrimination suit against Columbia
Yahoo
05-06-2025
- Yahoo
The Scottish ‘tartan turf war' that went global
With a three-hour 'happy hour' and four big-screen TVs, Monaghans Bar in the Spanish resort of Fuengirola is a popular spot for those who like a night of soccer after a day of sun and sand. But on Saturday night, after drinkers watched the UEFA Champions League Final, a showdown of a less sporting sort unfolded outside. Just as the bar was emptying around 11.30pm, a car pulled up outside from which a black-clad gunman emerged. He shot dead the bar's Scottish owner, Ross Monaghan, and his Glaswegian friend Eddie Lyons Junior, before fleeing into the night. The double murder was the latest in a series of recent shootings on Spain's southern coast, long considered the 'Costa Del Crime'. Yet the hit may have been ordered from the rather less balmy climes of Glasgow, where a quarter-century feud between the city's two most powerful crime families is now spiralling out of control. In scenes that resemble an over-hyped episode of Taggart, the rival Lyons and Daniel gangs have been in open warfare for the past three months. Scores of homes and businesses, including garages, cab firms and beauty parlours, have been firebombed. Suspected associates have been attacked with machetes. Masked thugs behind the mayhem post videos of their handiwork online – shattering decades of painstaking PR in which Glasgow reinvented itself as a 'City of Culture'. The so-called 'tartan turf wars' are a throwback to the rougher Red Clydeside movement of the 1960s, when razor gangs terrorised the city. Today's Glasgow hard men, though, wield much deadlier weaponry than long-handled shaving blades, and their fiefdoms are no longer confined to council estates like Easterhouse. Attacks have taken place all over central Scotland, spreading to well-heeled districts of Edinburgh too. The feud reportedly dates back to the Lyons gang stealing a drug stash from the Daniels some 25 years ago, but onlookers fear it has become a battle to master the entirety of urban Scotland's lucrative drug trade. 'These groups have grown obscenely wealthy, preying on communities of very vulnerable people,' says MSP Russell Findlay, the leader of the Scottish Conservatives, who says the government has been complacent about the rising threat of organised crime. 'These two individuals who were killed were prominent members of organised crime, and while it's still unclear who was behind their deaths, it seems they are paying the price for the lifestyle they led.' Mr Findlay is well-qualified to comment on the subject, having previously worked as an investigative crime reporter for Scottish TV and tabloid newspapers. In 2012, he wrote a book about the Daniel-Lyons feud, chronicling the misery it inflicted on Glasgow's Milton housing estate, the Lyons' original stronghold. The book's title, Caught in the Crossfire, was to prove horribly prophetic: three years later, Findlay himself was attacked on his doorstep by a knifeman who threw acid in his face. It was the kind of brazen intimidation more associated with Latin American narco-states – something that Scotland will come to resemble if more is not done, he warns. 'I remember thinking at the time: 'Why is nobody else saying enough is enough?'' he says. 'This is what happens when organised crime becomes too powerful: they try to take on mainstream society.' Spanish police have yet to identify the Fuengirola gunman, who some reports claim was a blonde-haired man presumed to be a fellow Scot. Scottish police, however, are likely to have no shortage of suspects already on their files. Both Monaghan, 43, and Lyons Junior, 46, were members of the Lyons gang, and no strangers to the art of the gangland hit themselves. Monaghan had been arrested then acquitted of the 2010 murder of Kevin 'Gerbil' Carroll, a notorious Daniel-gang enforcer. He then moved to Spain after being shot in the shoulder in Glasgow in 2017. He and Lyons Junior both also stood trial for attacking three men outside a bar in Dunbartonshire in 2016, the case only collapsing when the alleged victims claimed they had no memory of what happened. Indeed, those caught up in Lyons-Daniel violence have a marked tendency to 'forget' their testimony, much to the frustration of police. One incident that neither gang ever seems to have forgotten, though, is the theft of £20,000 worth of cocaine back in 2001 from a Daniel safe house. Nicknamed 'Morningside Speed' in honour of the posh Edinburgh suburb of the same name, cocaine was then relatively new to Scotland. Previously, heroin had been the drug of choice on impoverished housing estates – courtesy of smugglers like Jamie Daniel, the Daniel-gang founder, who flooded Glasgow with it in the early Eighties. Cocaine, though, was far more lucrative, and the theft of the stash, while relatively small in value, sparked a wider turf war over dealing patches. Escalating the violence was Carroll, who had allegedly been bullied by the Lyons' family during his schooldays, and was now a senior enforcer for the Daniel gang. He was infamous for so-called 'alien abductions', where rivals would be kidnapped, tortured and then dumped semi-naked on the street, too traumatised (or too terrified) to say what had happened to them. Not content with inflicting physical harm, he also vandalised a gravestone for Eddie Lyon Junior's younger brother, Garry, who died from leukaemia aged eight in 1991. Perceived as an outrage even by gangland standards, that act led to Carroll himself being shot dead in an Asda car park in Glasgow in 2010, in full view of horrified shoppers. So reviled was Carroll that police had nearly 100 potential suspects for his murder, and his death might have drawn a line under the feud. But it flared up again in 2016 when Jamie Daniel passed away from cancer – one of the few gang kingpins to die peacefully. His death left a power vacuum, which the Lyons' clan tried to exploit through five attempted murders in just five months. In one particularly savage case, Stephen 'Bonzo' Daniel was hunted down after a 100mph car chase through north Glasgow, before having his face macheted so badly that paramedics thought at first that he had been shot. 'His nose was hanging off on the left hand side near his ear', a policeman told a later trial of six Lyons associates, who were convicted of the five murder plots in 2019. Jailing them for a total of 104 years, a judge told them: 'You sought to turn Glasgow into a war zone for your feud. This is a civilised city, based on the rule of law.' With the violence now flaring up again, many Scots might well doubt that – not least those living in the streets where properties have been firebombed. While the gang kingpins often live in fortress-like mansions, equipped with CCTV, safe rooms and anti-ram-raid bollards, their footsoldiers often live on suburban estates. The precise spark for the latest hostilities remains unknown, although some believe it may be linked to the gangs' growing links to international drug cartels. The Lyons gang is said to have forged close links to Ireland's feared Kinahan cocaine cartel, whose senior members holed up in Dubai after pressure from the Dublin authorities. One Lyons family member has also lived in Dubai since an attempt on his life in Glasgow in 2006, and is said to have formed a 'Celtic cartel' with his Irish counterparts, whereby Lyons street dealers distribute Kinahan-supplied cocaine. Scottish police have already arrested at least 40 people over the feud, while Angela Constance, the SNP Justice Secretary, insisted that law-abiding Scots had nothing to fear. 'Scotland continues to be a safe place to live, with recorded crime down 40 per cent since 2006/07,' she said last month. Critics, however, complain the police service remains underfunded. For Findlay, the problems go even deeper. Far too much of Scotland's establishment, he says, has given the gangs the benefit of the doubt – from the Edinburgh professionals who act as their defence lawyers and accountants, to Left-leaning politicians who see them as victims of social injustice. He remembers how, in the mid-Nineties, Eddie Lyons Senior was given use of a former school in Milton for a 'community project', despite already being well-known to police. Objections, Findlay says, were overlooked by councillors who naively regarded Lyons Senior as a community activist. The centre was later shut down amid complaints it had become a gang hub. But Findlay cites multiple other examples where gangs are still flexing their muscles. In South Lanarkshire, a fellow Tory councillor, Graeme Campbell, quit his role after rows over planning issues led to gangsters attacking his house three times. And at jails across the country, prison officers' cars have been firebombed at least a dozen times. 'You've got attacks on journalists, councillors, prison officers: Scotland's isn't a narco-state, but this is how these things start. And, too often, the SNP's ethos has been to justify and explain, not to punish and deter – it is a social work mentality. The gangs must be rubbing their hands with glee,' he said. Meanwhile, in Spain, there are fears that violence could escalate further and Ana Mula, the mayor of Fuengirola, is calling for more resources to combat organised crime. She said: 'We live in a world and at a time where crime knows no borders. In places like the Costa del Sol, we're seeing developments that, as they spread, inevitable affect us. We need much greater involvement from the state on this issue.' Reports last month claimed the Lyons gang was seeking a truce in the feud. Given the recent events in Fuengirola that now seems unlikely. As Findlay points out, though, Saturday's shootings might not be connected to the Scottish feud at all, but rather the larger, global players that the Lyons gang is now part of. 'It could have been the work of their long-standing enemies in Scotland,' he said. 'But, out in Spain, they are swimming with much bigger sharks – who may be even more ruthless than they are.' Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Yahoo
03-06-2025
- Yahoo
Edinburgh child, 10, caught with knife as "truly shocking" stats show primary kids carry blades
Edinburgh Police caught a 10-year-old child carrying a knife in the city as new, "truly shocking" figures revealed that dozens of children have been found with blades across Scotland this year- including primary school pupils. Police Scotland confiscated knives from at least 91 people who were under the age of 18 in 2024 through stop-and-search powers, which adds up to one child caught with a weapon every four days, reports The Daily Record. The release of these shocking statistics comes just weeks after the death of schoolboy, Kayden Moy, the third teen to lose his life to youth violence in the last year. READ MORE: Family airlifted to Edinburgh hospital after baby struggles to breathe READ MORE: Edinburgh locals 'really bugged' by 'glaring mistake' on hit Netflix series Numerous incidents involving kids as young as 12 caught with knives occurred in Edinburgh, Ayrshire, Glasgow and Lanarkshire, according to an analysis by justice magazine 1919. Over a dozen 13-year-olds - including two girls - underwent blade searches that came back positive. Now, teens account for almost a third of positive knife searches across all age groups. The disturbing incidents prompted warnings of a 'youth violence epidemic' which has been repeatedly highlighted by the Record's Our Kids... Our Future campaign, launched two years ago after we reported a worrying series of attacks on teens across the country. Sign up for Edinburgh Live newsletters for more headlines straight to your inbox The Scottish Government is now under intensified pressure onto act after several high-profile cases. Labour justice spokesperson Pauline McNeill said: 'These shocking figures are yet another sign that there is a youth violence epidemic emerging in Scotland. "The SNP has created a perfect storm by cutting youth work services, letting police numbers fall, and mismanaging mental health and education. "Every one of these 91 cases is very serious for our communities and potentially for those actually carrying the weapon. "The only way to tackle this effectively is to have early intervention schemes that get to the root cause." The Scottish Conservatives blamed 'soft-touch' sentencing for under-25s, claiming it has emboldened young offenders. Sharon Dowey MSP said: 'Knife crime has spiralled out of control. There must be meaningful punishments for those who use a knife and expanded stop-and-search powers for police to act as a deterrent. "The SNP's soft-touch attitude towards justice represents an abject dereliction of duty by John Swinney's government." Scottish Police Federation chair, David Threadgold, added: "This is a concerning societal trend we now see emerging among younger members of our communities in Scotland," he said. 'Each of these statistics is a real situation which created significant risk for my colleagues, as well as potentially life changing consequences for the perpetrator, and sadly, the victims of knife crime, their families and friends. 'The solution to this problem cannot rest alone with the police; much greater and more effective preventative strategies have to be in place." First Minister John Swinney recently said the Government's strategy would focus on three steps – educating young people on the dangers of knives, police searches of people who they think may be carrying a knife and punishment of those caught with weapons. A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'Stop and search powers should be used where lawful, necessary and proportionate. Their use in individual cases is an operational matter for Police Scotland. 'Police do use stop and search, and it is one tool to tackle violence alongside a range of other measures such as prevention and education.' Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
