Exclusive: PBM trade group sues Arkansas over pharmacy law
The trade group representing pharmacy benefit managers sued on Monday to overturn a first-in-the-nation state law that prevents them from owning pharmacies in Arkansas.
Why it matters: The Pharmaceutical Care Management Association's lawsuit adds to legal challenges to the ownership ban and comes as other states consider similar policies that blame large drug-price middlemen for rising pharmaceutical prices.
Navitus Health Solutions, a PBM that's not a member of the trade association, is also a plaintiff in the lawsuit.
CVS Health and Cigna, two of the largest PBMs, have filed their own complaints against the law.
What they're saying: The law "will disrupt the way patients, especially patients with very complex medical conditions, receive their medication, and it will require consumers in Arkansas to find new pharmacies," said Katie Payne, senior vice president of public affairs and head of advocacy at PCMA.
More than 40 retail pharmacies in Arkansas that together fill millions of prescriptions each year will have to cease operation under the law, according to the complaint.
Payne said that the law will worsen drug affordability in the state by prohibiting out-of-state companies from running pharmacies that offer lower-cost options.
However, PCMA did not have projections on how Arkansas's law will affect drug prices in the state.
Zoom in: The lawsuit claims that Arkansas's policy gives preferential treatment to pharmacies based in the state, violating the Constitution's dormant Commerce Clause and Privileges and Immunities Clause. It also says the law improperly declares PBMs guilty of antitrust violations and delivers punishment without a trial.
"Rather than innovating and attempting to compete with PBM pharmacies on the merits, many independent pharmacies have turned to state lawmakers to manipulate the market with the heavy hand of government, to artificially tip the scales of competition in their favor," the complaint alleges.
Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders (R) has said the law is necessary to hold PBMs accountable for anticompetitive actions.
Lawmakers at the state and federal level are increasingly questioning large pharmacy benefit managers like CVS Caremark, Express Scripts and Optum Rx's outsize role in the pharmaceutical supply chain and whether they're contributing to high drug prices.
Between the lines: PCMA's complaint notes that an earlier version of the bill would have required Walmart — Arkansas's largest company — to close its pharmacies as well, since the company administers its own pharmacy benefits for employees.
State legislators amended the policy before it was passed so Walmart would no longer be subject to the law.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
29 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Military Member Joins Anti-ICE Protest, Tells Trump: 'We Are Not Pawns'
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A serving member of the U.S. Army openly joined the protests against Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in Dallas, Texas, and called on others in the military to "resist evil". "We are not pawns for Donald Trump," said the uniformed woman in a video posted to social media by the leftist activist channel BreakThrough News. She was not fully identified, but a patch that said "Colado" was on her chest where troops wear their last names. She joined the protests after President Donald Trump deployed Marines to Los Angeles, California, amid the riots and disorder. "Why now? It's because the military was called upon against the protesters. We, in our oath to serve, we serve the people of the United States, the Constitution," she said. "These constitutional rights are being stripped and just denied. And the military will not be pawns to that. "So I'm calling upon the conscience of military members who served previously and now. We have a conscience, a mind and we have a duty and moral obligation to say no and resist evil." BREAKING: After Trump deployed Marines to LA, this military member joined an anti-ICE protest in Dallas, declaring, 'We won't be pawns in stripping away constitutional rights.' — BreakThrough News (@BTnewsroom) June 11, 2025 This is a developing article. Updates to follow.
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Kurt Russell and Goldie Hawn's son Wyatt addresses claim he was viral protester scolding National Guardsmen during LA riots
Actor Wyatt Russell, son of Hollywood legends Kurt Russell and Goldie Hawn, has cleared the air after he was mistakenly identified as a man scolding law enforcement during the anti-ICE protests in Los Angeles in a viral video. The video showed a bearded protester, who has a fleeting resemblance to Wyatt Russell, donning a black sweatshirt and baseball cap and shouting at National Guardsmen standing post. The protester can be heard telling the guardsmen that they were on 'the wrong side of history' in the clip that went viral on X on Monday. 'Your assault rifles and your sticks? You should be standing here with us,' the man is heard yelling. 5 Wyatt Russell attends the New York Special Screening of 'Thunderbolts' hosted by The Cinema Society at iPic Theater on April 30, 2025 in New York City. Getty Images for Disney 'We know you got a job to do, but you took an oath to the Constitution, not to the fascists in the White House. Think about what you're doing now. Think about what this means.' Rumors started spreading like wildfire across the social media platform that the man in the footage was actually the '22 Jump Street' star. However, a spokesperson for the 38-year-old actor quickly put to rest any doubt that he was the man in the video. 'This is indeed NOT Wyatt Russell, and we have been working to try and correct the mis-identification,' the spokesperson told the Independent. The protester in the viral clip was actually Aaron Fisher, a former Ohio House Democratic Caucus staffer and now a partner at Statecraft Media — who said he got a kick out of being mistaken for his Hollywood doppelganger. 5 Wyatt Russell with his mom, actress Goldie Hawn. Shutterstock 5 Kurt Russell, Goldie Hawn and Wyatt Russell at 'The Hateful Eight' film premiere, in Los Angeles, on Dec. 7, 2015. Matt Baron/Shutterstock 'I found the mixup to be pretty humorous, and glad it helped to amplify the message,' Fisher told Entertainment Weekly. 'The proliferation of the words themselves, and the movement behind it, is what matters most.' Fisher then used the moment to bash the deployment of the National Guard in California to help control the violent ICE riots suffocating Los Angeles. 'The deployment of the National Guard against the wishes of our Governor is dangerously un-American, and I will continue to peacefully protest in my community,' he said. 5 Severe disorder takes place in downtown Los Angeles as hundreds of law enforcement officers and the National Guard try to keep order. Toby Canham for NY Post The city has been in turmoil since protests-turned-riots erupted as US Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents raided numerous workplaces and hauled off suspected illegal immigrants. The Trump administration has deployed 4,000 National Guard members to maintain order and help protect federal personnel and property. US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has also ordered 700 Marines to Los Angeles to support the National Guard troops on the ground, as well as local authorities. 5 Vehicles are seen being torched during the Los Angeles anti-ICE riots. Toby Canham for NY Post Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass announced that a curfew will go into effect in parts of downtown Los Angeles on Tuesday after five straight days of riots, looting, violent clashes with police, and more than 150 arrests. While it was confirmed that Russell wasn't the protester in the viral video, other celebrities have not shied away from throwing their support behind the anti-ICE riots. Actor Mark Ruffalo posted a lengthy message on Instagram condemning the ICE raids as things began to reach a boiling point in the city between protesters and law enforcement. 'When you have working class people going after the poor and other working class people you know you are living in an oligarchy,' Ruffalo captioned the post.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trump's tariffs can remain in place for now, but appeals court fast tracks a summer resolution
President Donald Trump's heftiest tariffs cleared a court hurdle for now, after a federal appeals court ruled Tuesday that they could take effect while legal challenges play out. But the appeals court put the tariff cases on a fast track for a resolution this summer. The decision came after the Trump administration appealed the Court of International Trade's ruling finding the president exceeded his authority to impose country-wide tariffs claiming a national emergency. 'Both sides have made substantial arguments on the merits. Having considered the traditional stay factors… the court concludes a stay is warranted under the circumstances,' according to the ruling. The stay is pending the course of the appeal, the court wrote, adding that the case will be heard on a sped-up basis by the full panel of judges at the court. 'The court also concludes that these cases present issues of exceptional importance warranting expedited en banc consideration of the merits in the first instance,' the order said. A lawyer for the plaintiffs said the decision was 'unfortunate' but that the expedited review could hopefully yield a permanent answer soon. 'All I can say is the court's decision is unfortunate,' wrote Ilya Somin, a law professor at Scalia Law School, George Mason University and plaintiff lawyer, in an email to CNN. 'The Federal Circuit also indicated in its ruling today that there will be expedited consideration of the case, and we hope to get a ruling on the merits faster than usual.' But the White House called the stay 'a welcome development.' 'The Trump administration is legally using the powers granted to the executive branch by the Constitution and Congress to address our country's national emergencies of persistent goods trade deficits and drug trafficking,' White House spokesman Kush Desai said in a statement. 'The US Circuit Court of Appeals' stay order is a welcome development, and we look forward to ultimately prevailing in court.' The appeals court ruling, however, has no bearing on the sector-wide tariffs Trump previously enacted, including those on aluminum, steel, cars and car parts. That's because he imposed those levies under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act – a different law than the one Trump cited for his broader trade actions. Section 232 gives a president significant power to levy tariffs on specific sectors if they believe there is a national security threat risk. That's just one of the levers the administration can continue to use regardless of how the case ultimately plays out. A handful of other laws give the president the ability to levy higher tariffs, albeit in a more limited way than under a law known as the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, or IEEPA. Trump has attempted to use that law to pass along 'reciprocal' tariffs, a 10% universal tariff and import taxes on Mexico, Canada and China over their alleged roles in enabling illegal migration and fentanyl to flow into the US. Barring any more new import taxes, without the IEEPA-related levies, the nation's effective tariff rate on goods would decline from 13-14% to 5%, JPMorgan economists estimated in May note to clients. That's still around double that of 2024 levels, however. The latest order does little to give businesses certainty about the future. Trump has imposed, paused, hiked and lowered tariffs at a dizzying rate since re-taking office, leaving businesses and consumers alike scrambling to figure out what products brought into the country will cost in the coming weeks and months. Trump has called for those businesses to bring production into the United States to avoid tariffs. But that process takes time and money – often into the years and millions or billions of dollars. This story has been updated with additional context and developments. CNN's Samantha Delouya and Samantha Waldenberg contributed reporting.
