Why an Ukraine-style evacuation of Indians is not possible in Iran
When the Russia-Ukraine war broke out in 2022, India swiftly launched 'Operation Ganga' to evacuate thousands of its citizens, mostly students, from the conflict zone. But as tensions escalate in West Asia, a similar large-scale evacuation from Iran may not be as easy.From geography and airspace restrictions to diplomatic sensitivities and the nature of the threat, multiple factors make an "Iran operation" far more complex and challenging. advertisementSIZE OF THE OPERATIONThere are about 10,000 Indians in Iran. Of which, there are approximately 1,500-2,000 students and 6,000 people who have been living and working there. Besides this, there are a number of Indian sailors and those associated with shipping-related operations. On the other hand, around 22,500 Indian nationals returned from Ukraine to India between February and March 2022.
Due to security concerns and logistical constraints, the government has not given the evacuation from Iran any name as it did in the case of 'Operation Ganga' from Ukraine. As many as 90 evacuation flights were operated under Operation Ganga, including 14 Indian Air Force flights from the neighbouring countries.The operation was relatively smooth because Indian evacuation flights operated without any hindrance from multiple locations such as Hungary, Romania, Moldova, Slovakia, and Poland.DIFFICULT NEIGHBOURHOODadvertisementIn the case of Iran, geopolitics is in the way of the operation. Though the number of Indians willing to return is relatively small, the available evacuation routes and options are limited.Evacuating via eastern neighbours of Iran like Pakistan and Afghanistan is not only a logistical challenge but also geopolitically difficult. On one hand, the Pakistani airspace is shut for India. Land route evacuation is also out of the question.Though India-Afghanistan relations have improved over the past few months, the logistical challenge remains. Air evacuation is not possible because the flights will have to cross Pakistani airspace, which is out of bounds.
People arrive with their luggage before the departure of buses slated to evacuate foreign passport holders, mainly European and Polish, out of Israel (AFP)
THE EASTERN AND WESTERN FLANKSDuring the initial days of the Russia-Ukraine war, thousands of people, including Indians, could leave Ukraine as the western borders were largely open and were not on Russian targets.The fighting was mainly concentrated in the eastern territories such as Donetsk, Luhansk, and Kharkiv. However, in the case of Iran, the aerial attacks carried out by the Israeli Air Force are widespread and not concentrated to specific geographies.TRANSPORT REMAINS AN ISSUEadvertisementThe road and rail connectivity in Ukraine largely remain operational even during the ongoing conflict. So, it was easier for people to get to safer locations and land border crossings like Lviv (Poland border) and Chernivtsi (Hungarian border). But, in the case of Iran, road and rail connectivity remains unreliable.EXIT TEHRAN PITCHThe Indian embassy in Tehran has asked Indians residing in the capital city to leave. Indian nationals have been advised to move to safe locations outside the city using their own resources.The evacuation process has already begun. The first batch of around 110 people, mostly students, has crossed over to Armenia. Around 600-700 people have been moved to the safer city of Qom in central Iran.Qom is an important religious site having various mosques and seminaries, including the famous Azam mosque. There are other cities such as Arak, Khorammabad, Isfahan, Tabriz and Kermanshah, which remain out of bound because of nuclear and military facilities.WHY ARMENIA?The Iranian airspace remains shut due to the ongoing conflict. Therefore, the land route becomes the only available option for those who want to leave Iran.The situation is quite similar to what happened in Ukraine, whose airspace remains closed till date. During 'Operation Ganga', Indians were evacuated via land route to countries like Hungary, Romania, Moldova, Slovakia, and Poland. The maximum evacuation happened via Poland because of better connectivity and good relations with India. Prime Minister Narendra Modi did thank Poland for their help during his visit last year.advertisementIran shares land borders with Armenia, Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan, Afghanistan, and Pakistan. The last two are the least preferred options because of logistic challenges and bilateral relations. In any case, Pakistan's airspace is closed for Indian flights after Operation Sindoor.In the recent conflict, Azerbaijan openly supported Pakistan, due to which it becomes an undesirable option.Turkmenistan still remains an option as the capital city of Ashgabat is close to Iran. The next batch of Indians may likely take the Turkmenistan route to get out of Iran.The geostrategic compatibility between Armenia and India makes the former a preferred choice.Must Watch
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
29 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Make Air India 'Volvo' of global airlines
Spirit in the sky In 1992, civil aviation minister Madhavrao Scindia resigned when a Russian aircraft leased by Indian Airlines crashed, despite zero casualties. An emotion-first response mechanism to disasters has historically been considered appropriate for Indian audiences, unlike the more rational SOP in the West. The tragedy of AI 171 must inspire Air India to build world-beating safety protocols, on a foundation of meaningful empathy. As per the Montreal Convention, families of perished passengers are already eligible for about ₹1.5 cr as insurance claims. Tata Sons has additionally contributed ₹1 cr, and Air India an interim of ₹25 lakh. Both chairman N Chandrasekaran and CEO Campbell Wilson have been hands-on in their commitment, while other CEOs of Tata Group are suitably aligned. In terms of emotional sincerity leading to actionable evidence, Tatas are doubtlessly delivering. They must now shift focus to hard-nosed safety considerations as a scalable service to the global flying community. According to DGCA data, India clocked 1.61 mn domestic flyers in 2024, while globally, the number was around 9.5 bn. For starters, Air India must take complete ownership over the accident inquiry, using regulatory authorities and equipment manufacturers as allies, setting a new benchmark in process and outcomes. This will ensure that it doesn't degenerate into a 'Machine vs Man' debate with allied conspiracy theories, fuelled by zealous online speculators. Safety and integrity are the Tatas' calling cards. This should lead to a continuing culture of intelligence-sharing with other airlines, pivoted on the supreme cause of passenger safety. This can be a valuable differentiator on a runway occupied by competitive nitpicking over 'softer' virtues like comfort, cuisine and an approach also makes sense in a digital search-intensive customer cohort, increasingly willing to pay a premium for 'hygiene' virtues, as proven by diverse categories like autos and wellness. 60% of Indian customers evaluate online prior to purchase, mirroring a global pattern. Air India is uniquely positioned to re-emphasise a safety-first credo to a customer base, equipped to co-create the emerging Air India Flying Training Academy at Amravati, Maharashtra, can be a vital pillar for this momentum, with the 'knowledge' resilience of the Tatas pooling in to build a leading facility. To this, one can add maintenance training and protocols, in tandem with softer but critical customer service interfaces, both physical and digital, resonating with a win-win safety and campaigns can be calibrated for in-flight customer accountability, extending to an overall 'tough love' care regime rooted in sincere empathy. In the envisioned future, Air India curated content can become globally viral for building a co-created safety culture. In the auto universe, Volvo's culture of safety is embedded in its ethos and drives a premium for prioritising human life. A 'Zero Accidents Vision', human-centric approach, and pioneering safety innovations like the 3-point seat belt (subsequently shared universally) and various other driver assistance tools have made the Swedish multinational the byword for auto safety. Global accident data is collated to ensure a safer future ride, which is further amplified by AI. This human value system is stock-in-trade for the Tatas. Adapting it proactively for Air India will lead to credible stakeholder leverage, coming from a diversified, and not just an industry, perspective. Over time, this can become a vital demonstration of Air India's intent to be a world-class airline, passenger-first on the most vital other aspects of safety, direct and extended, can be part of the airlines' agenda. The Montreal Convention, for instance, does not compensate crew members for loss of life - they are governed by employment contracts. High-rise construction near airports, endangering aircraft, is common across the world, and newer protocols must be considered. FDTL (Flight Duty Time Limitations) clearly do not consider mental health dimensions. An amendment to these may be in stringent legal provisions could deter the growing cult of unruly passengers from misbehaving. Customer-centric application of AI can smoothen the overall flying experience, from terminal management to scheduling to dietary preferences. Again, in all this, Air India can bring about a first-mover is usually a point of parity in the airline industry. It can equally become a point of valuable difference. With its time-tested pedigree, the Tatas can well make Air India the thought-to-action Volvo of global writer is an autonomous brand consultant (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. Benchmarked with BSE 1000, this index fund will diversify your bets. But at a cost. Yet another battle over neem; this time it's a startup vs. Procter & Gamble For investors with ability to take a contrarian stand: 6 mid-cap stocks from different sectors with upside potential of over 26% return Buy, Sell or Hold: Motilal Oswal remains neutral on Tata Motors; Antique recommends Hold on Hindustan Zinc These 7 banking stocks can give more than 21% returns in 1 year, according to analysts
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
HC closes proceedings against Shah after SC order
Bhopal: A division bench of MP high court, which had taken suo motu cognizance of the derogatory comments by tribal affairs minister Vijay Shah against Col Sofiya Qureshi, one of the two faces of Indian armed forces during ' Operation Sindoor ', and asked the DGP to register an FIR against the minister, closed the proceedings in the case following the supreme court directive to this effect. During the hearing of the case on Monday, the bench of Justice Vivek Agarwal and Justice S K Singh formally closed the case. The bench of Justice Arul Sreedharan and Justice Anuradha Shukla taking cognizance of Shah's address at a public function at Raikunda village in Mhow district on MJay 14 had asked that an FIR be lodged against the minister under sections 152 (endangering the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India), 196 (1) (b) (promoting enmity) and 197 (a) (c) (harmful imputations or assertions about certain groups). An FIR was registered against the minister at Manpur police station in Mhow district the same night. Later, hearing a petition of the minister, the supreme court had formed a SIT of three IPS officers to probe the case and present a report to the supreme court. The court, while reprimanding the minister for use of 'shameful' language, however, restrained the police against the minister from taking any coercive action and also asked the MP high court to close the case.
Deccan Herald
44 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
Indian Embassy in Israel suggests those looking for exit to avail land border crossings
Jerusalem: With national emergency in Israel still in place and the airspace closed, the Indian embassy in Tel Aviv on Tuesday asked for those Indians looking to leave the country to look at availing land border crossing an updated advisory, the Embassy has asked Indian citizens staying in Israel to register with the mission..'All Indians in Israel are safe and the embassy is constantly monitoring the situation and the safety of its nationals, setting up a 24X7 helpline, and by maintaining contact with members of the community,' the advisory said..'All Indian nationals intending to exit Israel may like to avail of the land border crossing options. Such travellers are advised to verify the operational timings, obtain appropriate visas and fees applicable at these border crossings at the mission said in the fresh says US won't kill Iran's supreme leader, 'at least not for now'.Those looking to leave via Jordan can apply for eVisa on the website of their Interior ministry ( the advisory to leave through Egypt, they can apply for eVisa on the portal: it mission also cautioned them to go through How to Apply, FAQ and disclaimer sections for further information..'For those continuing to stay in Israel, the Indian mission advised them to register with the embassy at on Sunday, the mission said that the 'safety and security of Indian nationals is paramount to us', asking its citizens to stay vigilant and strictly adhere to safety advisories / protocols issued by the Israeli Home Front Command ( also told its nationals to restrict movement and avoid unnecessary travel within Israel..'The Embassy of India in Tel Aviv is in touch with members of the Indian community in Israel, including caregivers, workers, students, businessmen and tourist groups,' the mission said..'The Embassy continues to monitor the situation closely and is in regular touch with the Israeli authorities,' it had mission also stressed that the round-the-clock helpline established by it is 'functional' for 'any assistance regarding the present situation' and listed contact numbers (+972547520711 and +972543278392) and email ( to reach out to in times of region is plunged into war after Israel launched attacks on Iran on June 13, killing key military leaders, and Iran launched retaliatory attacks.
