Your reaction to Blades' first-leg win at Ashton Gate

Yahoo

09-05-2025

We asked you for your reaction to Sheffield United's 3-0 win against 10-man Bristol City in the first leg of the Championship play-off semi-final at Ashton Gate.
Here are a selection of views from Bristol City fans...
Ian: The biggest football event in Bristol for 17 years, Ashton Gate rocking, two mins til half-time, penalty and a red card - City punished twice for a questionable penalty. Game over. 46 games all comes down to an over zealous referee! The decision decided the game! We will return stronger!
Matty: Red card and the injury to Williams changed the game. Once Sheff Utd went 1-0 up it was damage limitation. Can't have any complaints about the result. Proud of what Manning & co have achieved this season.
Jen: What ever happened to the double jeopardy rule? When the ref makes such a blatant error that potentially costs a club millions of pounds a post-match apology isn't really enough. What more can the FA do?
Paul: Really good and competitive game up to the penalty/sending off. I'm old school and it looked like a red to me but Dickie does get the ball and I understand in the rules that exist now that should have been a yellow. It's done in my opinion. Do City have 11 fit players for Monday?
Tim: Sending off and penalty changed the game but if it had been other way round we would have been fuming. After that it was going to be tough. Not sure subbing Nakhi was a great decision. Fair play to Blades they took advantage. We have overachieved this season. Board need to show real ambition now.
Cameron: Never a red. Possibly a pen but Rob Dickie played the ball as well so for me and many others it's not a red. It's in the laws of the game. I think personally that cost us the game. It's best to just to go all out in the away leg on Monday now.
Richard: The game was very open to begin with, the penalty and sending off killed this. It was disappointing as a Bristol City fan and it really spoiled the game and took away all the fun. I think, in that moment, Dickie could have and perhaps at this level, should have done better, given the guy was in on goal, better to let him go than risk the red and penalty.
Tom: Everyone is saying how we were well beaten by the better team, but until the red card it was a close game - a classic Championship game that felt like it could go either way. Unfortunately, the sending off changed that completely, and regardless of whether it was right or wrong, it was silly to give the referee the decision to make in such a crucial game. I genuinely believe that at 1-0 down with 11 v 11 we make a real go of it in the second half and potentially get something from the game. Such a shame, but pressure is off, stranger things have happened in football, so bring on Bramall Lane and something miraculous!
Blades fans also weighed-in...
Lola: Brilliant professional performance from the boys with subs making an impact when coming on. Got nothing to complain about. First foot in the final!
Rob: Brilliant performance. Moore caused them all sorts of problems. Even before the red card we had had the better chances. Has the playoff curse been lifted?
Thomas: That second-half performance is how we should've been playing all season. If we played like that when we lost against Millwall, Oxford or Plymouth we probably had a chance for promotion whether it was automatic or as champions.
Joe: Regardless of getting to the ball or not with his foot, the defender clearly had two arms pulling down the back of a striker that's one on one on goal 10 yards out. Even the most biased opinions can surely see this is a red card whether the Bristol City manager or fan base want it to be or not. Poor decision from the defender to get himself in that position knowing the costs of pulling down the attacker that would likely be at least a penalty.
Steve: Good, solid performance. Chris Wilder got his tactics right, especially when he took the team off early at the end to manage expectations. This is not over until the final whistle on May 24!
Alfie: I thought after the penalty and red card we showed how much we wanted to win and how much we wanted to end this play-off drought. If Wilder does do it it'll be his biggest achievement for us yet. I also think Andre and O'Hare were very big game changers for us when they got subbed on.
Ryan: I thought the Blades performance was professional, especially in the second half when Bristol City sat back. The red card ruined it as a contest but the decision was correct in my opinion. Not getting carried away as there is still a job to do on Monday.