Galway have lost faith in their hurlers and there's only one way to get them back
WHEN THE KINDLY Mary Morgan, Kilkenny PRO came down around the press box at half time asking if you might like the attendance, you thanked her kindly and listened in.
8,243.
Surely… Surely some mistake?
This was the big ticket item of the Leinster hurling championship. The biggest game between supposedly the biggest teams, the ones that have won Liam MacCarthy in the last decade.
But… 8,243?
Those in Leinster that get queasy when the praise for the Munster hurling championship spills over, must find this figure alarming. Sure, there will be brighter days for the overall health of the big counties in the Leinster championship.
What we can only say for now is that 9,621 attended the game in Pearse Stadium last year. 11,550 were in Nowlan Park in 2023.
Advertisement
14,034 turned up for Pearse Stadium in 2022.
Galway are not alone in having their public turn their back on their team. Nobody likes being associated with failure. But Micheál Donoghue returns to a side in need of a serious makeover.
They started the league with a 12-point loss at home to Tipperary. They showed immense promise for a while after that by beating Kilkenny away, All-Ireland champions Clare by seven points and then Wexford.
But the league programme ended as the championship began; 12-point losses to Limerick and Cork before Saturday's show.
It is clear that Donoghue's role as manager this time is vastly different to the one he inherited from Anthony Cunningham in 2016; a side that had been to and competed in All-Ireland finals, seeking the final push.
Donoghue's experience among Tipperary as a selector for Eamonn O'Shea gave him the broad perspective needed. In year one they lost by seven to Kilkenny in the Leinster final and one point to Tipperary in the All-Ireland semi-final.
The year after they went through the year undefeated on their way to claiming Liam MacCarthy.
They almost repeated the trick in 2018 only for their one-point loss to Limerick in the All-Ireland final.
In Donoghue's final year they were unbeaten heading into the last round of Leinster round-robin but lost to Dublin; leaving the four teams of Kilkenny, Wexford, Dublin and themselves on five points.
Galway's problem was that they didn't go bananas on Carlow to ratchet up their score difference.
The point is, in Donoghue's time they never succumbed to a defeat as heavy as last Saturday. The tone was set as early as the fourth minute when Galway goalkeeper Darach Fahy struggled to rise the ball and Martin Keoghan put enough pressure on for the ball to squirt loose, fired to the net by Adrian Mullen.
Despite that, they managed to wrestle the lead back and were on level peggings by the 23rd minute. The issue was that both teams were backfiring and spluttering. Short-range bounce passes that would hop off the turf in mid-summer were instead sticking in the mud.
Deliveries were coming off shins. Strikes were spinning in the air. Both teams were playing cat. It couldn't continue.
Kilkenny found their groove and in the last ten minutes of the half outscored Galway 0-8 to 0-2.
From that point on, the Tribesmen's confidence deserted them. Their full-forward line of Conor Whelan and Declan McLouhlin were swamped. Their markers Huw Lawlor and Mikey Butler were absolutely sensational in the way that full-backs can look when the service coming into the forwards is overcooked, undercooked and much, much too late.
McLoughlin compiled 2-2 in the league fixture between these two just a couple of months back. Here he looked vastly different.
By the end of the game, Donoghue was back with the Old Regiment; Pádraic Mannion, Cathal Mannion, Daithí Burke, Conor Cooney, Conor Whelan were all on the pitch. They all played in that All-Ireland semi-final loss to Tipperary nine years ago. Add in David Burke who was left on the bench, and you can see the obvious problem.
Daithí Burke. Leah Scholes / INPHO Leah Scholes / INPHO / INPHO
And yet, the veterans are needed. Burke's introduction in the backline brought an immediate improvement; Galway conceded only two more points before Keoghan's goal in garbage time.
Related Reads
5 talking points after Munster hurling day of draws and drama
Brian Lohan: 'We're just delighted with our lads, they always give that bit of fight'
Flowers for the Leinster hurling championship and the shocks you can't get in Munster
'You miss your leaders,' explained Neil McManus on The Sunday Game highlights show as the panel searched for deeper reasons as to their demise.
'And nobody more so than Daithí Burke. The difference he made for the last, was he on for 15 minutes? He made a huge difference. That man needs to be at the centre of defence. They (Kilkenny) were being switched around; Eoin Cody, Billy Ryan, Mossy Keoghan, one or two were inside at all times with one roving. Daithí Burke needs to just anchor that defence and then build from there.'
The tests will come. They have Offaly in Tullamore this Saturday. The combination of local rivalry and disgust in last weekend will show us what Galway have.
Then they host Wexford, a side that beat them last year. Notably, they have Dublin in the last day of the league, a side that have caused them significant heartbreak on that very day.
It might have been a low-key start to the Leinster championship. But it could turn out to be a magnificent and nerve-shredding finish.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
30 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Ireland goalscorer Saoirse Noonan on 'surreal' Páirc Uí Chaoimh homecoming
Saoirse Noonan described her Páirc Uí Chaoimh goals as 'surreal' - as the former Cork Gaelic footballer marked her return to her hometown venue in spectacular style. It wasn't enough to earn Ireland the margin of victory needed to secure automatic promotion to League A, as the Girls in Green needed to beat Slovenia by four to leapfrog them into top spot. But with a promotion/relegation play-off still to come in October against one of Austria, Iceland, Belgium or Denmark, Ireland will have a second bite of the cherry. And if they can follow Noonan's lead, and make it second time lucky, then Carla Ward's side can look forward to top-tier football next year in the World Cup qualifiers. The Celtic striker didn't score when she represented Cork at the iconic Leeside stadium in 2020, in a league match against Westmeath, but she found the net on Tuesday evening. 'It was a bit surreal,' she said of her goal. 'Obviously my first competitive start so I was just trying to find my feet, ease my way into the game and not get caught up in the moment. 'It's unbelievable, I'm absolutely delighted.' She added: 'Obviously the first thing was to go out and win the game but the bigger picture, we obviously wanted to get the goals. 'We started off well, that's something that we've spoken about the last few days, I think we did that. We had a lot of chances, possession, we played really well. 'They're a good team, at least we got the win and it's something we can build on going forward.' Ireland had plenty of chances to add to that lead before half-time, while they continued to create openings after the break. However, they couldn't break down Slovenia's stubborn resistance. 'I think we thought, a 1-0 lead, can we get another one before half time? That was the focus,' said Noonan. 'We were pushing, we were unlucky, one or two decisions we could have made better. 'Look, it's about building. This team is good, we're working hard every day, we're growing - you can see the growth. 'From the first time Carla came in to now, even for myself, I feel like each camp and each day, you feel like you're getting better.' As for playing again in Páirc Uí Chaoimh, she said: 'To come back wearing a different shirt, it's the same feeling, you're representing something you're really proud of. It's phenomenal.' Meanwhile, Ireland coach Ward confirmed that centre-half Anna Patton would have to sit out the first-leg of the play-off through suspension. She added that the performance last night, although lacking in the goals needed to top the group, offered much to build on ahead of the play-offs. Next up for Ireland is a friendly double-header away to the USA at the end of the month. 'We are still building,' said Ward. 'Through this entire campaign we have had five training sessions with the entire squad, so to build the way we are and to finish the way we did, I could not ask for more. 'A couple of more goals? Yes. But we got to be proud of that performance. That was an Irish performance.' Describing the performance against Slovenia, the former Aston Villa boss added: 'Probably the way I'd put it would be a Carla Ward team on the ball and an Irish mentality off the ball. 'That's what we need to build on. We have to build on. 'If we want to play in an exciting way going forward, and that's the way I like my teams to play, we have to be better off the ball. And that was the start of it tonight. 'Now we go to the US and play the best in the world and try to continue that work, but there is still a lot of work to do. 'What it does do is put us in a position to build. And I said to the group; that's something, firstly, you can be proud of, secondly, that you can build upon and, thirdly, if we can combine the two, the future is bright.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Carla Ward: ‘Katie McCabe is on the verge of burnout'
'The way I would put it,' said Carla Ward , the Ireland manager, after a disappointing 1-0 defeat of Slovenia at Páirc Uí Chaoimh, 'it was a Carla Ward team on the ball and an Irish mentality off the ball. 'That's what we need to build on. If we want to play in an exciting way going forward, and that's the way I like my teams to play, we have to be better off the ball. 'And that was the start of it tonight. Now we go to the US and play the best in the world. There is still a lot of work to do but the future is bright.' Maybe so, but Anna Patten is suspended for the Nations League promotion play-off against one from Denmark, Belgium, Iceland or Austria, over two legs in October. READ MORE The draw takes place on Friday. Patten was one of five Irish players trying to avoid a second yellow card during a contest where Ireland needed a 4-0 result to top the group. It could have been much worse as Denise O'Sullivan avoided a booking and one-game ban. Referee Miriama Bočková shows a yellow card to Anna Patten of Ireland. Photograph: Ryan Byrne/Inpho 'We have to be tighter,' Ward continued after a campaign that yielded five wins and a 4-0 loss in Slovenia. 'The Irish have always been very good defensively. So, let's go back to the Irish basics, is what I'd call it. And it's just tight, it's compact, it's together. And then add in how we want to play with the ball 'We are still building. Through this entire campaign we have had five training sessions with the entire squad so to finish the way we did, I could not ask for more. 'That was an Irish performance.' Ward also confirmed that Katie McCabe and a number of senior players will not travel to the USA later this month for two friendlies against the Olympic champions in Colorado and Cincinnati. 'Katie has played an awful lot of minutes for club and country,' Ward explained. 'She's on the verge of burnout, as are some others. 'There's going to be conversations. It won't just be Katie that won't be travelling. 'You've seen with Millie Bright at England coming out, mental and physical fatigue is massive. I felt it as [manager of Aston] Villa. It's the reason I needed that break. 'It's a really tough place to be, and I think there's a lot of players close to that. They've played a lot of minutes, so we have to protect them. We have to protect them as people, and we'll support anybody that needs that break.' Ward confirmed that Louise Quinn has retired after winning her 122nd cap off the bench. 'It's been a really good, but emotional few days for everybody. I think everybody knows, Quinnie's a national sweetheart. She's a legend. She's somebody that everyone admires. 'So, we just had a few words, and she basically just touched on to the next generation - what it'– meant to her to wear the shirt is the proudest thing that you can ever do as an Irish person and make sure that you do not take a single minute for granted because she never did. 'I thought it was an unbelievable message to leave: 'Over to you girls.'' The next generation of players definitely include Jessie Stapleton, Emily Murphy and Abbie Larkin, who all excelled against an aggressive Slovenian side. Larkin, in particular, looks rejuvenated under Ward. 'Abbie probably doesn't realise how good she is, she is quite a quiet girl. She's got an abundance of quality, she's quick, she started the game electric. She's got a massive future ahead of her. I think her and Emily Murphy today, until they probably blew up because of the intensity they played at, were excellent.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Letters to the Editor, June 4th: On housing, rugby refereeing and bad sportsmanship
Sir, – I note the article by N icholas Mansergh, 'Ireland is overdependent on apartment development,' ( Business, June 2nd), where he states that an apartment of 80sqm costs an €150,000-€190,000 to build compared to a terraced house of same floor area. Here in Turkiye (Turkey) where I live for part of the year, the standard residential provision is a 12-storey apartment block, with two penthouses on top, comprising 50 two-bed apartments in total. It is difficult to find a house anywhere. How is it the case that the Turks can produce these developments cheaply and efficiently while we in Ireland cannot? I might also point out that Turkish modern apartments are of excellent design and quality. There is something wrong. How can, say, an apartment in a 50-unit block in Ireland cost in excess ¤150,000 more than a terrace house in a similar area? READ MORE Such an apartment shares the same site with adjacent apartments. It also shares floors, roofs, structural uprights, water and sewage systems and electrical systems with other adjacent apartments which logically should lead to lower costs for each individual unit. In general, materials for apartments and terraced houses cost the same. In Ireland it seems that there is over-regulation and over-specification regarding apartment construction. Indeed, Tánaiste Simon Harris recently indicated that he is open to seeing if these can be eased. The Irish have a historical bias against apartments and almost every proposed development is met by planning objections. The costs and time delays to apartment developers adds to the overall cost of construction. Large apartment developments require large construction companies and since the demise of the Celtic Tiger, these appear to no more. A solution may be to bring in large foreign companies from outside. Mr Mansergh makes the extraordinary claim that apartments are not suitable for owner occupiers and may not be viable in the future. Really? The rest of the world does not think so. – Yours, etc, TIMOTHY RYAN, Castleknock, Dublin 15. Sir, – I completely agree with Nicholas Mansergh that Ireland is over-dependent on apartment development while unduly focused on private investment funds to satisfy our housing needs. While the rapid expansion of apartment buildings in the 1990s in Dublin, led by major Irish builders, produced much-needed apartment accommodation for workers and students, at that time private buyers were also incentivised to purchase. Since then while apartment blocks were built, few individual units were advertised for sale. Entire blocks were purchased by investment funds and this continues to be the case. There are many unintended consequences: workers are forced to rent at very high rates (as investors seek a return); few apartments are being sold to owner occupiers, few family homes are being built that might be purchased by tenants who want to a home to raise a family. If we continue to focus on investment-led office and apartment blocks, we are left with few contractors and skilled staff to build much needed family homes. In order to explore this issue further, it would be helpful to compare the number of new builds by city and county councils. For instance, have some counties – like Galway – generated more domestic family units in suburbs and village communities than others. If so what are the factors that actively contribute to such developments? A regional 'best practice model' would help the Government to further explore and resolve our housing needs. – Yours, etc, Dr EVELYN MAHON, Fellow Emerita, School of Social Work and Social Policy, Trinity College, Dublin 2 . Sir, – Your columnist Pat Leahy's article ('Housing emergency? It's not even treated as mildly urgent', May 31st) makes for depressing reading. There is zero chance, just several months into a new administration, of the Government meeting its promised 300,000 completed units during its term. The simple truth is that the biggest societal challenge within Ireland today is going to become more serious and more socially alienating over the short- to medium-term future. The likelihood of amplified social unrest is very high, driven by frustration and anger at a continuing failure to address what has been a known problem for over a decade now. The current approach to fixing the problem is clearly suboptimal. It is time for the Taoiseach to show real leadership and steer through the necessary emergency legislation that rapidly removes the identifiable roadblocks, be they infrastructural, planning, financial, tax-based etc. Such legislation was passed in 2020 in the public interest in response to Covid 19. It is past time to recognise our housing crisis as the social challenge that has and will increasingly have an impact on every aspect of our society, in an ever-increasing negative way. More of the same approach to addressing this crisis will commit us to certain failure and a likely dual outcome of increased emigration and domestic social upheaval. – Yours, etc, GERRY PRIZEMAN, Clontarf, Dublin. Leaving Certificate results Sir, – This is the week that the Leaving Cert starts in Ireland. Here in France the equivalent state exam, the Baccalauréat, starts next week. In both countries the exams will end in the third week in June. And then something very odd happens. Here in France, students will get their results within two weeks, and this has been the norm for generations. But in Ireland, students have to wait a staggering two months. This delay has always been the case in Ireland, but it is also very unfair on students. Stress and uncertainty could be avoided, particularly by students being able to plan and prepare for the future during the summer, as opposed to rushing and panicking in the last week in August. Can we not do better ? Make 'beatha an scoláire aoibhinn arís'. Make student life joyful again. – Yours, etc, CIARÁN Mac GUILL, Clichy, France. Sir , – Can I respectfully request The Irish Times and other print and broadcast media outlets to desist from their daily analysis of the Leaving Certificate examinations? This annual exercise of detailed exam postmortems is not only futile, but puts added stress on students and their parents/guardians. – Yours, etc, Dr PADRAIG McGARTY, Mohill, Co Leitrim. Tsar play Sir, – In reference to your editorial 'To tsar or not to tsar ' (May 31st), you quoted the secretary general of the relevant department as saying such a person is not needed and also pointed to the fact that a tsar could in fact be a person appointed by government to resolve a particular issue. First of all, let me say that the reaction of the secretary general is typical. Secretary generals never want to cede power. Secondly, numerous politicians and ministers over the years realise that their departments and civil servants are incapable of resolving particular issues and delivering the required change. As a result, they establish agencies to do so and oft times put in place specific legislation to allow them to resolve issues and effect change. Even so, the departments resist the efforts of agencies to deliver their legislative responsibilities. They do not like the fact that their minister can actually refer to the chair of an agency rather than them. More times than not, the chief executive is caught in the middle, keeping the balance and bearing the responsibility between chair, board and department. In most cases, the department wins such struggles. I had the benefit of managing such tensions for many years as chief executive of the Heritage Council. My experience tells me that with the legislative responsibilities given by government to agencies (tsar or no tsar) at least the agency has a clear idea what it has to do and very often does just that. Certainly, to date as far as housing is concerned no department has come anywhere near. – Yours, etc, MICHAEL STARRETT, Kilkenny. Defence Forces and pay issue Sir, – M artin Wall's article ('Expert group raised Air Corps staffing concerns in 2021, June 2nd) outlines the recommendations made by the joint Department of Defence/Defence Forces Group in 2021 to dissuade military air traffic controllers from leaving the Air Corps for the better paid private sector. His article also states that this 2021 report was not acted on, which now raises the prospect in 2025 of Air Corps management having to restrict its decades long 24/7 air-traffic control services. For clarity, I'm adding here that it is various Civil Service departments who control pay and conditions and not Air Corps management in this instance. So, the obvious question is why has this deteriorating situation been allowed to drag on? Mr Wall's comment that the 2021 report was not acted on provides a partial answer. The full answer needs the question to be asked, which is: which department/person rejected the group's recommendations and what reasons were given at the time? Was it based on technical or financial advice or something else? The Civil Service sometimes acts in an arcane way but this is one simple answer that doesn't need the imprimatur of the Minister of Defence. Of course, the Minister himself has the power to put an end to this needless morale sapping of the Air Corps capabilities. It's a situation crying out for political action and not mere words anymore. – Yours, etc, Comdt FRANK RUSSELL (ret'd) Blanchardstown, Dublin 15. National Anthem Sir, – I noticed that prior to the Dublin v Armagh senior football championship fixture in Croke Park on Sunday, an announcement was made over the public address system to players and spectators to respect in full the national anthem. It reflects positively on all concerned that the message was complied with. Perhaps someone in authority in Croke Park had read Kevin O'Regan's letter of May 30th in the Irish Times letters page: Our international rugby and soccer teams stand proudly to attention at all times during the playing of our anthem, so why not GAA players? – Yours, etc, RICHARD POWER, Ballymacarbry, Co Waterford. Sir, – A correspondent compares the pride and passion displayed by Ireland rugby players in their singing of the national anthem compared to GAA players. My observation, since I depend a lot on lip-reading, is that not all the Ireland rugby players know all the words and their obvious guessing makes me cringe. It must be stressful for them too on a day which is already exacting enough. I think the anthem, sung only for home games, should be dropped. Ireland's Call, whatever its defects, has at least the unifying advantage of representing all the provinces, and is easy to learn. – Yours, etc, PATRICK O'DONOGHUE, Maynooth, Co Kildare. Nuclear energy Sir, – Dr Anne Baily (Letters, June 2nd) suggests nuclear energy as a means to help Ireland meet its climate targets. While the urgency is undeniable, the proposed solution deserves closer scrutiny. Replacing fossil fuels (which we now know have caused profound harm) with nuclear technology (that we already know is deeply hazardous and problematic for a very long time) is hardly an improvement. It risks exchanging one legacy of environmental damage for another. Climate breakdown cannot be solved purely through technological fixes, or by sidestepping the more difficult task of changing the systems and lifestyles that fuel greenhouse gas emissions as well as a host of broader environmental crises. The real challenge is to rethink how we live, consume and use energy. Renewables, energy efficiency and community-based solutions already offer safer, faster and more democratic ways forward. Ireland should invest in those, rather than repeating old mistakes under a new name. – Yours, etc, HANS ZOMER, Chief Executive Officer, Global Action Plan, Dublin. Calling foul on rugby antics Sir, – As usual Owen Doyle ( 'Persistent acceptance of foul play is a dreadful reflection on rugby', June 3rd) is exactly right. What was once a beautiful game has been allowed to degenerate, on and off the field. The forward-dominated assaults on the goal line, with the endless penalty advantages, the ping-pong kicking, the boorish behaviour of some players and the ignorant and abusive antics of sections of supporters are killing the game. I feel sorry for referees attempting to deal with the ever-changing and often inconsistent laws, and players trying to pull the wool over their eyes, but that does not disguise the fact, as Doyle points out, that some are simply not up to the task, and nor, it seems, are many of the administrators, who are guilty of neglect. – Yours, etc, BILL REDMOND, Edinburgh, Scotland. Sir, – As an avid soccer fan I have been admonished, patronised and chastised by rugby-supporting friends about the moral superiority surrounding the conduct of rugby players on the field of play. The antics of Jaden Hendrikse at Kings Park, Durban, on Saturday nailed this myth once and for all. Not alone did Hendrikse enact a fabricated 'cramp' episode to inconvenience an opponent, he added a 'wink' as his coup de grace. Gerry Thornley bemoans the failure to maintain the values of respect shown by this episode ('Sharks shameful antics betrayed moral code that makes rugby special', Tuesday, June 3rd). Perhaps, the moral code attributed to rugby now resides 'with O'Leary in the grave'. – Yours, etc, JOHN NAUGHTON, Leopardstown, Dublin 18. Bigger picture Sir, – We are hearing again about the Calor Gas-sponsored housewife of the year competition that took place annually from 1967 to 1995. When I hear negative comments about this event I think it's important to keep the bigger picture in mind and not get drawn into presentism and to remember that you cannot judge the morning by the rules of the afternoon. – Yours, etc, MARY DALY, Dublin.
