Ireland ‘silent' on watering down of European Union's sustainability rules for companies
The Government has been 'silent' on the watering down of EU legislation aimed at obliging big companies to stamp out human rights abuses and environmental harm 'despite many other member states speaking out', an Oireachtas committee has heard.
Officials from Irish Coalition for Business and Human Rights (ICBHR) and business lobby group Ibec were before the
Oireachtas Committee on Enterprise, Tourism and Employment
on Wednesday to offer expert views on two pieces of European law.
The
EU's corporate sustainability due diligence directive
requires large companies to investigate human rights and environmental abuses in their supply chain, while the corporate sustainability reporting directive (CSRD) forces them to report on their impact on the environment and their exposure to climate risk.
However, the European Commission published omnibus legislation in February that delayed the implementation of both laws, significantly watered down the proposals, and effectively reduced the number of businesses within the scope of the laws from about 50,000 to 10,000.
READ MORE
ICBHR policy and advocacy officer Ross Fitzpatrick said his group has met with Government officials on 'numerous occasions', but 'thus far the Irish Government hasn't outlined its position on this'.
'The only real position we have managed to elicit is that Ireland is in favour of the simplification agenda but they do not want to see human rights and environmental protection undone,' he said.
'If that is the case though, the time to speak up is now. Not in six months when this directive has been completely gutted at Brussels' level. What we've heard is that the Government has been silent despite many other member states speaking out.'
Will rent reform make building apartments viable?
Listen |
40:12
The ICBHR policy co-ordinator Evie Clarke said negotiations are ongoing at European Council level, but 'may be wrapped up within the next month or so'.
Ibec head of EU policy Neil Willoughby said legislation 'should be practical' for companies to comply with and for national authorities to enforce, as well as being 'complementary and additive' to existing national laws in EU member states.
'It is clear the original legislation did not meet these criteria,' he said. 'The CSRD introduces significant new requirements and related costs for businesses of all sizes by putting sustainability reporting on a par with financial reporting.
'For all companies in scope, it represents a new departure in terms of the level of detailed information that must be reported and the corresponding increase in the number of resources that must be allocated.'
He added that the cost to companies would be 'enormous'.
Ibec head of skills and social policy Kara McGann said the laws would be 'challenging in terms of time, capital, and people' and that the reporting aspect itself 'can on occasion nearly divert from the actual need of addressing the particular risk'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Post
5 hours ago
- Irish Post
In Ireland cattle is still king, but for how long?
AMERICAN firm Stacy May memorably declared that 'in the Irish economy cattle is king' when it released its economic report in the 1950s. 75 years later, the cattle and beef industry is still going strong, although they now share the economic crown with tech and pharmaceuticals. But behind the rolling green fields and premium quality beef, the industry faces a dual challenge: climate pressure at home and market instability abroad. Ireland's mild, wet climate makes it perfect for grass-growing year-round, which in turn is ideal for cattle farming. This natural setup allows cows to graze freely, reducing the need for indoor housing and expensive feed imports. From a welfare and economic standpoint, it's a win-win: lower costs and happier herds. Grass-fed cattle are not just a selling point for foreign markets; they also form the backbone of Irish dairy and beef production. Grass-based diets have long been linked with more nutritious and better-tasting meat and milk. This green image is a key selling point abroad, but it may also be its Achilles' heel. Despite the idyllic image of cattle grazing under the Irish sun, or more often the Irish rain, the environmental cost is particularly high. Methane from cattle digestion is a lot more potent than CO₂ as a greenhouse gas. The Environmental Protection Agency reports that the average cow emits around 2.3 metric tonnes of CO₂ a year. Agriculture now accounts for about a third of Ireland's total emissions. Despite a livestock population of over seven million cattle and five million sheep, Ireland did not meet its 2020 EU emissions targets and could now face potential penalties. Alongside Malta, it is one of just two EU member states that missed its carbon reduction goals. Various ways to tackle this have been raised over the years, including modifying cattle diets to include lower-fibre feed or using biodigesters to recycle manure. One promising solution involves sending any money from EU fines towards establishing a national institute for sustainable agriculture research. Such a centre could explore new practices like silvopasture, which integrates tree planting into grazing areas, which has shown promise in Spain with the famed acorn-fed Jamón Ibérico pork. Not only do trees trap carbon, but they also provide shelter and food sources for livestock. Offsetting emissions through tree planting, especially with native trees like oak, could also make a big difference. With beef and dairy consumption slowly falling each year across Europe, the industry faces both economic and environmental headwinds. Helping farmers adapt now could help in the long term and position Ireland as a global leader in sustainable agriculture. Currently, Irish beef prices have reached record levels, driven by tight supplies across Britain and Europe. Live exports are up 17%, which amounts to roughly 34,000 head. While a fall in calf registrations, along with decreasing suckler and dairy cow numbers, is tightening the supply line. Ireland's overall number of cattle fell by over 200,000 in 2024, a 3.3% decrease. Suckler cows fell by 6.2%, and dairy herds shrank by 2%, according to the Central Statistics Office (CSO). These numbers are echoed throughout Europe. The European Commission expects a 1% drop in beef production in 2025 and projects a 0.6 million tonne reduction by 2035. Suckler cow numbers alone are forecast to fall 11% EU-wide during this time. Britain faces similar shortfalls. The suckler cow population dropped by nearly 5%, although the dairy herd grew slightly. Disease outbreaks like bluetongue in Europe have also added to cattle supply chain issues. Ireland's reputation for premium beef is seen as a big selling point internationally, including recent access to the South Korean market. After a two-decade absence due to BSE-related bans, Irish beef returned to Korean shelves in May 2024. A recent trade mission to Seoul, led by Agriculture Minister Martin Heydon, aimed to strengthen trade between the two countries. 'Korean consumers associate beef as being the top purchase for protein,' Heydon said. 'Grass-fed beef is considered the healthier option, which fits very well with our Irish product.' With four Irish processors now certified to export to Korea and the first shipments already there, Bord Bia seems quite confident for the future. Although 2024 food exports to Korea amounted to only €36 million, a small portion of the €17 billion global total, the priority seems to be forming long-term partnerships. 'The value is in the values,' said Bord Bia CEO Jim O'Toole, noting Korean interest in both quality and sustainability. Ireland's cattle and beef industry is entering a new era. On one hand, it enjoys strong global demand, especially in premium markets. On the other, it faces existential environmental challenges and continuing decline in Europe. If cattle is still king, it's a monarch facing very modern challenges. See More: Beef, Cattle, Economy, Martin Heydon, South Korea
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Aviation stocks pull European shares indices lower
Aviation stocks plunged globally on Thursday after an Air India flight crashed in India, killing at least 200 people, while concerns about rising tensions in the Middle East weighed heavily on investor sentiment. With question marks hanging over the US and China's trade truce, risk assets sold off as investors jumped into safe havens, including gold. Dublin The Iseq index closed 0.7 per cent lower on Thursday as Ryanair and listed home builders Cairn Homes and Glenveagh edged lower. READ MORE Ryanair dropped 2.7 per cent to €23.85 per share after the fatal air crash in India involving a Boeing aircraft. Glenveagh and Cairn Homes were down by 1 per cent and 0.7 per cent to close at €1.81 and €2.25 per share, respectively. Thursday's decline for the home-building sector followed a surge on Wednesday after the Government unveiled its significant reforms to its rental sector regulations. Banking stocks, meanwhile, were mixed with AIB up 1 per cent to €7.04 per share while Bank of Ireland shed 1 per cent to close at €12.16. Kingspan improved by 0.5 per cent to €78.15 per share and Kerry Group was essentially flat on the session at €97.45. London Bucking European trends, the benchmark FTSE 100 index advanced by 0.2 per cent, closing near a record high amid strong buying in the energy sector. The mid-cap FTSE 250, meanwhile, closed down by 0.2 per cent. Halma led the blue-chip index on Thursday after the British health and safety device-maker forecast higher revenue growth for fiscal year 2026 and beat annual profit expectations, sending its shares to a record high. Energy stocks also helped buoy the FTSE with oil majors BP and Shell up by 1.9 per cent and 1.2 per cent on the session. Precious metal miners advanced 3.2 per cent, tracking higher gold prices as investors moved into the traditional safe-haven asset. Moving down the index, Aer Lingus owner IAG fell by more than 3.1 per cent and EasyJet shed 3.8 per cent as part of a wider sectoral move after Thursday's Air India crash. Among other stocks, Intermediate Capital Group and JD Sports lost 3.5 per cent and 3.8 per cent, respectively, as they traded without entitlement to their latest dividend payout. Europe Airline's dragged Europe's main stock indices lower, with the Stoxx 50 falling by more than 0.6 per cent and the pan-European Stoxx 600 down 0.3 per cent. Air France plunged 7.2 per cent while German carrier Lufthansa sank 3.7 per cent lower. Automakers Mercedes, Ferrari and Stellantis shed between 0.7 per cent and 2.7 per cent, while BMW edged 0.5 per cent lower and Volkswagen dropped by 0.9 per cent. Luxury brands Kering, down 3.1 per cent, and LVMH, down 0.3 per cent, also lost momentum. New York The S&P 500 and Nasdaq edged higher on Thursday as Oracle's results boosted optimism around artificial intelligence, offsetting concerns around rising tensions in the Middle East and a drop in Boeing shares. Oracle shares shot up nearly 14 per cent to record highs after the cloud service provider raised its annual revenue growth forecast, driven by strong demand for its AI-related cloud services. Alphabet declined 1.1 per cent, while Nvidia nudged 0.3 per cent higher. Boeing declined 5 per cent after an Air India 787-8 Dreamliner jet crashed minutes after taking off in India's western city of Ahmedabad, killing more than 200 people. U.S.-listed shares of gold miners also advanced, as bullion prices hit a one-week high. Newmont gained 2.4 per cent, Harmony Gold was up 2.1 per cent and AngloGold Ashanti rose 5.2 per cent. – Additional reporting: Reuters, Bloomberg
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Russian embassy denies ‘pathetic' accusation Moscow is deliberately targeting Ukraine civilians
Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris has said Ireland remains 'steadfast' in its support for Ukraine in a statement that has caused a reaction from the Russian embassy. Mr Harris accused Russia of escalating the war in Ukraine with more than 2,000 drone and missile attacks on Ukraine since June 1st. In response, the Russian embassy accused Mr Harris of 'pathetically' suggesting Russia is deliberately targeting civilians. In a statement issued after a week of heavy bombardment of Ukraine, Mr Harris said Russian attacks have been predominantly against civilian targets including a maternity hospital. READ MORE 'I condemn them completely, as I do Russia's ongoing war of aggression,' he said. 'I extend my condolences to the families of those who have been killed and injured. Our solidarity with Ukraine remains steadfast. 'Russia started this war. As the aggressor, it is for Russia to demonstrate a genuine commitment towards peace by halting its brutal attacks. It can do so at any time,' he said. Last week the Russian ambassador to Ireland Yuriy Filatov accused Ireland of supporting 'state terrorism by the Kiev [sic] regime' and being 'de facto accomplices' in the blowing up of a train bridge near the Russian city of Bryansk that killed seven civilians. He warned the Irish Government Russia would hold it and other European governments responsible for Ukraine's actions and they 'should be aware that the day of reckoning will inevitably come'. In a follow-up statement issued on Thursday, the embassy accused Mr Harris of 'anti-Russian propaganda which distorts reality and misleads the public'. [ Russia attacks Kyiv with missiles and drones 'in response' to Ukraine actions Opens in new window ] Despite video and photographic footage that shows Russian attacks on residential buildings and a maternity hospital in the last week, the embassy claimed Russia 'never' targets civilians and is only interested in military installations in Ukraine. These include missile, armour and shipbuilding industry enterprises in Kyiv, command posts, military equipment of Ukrainian formations and factories producing long-range drones. The embassy claimed that Russia is committed to a peaceful settlement of the Ukrainian war and had sought diplomatic ways to avoid war in 2014, 2021 and 2022. The West's plans, the embassy concluded, has 'always been not peace in Ukraine but imposition of war on Ukrainian and Russian peoples. Now the West reaps what it sows, trying to shift the blame to Russia. The world and the large part of the Irish public are not buying that.'
