The Irish Times view on the EPA emissions report: Ireland falling ever further behind key targets
The fact that
Ireland is not on track
to meet its critical 51 per cent carbon emissions reduction target by 2030 is no surprise. It tallies with EPA projections of recent years and repeated failures to meet carbon budgets. What is a shock is confirmation that climate progress
has slipped backwards
and the gap to that target is widening.
Last year a 29 per cent reduction by 2030 was the best-case scenario; this year it is 23 per cent. Even with full implementation and delivery of the Government's climate plan,
Ireland is projected to exceed the 2021-2025 carbon budget
by 12 million tonnes and the 2026-2030 equivalent by 114 million tonnes.
This comes in the wake of the ambitions of successive governments, reinforced by legally-binding targets. These were meant to put an onus on the worst carbon polluters to transform their activities. The State, for its part, committed to supporting the clean energy transition while giving agriculture an easier path to decarbonisation.
The response in transport, agriculture, land use and buildings
has been nowhere near what was required
. The exception is power generation using renewables – but even that is coming up short. Systemic delays, notably in permitting and planning, are slowing progress on many fronts, including offshore wind, electric vehicles, district heating and biomethane use. Vital grid infrastructure is also behind schedule.
READ MORE
Since the introduction of carbon budgets, there had been some progress. Emissions fell by 6.8 per cent in 2023, suggesting downward momentum was finally being achieved. Ireland was seeing real decoupling of emissions from economic activity. Yet the country is not on a sufficiently sustainable footing, and the EPA data indicates the current position could unravel further, as options become more limited closer to 2030.
This could all involve severe financial penalties for the State. The EPA projections suggest the bill for buying carbon credits to offset emissions being ahead of target could be at the higher end of Irish Fiscal Advisory Council estimates, which range from ¤8 billion to ¤26 billion. A further difficulty is surging energy demand, while fossil fuels continue to account for 80 per cent of Ireland's energy supply, almost half of which is imported.
The days when minimal incremental reductions in emissions can be spun as progress are over. The emissions gap has to be closed by the Government with a new strategic focus across all departments and State agencies. Otherwise, its spending options will become severely constrained – not just under climate and energy headings – and we will have undermined efforts to curb global warming and its menacing consequences. And we will also have missed the chance to enhance the life of Irish citizens by improving the natural environment and cutting pollution.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Ireland facing backlash in US over Gaza stance, says President Higgins
The Taoiseach and the President have warned of an international propaganda campaign against Ireland because of the Government's criticism of Israel's bombardment of Palestinians. Micheál Martin has called out Israeli 'propaganda' that implies the people of Ireland support Hamas and accused Israel of twisting the Irish position of recognising Palestine and our support of the International Court of Justice case against Israel. Earlier, President Michael D Higgins said there is an active campaign against Ireland in the US. Mr Higgins said it is 'a disgrace and a slander' to suggest that criticism of Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu's policies is somehow antisemitic. 'That is a disgrace and a slander and has been a slander against Ireland, against individuals, including myself,' he said. 'The idea that propaganda can pay against Ireland is now active in the United States so that when we are seeking to have meetings with people who are investing in Ireland, they are being contacted in advance with a suggestion of saying: 'You must open with, why is Ireland so against the US position in Israel?'.' Mr Martin agreed that there are attempts to 'smear Ireland' and that Mr Higgins had been a focus of some of this, which he described as 'regrettable'. The Taoiseach stressed that he and the Government had consistently condemned Hamas, but said the Irish people 'are sickened by the barbarity and the scale of what is happening' with Israeli attacks on Gaza. Mr Martin also warned there was 'some distance' to go before an EU majority supports a suspension of the EU-Israel Association Agreement, but that a recent EU move to review the agreement was not something he would have anticipated six months ago. Taoiseach Micheal Martin (left) with Nessa Doran O'Reilly (right), the Furniture Program Manager at the Rediscovery Centre in Ballymun, on the opening day of the annual Bloom festival at Phoenix Park in Dublin. Picture: Liam McBurney/PA Wire Shortly after the Taoiseach's comments, it was confirmed that several shots were fired in an area near where Irish peacekeeping troops are serving in southern Lebanon, near Israel's blue line. None of the Irish personnel, who were recently deployed as part of the UN operation, were injured in the incident. In a statement, the Defence Forces said a number of rounds were fired in the vicinity of the area where the patrol was operating. 'The patrol withdrew from the area, there were no injuries to the personnel on the patrol and no damage reported to the armoured vehicles they were operating from,' the statement said. 'All personnel of the Irish contingent in Lebanon are reported to be safe and well, they continue to monitor the situation in southern Lebanon and are committed to the stability of the region as impartial peacekeepers. 'We wish to remind all actors of their responsibility to ensure the safety and security of UN peacekeepers.' Yesterday, Israel said it will establish 22 new settlements in the occupied West Bank — including the legalisation of outposts already built without government authorisation — after a security cabinet vote held in secret last week. Israel occupied the West Bank, capturing it from Jordan, in the six-day war of 1967. Since then, successive Israeli governments have tried to permanently cement control over the land, in part by declaring swathes as 'state lands', which prevents private Palestinian ownership. Meanwhile, the White House said Israel 'backed and supported' a new peace proposal, which Hamas continues to evaluate. The proposal was intended to return surviving as well as dead hostages still being held in Gaza in exchange for an extended truce in fighting. Hamas has said it had agreed with US president Donald Trump's special envoy, Steve Witkoff, on a 'general framework' of an agreement that would lead to a lasting ceasefire, a full Israeli withdrawal from Gaza, an influx of aid, and a transfer of power from the militant group to a politically independent committee of Palestinians. Read More Carbon footprint of Israel's war on Gaza exceeds that of many entire countries
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Climate action progress could attract investment, experts say, amid looming hefty EU fines
The Government's delayed approach to complying with climate-related targets and agreements may threaten Ireland's position as an attractive place to do business, according to collaborators of a major report. Marie Donnelly, chair of the Climate Change Advisory Council (CCAC), along with budgetary watchdog Ifac's chief economist Eddie Casey cautioned, since the publication of their report in March, that a likely hefty EU fine for incompliance with agreements could impact foreign direct investment (FDI) opportunities. 'There's good reason to say, given what we are seeing internationally happening and all this uncertainty that is threatening Ireland's competitiveness, that we're going to lean into these areas that are helping (FDI) and attracting multinationals to stay here,' said Mr Casey. The report, 'A Colossal Missed Opportunity — Ireland's climate action and the potential costs of missing targets', found the Government could be on the hook for fines between €8bn and €26bn if it fails to meet its agreed EU climate commitments outlined in legislation. 'The danger is that this is quite close to reality because the additional measures that they have said they will enact, they haven't followed through on yet,' said Mr Casey. If the Government implements the additional measures in its own Climate Action Plan by 2030, it could reduce the fine range to €3bn to €12bn. 'With every crisis, you have opportunities too,' he said. Mr Casey stressed the significance of investing in the renewable sector and meeting climate agreements to maintain relationships with multinationals, especially as trade tensions continue to simmer amid US president Donald Trump's tariff threats and his ambition to lure large firms back to the US. Eddie Casey, chief economist, Ifac. 'Thankfully, it looks like the Government is taking more urgency following the tariffs debacle to really get a grip on how they can deliver and accelerate it,' said Mr Casey. Ifac has long warned against the Government's overdependence on corporation tax for financial padding in annual budgets, however three quarters of the corporation tax haul last year was from US companies and around 40% was collected from just three companies. 'We are incredibly reliant on them and we don't want to lose that,' said Mr Casey. Multinationals have become increasingly interested in locations with a renewable energy supply and a reinforced energy grid as they come under mounting pressure to fuel their electricity-guzzling data centres in a more sustainable way. 'They've been really worried for a long time about Ireland's ability to actually deliver energy so they can, as a tech firm, have a larger data centre,' said Mr Casey. Ms Donnelly echoed Mr Casey's comments and said the EU's Green Deal and its clean competitiveness agenda 'are effectively the same thing'. 'Europe understands that we have to have energy both for our society and our economy,' she continued. 'It's clear that the energy we currently use is neither sustainable, it doesn't have supply security, it can blow the cost of living out of the water, it's largely drawn by not very politically stable parts of the world and it's very bad for our climate because it's full of emissions,' she said. These legally binding EU agreements that Ireland has entered require domestic reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, an increasing share of renewable energy, and improved energy efficiency. A key piece of the legislation is the Effort Sharing Regulation, which Ireland and other EU countries agreed to adopt in 2018. It covers emissions from domestic transport, buildings, small industry, waste, and agriculture. If Ireland emits more than allowed, the state will have to purchase the gap from overperforming countries — those that reduce their emissions more than required. Other countries, including Spain and Portugal, have been overperforming in terms of their climate mandates because they have taken money from other countries that are underperforming. However, Ireland has around five times the cost of missing targets compared to a larger economy such as Germany which is underperforming. However, Mr Casey explained that Germany can afford to miss targets. Marie Donnelly, chair of the Climate Change Advisory Council (CCAC). Ireland has shown Europe it is capable of economic miracles, including its recovery from the banking crisis in 2008 to boasting healthy public finances after years of volatility, including covid lockdowns, soaring inflation and interest rate hikes. However, Ireland has not been as skillful in performing miracles when it comes to its emissions targets. In 2022, Ireland had the second-highest emissions of greenhouse gases per capita in the EU at 11.7 tonnes of carbon dioxide, figures from the Central Statistics Office showed. Ireland's emissions were 56% higher than the EU average of 7.5 tonnes. Meanwhile, the most recent projections from environmental agency EPA showed Ireland can achieve a 25% reduction of emissions by 2030, which is considerably short of the 42% reduction target. In addition, Ireland fell below its renewable energy share target baseline share in 2021, 2022 and 2023 and could face costs from purchasing compliance for falling below its baseline share in 2021 and 2022 but as things stand, not for 2023, according to the climate report. This is because countries have one year to return above their baseline share. Ireland is expected to return above its baseline share in 2024. Ireland's slow movement towards climate progress may be driven by a lack of serious consequences to date. 'There is a view amongst some that this is never going to happen, that they wouldn't be fined,' said Ms Donnelly. She repeated the point that if Ireland does get fined, the bill will without doubt be at least an eye-watering €8bn. Mr Casey also said that 'if they're not going to do it, they're basically breaking the law. The State would have the resources to do that without having to hike taxes or cut spending on any ongoing supports,' he said. Mr Casey added that if this were to happen, it 'would be a colossal wasted opportunity because that is money that could be put towards loads of potential measures that would meet the targets'. If Ireland does not comply with the EU's mandate, the money that Ireland will be fined will transfer to other countries in Europe.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Dublin City Council pays €2m a year for vacant hostel
An investment fund promoted by barrister and debt adviser Ross Maguire is receiving rent of €2 million per year from Dublin City Council for a vacant hostel. Avalon House at Aungier Street, Dublin city, has been dormant since a legal wrangle six years ago when local objectors went to the High Court to block plans by the Peter McVerry Trust (PMVT) charity to provide homeless accommodation in the property. The dispute led Dublin City Council to take over the McVerry Trust lease in May 2021. The council pays €300,000 in annual insurance, security and utility costs in addition to the €2 million annual rent. Apart from a ground floor café, the property is vacant. Under the PMVT and council tenancies, the total rent bill was €10 million between 2020 and 2024. In the same period, the additional costs were about €1.5 million. READ MORE 'Avalon House is not usable without significant capital works, as PMVT had commenced strip-out prior to the lease transfer,' said the Dublin Region Homeless Executive (DRHE), a division of the city council. A new planning process was set in motion in February 2023, but an application to develop a homeless family hub in the property has still not been submitted. Since 2022, the landlord is Irish Social Housing Fund 1, an investment vehicle promoted by Mr Maguire in partnership with international investors. 'It is not my fund and I have no ownership in the fund,' Mr Maguire said in reply to questions. A senior counsel, he came to prominence after the financial crash as a debt adviser to people in mortgage arrears and later moved into investment. The fund is listed among the partners of his advisory company New Beginning on its website. Avalon House, once a medical school, is a protected structure, meaning owners are required to prevent it from becoming endangered. The building was a hostel for backbackers before the PMVT set out plans to provide emergency accommodation for up to 155 rough sleepers. The trust had taken out a 20-year lease on the property in November 2019 with a company called Trittkopf, whose ultimate parent is BJM, a firm based in Cyprus. The city council took over the lease 'for the residue of the term' as part of the settlement of the court case. When Irish Social Housing Fund 1 acquired Avalon House in 2022, Mr Maguire was described as its 'authorised signatory' in a planning submission to the council. Mr Maguire suggested questions should be directed to the fund itself but a phone call to the fund was answered in his New Beginning office. The fund is authorised and supervised by the Central Bank. However, the bank said it 'does not have any regulatory role to make publicly available the prospectus or financial statements of the fund'. Responsibility for releasing financial information was with the alternative investment fund manager, the bank said. The fund manager, IQ-EQ, did not return phone calls or reply to questions emailed to a named company official in Dublin. The DRHE said it considered 'all options' for Avalon House, including exiting the lease or an alterative use for it. 'A family hub was considered to be the only viable use,' it said. 'The DRHE commenced the capital works application process, conditional approval was granted by the DHLGH in February 2023 and full Stage 1 approval given in June 2023, following compliance with the funding conditions,' it added. 'In late 2023, the DRHE tendered to procure an integrated design team. An integrated design team for the transformation of Avalon House into a family hub was appointed on April 5th, 2024, and we are currently preparing a planning application for a family hub.'
