Simeon Brown Hid Dunedin Hospital Downgrade
Simeon Brown needs to come clean to the people of Dunedin about why he hid plans to downgrade their new hospital's Intensive Care Unit.
The Otago Daily Times today revealed then-Health Minister Dr Shane Reti was told on January 23 this year that the number of ICU beds would be reduced on opening from 30 to 20.
'Simeon Brown then took over as Health Minister and swooped into Dunedin a week later trying to act the hero on the hospital. But he failed to share this important information about downgrading the number of ICU beds,' Labour acting health spokesperson Peeni Henare said.
'While attempting to patch up the mess National had made of Dunedin Hospital he hid the fact a third of its planned intensive care beds had been cut.
'That is hugely disingenuous. I can see why locals, including the former head of the emergency department, are angry,' Peeni Henare said.
This follows reporting by Stuff at the weekend that New Zealand is nationally 500 hospital beds short.
'Simeon Brown continues to claim everything is going to be okay despite announcing a health infrastructure plan without a cent of actual funding attached, and stopping hospitals from hiring the workforce they need under the guise of saving money,' Peeni Henare said.
'National's track record is to scale back and delay hospital builds as it has done with Nelson and Dunedin hospitals, which will cost New Zealanders more in the long run. Simeon Brown is content kicking the can down the road while people's health suffers,' Peeni Henare said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
2 hours ago
- Scoop
Radiology Backlog Cleared At Taranaki Base Hospital
Hon Simeon Brown Minister of Health Health Minister Simeon Brown has welcomed the clearance of a significant radiology backlog at Taranaki Base Hospital, calling it a practical outcome that puts patients first. 'In March, more than 6,000 x-ray reports were sitting unprocessed at Taranaki Base Hospital. That was causing unacceptable delays for patients needing diagnosis and treatment,' Mr Brown says. 'People in Taranaki deserve access to timely, high-quality healthcare – and that includes getting diagnostic results back quickly. With the backlog now cleared and all results referred back to GPs, patients are now receiving their results.' To address the backlog, Health New Zealand made full use of available public radiology resources and engaged private imaging providers to boost reporting capacity and return results directly to patients' GPs. 'This was a practical, solutions-focused response. By combining public capacity with private sector support, the backlog was cleared efficiently, and care has been sped up for thousands of people.' Outsourcing remains in place to manage ongoing demand and reduce the risk of future backlogs. 'Taranaki Base Hospital will continue to use private capacity where needed – an approach that is consistent with the Government's broader strategy to reduce waitlists across the health system. "Our focus on reducing waitlists has already resulted in more than 8,600 additional elective procedures being delivered through outsourcing. It's a clear example of how we can apply the same approach to diagnostics – using targeted outsourcing to deliver faster care. 'We are committed to practical improvements that reduce delays, support frontline services, and deliver better outcomes for patients. 'This result in Taranaki shows what can be achieved when we stay focused on what matters – making sure New Zealanders get the care they need, when they need it,' Mr Brown says.
The Spinoff
7 hours ago
- The Spinoff
The water cremation floodgates are officially open in Aotearoa
It's the biggest change to the funeral industry in over a century, and there's already a queue forming. This month, a Christchurch woman named Margaret made history as the first person in New Zealander to be water cremated. 'She had been unwell for some time, and she wanted to be the first,' says Debbie Richards, founder of Water Cremation New Zealand. 'She was a very adventurous woman and a bit of a pioneer, and she'll always be a very special person to me.' A gold plaque with Margaret's name on it was unveiled last week in the water crematorium at Bell, Lamb and Trotter in Ōtautahi, one of the country's oldest funeral homes. Richards and managing director Andrew Bell then cut the giant red ribbon around the resomator, the giant SUV-sized stainless steel machine responsible for water cremation. A patter of polite applause heralded the arrival of a groundbreaking new technology for people seeking a more eco-friendly option in death. Despite this being the biggest thing to happen to dying in Aotearoa in about 100 years, the opening ceremony was relatively small. Notable guests included Margaret's family, representatives from Ngāi Tahu, Labour MP Duncan Webb and Reverend Dr Peter Carrell. Before he led the room in prayer, he apologised for not being able to stay for food and drink afterwards. 'As it happens, I have a funeral to go to on the other side of the city,' he said. Richards, a former midwife and nurse, has been championing water cremation since 2018. During the water cremation process, the body is wrapped in a shroud and dissolved in a 95% water 5% alkaline solution. After four or so hours, all that is left are 'pure white' bones (given to the family as ashes), any implants or prosthesis (which are recycled), and a sterile liquid (which enters the wastewater system). It is 90% less harmful to the environment than flame cremation, which produces 242kg of carbon dioxide (roughly the same amount as driving a petrol car from Christchurch to Cape Reinga). After the ribbon cutting ceremony, I got chatting to Dean Fisher who was an early adopter of water cremation when working with donated bodies at the Mayo Clinic in Minnesota and had travelled all the way over here for the opening. He explained that flame cremation is more 'violent' than the watery alternative, which is much closer to the natural decomposition process found in soil. 'We're just gently moving liquid around you, breaking down soft tissue and leaving the bone. More or less, we are skeletonising the body.' A woman offered me a chicken skewer, and I politely declined. Squeamishness aside, there's an undeniably attractive environmental appeal here – the Christchurch resomator has a carbon footprint of zero at the point of use. 'These aren't putting anything into the atmosphere at all,' says Fisher. 'They're all throughout the US and Europe now, people see the environmental side of this and they just love it. 'I'm so happy for the people of New Zealand, because now you have another choice. It might not be your choice, but it's giving a choice for somebody else,' Fisher adds. Currently around 80% of New Zealanders are cremated by flame (average cost of $5,000), the remaining opting for either plot burials (which costs an average of $10,000) or natural burials (average cost just under $5,000). Water cremation doesn't require a casket and is a slightly more affordable option than flame, arriving at a time where funeral costs are in the spotlight. Although the environmental benefits are clear, it hasn't been easy for Richards to swim against the tide. The last major advancement in the local funeral industry came in 1909 with the first flame cremation, and prior to that was embalming in 1896. The Burial and Cremation Act was written in 1964 – so old that it still mentions pounds and shillings – so trying to pioneer something new after over a century of stasis was a regulatory 'rollercoaster', says Richards ('I don't want to talk about the council,' she would jibe in her opening speech.) One of the last and most significant hurdles was securing a water permit from the Christchurch City Council to release the processed liquid into the water treatment system. Richards worked closely with water engineers, had an independent report written by GHD, and crucially secured local support from mana whenua. 'It's always hardest being the first – we knew were always going to be the ones that would be the most closely scrutinised, so we've just had to be completely transparent and share all the knowledge that we have,' she says. And with Richards having done the hard yards in Ōtautahi with Bell, Lamb and Trotter, the floodgates are now open for more people in the funeral industry to follow suit. 'It's the first in the country, but I believe there's going to be a few people not too far behind us,' says Richards. 'I'm getting emails from city councils around the country, wanting to know what we've done and how we've done it, so they can replicate and be able to offer the process as well. I would like to help people, because I want this to be an option for everybody in New Zealand.' Reflecting on nearly a decade of work to bring water cremation to Aotearoa, Richards says stubbornness helped a great deal. 'I just hung in there and I didn't give up,' she laughs. 'People have wanted me to go away, and I just haven't.' With people now ringing her from all around the country seeking guidance about council regulations and water treatment, she says that her main piece of advice is staying the course. 'Keep going and don't let them turn you away. You can get there in the end – you just have to keep putting one foot in front of the other.'
Otago Daily Times
8 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Attitude to eye health criticised
A multinational pharmaceutical company has stooped to "punching down" on New Zealand's disabled community while promoting its vision loss treatment, a Dunedin advocate says. Market research by the New Zealand arm of Roche, a Swiss multinational holding healthcare company, was released last week and said while most people understood the importance of vision, public awareness of specific eye conditions, symptoms and how to prevent vision loss remained low. "New Zealanders overwhelmingly value their vision above all other senses according to recent market research, with participants saying they'd be willing to lose 5.6 years of perfect health, rather than live a decade without sight," the company's media release began. In New Zealand, Roche distributes Vabysmo, a medicine approved by MedSafe to treat age-related macular degeneration, the leading cause of blindness in the country. Blind and low vision advocate and Dunedin resident Julie Woods, who is also known as "That Blind Woman", said it "distresses" her the company was comparing hypothetical trade-offs between life expectancy and vision loss. "That just shows how afraid people are of vision loss," she said. "You can live a perfectly good life without vision, but you can't without your health." She said preserving eye health was "obviously" a great cause. "But it doesn't give organisations the right to push their own product and put down [or punch] down a community of people." Ms Woods said Roche's approach spoke to a medical model of disability which was: "we can't fix you, therefore you're broken". "Whereas the social model of disability says that we are disabled by the barriers that society creates, and we're not broken and we're not less than." She said Roche's use of New Zealanders' fears of not seeing loved ones' faces or recognising facial expressions, body language and social cues was "bull...." and was emotive toward sighted people. A Roche spokesperson said the market research was based on a similar study conducted in the United Kingdom and the company sought guidance from professionals within the eye community, including a patient advocacy group. "Their advice advocated for raising awareness about the importance of eye health and regular eye examinations to prevent irreversible, yet preventable, vision loss," the spokesperson said. "The intent of the campaign was to raise awareness of the importance of eye health and preventable vision loss, encouraging individuals to get their eyes tested or seek help if they are experiencing symptoms." The spokesperson said Roche respected Ms Woods' opinion and acknowledged her advocacy for the blind and low vision community in New Zealand.
