Cogta Committee challenges initiation death targets, insists on zero casualties
Parliament's Cogta Committee has criticised the Department of Traditional Affairs for proposing reduced, not eliminated, initiation deaths. The committee has called for revised targets that reflect a zero-death and zero-injury policy.
However, the committee's urgent demand for immediate revisions underscores a growing frustration over perceived complacency in tackling the issue at hand.
The department had laid out a plan to drop initiation deaths from a troubling 63 to just 13 by 2029, accompanied by a proposal to reduce the number of illegal initiation schools from 429 to 229. These initiatives were to be augmented through enhanced oversight, community education, and regulatory reforms focused on this sensitive cultural practice.
During a recent briefing regarding the department's annual performance plan for 2025/26 and its strategic direction through 2025 to 2030, committee members spotlighted their dissatisfaction with the lack of urgency in reducing initiation-related harm, making it clear that their expectations are centered around a singular, unwavering goal: zero deaths and injuries.
The Portfolio Committee on Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta) has taken a firm stance against the Department of Traditional Affairs, outright rejecting their proposed targets aimed at addressing harmful practices linked to illegal initiation schools.
''This enables committees to scrutinise departmental performance and spending and hold them accountable to the public. Members learnt that the department's strategic plan will centre around four outcomes, including ensuring that institutions of Traditional and Khoi-San leadership are functional, legitimate, and governed in compliance with applicable laws.
''Other outcomes focus on transformation, ensuring that traditional leadership structures are inclusive, rights-based, and aligned with constitutional values. It was; however, the targets set for promoting safer initiation practices by reducing illegal initiation schools and related injuries and casualties that particularly concerned members.''
Committee Chairperson Dr Zweli Mkhize criticised these targets, highlighting a significant discrepancy with the government's zero-tolerance stance on initiation casualties.
"All targets should be zero.If not, you will be accused of running this programme in a way that allows certain deaths and amputations," Mkhize said.
He further pointed out that setting any target other than zero would send the wrong message to the public, suggesting that such a target would "risk legitimising the very harm we are meant to eradicate."
Mkhize described the targets as 'indefensible,' adding that the department's approach risked normalising preventable harm under the guise of bureaucratic compliance.
He stressed that 'the only acceptable target for loss of life or amputation is zero,' underlining the need for more stringent measures to address these issues.
The committee also discussed the need for amendments to the Traditional and Khoi-San Leaders Act, which was found unconstitutional, and emphasised the importance of a collaborative approach to the recognition of Khoi-San traditional leaders.
Mkhize suggested a more inclusive process and recommended that the department share relevant information and establish mechanisms to facilitate interaction with the body responsible for traditional leadership matters.
hope.ntanzi@iol.co.za
IOL News
Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
IOL Politics
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Eyewitness News
2 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
'Resilient, and a man of unwavering principle' - President Cyril Ramaphosa pays tribute to anti-apartheid activist, Reverent Tshenuwani Farisani
JOHANNESBURG - Resilience - the word many used to describe the late reverend Tshenuwani Farisani - a respected anti-apartheid activist and former member of Parliament. Mourners, including senior government officials, gathered at the University of Venda in Thohoyandou, Limpopo on Saturday to honour the man who they say never wavered in his fight for liberation. ALSO READ: Dr Tshenuwani Farisani remembered as a dedicated public servant Farisani passed away on Thursday at the age of 76, following an undisclosed illness. President Cyril Ramaphosa, who delivered the eulogy, reflected on Farisani's courage, recalling how he was arrested three times during Apartheid for his activism. In 1987, Farisani went into exile in the United States, but later returned - a move Ramaphosa has described as a powerful symbol of his commitment to justice and freedom. "He was a man of unwavering principle, nothing could sway him from what was right, from his dedication to the cause, the people of South Africa and their total emancipation."
Mail & Guardian
8 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Unpacking the dangers of the proposed amendments to Zambia's constitution, Part II
Zambia's President Hakainde Hichilema. In this series on Zambia, Part II looks at legalising the use of public resources for election campaigns. ( The second benefit that Zambia's President Hakainde Hichilema seeks to achieve through Article 81 (3) of Once parliament is dissolved by operation of law, MPs are no longer MPs and lose access to all the Dissolving parliament long before the election is important to the democratic process for two reasons. First, it allows those who were MPs before dissolution to focus on political campaigning instead of being encumbered by parliamentary business. Second, it prevents MPs from using Through Bill 7, Hichilema is proposing two amendments to the provisions governing dissolution. The first proposal is to amend article 81 (3) to read: 'Parliament shall stand dissolved a day preceding the date of the next general election . ' The The second proposal is to make MPs retain their position for this additional three-month period but In making these two proposals, Hichilema has three objectives. The primary objective is to entice all MPs to support the passage of Bill 7 by dangling a carrot in front of them. If there is anything that Hichilema learnt from his predecessor's This lesson explains why Hichilema could not embark on these constitutional changes Hijack and take control of the opposition Patriotic Front (PF) by Delay the resolution of the resultant PF leadership wrangles using Induce vacancies in several constituencies by using the police to arrest incumbent MPs on what appears to be Prevent the main opposition party from sponsoring candidates in the ensuing parliamentary by-elections either by Use incumbency advantage and Combined, these legal manoeuvres have enabled the ruling United Party for National Development (UPND) to easily secure This abbreviated history of Hichilema's political schemes provides the clearest evidence that the president knew earlier that he would take self-serving and personally-driven amendments to the Constitution to parliament, rather than implementing his party's 2021 manifesto that Hichilema's hope is that the UPND will win the forthcoming by-elections before Bill 7 is tabled in parliament to reduce by one or two the number of MPs whom the ruling party might need to bribe to pass the dire constitutional changes. In the meantime, however, the president is offering a more transparent form of bribery that he hopes will appeal to all MPs — a The second objective is to enable MPs to campaign for their own re-election using public resources. Campaign finance is ordinarily difficult to raise in Zambia, making attractive any interventions that would help deflate Moreover, MPs receive constant requests for financial support from their constituents and are required to make monthly financial contributions to their political parties for by-election and day-to-day operational expenses. Allowing them to draw salaries for three months, The third objective is enabling MPs to campaign for Hichilema using public funds drawn from the free salaries and the consequent increase in their pensions . Currently, lawmakers receive about 3 million kwacha (the equivalent of $110 000) as payment for Altogether, the proposed changes would encourage electoral fraud, corruption and unfair practices during campaigns and gravely Furthermore, the proposals are likely to work to the advantage of the UPND because candidates belonging to parties in government generally find it much easier to attract external financing or resources from Sishuwa Sishuwa is a senior lecturer in the department of history at Stellenbosch University.
Eyewitness News
a day ago
- Eyewitness News
Ramaphosa pays tribute to anti-apartheid activist and reverend, Dr Tshenuwani Farisani
JOHANNEBSURG - President Cyril Ramaphosa has paid tribute to anti-apartheid activist and reverend, Dr Tshenuwani Farisani, describing him as an extraordinary man who will be dearly remembered. Ramaphosa was speaking at Farisani's funeral at the University of Venda in Thohoyandou, Limpopo. The reverend is being honoured with a special official provincial funeral. Family, mourners and top government officials, including president Ramaphosa and Limpopo Premier, Dr Phophi Ramathuba, gathered to pay their final respects to reverend Farisani. A Lutheran minister and black consciousness activist, Farisani played a key role in the struggle against Apartheid. His activism led to his appointment as a member of Parliament and later Speaker of the Limpopo provincial legislature in 2004. The 76-year-old died on Thursday after suffering from an undisclosed illness. President Ramaphosa said: "These experiences instilled in him a deep sense of understanding injustice. It was planted in the mind and the head of Dr Farisani, the seeds of political consciousness when he was still a teen." He is survived by his wife, two daughters, and a son.
