
Trump administration doubles down on stand on deportation flights to El Salvador
The Trump administration continues to insist it didn't defy a federal judge's order when it failed to turn around planes carrying Venezuelan migrants to El Salvador.
U.S. District Judge James Boasberg is weighing whether the government defied his order blocking the deportations of alleged gang members who hadn't been afforded due process. It's a case that's become a flashpoint in the rising tension between the administration and federal courts.
In a
14-page document filed late Tuesday night
, the Justice Department spelled out before Boasberg why it didn't turn around the two flights carrying alleged Tren de Aragua gang members despite his verbal order to do so.
"These removals both complied with the law and safeguarded Americans against members of a foreign terrorist organization. The Government will continue to defend the removals before this Court and, if necessary, on appeal challenging this Court's two injunctions issued on March 15," the filing reads. It's signed by Attorney General Pam Bondi and other senior DOJ officials.
The government attempts to thread the needle regarding Boasberg's directive, arguing that it didn't "remove" any of the migrants after he entered his order and that it "complied with the Court's injunction with respect to the two flights at issue" because it didn't formally remove anyone after 7:25 p.m. Saturday, though acknowledging it "did not order any removal flights to return to the United States."
The DOJ continued to argue that Boasberg's order was unclear and insufficient to be binding, asserting it "failed to satisfy the requirements for issuing a binding injunction "because Boasberg and the court didn't state "the reasons why it issued" the injunction.
"It is well-settled (in law) that an oral directive is not enforceable as an injunction," the filing says.
The DOJ later in the filing argues that once the flights were out of U.S. airspace, they were "military matters" and President Trump has the power to order military flights wherever he wants.
On Monday, the administration
invoked a state secrets privilege
and refused to give Boasberg any additional information about the deportations.
Boasberg, the chief judge of the federal district court in Washington, has
asked for details
about when the planes landed and who was on board, information the administration asserts would harm "diplomatic and national security concerns."
Government attorneys also asked an appeals court on Monday to lift
Boasberg's order
and allow deportations to continue, a push that appeared to divide the three-judge panel.
Circuit Court Judge Patricia Millett said, "Nazis got better treatment under the Alien Enemies Act than has happened here," referring to the way
Nazis detained in the U.S.
during World World II were processed compared to the Venezuelan immigrants
deported
to El Salvador this month under the same statute.
"We certainly dispute the Nazi analogy," government attorney Drew Ensign responded during a hearing of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.
Millett noted that during World War II, Nazis were put before hearing boards under Franklin D. Roosevelt's administration, and the Trump administration has conceded the alleged
Tren de Aragua
gang members deported to El Salvador and detained in a maximum security prison didn't have the chance to appear in court.
Millett is one of the three appellate judges who will decide whether to lift a March 15 order temporarily prohibiting deportations under the Alien Enemies Act of 1798. They didn't rule from the bench Monday.
Judge Justin Walker, who also sits on the appeals court, appeared open to the administration's argument that the migrants should be challenging their detention in Texas rather than the nation's capital. The third judge on the panel didn't ask any questions.
The administration has transferred hundreds of Venezuelan immigrants to El Salvador, invoking the Alien Enemies Act for the first time since World War II.
Also on Monday, attorneys representing the Venezuelan government filed a legal action in El Salvador to free 238 Venezuelans who are being held in a Salvadoran maximum-security prison after the U.S. deported them.
The Alien Enemies Act allows noncitizens to be deported without the opportunity to go before an immigration or federal court judge. Mr. Trump issued a proclamation calling the Tren de Aragua gang an invading force.
Ensign argued that Boasberg's ruling was an "unprecedented and enormous intrusion upon the powers of the executive branch."
"The president has to comply with the Constitution and the laws like anyone else," said Millett, who was nominated by Democratic President Barack Obama in 2013.
Judge Justin Walker, whom Mr. Trump nominated in 2020, seemed to be more receptive to the administration's arguments based on his line of questioning. Walker pointed to the government's assertions that the plaintiffs should have filed their lawsuit in Texas, where the immigrants were detained.
"You could have filed the exact same complaint you filed here in Texas district court," Walker told American Civil Liberties Union attorney Lee Gelernt.
"We have no idea if everyone is in Texas," Gelernt said.
Walker also pressed the plaintiffs' lawyer to cite any prior case in which a judicial order blocking "a national security operation with foreign implications" survived appellate review.
Gelernt accused the administration of trying to use the law to "short circuit" immigration proceedings. Plaintiffs' attorneys had no way to individually challenge all the deportations before planeloads of Venezuelans took off on March 15, he added.
"This has all been done in secret," Gelernt said.
Judge Karen LeCraft Henderson, who was nominated by Republican President George H.W. Bush in 1990, was the third judge on the panel. She's the one who didn't ask any questions during a hearing that lasted roughly two hours.
Boasberg, also an Obama nominee, ruled that immigrants facing deportation must get an opportunity to challenge their designations as alleged gang members. He said there is "a strong public interest in preventing the mistaken deportation of people based on categories they have no right to challenge."
"The public also has a significant stake in the Government's compliance with the law,"
the judge wrote
.
Mr. Trump and his allies have called for impeaching Boasberg.
In a rare statement, Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts said "impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreement concerning a judicial decision."
Just after midnight Monday, Mr. Trump posted a social media message questioning Boasberg's impartiality and calling for him to be disbarred.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Axios
36 minutes ago
- Axios
Reworking Qatari jet will cost less than $400 million, says Air Force
It will cost less than $400 million to turn a luxury Qatari jet into President Trump's airborne command center, according to the U.S. Air Force. Why it matters: That's far less than previous public estimates for the Air Force One conversion, which should account for counterintelligence sweeps and the installation of specialty communications gear, medical equipment, avionics and defensive countermeasures. Driving the news: Rep. Joe Courtney (D-Conn.) pressed Air Force Secretary Troy Meink for a price tag during a House Armed Services Committee hearing last week. "Based on the experience that we already have gone through with retrofitting planes, 747s, it's clear that this is going to be a drain on the Air Force's budget," Courtney said. The sooner "we just sort of rip the Band-Aid off and get that information out there, it would be helpful for us in terms of deciding whether this is a smart path to go down." Meink said some estimates floating about are inflated by training and spare-parts costs. Zoom in: L3Harris Technologies was tapped for the modifications, CNBC reported. The company declined to comment when Axios reached out. Between the lines: Trump has for years made clear his desire for a new Air Force One (with a revamped paint job). The president in May said it would be "stupid" not to accept the gift from Qatar. But the arrangement — a sign of Washington's growing ties to the Gulf — was panned by lawmakers and influencers on both sides of the political aisle. By the numbers: Presidents reported $3.8 million worth of gifts from foreign countries between George W. Bush's inauguration and 2023.


Axios
37 minutes ago
- Axios
Mayor Cherelle Parker silent on Los Angeles protests
As other Democratic leaders condemn President Trump for federalizing California's National Guard amid protests in Los Angeles, Philadelphia Mayor Cherelle Parker is keeping silent. The big picture: This week, Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro joined more than a dozen other Democratic governors in calling Trump's deployment of California's National Guard without the state's consent an " alarming abuse of power." California Gov. Gavin Newsom called the deployment of military personnel " unlawful" and is suing the Trump administration over it. Newsom's office pulled Philly into the conversation Tuesday. "Are you going to send in the Marines the next time the Philadelphia Eagles win, too?" the Democratic governor's press team asked in a post on X alongside a photo of a fire set in the street as Birds fans celebrated the team's recent Super Bowl win. Meanwhile, Democratic U.S. Rep. Mary Gay Scanlon, whose district includes parts of Philly and the surrounding suburbs, denounced deploying military personnel in LA, saying in a statement that it "appears to be a manufactured escalation designed to justify abuses of power and stoke fear across the country." On the other hand, New York Mayor Eric Adams called "the escalation of protests" in LA "unacceptable" and warned that his city will not tolerate such clashes. Zoom out: The responses come after protests popped up across the U.S. this week, including in Philly, in solidarity with LA demonstrators. State of play: Parker spokesperson Joe Grace declined Axios' request for comment about the mayor's stance on the LA protests. Grace deferred comment to the Philadelphia Police Department. Zoom in: Philly police "continuously monitor events locally and nationally to ensure we are prepared for any scenario," PPD spokesperson Sgt. Eric Gripp tells Axios. He adds that officers will both safeguard public safety and ensure people can exercise their rights without fear or interference. Between the lines: Avoiding political fights with Trump and sticking to her own agenda has long been Parker's playbook.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
LA police enforce curfew as protests against Trump's crackdown continue
Los Angeles police swiftly enforced a curfew on Tuesday night, making arrests moments after it took effect while deploying officers to break up a group demonstrating against President Donald Trump's immigration crackdown. Members of the National Guard stood watch behind plastic shields, but did not appear to participate in the arrests. Hours later, many of the protesters had dispersed, although sporadic confrontations continued that were much smaller than in previous nights. Officials said the curfew was necessary to stop vandalism and theft by agitators looking to cause trouble. Democratic governor Gavin Newsom earlier accused Mr Trump of drawing a 'military dragnet' across the nation's second-largest city with his escalating use of the National Guard. He also deployed marines, though none were seen on the streets. Mr Newsom asked a court to put an emergency stop to the military helping federal immigration agents, with some guardsmen now standing in protection around agents as they carried out arrests. He said it would only heighten tensions and promote civil unrest. The judge set a hearing for Thursday, giving the administration several days to continue those activities. The change moves troops closer to engaging in law enforcement actions like deportations as Mr Trump has promised as part of his administration's immigration crackdown. The Guard has the authority to temporarily detain people who attack officers but any arrests ultimately would be made by law enforcement. Mr Trump has activated more than 4,000 National Guard members and 700 marines over the objections of city and state leaders. They were originally deployed to protect federal buildings. Demonstrations have spread to other cities nationwide, including Dallas and Austin, Texas, Chicago and New York, where a thousand people rallied and multiple arrests were made. Mr Trump left open the possibility of invoking the Insurrection Act, which authorises the president to deploy military forces inside the US to suppress rebellion or domestic violence or to enforce the law in certain situations. It is one of the most extreme emergency powers available to a US president. 'If there's an insurrection, I would certainly invoke it. We'll see,' he said from the Oval Office. Later the president called protesters 'animals' and 'a foreign enemy' in a speech at Fort Bragg ostensibly to recognise the 250th anniversary of the US Army. Mr Trump has described Los Angeles in dire terms that Mr Newsom says are nowhere close to the truth. In a public address Tuesday evening, Mr Newsom called Mr Trump's actions the start of an 'assault' on democracy. Mr Newsom warned people against inciting violence, but urged them to stand up to the president's actions. The protests began on Friday after federal immigration raids arrested dozens of workers in Los Angeles. Protesters blocked a major freeway and set cars on fire over the weekend, and police responded with tear gas, rubber bullets and flash-bang grenades. The demonstrations have been mostly concentrated downtown in the city of four million. Thousands of people have peacefully rallied outside City Hall and hundreds more protested outside a federal complex that includes a detention centre where some immigrants are being held following workplace raids.