Supreme Court rules that CAPF officers to be ‘organised services' for all purposes
The Supreme Court on Friday (May 23, 2025) ruled that Group A officers of the Central Armed Police Force (CAPF) from batches dating back to 1986 are recognised as 'Organised Services' for 'all purposes'.
A Bench of Justice A.S. Oka and Justice Ujjal Bhuyan said in a judgment that the deputation posts of Indian Police Service (IPS) officers in the Senior Administrative Grade (SAG) or up to the rank of Inspector General (IG) in CAPFs should be 'progressively reduced over a period of time, say within an outer limit of two years'. It was Justice Oka's last day in office.
Friday's (May 23, 2025) judgment paves the way for service rules or recruitment rules to be amended, allowing all connected benefits of Organised Group A Services (OGAS) to CAPFs and cadre review within six months.
Presently, 20% of posts in the rank of Deputy Inspector General (DIG) and 50% of posts in the rank of Inspector General (IG) in CAPFs are reserved for IPS officers.
The decision is likely to benefit around 13,000 CAPF officers. A CAPF official said that presently, an officer who joins as Assistant Commandant (AC) takes 25 years to be promoted as a Commandant, whereas he or she should attain the seniority in 13 years. A DIG rank official said that he reached the position after 31 years in service, against the 21-year required tenure.
Also read: Over 50,000 CAPF personnel quit jobs in past five years: MHA informs parliamentary panel in 2023
The Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) is the cadre controlling authority of CAPFs.
The CAPFs comprise the Border Security Force (BSF), Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB) and Indo Tibetan Border Police (ITBP).
The issue was earlier examined by the Delhi High Court and the Supreme Court in 2015 and 2019, respectively, when it was decided that CAPFs come in the category of organised services such as the Indian Foreign Service and the India Revenue Service (IRS), among others.
In 2021, Group A officers of the CAPFs approached the apex court again, seeking Non Functional Financial Upgradation (NFFU), cadre review and restructuring and amendment of recruitment rules to eliminate IPS deputation and allow internal promotions up to SAG.
The Court said that the 'core of the grievances of the appellants as it appears, are non-recognition as OGAS, non-grant of NFFU and service stagnation'.
In 2006, as a part of the Sixth Central Pay Commission's recommendations, the concept of NFFU was introduced to address stagnation among Group A service officers. So, in case of a lack of vacancies, if an officer of an organised service is promoted, the others of that batch will also get financial upgradation even if they are not promoted.
'The grievance is focused on the existing recruitment rules which provides for lateral entry into their respective services by way of deputation to various posts by officers belonging to the IPS, in the process resulting in complete stagnation in their service careers,' the Court said. The appellants contended that once the CAPFs are declared as OGAS for 'all purposes', consequential steps like cadre review and restructuring of the service rules/recruitment rules will follow eliminating lateral entry, like by way of deputation.
The Centre told the Court that 'being an armed force of the Union, the purpose is to keep each of the CAPFs fit for fighting as well as to ensure coordinated action between the States and the Centre within the federal framework of our country' and therefore, 'deputation of IPS officers is necessary'.
The Court said that it cannot be 'oblivious of the grievance' expressed by CAPF.
'Their dedicated service upholding the security, integrity and sovereignty of the nation while safeguarding our borders and maintaining internal security within the country cannot be ignored or overlooked. They discharge their duties under very demanding conditions. They have a grievance that because of lateral entry into the higher grades of the respective CAPFs, they are unable to get their timely promotion. ...Such stagnation can adversely impact the morale of the forces,' the Court said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
8 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Lesson from stampedes: Communication key to crowd control, say experts
This year, stampedes at a major railway station in Delhi, at the Maha Kumbh in Uttar Pradesh, and during a cricket match victory celebration in Karnataka have led to at least 72 deaths and a few hundred injuries so far — a grim statistic which exposes the glaring gaps in crowd regulation rules, official apathy and tokenistic governance. Action taken following these tragic, largely preventable deaths does little to avert such incidents in the future — after the June 4 stampede in Bengaluru, the state leadership, replicating the action of its counterparts in other parts of the country, suspending the city's top cop and other police staff, and ordered a magisterial inquiry. Later, the Karnataka high court also took suo motu notice. In light of these developments, HT spoke with veteran police officers, planners, urban designers, and academics to dissect the anatomy of stampedes and how to prevent them. Prakash Singh, a retired IPS officer who was the state police chief of Assam and Uttar Pradesh and the director-general of the Border Security Force, said the Bengaluru tragedy appears to be a case of overriding political desire overruling reservations from the police. Multiple reports, including by HT, suggest that the police had initially dismissed the idea of a parade due to paucity of time. But as some players from the overseas were scheduled to return home, there was a rush to hold the celebrations on June 4 itself, according to people aware of the matter. 'But this should have never been made part of the consideration. No event can be organised without the clearance from the police,' Singh said. The second issue, he pointed out, was the inconsistent messaging. 'There were multiple versions of when and where the parade will be held.' The most significant lapse, however, was the police's alleged failure to react when the crowd started trickling, Singh said. 'Around 200,000-300,000 people tried to make their way towards the stadium when the capacity was only 36,000. It was a policing failure, given that there are enough surveillance measures that would have indicated swelling of crowds.' Police should have, through existing intelligence and surveillance measures, prevented the crowd from converge from all directions. Another lapse was the inadequate deployment of forces, he added. 'Ideally, civic volunteers, armed battalions, and the fire brigade should have been mobilised. If there was fatigue, police from outside the commissionerate should have been engaged, he said. While Karnataka home minister G Parameshwara has announced that the government will formulate a new SOP for crowd control, these mechanisms are not alien to India, where heavy footfall events such as the Maha Kumbh are held regularly. They have been part of the police manual since colonial times, and even the National Disaster Management Agency (NDMA) has issued guidelines to manage crowds at events. To prevent stampedes, the administration — be it government, private organisers or temple trusts— should actively control the 'hype' through constant messaging, said Monika Vij, a geography professor at Delhi's Miranda House, who has researched extensively on crowd management at religious events. Referring to the Kumbh tragedy in January, where the official death toll was 30, she said, while the authorities made 'excellent arrangements', the hype of a historical event overshadowed everything. Authorities could not effectively communicate with the crowd when the stampede took place, she said. 'There has to be greater control and responsibility over disseminating information.' On the Bengaluru stampede, she said it was the 'lack of clarity over the venue and ticketing' which led to the tragedy. Similar confusion was seen at the February 15 stampede at the New Delhi Railway Station over train departures, Vij said. Another retired IPS officer Nazrul Islam, who was the ADGP in West Bengal, said a crowd, by default, is fuelled by frenzy and not rationality — be it a religious procession or a sports event. 'Visible, prompt policing is important to keep the crowd disciplined. Staggered movement of crowds is essential, and for that, checkpoints are installed in all directions from approaches to the event venue,' he said. KT Ravindran, founder of the Institute of Urban Designers India, said, for any kind of gathering, authorities must ensure that designing standards, such as entry and exit points and emergency exit, are followed. 'At any point in time, the potential to disperse should be higher than the potential to gather.' Ujan Ghosh, the former president of the institute, said the combined action of authorities, including police, along with the architecture, either prevents or causes a stampede. He also questioned if the Bengaluru stadium was the right choice as the venue for the cricket felicitation event. Spaces, such as streets and pavements, are often designed for specific purposes, he said, suggesting that stadiums are usually for ticketed events.
Time of India
14 hours ago
- Time of India
Bengaluru stampede: Railways minister Somanna slams government response to stampede
Union minister of state for railways V Somanna on Sunday stated that even an entire year's state budget can't compensate for the tragic loss of lives in the stampede at Chinnaswamy Stadium. His remarks came in response to questions from the media on the govt's revised compensation of Rs 25 lakh per victim, up from the initial Rs 10 lakh. "It was known that Royal Challengers Bengaluru reached the IPL final... the authorities should have planned accordingly. Unfortunately, the chief minister mishandled the situation. Perhaps he acted on poor advice from his associates," said Somanna. The minister also criticised the suspension of police commissioner B Dayananda, calling it unjust. "I've known the work of the IPS officer for many years. His suspension is unfair, especially when he had no direct role in the stampede. It was a good decision to appoint him as commissioner, and he should be reinstated immediately. The govt has gone off track, and it must be held accountable for this tragedy," he added. Reflecting on his past association with Siddaramaiah, Somanna expressed disappointment over what he described as a shift in his leadership style.
India.com
15 hours ago
- India.com
Meet IAS Amit Kataria, India's richest IAS officer, took just Rs 1 as salary, his family business is..., net worth is Rs...
IAS Amit Kataria, India's richest IAS officer, is married to Asmita Handa, a commercial pilot by profession. (File) IAS Amit Kataria: Civil servants are nothing short of celebrities India as millions across the country celebrate their UPSC accolades and achievements as top bureaucrats. A few names that are often part of conversations about celebrity IAS and IPS officers, include famous names like IAS Tina Dabi, her younger sister IAS Ria Dabi, IPS Lodha, etc. But have you ever wondered who is the richest IAS officer in India? The answer is IAS Amit Kataria, a young IAS officer from Gurugram, who is considered the wealthiest civil servant in the country, and initially used to take just Rs 1 as salary. Who is IAS Amit Kataria – India's richest IAS officer? Born in an affluent business family based in Gurugram, Haryana, Amit Kataria did not join his family's vast business empire, and instead chose to become a civil servant to satiate his undying passing of serving the country and its people. The Kataria family owns a thriving real-estate business, which is spread across the entire Delhi-NCR region, and has annual turnover in crores of rupees. According to reports, IAS Amit Kataria used to take a salary of just Rs 1 when he first joined civil services, stating that his only motive of becoming an IAS officer was to serve the country, not monetary gain. Interestingly, Amit Kataria hogged the headlines in 2015 for the wrong reasons, when he was spotted wearing black sunglasses during his meeting with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, which is against protocol. At the time, Kataria was posted as the District Collector of Naxal-infested Bastar district in Chhattisgarh The incident invited a show-cause notice sent to IAS Amit Kataria from the then chief minister of Chhattisgarh, Raman Singh. IAS Amit Kataria net worth According to media reports, IAS Amit Kataria has an estimated net worth of around Rs 8.90 crore, earning him the title of India's richest IAS officer. IAS Amit Kataria UPSC success Amit Kataria completed his schooling at the Delhi Public School, RK Puram, and later earned a degree in Electrical Engineering from the prestigious IIT Delhi. After his graduation, Kataria began preparing for the UPSC Civil Services Examination (CSE), and ultimately aced the tough recruitment test in 2003, securing an All-India Rank (AIR) of 18, and realizing his dream of becoming an IAS officer. He was accorded the Chhattisgarh cadre. IAS Amit Kataria wife IAS Amit Kataria is married to Asmita Handa, a commercial pilot by profession. The couple are fond of travelling, and often share vacation photos on their Instagram pages.
