Pub is forced to pay family £75,000 after wrongly accusing them of 'dine and dash' over £150 restaurant bill
A family wrongly accused of leaving a restaurant without paying their £150 bill have been awarded £75,000 in damages.
Peter and Ann McGirr were maligned by bosses at the Horse and Jocket in Tideswell who condemned them for their 'shocking behaviour' in a public Facebook post.
The couple, with their two children, ate two £27 10oz ribeye steaks with all the trimmings and two £15.25 Derbyshire gammon steaks, washed down with several real ales and lagers.
But it later emerged that the group did in fact pay the bill in full, though a member of staff forgot to ring the transaction through the till.
This was not before the pub had already uploaded CCTV images of the diners online, with the allegations being repeated in four press reports.
Belfast Crown Court heard on Friday that the family, from County Tyrone, Northern Ireland, had suffered significant embarrassment and reputational damage.
Referred to as 'dine-and-dashers', the family sued the pub for libel on the basis of the 'serious and defamatory accusations'.
Peter Girvan, the barrister representing the family, told the court: 'These articles contained serious and defamatory accusations that the plaintiffs had engaged in dishonest and criminal conduct by deliberately absconding without settling a bill of approximately £150.
'The allegations were entirely false. The plaintiffs had not engaged in any such conduct, and the statements made by the defendants had no factual basis.'
The pub agreed to pay £75,000 in damages as well as the family's legal costs, as part of a settlement agreement.
It accepted there was 'no basis whatsoever' for the allegations and apologised, the court heard.
The family's solicitor, Darragh Carney, said they had been 'vindicated', reading a statement on their behalf outside court.
He added the group were 'very satisfied with the settlement' by way of compensation for 'defamation of their character'.
It comes after the pub last year blamed the error on an 'inexperienced member of staff' who was said to have taken payment via card machine but not printed the bill on the till.
A statement issued by the pub in July last year read: 'We want to sincerely apologise to the people involved because we have now learnt that they did in fact pay for their meal.
'There was no dishonesty involved from our staff, it was an honest mistake but we have dismissed the member of staff responsible for the error.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Tributes paid after death of pioneering drugs reformer Peter Krykant
Mr Krykant became a public figure after he set up an unofficial drugs consumption room in 2020 in a converted ambulance in Glasgow city centre. He set up the van, which operated in 2020 and 2021, after crowdfunding and using his own money in an effort to highlight the need for a safe space for drug users to inject. The van was modelled on a similar operation My Krykant, who also battled addiction, visited in Copenhagen and had sterile injecting kits, swabs and Naloxone, as well as a defibrillator. In 2021, he met with then First Minister Nicola Sturgeon to discuss the possibility of opening an Overdose Prevention Centre (OPC) in Scotland. It is understood Mr Krykant passed away at his home in Larbert. He was 48. READ NEXT: Two drug users an hour attend drug consumption van service in city centre Police were called to a property on Graham Avenue in Larbert at around 5.15pm on Monday, June 9 following a report of concern for a person. The body of 48-year-old man was found inside. The death is currently being treated as unexplained and a post-mortem examination will be carried out in due course. Officers said his next of kind has been informed. READ NEXT: First Minister to meet with Glasgow safe drug consumption activist Now, tributes have been paid to Mr Krykant who has been described as a "tireless campaigner" and a "one man army". Paul Sweeney MSP said he was "deeply saddened" by his death. In a post shared on X he wrote: "I am deeply saddened at the passing of my friend Peter Krykant. "I don't think Peter often realised the impact he had, but his work did save lives - I saw it with my own eyes. "May he rest in peace." I am deeply saddened at the passing of my friend Peter Krykant. I don't think Peter often realised the impact he had, but his work did save lives - I saw it with my own eyes. May he rest in peace. — Paul Sweeney (@PaulJSweeney) June 11, 2025 Patrick Harvie MSP, Scottish Greens co-leader, said: "We are all deeply saddened to hear of Peter's passing. Everyone from the Scottish Greens is thinking of his family and friends at this extremely difficult time. "Peter was a tireless campaigner for a fairer, more compassionate approach to handling drug misuse and addiction, and his campaigning has left such an important legacy in the UK's first safe consumption room in Glasgow. "His advocacy for drug reform, and of course, his yellow van have no doubt saved countless lives in Scotland." READ NEXT: Consumption room must be the start of real fightback against drug deaths Lawyer Aamer Anwar said in a post on X that he was "privileged" to represent Mr Krykant when he was arrested for setting up his safe consumption van. Charges against him were later dropper. He said: "Peter Krykant was a one man army, with a mission to save lives - I was privileged to represent him when he was arrested after setting up his own safe consumption van. "It was humbling to see him single handedly fight to deliver the first safe consumption room for drugs in the UK. "Since childhood he was driven by demons, but Peter was also a beautiful, kind and courageous man- he leaves behind his two boys whom he loved dearly and family and friends who will be utterly devastated. "I hope with time they can find some comfort in that Peter will be at peace and his name will one day be remembered as a drugs campaigner decades ahead of his time." A Police Scotland spokesperson said: "Around 5.15pm on Monday, June 9, police attended an address in Graham Avenue, Larbert following a report of a concern for person. "The body of a 48-year-old man was found within. "His next of kin has been informed. A post mortem examination will be carried out in due course. The death is being treated as unexplained."
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Drug policy reform campaigner Peter Krykant dies aged 48
Mr Fitzpatrick later lost his job after Scotland's drugs deaths soared to 1,264 in 2019. Krykant, who battled his own addiction issues, said his mobile injection room saved lives and argued for similar facilities to be set up to cut Scotland's soaring drug deaths. Peter Krykant in the converted ambulance, which allowed drug users a safe space to inject (Image: Mark F Gibson) It has been reported that he was found dead at home in Falkirk . He faced police charges over the ambulance, but these were later dropped. He said: "We are all deeply saddened to hear of Peter's passing. 'Everyone from the Scottish Greens is thinking of his family and friends at this extremely difficult time. "Peter was a tireless campaigner for a fairer, more compassionate approach to handling drug misuse and addiction, and his campaigning has left such an important legacy in the UK's first safe consumption room in Glasgow. "His advocacy for drug reform, and of course, his yellow van have no doubt saved countless lives in Scotland." Police Scotland have said that no suspicious circumstances surround the death at Krykant's home in Larbert, Falkirk, on Monday this week. Labour MSP Paul Sweeney, who had helped man the mobile service, which was regarded as illegal at the time, said 48-year-old Krykant's efforts had helped make significant changes to Scotland's drugs policy. READ MORE: Mr Sweeney told The Daily Record: 'I'm shocked and saddened to hear of Peter's death. We can't underestimate the contribution he made to the drugs debate in Scotland, which came amid many years of increasing overdose deaths. 'He undoubtedly played a major part in changing policy in a political a system that was very much set in its ways and resistant to the kind of radical change that Peter advocated.' Earlier this year, The Thistle safe drugs consumption facility opened in Glasgow after years of political wrangling between the Scottish and UK governments, allowing those who inject drugs like heroin and cocaine a safe place to do so, with medical professionals on hand should they be needed. The centre has seen 17 overdoses since it opened, according to service manager Lynn Macdonald in March, some of which she believes would have resulted in death had staff not stepped in.
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Watch: Moment suspected gas explosion rips through Derbyshire house
Watch the moment a suspected gas explosion rips through house on a street in Derby. Footage from a nearby home on Eden Street shows a huge blast rip through the terraced property on Tuesday (10 June), with a car driving along the road getting hit by a massive plume of smoke. A man remains in hospital with serious injuries following the explosion. A dog was also injured and was rescued overnight by search teams, before being passed into the care of a vet. Derbyshire Police confirmed that residents from 14 properties would have to stay away from their homes overnight for 'safety reasons'. A joint police and fire investigation into the cause of the explosion began on Wednesday (9 June).
