How related are dire wolves and gray wolves? The answer might surprise you.
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission.
In a controversial announcement earlier this month, scientists with the company Colossal Biosciences claimed they have brought back dire wolves from extinction using genetic engineering.
Dire wolves (Aenocyon dirus) lived in North America during the last ice age and died out around 12,500 years ago, but fossils have preserved enough of these predators' DNA for researchers to partly reconstruct their genome.
The announcement drew criticism from paleogeneticists and other experts, who argued that the newly created animals — three snow-white pups named Romulus, Remus and Khaleesi — are only like dire wolves in appearance and so are not true dire wolves. To "resurrect" the dire wolf, Colossal scientists made 20 tweaks to 14 genes in a modern-day gray wolf (Canis lupus) genome, modifying characteristics like body size and hair color.
"Colossal has said that the gray wolf and dire wolf genomes are 99.5% identical, but that is still 12,235,000 individual differences," Nic Lawrence, a paleogeneticist and associate professor at the University of Otago in New Zealand, told Vox. 'So a gray wolf with 20 edits to 14 genes, even if these are key differences, is still very much a gray wolf.'
In addition to the tiny number of DNA changes, experts pointed out that dire wolves and gray wolves aren't closely related in evolutionary terms. While the two species share many physical traits and the wolf-pack social structure, a seminal study published in 2021 in the journal Nature indicated that dire wolves aren't technically wolves.
Related: Reintroducing wolves to Yellowstone helped entire ecosystem thrive, 20-year study finds
According to the study, dire wolves branched off from modern wolf-like canids — a group that includes gray wolves, coyotes (Canis latrans), dholes (Cuon alpinus), African wild dogs (Lycaon pictus) and African jackals — roughly 5.7 million years ago.
So just how closely related are dire wolves and grey wolves — and what does the best available evidence tell us about the evolutionary relationship between these species?
The latest peer-reviewed research suggests that dire wolves and gray wolves are only distantly related, Mairin Balisi, a paleontologist and curator at the Raymond M. Alf Museum of Paleontology in California, told Live Science in an email.
In the 2021 study, scientists found that dire wolves and gray wolves share a last common ancestor 5.7 million years ago during a period known as the late Miocene, said Balisi, who studies the evolution of mammalian carnivores but did not contribute to the 2021 study.
The analysis, which was based on DNA extracted from five dire wolf fossils, "showed that dire wolves diverged from the ancestor of not just gray wolves, of not just the group comprising [gray wolves and their closest relatives], but of all wolf-like canids including African jackals," Balisi said. "This distant relationship justifies the genus name Aenocyon for dire wolves differing from the genus name Canis for most other wolf-like canids."
The 2021 study revealed what was a decidedly blurry picture of canid evolution. "Previously scientists had interpreted dire and gray wolves to be sister species, or at least cousins through another extinct large wolf, Canis armbrusteri, because of strong similarity in their bones and teeth," Balisi said. C. armbrusteri lived in North America during the last ice age and was likely an ancestor of dire wolves, according to the study.
Previous research also placed the split between dire wolves and gray wolves much later than the 2021 study, with dates ranging between 2 million years ago and 2.5 million years ago, Balisi said.
The 2021 study clarified some aspects of canid evolution, but many questions remain unanswered. For example, it's still unclear which wolf-like canids are most closely related to dire wolves, Balisi said.
It's entirely possible that dire wolves are more closely related to African jackals than gray wolves, she said, despite their physical appearance being closer to gray wolves, adding that "future analyses on more and/or higher-quality genomic data may shed more light on the fine-scale relationships among these canids."
African jackals are divided into two species — the black-backed jackal (Canis mesomelas), native to eastern and southern Africa, and the side-striped jackal (Canis adustus), native to sub-Saharan and southern Africa. The 2021 study found that African jackals diverged from other wolf-like canids around 5.1 million years ago, forming their own branch on the evolutionary tree approximately 600,000 years after dire wolves formed theirs.
Fossils show that dire wolves were larger than modern-day gray wolves and had more robust jaws and teeth, which enabled them to take down larger prey. Current studies of canid evolution rely on these fossils to determine the relationships between species, but the record may have erased crucial information, Balisi said. "It is possible that other traits that don't fossilize as readily also set apart dire wolves from gray wolves today," she said.
There is also a question mark over whether dire wolves and gray wolves ever interbred. While it is possible that they did, the 2021 study found no evidence for gene flow between the two species, or between dire wolves and coyotes, Balisi said.
"Wolf-like canids do hybridize today — e.g., gray wolves and coyotes — so interbreeding between dire and gray wolves may have happened and just has yet to be detected," Balisi said. But gray wolves and coyotes are much more closely related to each other than gray wolves and dire wolves, so it may be that the latter two have evolved bigger reproductive differences, she said.
Following Colossal's announcement, the company uploaded a paper to the preprint database bioRxiv with new (but not yet peer-reviewed) findings about the dire wolf's evolutionary history.
RELATED STORIES
—Wolves in Ethiopia spotted licking 'red hot poker' flowers like lollipops
—Dogs may have domesticated themselves because they really liked snacks, model suggests
—Yellowstone's 'queen of the wolves' killed by rival pack after living to 11 years old and having 10 litters of pups
The results, based on two fossils dating to 13,000 and 72,000 years ago, suggest that dire wolves descended from a lineage that was itself born from interbreeding between two lineages: a sister lineage to the one that produced modern-day South American canids (Cerdocyonina) and a sister lineage to the one that produced the African wild dog.
The research may shed light on how dire wolves evolved as a species, but it does not claim to rewrite the findings of the 2021 study. Overall, the new clues "may be a valid update to the literature," so long as they hold up to peer review, Balisi said.
Regardless of whether peer review deems the study robust, the currently available evidence tells us that dire wolves and gray wolves are not closely related, which means that Romulus, Remus and Khaleesi are not dire wolves.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
30 minutes ago
- CBS News
Tiny fragment of asteroid giving Field Museum scientists a glimpse 4.6 billion years into the past
The Field Museum is the new temporary home to a tiny piece of pristine asteroid. The fragment of the asteroid Bennu, on loan from NASA, won't be on display for visitors, but will give scientists the chance to study an asteroid sample uncontaminated by Earth's atmosphere. A tiny, black fragment might not seem exciting, until a scientist explains it's a specimen from space. "It's an honor of a lifetime to be able to study this sample," said Field Museum curator Dr. Philipp Heck. How did Heck feel when the little rock first arrived at the museum and he held the vial containing the sample? "It was amazing. I was looking forward to that moment for a long time," he said. NASA's OSIRIS-REx mission was planned decades ago. In 2016, a spacecraft launched. In 2018, it arrived at Bennu, a near-Earth asteroid as wide as the Sears Tower is tall. The mission collected pieces of the asteroid and brought them back to Earth in 2023. "This is the first U.S. mission that sends a spacecraft to the asteroid and brings a sample back to Earth," said University of Chicago graduate student Yuke Zheng, who is part of the OSIRIS-REx sample analysis team. "It's a tiny, dark, black fragment that is fragile, so we want to protect it very carefully." She'll use the museum's scanning electron microscope to get an up-close look at a tiny sample of Bennu. "What struck me is how dark the sample is. I had never seen such a dark sample," Heck said. The fragment is like a time capsule, taking scientists back 4.6 billion years. "We believe Bennu contains part of the ingredients for life, and part of the ingredients of the formation of Earth," Heck said. Suddenly, a fragment at the bottom of a vial can have you pondering your place in the universe. "I've never studied a pristine sample from an asteroid," Heck said.
Medscape
34 minutes ago
- Medscape
Fast Five Quiz: Late-Onset Pompe Disease
Multiple genetic variants have been associated with LOPD. However, the c.-32-13T>G splice site variant is found in up to 90% of adults and 50% of pediatric patients. Patients with LOPD often have compound heterozygous genotypes, with one allele carrying the common c.-32-13T>G splice-site variant and the other harboring a more deleterious GAA mutation (eg, nonsense, frameshift, or large deletion). Other variants— such as and c.1935C>A — are more commonly seen in infantile forms of Pompe disease. Learn more about the pathophysiology of LOPD. Diagnosis of LOPD typically follows a two-step approach: first, measuring GAA enzyme activity (often via dried blood spot assay) followed by confirmatory molecular genetic testing to identify pathogenic GAA variants. Although once considered a first-line diagnostic tool for LOPD, muscle biopsy is no longer preferred due to its invasive nature and the non-specificity of histologic findings. Muscle biopsy may still be considered in rare, ambiguous cases when enzyme and genetic testing are inconclusive or conflicting. CK levels might be elevated in some patients but are nonspecific and primarily serve to raise clinical suspicion. Learn more about the workup for LOPD. Enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) has significantly changed the natural history of the disease by improving survival and stabilizing motor and respiratory function. However, key limitations in skeletal muscle uptake and variability in clinical response remain. This is due to low expression of the mannose-6-phosphate receptor in muscle tissue, which hampers enzyme internalization. As a result, patients might experience a limited or plateaued response. Newer approaches, including modified ERT and gene therapy, are being developed to address this issue. High toxicity to cardiac muscle, uniform patient response, and development of cardiac hypertrophy have not been reported as key limitations. Learn more about treatment options for LOPD. NBS programs have reshaped the understanding of Pompe disease, particularly LOPD. A significant proportion of screen-positive newborns harbor genetic variants associated with LOPD, including pseudo deficiency alleles and variants of uncertain significance. These individuals are often asymptomatic at birth and might not develop symptoms for years, if at all. This has raised important clinical questions around monitoring, counseling, and when (or whether) to initiate therapy; expanded screening has also revealed that the true prevalence of LOPD might be higher than historical estimates suggested. Learn more about the management of LOPD. Editor's Note: This article was created using several editorial tools, including generative AI models, as part of the process. Human review and editing of this content were performed prior to publication. Lead image: UCSF/Science Source
Wall Street Journal
an hour ago
- Wall Street Journal
Voyager Technologies Rises in Debut, Signaling Improving IPO Market
Shares of space and defense technology company Voyager Technologies surged in their New York Stock Exchange debut Wednesday, another sign of an improving market for initial public offerings. The stock ended the regular session at $56.48 and was up 6% after hours to $60.15.
