Canterbury Regional Council defends its management of Lake Ellesmere during storm
Lake Ellesmere during heavy rain in Canterbury.
Photo:
Jan Daffin / Supplied
The Canterbury Regional Council says there was an agreement to open Te Waihora/Lake Ellesmere to the sea last Tuesday but sea conditions prevented it from happening before the rain storm hit.
Environment Canterbury is being criticised for its management of
Lake Ellesmere, with people in Selwyn
telling RNZ they are frustrated the lake was not opened to the sea earlier.
Taumutu farmer Tim Sanson said there had been good warning that a fairly serious weather system was on the way.
He was expecting around 80 millimetres of rain but received more than 150mm on Thursday, which was "a fairly significant chunk of rain in a short period of time".
"That is a lot more than what we were expecting from the forecast, that happens occasionally, but to get more than sort of two inches in one hit here, particularly where I live on the coast, is pretty unusual," he said.
Sanson said the decision-making around opening Lake Ellesmere was a long-running "bugbear" for many locals.
"It's a bit like having a bucket that's full of water, you keep putting water in it, it's going to start running out. Well, if you put a hole in it somewhere, it'll drain away, and potentially we should be doing that with the lake with a bit more management," he said.
It was not an easy job to open the lake, which required heavy machinery and hard work, he said.
"It did seem crazy to me watching the bulldozers head down there at high tide. I think it was yesterday morning or the morning before, to start preparing for opening with the southerly roaring in," he said.
Doyleston's Tom Dowie, whose home was flooded overnight, said he thought the lake should have been opened sooner.
He woke at 4am on Friday to find six inches of water through his home after a nearby creek overflowed.
His house had since been yellow stickered.
"If the council had opened the lake last weekend when it was nice and sunny, then there would have been far less room for the water to move to the lake and travel on its way out to the sea," he said.
Lake Ellesmere during heavy rain.
Photo:
Jan Daffin / Supplied
Pip Adams, who lived near Tai Tapu, also questioned why officials did not act earlier to open the lake before the heavy rain caused widespread flooding.
She said she struggled in vain to get officials to open Lake Ellesmere to help the rising floodwaters drain away on Thursday evening.
She rang the Christchurch City Council and the Canterbury Regional Council after she got home to find water lapping on neighbours' doors.
The regional council told her it was after hours, to call again in the morning and that the lake's opening was out of staff hands.
Adams said her property was a disaster zone, her paddocks full of water, with a repair bill estimated to cost tens of thousands of dollars.
The council used diggers to create a channel between the lake and sea at certain times, governed by a 1990 water conservation order and resource consents held jointly with Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu.
Lake Ellesmere at Birdlings Flat.
Photo:
Jan Daffin / Supplied
ECan general manger of hazards Leigh Griffiths said consultation for a lake opening began on Monday and by Tuesday afternoon, a joint decision had been made to open the lake.
"We can only open the lake once a joint decision has been made, and the lake height reaches a minimum of 1.13m (from 1 April to 15 June). The lake conditions were not met until Tuesday 30 April," she said.
Griffiths said earthworks had begun to open the lake but in current sea conditions it would not be successful because the cut would fill in and it was unsafe for people to operate machinery in the surf zone.
"We are watching conditions closely and the lake will be opened to the sea as soon as weather and sea conditions allow. This is likely several days away at the earliest," she said.
RNZ also approached Ngāi Tahu for comment.
Emergency Management Minister Mark Mitchell said he was confident officials had made the right call not to open Te Waihora/Lake Ellesmere to the sea earlier.
Mitchell met Environment Canterbury staff and mana whenua on Friday about the lake.
"It is very apparent there is a lot of work and focus on how they manage Lake Ellesmere and the fact that there was a request to put in to widen that access," he said.
"All the information that they had in relation to that was what informed their decisions and they're all united in the fact that they've done the right thing and they've made the right decisions and they've done what they could."
Mitchell said he had full confidence in that decision but he was prepared to hear more about the community's concerns over the the lake's management.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
Flooding processes defended
Selwyn District Council and Environment Canterbury have defended how they responded to the major flooding in the district early last month. Mayor Sam Broughton and Environment Canterbury chair Craig Pauling have told Emergency Management Minister Mark Mitchell the flooding infrastructure held up, and the processes to manage flooding were up to standard. They were responding to a letter from Mitchell sent to councils across New Zealand asking them to have a 'frank and honest' discussion about responding to flooding. In his letter he highlighted the flooding in Canterbury, where parts of Selwyn and Banks Peninsula were hit hard. "No stopbanks were breached or overtopped, and although drainage schemes were overwhelmed in places, they behaved as expected with water entering known ponding areas,' Broughton and Pauling said in a letter sent to Mitchell. The district saw two months of rainfall fall in about 48 hours, causing a large amount of flooding, particularly around Ellesmere and Tai Tapu. A particular concern among the community was whether Te Waihora/Lake Ellesmere could have been opened ahead of the flooding to reduce the impact. Broughton and Pauling told Mitchell even if the lake could have been opened, it would likely have made little difference. 'Unfortunately, sea conditions prior to the event were not favourable, and any opening attempt would have been unsafe and unsuccessful. Had an opening attempt been made a week earlier, it would have closed quickly and likely would have had little effect on water levels during the event.' It was noted in the letter that ECan wants the Government to continue to assist with funding for telemetry to monitor river levels and flows. "To further support upgrades and strengthen resilience, co-funding with central Government has been sought within the Regional Infrastructure Fund to further accelerate our work.' As part of its continued review of the May floods, the district council is paying particular attention to Doyleston, which was one of the worst-hit areas in the district. On Sunday, council staff met with Doyleston residents to get local knowledge of locations that may have contributed to the flooding. Staff said it would use that information to establish the next steps for the settlement.
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
Heavy fog disrupts flights at Auckland Airport
Heavy fog blankets Auckland on 10 the morning of June. Photo: RNZ Dozens of domestic flights at Auckland Airport have been delayed or cancelled due to a thick fog enveloping the city this morning. About 23 flights were delayed and 9 flights were cancelled due to the fog. But the Airport says fog restrictions have been lifted about 7am. International flights have not been affected. The fog is expected to give way to showers and thunderstorms later, NIWA says. Meanwhile, parts of the South Island have again woken up to sub-zero temperatures this morning, with Mount Cook the lowest in the country at -10degC. It's followed by Lake Tekapo at -9deg and Central Otago at -4deg. It's also chilly on the North Island's Desert Road at -3.7deg. MetService says there may be thunderstorms to Northland this morning, and Auckland this afternoon.
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
Fog disrupts flights at Auckland Airport
A file pic of fog at Auckland Airport. Photo: RNZ / Jessie Chiang Several flights have been affected at Auckland Airport on Tuesday morning due to fog. One domestic flight has been cancelled and six other domestic flights have been delayed. International flights have not been affected. Meanwhile, parts of the South Island have again woken up to sub-zero temperatures this morning, with Mount Cook the lowest in the country at -10degC. It's followed by Lake Tekapo at -9deg and Central Otago at -4deg. It's also chilly on the North Island's Desert Road at -3.7deg. MetService says there may be thunderstorms to Northland this morning, and Auckland this afternoon.
