Trump admin backs Jewish professor's discrimination case against CUNY school
The Trump administration filed federal court papers backing a Jewish professor who claimed she was subjected to a hostile work environment fueled by antisemitic, Israel-bashing protests at CUNY's Hunter College.
CUNY-Hunter filed a motion to dismiss the civil rights lawsuit filed in Manhattan federal court by Leah Garrett, chair of the Jewish Studies Center, saying the vitriol was protected by free speech under the First Amendment.
But the US Department of Justice headed by Attorney General Pam Bondi intervened in the case Monday, filing a 'statement of interest' stressing the importance of abiding by the federal civil rights law that bars discrimination and subjecting employees and students in educational institutions to a hostile workplace.
Advertisement
4 Leah Garrett of Hunter CUNY from her faculty profile with the Jewish Studies Center.
hunter.cuny.edu
'CUNY Hunter may not simply rely on the First Amendment to avoid any scrutiny of whether it is liable under Title VI (Civil Rights law] for its failure to prevent disruptions that Dr. Garrett contends contributed to a hostile work environment,' the 26-page brief filed by the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division said.
'The First Amendment does not prevent CUNY Hunter from regulating material campus disruptions that may contribute to a hostile work environment under Title VI [of the civil rights law].'
Advertisement
In her suit filed last December, Garrett ripped the public university's leaders for turning a blind eye to antisemitic demonstrations across its Upper East Side campus in the aftermath of Hamas' Oct. 7, 2023 terror attacks on Israel. Garrett claimed the school allowed students to brandish posters with blood dripping from a Star of David and demanding Zionists be expelled.
She also begged officials to cover up swastikas drawn on Israeli hostage posters around campus, claiming their hands were tied over bureaucratic and legal reasons, according to the suit.
The Lawfare Project, the Jewish legal civil rights group representing Garrett along with the private law firm Alston & Bird, applauded the Justice Department's intervention.
4 A group of National Students for Justice in Palestine protest the filming an episode of CBS show, FBI: Most Wanted at Queens College of City University of New York (CUNY) on July 23, 2024 in New York City, United States.
Anadolu via Getty Images
Advertisement
'This is a critical moment in the fight against institutional antisemitism,' said Brooke Goldstein, founder and executive director of The Lawfare Project.
'The DOJ has made clear that public universities cannot look the other way while Jews are harassed, threatened, and silenced. This marks a turning point—federal civil rights laws apply to Jews, and schools that fail to uphold those protections will be held to account.'
A Hunter College representative said the school cannot comment on pending litigation.
4 Protesters are pushed to the ground after blocking a CUNY security car from entering Brooklyn College during a pro-Palestine protest on May 8, 2025 in Brooklyn, New York.
Michael Nigro/Pacific Press/Shutterstock
Advertisement
'Hunter College has no tolerance for antisemitism or hate of any kind, and we're committed to fostering a safe and welcoming campus environment for everyone,' the spokesperson said.
The rare intervention in a federal lawsuit is just the latest example of the Trump administration's aggressive crackdown on private and public universities that it claims are failing to stop anti-Israel protests that spew Jew hatred.
Hunter is not the only CUNY campus in the crosshairs.
4 Leah Garrett of CUNY Hunter gives a talk on Mad Magazine in 2019.
hunter.cuny.edu
Last week, anti-Israel agitators brawled with cops at Brooklyn College after they set up a tent encampment and disrupted final exams. The melee drew outrage from Brooklyn lawmakers, who demanded CUNY brass take swift disciplinary action.
Meanwhile, Trump's Joint Task Force to Combat Anti-Semitism announced Tuesday that it cancelled another $450 million in grants to Harvard University after it said the Ivy League school 'repeatedly failed' to quell race discrimination and antisemitism on campus.
The president's campus monitors in March also scrapped $400 million in federal grants to Columbia University over the Morningside Heights school's 'failure to protect Jewish students from antisemitic harassment.'
They're also threatening to revoke visas and deport foreign students who engage in disruptive protests and illegal activity.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Netanyahu: Boulder attack fueled by blood libels against Jewish state
The antisemitic attacks around the world are "a direct result of blood libels against the Jewish state and people, and this must be stopped," Netanyahu urged. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he trusts "the United States authorities to prosecute the cold-blooded perpetrator to the fullest extent of the law and do everything possible to prevent future attacks against innocent civilians," the PMO announced on Sunday. The statements followed a potential terror attack in Boulder, Colorado, that occurred at an event raising awareness for the Israeli hostages. "This attack was aimed against peaceful people who wished to express their solidarity with the hostages held by Hamas, simply because they were Jews," the PMO announcement remarked. The antisemitic attacks around the world are "a direct result of blood libels against the Jewish state and people, and this must be stopped," Netanyahu urged. On Sunday afternoon, a man threw Molotov cocktails and used an improvised flamethrower to target participants of a weekly walking group that raises awareness for the hostages in Hamas captivity. Israeli Opposition Leader Yair Lapid also condemned the violent terror attack in Colorado against protesters who were calling for the release of Israeli hostages, adding that this situation is the "direct result of the extreme rhetoric that has fanned the flames of antisemitism," and that the events illustrate the true meaning of "when extremists call to 'Globalize the Intifada.'" "Have faith that the perpetrator will be prosecuted to the full extent of the law," Lapid stated. The Hostages and Missing Families Forum also expressed concern about the tragic attack in Colorado: "For over 600 days, this community — along with so many others around the world — has stood with us, marching, praying, and raising its voice for the hostages still held in Gaza. Today, we stand with you — with care, with solidarity, and with deep appreciation for your unwavering support." "We remain steadfast in our mission: 58 of our brothers and sisters are still held captive in the tunnels of Gaza. They need us to be their voice, their strength, their hope. We will not stop until each and every one of them is brought home," the forum concluded in the statement.
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Lindsey Graham's 'Deranged' Post About Greta Thunberg Is Condemned Online
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) drew fierce blowback on Sunday over his social media post about 22-year-old Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg. Graham shared a news article about Thunberg's presence on a flotilla that is headed to Gaza and whose occupants want to deliver humanitarian aid to the Palestinian people, amid the monthslong, starvation-inducing Israeli blockade. 'Hope Greta and her friends can swim!' the top ally of President Donald Trump, who is a staunch supporter of Israel, wrote on X, the Elon Musk-owned platform formerly called Twitter. Critics condemned Graham as a 'shitty person' for the post. 'In a good country, this kind of tweet would be disqualifying for public office,' said one. Asked another: 'Are you aware that you are a sitting US Senator??' New England Patriots Prompt Right-Wing Freak Out With Pride Post Trump 'Clearly' Wants To Avoid 1 Thing With Elon Musk, Says Maggie Haberman Kayleigh McEnany Makes Chilling Demand For '60 Minutes' Reporter Over Anti-Trump Speech
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trump's education secretary threatens federal civil rights lawsuit over Long Island high school being forced to ditch Chiefs mascot
She's going to the mat for the Chiefs. President Trump's Secretary of Education Linda McMahon is threatening to bring a civil rights case against the Empire State for forcing a Long Island high school to ditch its Native American mascot. The former WWE promoter called the New York Board of Regents' 2023 decision to ban Massapequa High School's beloved 'Chiefs' nickname a 'violation' of Title VI of the federal Civil Rights Act during a visit to the school Friday. If the state doesn't reverse course and allow the Chiefs and their feathered headdress logo to remain, McMahon said she would refer the issue to the Justice Department to pursue. 'That's how serious we are about it,' McMahon said inside the high school's gym after touring classrooms and telling students, 'it's a real pleasure to be in a room full of Chiefs.' She claimed New York was targeting the Chiefs, while allowing other schools with names like Vikings or Dutchmen to remain. 'If you look at the states, you've got the Huguenots, we've got the Highlanders, we've got the Scotsman. Why is that not considered in any way racist?' she asked. While McMahon and the local supporters defended the name, state officials said they were 'doing the students of Massapequa a grave disservice by ignoring the facts and true history of the local Indigenous people.' State Education Department spokesperson JP O'Hare criticized that the town has 'failed to get even the most basic facts right' — such as the feathered headdress that Massapequa displays being locally inaccurate, and that the term chief was not used in the area, either. 'And most importantly, there is no recognition of the ways in which European settlers were responsible for displacing Indigenous people from their homes,' O'Hare's statement said, adding that 'local Indigenous representatives' find that 'certain Native American names and images perpetuate negative stereotypes, and are demonstrably harmful to children.' 'Equally troubling is the fact that a U.S. Secretary of Education would take time out of her schedule to disrupt student learning in the name of political theatre.' Massapequa school board president Kerry Wachter rebutted, saying, 'They're sticking to their talking points and listening to only one side of the story.' She pointed to a 2016 poll which showed nine in 10 Native Americans do not take offense to terms like 'Redskins.' Trump, who posed with a Massapequa shirt in the Oval Office, ordered McMahon to take up the issue in April. The federal government became involved after a plea from Wachter, whose district, among other Native American-named towns on Long Island, unsuccessfully sued New York over the mandate. 'This is a school that really takes its education seriously, and they're incredibly, incredibly behind their school, behind their Chiefs,' McMahon told The Post Friday. 'I think this is wrong — what's happening at Massapequa, to take away this incredible mascot and emblem of Chiefs.' After Trump intervened, O'Hare said in a statement that Massapequa 'did not reach out to Indigenous leaders or engage with the Department's Mascot Advisory Committee to determine whether its Native American team name and mascot would be permissible.' 'If members of the Massapequa board of education are genuinely interested in honoring and respecting Long Island's Native American past, they should talk to the Indigenous people who remain on Long Island,' the rep said. 'Our regulations, in fact, specifically permit the continued use of Native American names and mascots if approved by local tribal leaders.' But Massapequa School District Superintendent Dr. William Brennan called the state's claim 'simply inaccurate.' He added that 'several attempts' were made by the district and local tribal leaders attended a roundtable in summer of 2023. Frank Black Cloud, a leading member of the Native American Guardians Association, which is working with Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman on the issue, is a firm supporter of keeping names like Chiefs in schools and calls it a term of endearment. 'People want to emulate you,' Black Cloud, who has previously defended names like Fighting Sioux and Redskins, said at the event. 'You're talking about strength, talking about being something that people uphold.' Town of Oyster Bay Supervisor Joseph Saladino, an MHS alumnus and hockey player, doubled down that this is a case of 'rules for thee but not for me' in the Empire State. 'The New York State Department of Education has someone who is the chief of staff,' he said. 'Are they going to change their name?' Massapequa's suit — a last-ditch effort to stop the district's nine schools from spending $1 million on a forced rebranding — was, ironically, dismissed by a chief justice weeks ago, Wachter explained. Salt in the wound, Seaford, the first town west of Massapequa, along with Port Washington, named their teams the Vikings, to no objection from the state of New York. Hofstra University in Nassau was previously known as the Flying Dutchmen as well. 'They have Spartans and Vikings and all these things, but they're seeing this particular group of people who are not allowed to be represented,' said Wachter, whose district also filed an amended court complaint ahead of a June deadline. 'That's a civil rights issue … We're standing tall, showing Massapequa pride, and we do take offense to them trying to take it away from us.' The town will be having a 'Save the Chiefs' fundraiser next weekend at the high school, and Black Cloud will engage in a Native American seminar at Massapequa's popular Nautilus Diner on Saturday. 'We're about education, not eradication,' said Black Cloud, who flew from his North Dakota home to meet McMahon. 'If you have an opposing idea, let me hear it. I'd like to open up a dialogue with you.'
