Big Pit charging mine admission is 'wrong'
It is wrong to charge people to enter the Big Pit National Coal Museum, a Senedd report says.
The museum in Blaenavon, Torfaen, has started charging £8 per person, with some concessions, on a trial basis until July 2026.
But the culture and sport committee says access should remain free on principle and not be a luxury for those who can afford it, calling for better funding for Welsh museums so collections remain free for all.
The Welsh government said it was committed to keeping entry to all seven museum sites free, as well as to the national collections, and would consider the report's findings.
Tours of Big Pit, one of Amgueddfa Cymru's seven museums, are led by former miners and explore original mine shafts and museums.
A sign outside the entrance now states: "Due to financial pressures and funding cuts, from 5 April we will be charging for the underground tour."
But Delyth Jewell MS, chair of the Senedd's culture and sports committee, said the tours are "a fundamental part of our national collections, they are part of our national story, and that shouldn't be limiting if people can't afford to access them".
The report says the Welsh government has "not fulfilled its responsibility in funding museums adequately", citing a 17% cut in real terms to funding for culture and sport in Wales in the last decade.
"We appreciate that it is expensive for Amgueddfa Cymru to provide access to the underground workings at Big Pit," it says.
"However, we think this is an argument for the Welsh government to provide an adequate level of funding, not for Amgueddfa Cymru to charge for access."
Bygone photos show life in Wales' oldest multi-ethnic community
Tom Hanks writes letter backing rural war museum
Publicly funded gallery 'turning its back on art'
Visitors gave a mixed response to the charge, with Deborah Clubb from Merthyr Tydfil saying: "I think [the fee] would make it something that I wouldn't visit as often, definitely, because it was always a free attraction before and something that you could do as a family without thinking about."
Mother-of-six Amy Hughes, from Aberdare, said she took the underground tour several times when it was free.
She said: "[The admission fee] does make me not want to take all my kids down there but I do feel it's such good value to be able to go underground and see an actual mine.
"It would be good if they did a family ticket."
Savannah Knox, visiting from Southern Ontario, said she didn't mind paying because she is used to doing that back home in Canada.
She said: "If it's historical or a museum it's usually charged. It helps with the upkeep, right?"
Showing her around Wales was Lauren Price from Risca, who said she didn't mind paying the fee "if the money's going back into keeping it up and going".
Amgueddfa Cymru said the Big Pit experience extends "far beyond" the underground tour, and the rest of the site remains free. It said it looks forward to continuing working with the Welsh government as they consider the report's findings.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
16 hours ago
- Yahoo
Wildlife experts announce bold plan to bring back species lost for 3,000 years: 'I'd like to see them sooner rather than later'
Efforts to bring elk back to the United Kingdom are advancing. The Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire wildlife trusts secured £15,000 ($20,190) in funding from Rewilding Britain to begin feasibility studies, the BBC reported. Their goal? Reintroduce elk to the East Midlands, where they once roamed freely before hunters drove them to extinction about 3,000 years ago. Elk are impressive not only because of their features and size. They're also effective landscapers of nature. These massive creatures help shape entire ecosystems. They clear out dense vegetation as they graze. When elk wander through wetlands and grasslands, they act like a groundskeeping crew that controls overgrowth and creates clearer pathways for smaller animals. NWT's Janice Bradley noted that elk may have roamed through the Trent wetlands, making them native to the woods and the local landscape. Experts hope to bring them back to these grasslands to fulfill their role in improving habitats for other animals. She also said that while it may take time for the public to get used to the idea of elk returning to the area, they encourage people to engage and get excited. "But I'd like to see them sooner rather than later," she shared, per BBC. The initiative to reintroduce rare species and extinct wildlife isn't new. U.K. conservationists have already seen some success with rewilding projects. In Wales, marsh fritillary butterflies have made a comeback. Meanwhile, efforts by rewilding groups helped water voles thrive in the Welsh uplands after decades of absence. Bringing beavers back to the U.K. wetlands has also shown great results. In Dorset, reintroduced wild beavers created new habitats for other animals and helped reduce floods. The same positive changes occurred in Hampshire. Reintroducing elk to the U.K. is a bold move. However, if it works, it will add balance to the environment, benefiting plants, animals, and nearby communities. A healthy ecosystem means cleaner air and water, as well as a stronger connection to nature. Support biodiversity by planting native species at home to rewild your yard. Should the U.S. invest in building more wildlife overpasses? Absolutely Depends on how we do it Depends on where we do it Nope Click your choice to see results and speak your mind. Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Labour's approach to maths just doesn't add up, says Newport's Asghar
Newport MS Natasha Asghar says young people in Wales are being failed by poor standards of maths in schools. The Welsh Conservatives have raised concerns after a report by Estyn inspectors highlighted significant variation in teaching quality, inadequate training and a lack of understanding of the curriculum. Shadow cabinet secretary for education, Ms Asghar, said: "This report lays bare the systemic failings of the Welsh Labour Government. "After 26 years in charge, Labour continues to let students down by poor teaching standards and a lack of support for teachers. "These are not just statistics; they represent real opportunities lost for our young people." Earlier this week the Welsh Conservatives criticised Labour's announcement of £44million in grants for schools, stating that they were failing to prioritise core subjects. Ms Asghar said: "Labour's track record on education in Wales highlights their continued failure to make the right calls." She continued: "Maths is the backbone of our future economy, from AI to engineering, and we cannot afford to undermine it. "Yet Labour's weak guidance, chronic underfunding, and lack of support for teachers are failing our schools and jeopardising the future prospects of our children.'
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
'Clinging to hope': Harvard students slam latest Trump visa ban
Donald Trump's late night proclamation blocking Harvard's new international students has sparked fear and anger among existing students left in limbo amid the escalating showdown between the US president and their university. Alfred Williamson, a Welsh-Danish physics and government student in his second year at Harvard, said he was "clinging onto the hope that Harvard will win this fight and that I will get to return next semester." Harvard had won a reprieve from a judge who paused an earlier bid by Trump to revoke the university's ability to sponsor the school's large international student population -- 27 percent of the total. "Then the Trump administration does whatever it can to crush those dreams," Williamson, 20, told AFP of Trump's proclamation Wednesday alleging that "Harvard's conduct has rendered it an unsuitable destination for foreign students and researchers" and also threatened existing international students with visa cancellations. "This represents another authoritarian instance of executive overreach, which punishes international students for attending a university that refuses to bow down to the administration," said Williamson who is vacationing outside the United States. He said "Trump is targeting Harvard because it has the integrity to stand up to his unlawful and un-American demands." Harvard has been at the forefront of Trump's campaign against top universities after it defied his calls to submit to oversight of its curriculum, staffing, student recruitment and "viewpoint diversity." The government already cut around $3.2 billion of federal grants and contracts benefiting Harvard and pledged to exclude the Cambridge, Massachusetts, institution from any future federal funding while threatening its tax-exempt status. - 'Campaign of retaliation' - On Thursday, Harvard added the latest measure to legal action against the Trump administration, arguing in a court filing that "this is not the Administration's first attempt to sever Harvard from its international students." It called it part of a "campaign of retaliation." A graduate student at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government from India who declined to be named said: "I just read this latest news. We have not received anything from Harvard yet, but this isn't surprising -- albeit concerning." "I knew it was going to be a long summer." One international student who declined to be named for fear of retribution raised the plight of international students who had moved their lives to Harvard, leaving for the summer break, and now faced uncertainty following Trump's order. "What about students who went home for the summer? There's a risk they won't be able to come back," said the student who is currently seeking to renew their own visa. Legal experts said Harvard would need to explore a range of options to protect its foreign students alongside the legal action. "(They) need to act quickly on an administrative level to explore options for its international student population which could possibly include program deferrals, transitions to online instruction, or other alternatives to ensure academic continuity," said attorney Khensani Mathebula, who works with the Laura Devine Immigration firm. "Staying informed and proactive is essential in protecting (students') academic and immigration status." A US Harvard student of government going into her fourth year who is friends with many international students, Olivia Data, said "this news is heartbreaking and scary." "Our friends and classmates are being used as collateral in a dictator's grab for power, and none of us know where it will end or whether our university can protect its students in our current political system," she said. gw/sla