The Italian mums who 'poisoned' their children
Elisabetta Donadello "poisoned" her children. After unwittingly living off polluted land in northeast Italy for decades, she had toxic chemicals in her blood -- which she passed on with each pregnancy.
Donadello, 50, is one of thousands of mothers in the region who discovered they had ingested "forever chemicals" known as PFAS and transmitted them to their babies, both in the womb and through breastfeeding.
Some are now civil plaintiffs in a criminal case against chemicals company Miteni, which is accused of causing one of Europe's biggest environmental disasters for discharging the hormone-altering substances into water sources, affecting 350,000 people.
"For 40 years I ate the vegetables grown here, and passed them on to my children in pregnancy... so basically I poisoned my children," said Donadello, who lives in the house in which she grew up.
Both children, now eight and 10, have high levels in their blood, but especially Donadello's first born, "because it's awful... the mother dumps them (the chemicals) on her first child", she told AFP.
Chronic exposure to even low levels of PFAS has been linked to liver damage, high cholesterol, reduced immune responses, low birthweights and several kinds of cancer.
Donadello says both children appear well, but she finds herself watching them closely for sickness.
"I'm afraid. I don't have normal reactions when they have even trivial symptoms... because there is always the fear that it could mean something is happening because of the pollutants," she said.
- No taste, colour, smell -
Fifteen managers of the Miteni factory are on trial in Vicenza, accused of knowingly leaking PFAS into a waterway that fed into others, polluting a vast area between Vicenza, Verona and Padova.
Donadello is part of a group of mothers dubbed the "Mamme No PFAS" (Mums Against PFAS), who united after discovering their families had the chemicals in their blood.
She lives around 12 kilometres (7.5 miles) from the factory, which is now closed down. But her garden sits above a polluted aquifer that feeds the well and was used to water the allotment.
She stopped using the well in 2015 and has turned it and part of her allotment over to scientists from Padua University, so they can study the extent to which the water with PFAS contaminates fruit and vegetables.
"The first year salad and tomatoes were planted. Soil and water analysis before, during and after, showed the vegetables... if irrigated with contaminated water, are themselves contaminated," she said.
The vegetables now watered with rainwater are safe, but the family has stopped eating their home-grown kiwis or making grape jam from their vines, for the plants have deep roots that draw on the aquifer.
Donadello said PFAS were found even in the eggs from the family's free-range chickens.
She and other campaigners accuse Veneto regional authorities of failing to properly inform people about the contamination, so that many families continue blithely to eat home-grown or locally grown produce.
The region is also a plaintiff in the case.
"PFAS have no taste, colour or smell, (so) the vegetables taste fantastic," she said.
"How do you convince someone who has been eating the things he has been self-producing for his whole life... to stop eating them? With indisputable data, stated clearly and with authority."
- Paradise lost -
Donadello's 84-year-old father has a tractor, a shed piled high with tools and a passion for the allotment. She remembers helping him as a child, pulling up radishes and leeks with her sister.
He was reluctant to stop using the land, and only did so when faced with his grandchildren's blood test results.
"It's terrible for a person who is in touch with his land to think that he can no longer use it," Donadello said as she watched him and her young son uproot a contaminated cherry tree.
The Miteni factory shut in 2018 but the land is still full of PFAS, which are washed into the torrent running beside it when it rains.
Donadello is close to tears when she looks across the green fields to snow-capped mountains beyond and thinks of the ruin of what was once "my paradise".
"It is painful to think that poisoned water is flowing under my feet, and it will probably be like that forever, if there is no cleanup," she said.
"This was my grandparents' land, my father's land. What am I leaving to my children?"
ide/ar/js
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
SC river the ‘most contaminated' from dangerous forever chemicals, study finds
When researchers completed a national study of hazardous forever chemicals recently, they found that a South Carolina river had higher levels of pollution from the toxins than any other waterway they examined across the country. It was a troubling discovery that potentially threatens public health for those who eat fish from the Pocotaligo River in Sumter and Clarendon counties, as well as rivers downstream. It also raises concerns about the Pocotaligo River if it is ever sought as a source for drinking water. The report, by the Waterkeeper Alliance environmental organization, says the prime suspect in the pollution is an aging wastewater treatment plant that serves the city of Sumter. The plant receives wastewater from nearly a dozen industries that may be handling and releasing the chemicals, formally known as PFAS, the report said. Those include metal coating industries, plastics businesses, chemical manufacturers and textile businesses, the report said. Other possible sources of the PFAS contamination include military installations. Shaw Air Force Base is known to have released forever chemicals that polluted groundwater at nearby mobile home parks. While the Sumter Pocotaligo sewer plant is designed to treat polluted wastewater before releasing it back into the river, its treatment process does not filter out forever chemicals that flow into the plant, according to the report. That's typical of sewer plants across the country, which are designed to handle bacteria pollution and certain other contaminants but not forever chemicals. The stretch of Pocotaligo River examined by the Waterkeeper Alliance below the sewage plant was called 'the most contaminated location detected'' in the study of PFAS in rivers in 19 states from California to Connecticut to the Carolinas and Georgia. The river links with the Black River, which like the Pocotaligo, has previously been found with elevated PFAS levels. The Black River meanders through a new state park and to the coast near Georgetown. According to data compiled by the Waterkeeper Alliance in the fall of 2024, a stretch of the Pocotaligo River below the Sumter sewage plant had the highest collective levels of all forever chemicals tested nationally. Total forever chemical levels exceeded 228 parts per trillion in the Pocotaligo. The next highest amounts exceeded 144 parts per trillion in North Carolina's Haw River and 117 parts per trillion in the Santa Ana River of California, the report found. Levels in the Pocotaligo below the sewer plant were more than 100 percent higher than levels of PFAS found in the river above the Sumter treatment plant, the report said. Forever chemicals are a class of toxic compounds that are of increasing concern nationally, as more is learned about their health effects. Exposure to forever chemicals has been linked to certain types of cancer, immune system deficiencies, thyroid problems and other ailments. Once the chemicals get into people's blood, it can take years to expel the toxins. There are thousands of different types of forever chemicals, many of which are toxic. Used in a variety of household products, ranging from non-stick frying pans to food wrappers and water resistant clothing, PFAS compounds do not break down quickly in the environment, thus the name forever chemicals. The Pocotaligo River is a meandering stream popular with fishermen in the Sumter area, about an hour's drive east of Columbia. One of the biggest threats from PFAS in rivers like the Pocotaligo is to people who regularly eat fish from those waters. Many are subsistence fishermen who take what they catch home and prepare the fish for meals. PFAS can build up in the flesh of fish and expose people who eat certain species to harm. That's a worry because PFAS isn't the only type of chemical compounds found in some species. Mercury, a powerful neurotoxin, for years has been documented in fish across much of the state, including the Pocotaligo and the Black rivers. The state has issued warnings, urging people to limit consumption of fish in many rivers because of both PFAS and mercury contamination. The threat to low-income and minority communities is of particular concern, the report said, noting that 65 percent of people living within a mile of the Sumter treatment plant are those of color and 42 percent are low income. Carl Brzorad, an attorney with the Southern Environmental Law Center, said people should pay attention to what the Waterkeeper Alliance report lays out. Brzorad was not involved in compiling the report, but his group has been following the issue of forever chemical pollution in southern waterways. 'The high levels of PFAS in the Pocotaligo River are very concerning, especially for the people who fish in the river,'' he said in an email to The State. 'All indications are that industrial dischargers in Sumter are dumping toxic PFAS into the Pocotaligo through the town's wastewater treatment plant, which is not equipped to treat these chemicals. These industrial polluters need to treat their PFAS so that it doesn't poison rivers and fish.'' He criticized the S.C. Department of Environmental Services for failing to use the federal Clean Water Act to limit discharges by wastewater plants of PFAS. The law allows DES to regulate discharges, but 'DES has never set limits on PFAS in a discharge permit,'' he said. 'The Pocotaligo is perhaps the worst example in South Carolina of DES's failure to enforce the law and control industrial PFAS pollution.'' Although neither the Pocotaligo nor the Black rivers currently are sources of public drinking water, the presence of PFAS could chill efforts to establish such plants in the future as groundwater supplies dwindle. Already, one water service provider in the Lowcountry that had been interested in drawing water from a canal near the Black River, backed away after learning of the PFAS contamination, said Erin Donmoyer, the Black Riverkeeper. 'Right now, PFAS chemicals are flowing into the Black River watershed, and into the Pocataligo, without limits, without treatment, without accountability,'' Donmoyer said during a news conference to discuss the Waterkeeper Alliance findings. Donmoyer, who sampled water in the Pocataligo for the waterkeeper report, called the results 'rather unsettling.'' In addition to overall levels of PFAS being the highest amounts found in the study, other individual forever chemicals also were at or near the top nationally. The level of PFOS, a toxic and highly studied type of forever chemical, reached 30 parts per trillion below the Sumter sewage plant, which was higher than anywhere else for that specific chemical. Another well-known forever chemical, PFOA, registered at 28 parts per trillion, second highest in the country, the study found. Both of those levels are more than 20 percent higher than the government's pending safety limits on PFAS in drinking water, Donmoyer said. Officials who worked on the study nationally said their findings that PFAS levels were higher below sewage plants than above them indicates the plants are a major source. That's true with the Sumter plant, although Donmoyer said PFAS levels in the river above the plant indicate that forever chemicals are draining downstream from other sources. 'The Sumter Pocotaligo River wastewater treatment plant outfall is likely a significant source of PFAS in the Pocataligo River,'' the report said. Officials with the Department of Environmental Services said they plan to provide answers to questions from The State, but did not have them available Thursday. The agency in 2023 said it would begin requiring wastewater plants and industries to begin disclosing whether they use, receive or generate forever chemicals. Efforts to reach Sumter city officials were not successful. The report by the Waterkeeper Alliance, a national river protection group that has been tracking forever chemicals in rivers for years, is significant because it provides details about discharges from wastewater plants, as well as chemicals that are dumped on the landscape in sewage sludge, and PFAS pollution that is occurring downstream. Testing done for the study occurred for about a month last fall, as opposed to onetime samples that have been taken in the past, officials said. The recent waterkeeper sampling is believed to be a better indicator of how fish might be impacted. The report said 98 percent of all rivers tested had some amount of PFAS in the water, with the highest amounts often in stretches of river below wastewater plants and sludge fields. Some 95 percent of rivers below treatment plants had elevated concentrations of PFAS, while 80 percent of rivers below sludge fields had elevated concentrations, the report said. The report did not examine rivers below sludge fields in South Carolina, where the material has been used as fertilizer. The Waterkeeper Alliance's findings follow an array of previous reports that highlighted the threat of PFAS to the Pocotaligo and other rivers in South Carolina. The alliance in 2022 said more than 80% of the waterways tested nationally had at least one type of forever chemical in the water. The S.C. Department of Environmental Services also has previously found PFAS in virtually every South Carolina river it tested, including the Pocotaligo. The Pocotaligo had the highest levels in South Carolina of all types of PFAs recorded in rivers by the state agency, state regulators said in a 2023 study. Additionally, The State and McClatchy in 2023 found multiple examples of contamination in rivers below areas where sludge laden with forever chemicals was spread on the landscape. The news outlets' reporting found that groundwater had been contaminated in areas where PFAS-riddled sewer sludge had been put on the land by unsuspecting farmers as a fertilizer, at the recommendation of the government. Some farmers and their neighbors in Darlington County said their health had been affected from drinking the water, The State and McClatchy reported in the news organizations' Toxic Deals investigative series. The Waterkeeper Alliance report is being released as the federal government is moving to scale back plans to more strictly oversee the amount of PFAS allowed in drinking water. Under President Donald Trump, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has sought to delay tougher standards for two of the most common types of forever chemcials — PFOA and PFOS — and it has scrapped plans to institute limits on a least three other types of PFAS in drinking water. The alliance said that needs to change. The EPA should begin regulating PFAS as a class of toxic contaminants, as opposed to limits on individual types of the chemicals. 'Rather than weakening protections, EPA must finalize, adopt and enforce pending reforms .... to help stem the accumulation of PFAS in the nation's waterways,'' the report said. This story has been updated with additional test results for the Pocotaligo River.
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
Verdict expected in Italy 'forever chemicals' trial
A verdict is expected Thursday in the trial of 15 managers of a chemical plant accused of knowingly contaminating the water of hundreds of thousands of people in Italy. The now-shuttered Miteni factory near the northeastern city of Vicenza is alleged to have polluted one of Europe's largest groundwater basins with PFAS, dubbed "forever chemicals" because they never break down. The prosecution alleges that the plant in Trissino, which produced PFAS from 1968 and was run by three companies until its closure due to bankruptcy in 2018, leaked chemical-laced wastewater into a waterway, polluting a vast area between Vicenza, Verona and Padova. Fifteen managers from Mitsubishi, International Chemical Investors (ICIG) and Miteni are charged with contaminating nearly 200 square kilometres (77 square miles) of drinking water, as well as soil. Prosecutors in the trial, which began in 2021, have called for the managers to be sentenced to a total of 121 years in jail, lawyer Edoardo Bortolotto told AFP Thursday. Over 200 civil plaintiffs have joined the trial, including Greenpeace and local mothers who united after discovering their families had the chemicals in their blood. PFAS have been used since the late 1940s to mass produce the nonstick, waterproof and stain-resistant treatments that coat everything from frying pans to umbrellas, carpets and dental floss. But chronic exposure to even low levels of the chemicals has been linked to liver damage, high cholesterol, reduced immune responses, low birthweights and several kinds of cancer. The contamination was discovered in 2013 after Italy's environment ministry ordered tests of the Po River following a 2006 European project assessing exposure to such chemicals in rivers. Of all the rivers studied, the Po had the highest concentrations of one specific PFAS called PFOA, a known carcinogen. Further investigation identified Miteni as the source. At the time, there were no Italian or EU thresholds for PFAS content in drinking water, according to a regional report by the World Health Organization (WHO). ide/giv
CBS News
2 days ago
- CBS News
Wisconsin Supreme Court sides with environmentalists in fight over PFAS "forever chemicals"
How scientists are working to clean up PFAS How scientists are working to clean up PFAS How scientists are working to clean up PFAS The Wisconsin Supreme Court delivered a victory for environmentalists on Tuesday in the fight over "forever chemicals" known as PFAS, issuing a ruling that advocates said will hold polluters accountable. The liberal-controlled court ruled that state regulators can force landowners to clean up emerging pollutants such as PFAS before they are officially designated as hazardous substances. The 5-2 ruling is a defeat for the state's powerful group representing businesses and manufacturers, which had argued the state couldn't enforce regulations on substances before they were officially designated as hazardous. It is the latest development in a yearslong battle in Wisconsin and nationally involving regulators, environmentalists, politicians and businesses over how to deal with PFAS contamination. Cities large and small across Wisconsin, from Madison to Marinette and La Crosse to Wausau, are grappling with PFAS contamination. PFAS, or perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances, are a group of chemicals that have been around for decades and have now spread into the nation's air, water and soil. The chemicals helped eggs slide across nonstick frying pans, ensured that firefighting foam suffocates flames and helped clothes withstand the rain and keep people dry. They resist breaking down, however, which means they stay around in the environment and have a hard time breaking down in the body. There is a wide range of health harms now associated with exposure to certain PFAS, including low birth weight, cancer and liver disease. The Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled in a case brought by the state's largest business group, Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce, which sued the DNR in 2021 on behalf of Leather Rich, a dry cleaning business in Oconomowoc. Leather Rich became aware of PFAS contamination in 2018 and was working on cleaning it up when the DNR posted a message online in 2019 saying it now considered PFAS chemicals a hazardous substance. The agency ordered the dry cleaner to test its groundwater for PFAS but didn't tell the business which compounds it needed to test for or what levels would be considered dangerous. Leather Rich argued the DNR can't force businesses to test and clean up contamination from emerging pollutants like PFAS without first designating them as hazardous substances. That process can take years and requires approval from the Legislature. All that time, polluters could harm the environment and put people's health and safety at risk with no obligation to begin cleanup, the DNR argued. A Waukesha County judge and the state appeals court sided with Leather Rich. The DNR appealed, saying the lower court's ruling would neuter the state's "spills law," which was designed to confront pollution. That law, enacted about 50 years ago, requires anyone who causes, possesses or controls a hazardous substance that's been released into the environment to clean it up. "Wisconsin's Spills Law safeguards human health and the environment in real time by directly regulating parties responsible for a hazardous substance discharge," Justice Janet Protasiewicz wrote for the majority. No state law required the DNR to implement a rule before requiring Leather Rich to begin cleaning up the site, she wrote. "The DNR has explicit authority to enforce a threshold for reporting the discharge of hazardous substances," Protasiewicz wrote. The court's four liberal justices were joined by conservative Justice Brian Hagedorn in the majority. Conservative justices Annette Ziegler and Rebecca Bradley dissented. They said the ruling allows bureaucrats to "impose rules and penalties on the governed without advance notice, oversight, or deliberation. In doing so, the majority violates three first principles fundamental to preserving the rule of law — and liberty." Democratic Gov. Tony Evers and environmental advocates hailed the decision. Evers called it "a historic victory for the people of Wisconsin and my administration's fight against PFAS and other harmful contaminants." Rob Lee, attorney for Midwest Environmental Advocates, called the ruling "a victory for the health and wellbeing of the people of Wisconsin" that reinforces "a bedrock environmental and public health protection that has kept Wisconsinites safe from toxic contamination for almost fifty years." But Scott Manley, a vice president at WMC, said the ruling leaves it up to businesses and homeowners to guess about what is hazardous, leaving them subject to "crushing fines and endless, costly litigation." "This ruling blesses a regulatory approach that is fundamentally unfair, unworkable, and impossible to comply with," Manley said. Federal regulators placed the first-ever national standards on PFAS in drinking water last year, but the Trump administration said in May that it planned to weaken those limits. The state has imposed less restrictive limits on PFAS in surface and drinking water, defined as piped water delivered through public systems and noncommunity systems that serve places such as factories, schools and hotels. But it has not implemented PFAS standards for groundwater, the source of drinking water for about two-thirds of Wisconsin residents. The agency stopped efforts to draft them in 2023 after determining that compliance would be too expensive.
