logo
Key takeaways of court ruling on legal definition of woman

Key takeaways of court ruling on legal definition of woman

BBC News16-04-2025

The UK Supreme Court has ruled that the legal definition of a woman should be based on biological sex.So as the dust settles on the ruling, what can we take away from it?
Clear ruling
Firstly, it provides much greater clarity than many expected. The judges ruled that when the term "woman" is used in the Equality Act it means a biological woman, and "sex" means biological sex.It also makes it clear that if a space or service is designated as women-only, a person who was born male but identifies as a woman does not have a right to use that space or service.The Supreme Court justices argued this was the only consistent, coherent interpretation.
Public bodies to review evidence
Many public bodies will now be reviewing their gender policies, but how much day-to-day change we'll see is going to take time to find out.There is already Equality Act guidance which allows for women-only spaces, such as toilets, changing rooms and hospital wards in certain circumstances.It says this could be for "reasons of privacy, decency, to prevent trauma or to ensure health and safety."So, where organisations want and where appropriate, they can already point to this to justify single-sex spaces.However, cases like that of the nurse, Sandie Peggie, who was suspended after refusing to share a changing room with a transgender doctor, are likely to be reviewed.On Wednesday NHS Fife, the health board involved in the case, told the BBC it noted the clarity provided by the ruling and would "carefully consider the judgment."
Implications for sports
In sports, there have been particularly heated arguments over whether or not trans women should compete in women's categories.And in recent years, many sports have tightened up rules around transgender athletes at the elite levels. Athletics, cycling and aquatics, for example, have banned transgender women from taking part in women's events.Other sports have put in place eligibility criteria. Earlier this month the English Football Association introduced stricter rules, but still allowed transgender women to continue to compete in the women's game as long as their testosterone was kept below a certain level.Again, Wednesday's ruling's straightforward statement that a woman is a biological woman provides a much clearer framework for those debates, and could see rules changed in various sports as a result.
GRC certificates
The Supreme Court justices emphasised that transgender people already have protections against discrimination and harassment written into the Equality Act.The arguments in court centred on whether trans women with gender recognition certificates (GRC) should be treated as women by the Equality Act.The Scottish government had argued that sex can be legally changed via the gender recognition process, and a transgender person with a gender recognition certificate (GRC) should have the protections of that sex.Campaign group, For Women Scotland, argued that these protections should only apply to people that are born female.Relatively few trans people have GRCs and the judgment concluded if they were treated differently to those who do not have certificates, it would create an unworkable two-tier system of protections for the group.Some people in the transgender community now worry GRCs have lost their legal weight and will only serve a symbolic purpose from now on.
Next steps
Trans rights campaigners have said they will be examining the judgment closely to decide on their next steps. It is possible they could attempt to put pressure on the government to change the Equality Act.The Scottish government has also said it will need to work with the UK government to understand the full implications of the ruling.So, while the judgment provides clarity on the law, the jury is still out on its practical impact.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump team sends removal notices to more than half a million migrants allowed into the country under Biden program
Trump team sends removal notices to more than half a million migrants allowed into the country under Biden program

The Independent

time22 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Trump team sends removal notices to more than half a million migrants allowed into the country under Biden program

The Department of Homeland Security started handing out termination notices to thousands of migrants from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela this week after the Supreme Court ruled in favor of a decision that allows the Trump administration to end a Biden-era humanitarian parole program. Notices reviewed by CNN warned the migrants that if they do not leave voluntarily, they could face enforcement measures including detention and removal, 'without an opportunity to make personal arrangements and return to your country in an orderly manner.' The humanitarian parole program, introduced by the Biden administration, granted eligible migrants permission to enter the United States on a two-year stay. Approximately 530,000 citizens from the four countries were allowed in under the program. The Trump administration has criticized the program, claiming that it allowed 'poorly vetted' migrants into the country. But the program does require applicants to pass background checks and secure a financial sponsor to ensure they would not become a public burden. Last month, the Supreme Court granted an emergency request by the administration to halt the program, paving the way for DHS to begin rescinding protections for those living in the US under the program's terms. In a statement released Wednesday, DHS confirmed it would be revoking the work authorizations of those enrolled in the program. 'The Biden Administration lied to America,' DHS Assistant Secretary for Public Affairs Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement. 'They allowed more than half a million poorly vetted aliens from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua, and Venezuela and their immediate family members to enter the United States through these disastrous parole programs; granted them opportunities to compete for American jobs and undercut American workers; forced career civil servants to promote the programs even when fraud was identified; and then blamed Republicans in Congress for the chaos that ensued and the crime that followed.' The Biden administration had promoted the program as a strategy to relieve pressure on the southern border, offering a legal and controlled pathway for migration from nations frequently represented in asylum claims. With the program now dismantled, immigrant advocacy groups and legal experts are bracing for a wave of legal challenges and humanitarian concerns surrounding those now facing removal. It comes as tensions around immigration are at an all-time high. In Los Angeles, in the city and Trump responded by deploying the military. Elsewhere, other anti-ICE demonstrations ignited across the country, with more planned for Saturday.

Love Island star Shea Mannings' bond with 5-year-old son as he chats fatherhood
Love Island star Shea Mannings' bond with 5-year-old son as he chats fatherhood

Daily Mirror

timean hour ago

  • Daily Mirror

Love Island star Shea Mannings' bond with 5-year-old son as he chats fatherhood

The Love Island star has been open about how important it is that whoever he matches up with on the ITV2 dating show understands that his son is a big part of his life Love Island 's latest bombshell Shea Mannings isn't the typical villa flirt. In fact, this lad from Bristol has been very open about being a devoted dad, letting ITV bosses know that he is looking for a partner who will fit into his family. Shea is a scaffolder by trade but also has a passion for football, which he plays semi-professionally. His days are usually split between construction sites and the pitch. The 25-year-old has played for a string of Southern League clubs, including Swindon Supermarine FC and Bristol Manor Farm. ‌ While he clearly puts a lot of energy into his athletic abilities, the footballer has also been clear about how much he dotes on his son. Unlike some of his fellow Islanders who are just on the show for a laugh, Shea explained: "I'm 25 now, so I want to be settling down and have someone always by my side." ‌ While he is no stranger to the dating scene, as he did cheekily admit he is the CEO of "pulling girls", Shea insists he is ready to leave the casual flings behind in pursuit of something serious. He added: "I have a little boy, so I'll be taking him into consideration with who I couple up with." The Bristol local is looking for a bubbly girl with that "initial spark", but more importantly, he wants to meet someone with a kind heart who will have the maturity to understand his son's place in his life. The dad has chosen to keep his family life private on social media, sticking to posting snaps from the gym, football matches, and sunny holidays. The only details publicly known about his son are that he is five years old and was born in 2020. Shea Mannings has joined the current cast of Love Island season 12 as a bombshell alongside Remell from Essex, who has a reputation for being a bit of a playboy. ‌ While Shea has been keeping his cards close to his chest so far, Remell had a bit of a spark with Scottish beauty Alima, until he admitted that he once slept with five women in one night. This sexual confession seems to have turned Alima off, and viewers even took to X advising her to "run" and "save herself". While Alima was in the confessional booth after Remell shared his shocking secret with the group, she said: "This is the first time that he's walking into a villa like with new people. You then go and say that you've slept with five people in a night. I'm like why would you say that?" Fans suggested that she seemed to have 'the ick' already after the scenes. One fan wrote on X: "Alima has had enough of Remell already." Someone commented: "Alima was not impressed with Remell's story. Neither was I tbh." Another said: "Remell… now why would you say that of ALL things lmaoo Alima is DISGUSTED."

Strathaven pupil scoops top prize in national sport science poster competition
Strathaven pupil scoops top prize in national sport science poster competition

Daily Record

timean hour ago

  • Daily Record

Strathaven pupil scoops top prize in national sport science poster competition

Strathaven Academy pupil Ross Munro was the winner of the national competition consisting of 32 Outreach Hubs across the UK. A star pupil from South Lanarkshire has taken the top prize in a national poster competition, illustrating how sport and exercise science research is helping to improve health and sport performance. A thought-provoking initiative delivered by The Chartered Association of Sport and Exercise Sciences (CASES) and the Division of Sport, Exercise and Health at the University of the West of Scotland (UWS) saw students, who are studying sport and exercise science-related subjects, from over 100 schools and colleges take part in various activities through CASES Outreach Hubs. ‌ Fifth-year Strathaven Academy pupil Ross Munro, whose winning poster competition entry wowed judges, attended a CASES Outreach Day of Sport Science activities at University of West Scotland Lanarkshire campus in November 2024. ‌ Along with 120 pupils from schools across Lanarkshire, Ross learned about supporting athletes. Activities including learning about athletes training in extreme environments, how talent is identified and developed, and how to promote inclusion for athletes with disabilities. Pupils then designed a poster summarising their learning on any of the topics. Ross was the winner put forward from UWS, who had his poster entered into the national competition consisting of 32 Outreach Hubs across the UK. Prof John Dickinson PhD, FCASES, CASES Accredited Applied Sport Scientist is chair of the CASES Outreach Panel. He said: "This year we have seen a significant expansion with over 30 CASES Outreach Hubs engaging with over 100 schools and colleges. ‌ 'We had a significant number of high-quality posters submitted. We are delighted with the winning poster that Ross submitted to the CASES School and College poster competition. The judges were particularly impressed with use of data at the start that added depth to the content, clear take home messages, and overall poster design.' By winning the overall UK-wide competition, Ross has the opportunity for his school to receive a visit from a high-performance athlete. As Ross is a keen runner, he has asked for a Scottish middle-distance runner to attend his school. ‌ Dr Hayley McEwan and Dr Mia Burleigh from UWS who lead the Outreach Hub will work on engaging an athlete and supporting an event for the school to celebrate the success. Ross says would like runners from his local community to be involved as he also volunteers at his Junior Park Run. CASES is currently open to receive Expressions of Interest for institutions who would like to be an Outreach Hub and work with CASES to engage pupils aged 14-19 studying sport and exercise science based subjects. ‌ *Don't miss the latest headlines from around Lanarkshire. Sign up to our newsletters here. And did you know Lanarkshire Live is on Facebook? Article continues below

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store